10 ms·
Christchurch shooter was radicalized on YouTube, New Zealand report says
- draw_down 6y agoWell heck, if we want to stop the shootings I guess we better start censoring YouTube. Alas and alack, we have no choice but to start censoring!
- cityzen 6y agoThere is a really good podcast that talks about this from the New York Times called Rabbit Hole: Podcast link: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/rabbit-hole/id1507423923 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/rabbit-hole/id15074239... Article from NYT: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/08/technology/youtube-radical.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/08/technology/yo...
- finnthehuman 6y agoI think we're lying to ourselves when we look for answers that don't acknowledge systematic failure modes in socialization of today's youth. The baddies du jour isn't the root cause, just a link in a long causal chain. It's a cop out to say focusing on the baddies du jour is part of a multi-pronged approach, the other prongs aren't there or consist of perfunctory hamfisted interventions. But it's not really a surprise, our current approach to mental health is one of sweeping problems under the rug and hoping the rug doesn't notice. It's treated as a heartwarming story when someone is talked down from the side of a bridge, because comparatively nobody notices that they spend the rest of their life at a just-below-jumping threshold level of misery.
- ryanmarsh 6y agoEvents like this are a gold mine for opportunistic policy makers and think tanks. The initial read on Ted Kazinsky was flat wrong. He was practically manufactured. I’d like to know more about the origins of Brenton Tarrant. Both took the time to write lengthy manifestos which, if you read, were more than what you’d get from a YouTube binge. Ted, was, somewhat of an original thinker. Tarrant less so. Fascinating.
- thrower123 6y agoIt's a little bizarre that Kaczynski was a published mathematician of some note before he fell afoul of MK Ultra https://medium.com/cantors-paradise/the-mathematics-of-ted-kaczynski-43eb6ca16633 https://medium.com/cantors-paradise/the-mathematics-of-ted-k...
- wil421 6y agoYou see the problem here is that crazy has many forms. Like Ted Kazinsky crazy can be smart and intellectual. The writings seem to make sense, especially for a young mind, and people develop an empathy for the cause. People read his manifesto and others like Mein Kumph and sometimes people, especially growing minds, seem to think it makes sense. YouTube and other videos are much worse because you have full scale productions instead of books and letters. Do you remember the ISIS state videos? Where everything looked peaceful and welcoming? Then when people go there it was hell on earth, some raped, some killed, some even worse. There’s a line we haven’t figured out between free speech and hate speech. Ted’s manifesto is more like free speech but the ISIS stuff and Nazi stuff is pure hate.
- codetrotter 6y ago> Mein Kumph
- watwut 6y ago> But it's not really a surprise, our current approach to mental health is one of sweeping problems under the rug and hoping the rug doesn't notice. But I would say that people with mental health problems will always exist too. And we absolutely should also focus on those who intentionally push them toward extremism and then toward violent action. Because trying to pretend that issue is just mental health or just socialization is not accurate either.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 6y ago> current approach to mental health This is a red herring; nowhere in the section of the report on him does it describe him as being mentally ill, and it was not a sentencing factor at his trial (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-53919624 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-53919624) https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/christchurch-shooting/122581954/no-remorse-and-narcissistic-the-psychology-of-the-christchurch-mosque-shooter https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/christchurch-shooting/12258... : ". He said after being assessed by the psychologist and psychiatrist, there was no evidence the terrorist suffered from any mental disorders or psychiatric conditions, or that he showed any clinically significant cognitive impairment. The psychologist determined he displayed a range of traits akin to a personality dysfunction, but not to such an extent as to constitute a personality disorder" > systematic failure modes in socialization of today's youth This is rather complicated, because we're talking about radicalisation; he was "socialized" (or at least brought to those views) by the wrong adults, which he chose himself.
- meheleventyone 6y agoHe's also an adult himself and I believe was an adult when he was radicalized so that bit on "socialization" makes even less sense.
- cvhashim 6y agoIt’s a bit jarring when the excuses pour out of the woodwork for white lone wolf shooters and terrorists. I don’t disagree with what you say about systemic failures in the health system, but on the other hand, it ignores the crisis of white, young men getting radicalized at alarming rates.
- badconvincer 6y agoWhy would it be mental health? It’s a idealistic terrorist plain and simple. The very fact that you would suggest mental health issues is deeply disturbing.
- motohagiography 6y agoIn my day it would have been heavy metal and dungeons and dragons. If that seems glib about a terrorist outrage that cost dozens of lives and families, we should apply the same standard of gravity to the quality of the critical excuses authorities make for it afterward. There is a youtube rabbit hole, but it has nothing on the previous tumblr hall of mirrors, or the twitter chorus. Tech is a great scapegoat because it's not going to defend itself. I suppose part of moving on is finding a way to co-opt negative experiences and apply them to strengthen your agenda, but from politicians, it still seems like cynical cant.
- devenblake 6y agoI don't remember the "Tumblr hall of mirrors" or the "Twitter chorus" leading to mass shootings.
- AdrianB1 6y agoThere is no report yet to tell that. I think YouTube is just a scape goat for the society problems that led to that terrible event; any day someone can come forward with a theory that the bad things on the planet are caused by X, Y or Z where X, Y or Z can be anything from Youtube/Twitter/FB to video games or drinking beer, then the reaction will be to try to ban that. I saw the ban that was the result of this event, it was illogic to anyone with knowledge of the matter, but it was well accepted by uninformed public.
- mantas 6y agoAs a society, we learned a lot of creepy lessons from Orwell's 1984. But we didn't learn the positive lesson - a society needs a controlled way for rebelling for the sake of rebelling. Heavy metal, punks, hippies.. What's up today? Now it gets harder and harder to rebel as more and more things are becoming "normal". So people go more extreme. Soon biggest rebellion will be to do nothing "rebellious". Go to school, don't party too much, stick to classic conservative ideas, maybe go to church (or equivalent), dress in a shirt and jeans, go for family/kids/house with a white fence.
- user-the-name 6y ago
- 082349872349872 6y agoI've been thinking of YouTube as a great deradicalisation tool, because it tends to show that "they" are way more like "us" than we tell ourselves. Has anyone been thinking of ways to set up deradicalising rabbit holes? I guess the basic problem is "the algorithm" would tend to push viewers away from those kinds of burrows... Edit: I've been hoping that anti-"authoritarian follower" education might be helpful, as in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24807977 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24807977
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoIt's not a simple issue to address. People who become radicalized often don't trust the popular narrative, often for pretty legitimate reasons. If YouTube is too heavy-handed with their attempt to deradicalize, they're likely to just end up untrusted like a lot of media.
- claudeganon 6y agoGiven that YouTube's algorithms have been shown to push people toward content with more and more extreme views, I'm not sure why'd you'd think it would ever serve that purpose. https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3351095.3372879?download=true https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3351095.3372879?download=... It's been running as a defacto radicalization engine for years at this point.
- Applejinx 6y agoI've seen it do both. I remember the days when it shoved you towards literal Nazis, and then years later I got in a friendship-ending fight with somebody who was far more pilled than I had imagined. Among the wild stuff he was trying to tell me, was the idea that YouTube pushed people towards moderates, and he had a study that was fairly recent. If this study was anything like accurate, then AT THE TIME it was pushing people very gently towards more moderate YouTubers, in a subtle way. My nazi-adjacent former friend was really upset about this. Thing is, both he and I remembered and acknowledged the time when it was feeding people extremist views really noticeably. His problem was essentially that it had stopped. I guess my problem is: who stopped it, why, and when are they going to switch back to doing that again?
- frabbit 6y agoRoll this event back 25 years and people would be claiming that he was radicalized by Satanic heavy metal played backwards. Or jazz and marijuana. Or that Protestant heresy.
- 082349872349872 6y agoRoll back three or four centuries, and one can find claims about radical Quakers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23859546 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23859546 "In its first few pages, the book accuses the Quakers of obscenity, adultery, civil commotion, conspiracy, blasphemy, subversion and lunacy. Milton was not out of fashion in applying bad manners to propaganda. It is merely regrettable that he did not transcend the frailties of his time."
- user-the-name 6y agoThose things did not exist. Far-right extremism on Youtube actually exists.
- moojd 6y agoI assure you jazz does indeed exist.
- user-the-name 6y agoJazz that radicalises you to mass murder does very much not exist.
- rimiform 6y agoMusic has never radicalised anyone, nor video games. There's only a type of music (games) people listen to (play) who then go on to do radical things.
- user-the-name 6y agoWhat?
- drewcoo 6y agoI find hope in the knowledge that even the media or corporate masters allow us to use can be used to radicalize people. The questions I have are about what tools we can learn from white supremacists. All coverage of this is about maintaining the status quo. Where are the lessons learned about how to disrupt it?
- helen___keller 6y agoIf you've had a family member or a friend go down the rabbit hole, you'll understand both the zealotry and the difficulty in peeling it back. Here's what I've observed: Youtube videos of sermons & bible study -> youtube videos of sermons preaching the end of the world is nigh -> youtube videos of deep state / conspiracy discussion -> youtube channel for a particular conspiracy theorist -> alternative website that isn't youtube[0] to consistently dole out conspiracy information (end state) The end result a couple years later is that it now sounds crazy to suggest that Dr Fauci is not a mass murderer, to suggest that the US is not currently engaging in a shadow-WWIII with China, and to suggest that covid-19 is not a bioweapon produced by China. Forget about peeling back "ordinary" disinformation like the kind that gets flagged on twitter. [0] For example, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guo_Wengui#G_News https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guo_Wengui#G_News
- 082349872349872 6y agoSorry for asking, but is this shadow-WWIII supposed to be a hot war? An economic cold war seems obvious from my steady diet of such conspiracy-minded websites as Reuters. (and if covid-19 were a bioweapon, why would people be anti-mask anti-vax?)
- helen___keller 6y ago> Sorry for asking, but is this shadow-WWIII supposed to be a hot war? Well, I try to avoid talking about politics with her, but last I heard the US is "soon" going to be assassinating the leadership of China and potentially it will be sparking a nuclear war. > (and if covid-19 were a bioweapon, why would people be anti-mask anti-vax?) Theres different groups of conspiracy theorists. In this case they are not anti-mask at all, although for vax I was recently warned we don't know if the vaccine is actually part of China's ploy to infect people so we should be cautious.
- 082349872349872 6y agoAh, ok. Good luck!
- 6y ago
- wil421 6y ago> This is not the first time YouTube has been linked to radicalization and white supremacist content. There has been an ongoing argument about whether YouTube’s algorithm pushes people toward more extreme views over time. I can see this in the small tech bubble I’m apart of. Right now I’m bombarded with Apple M1 is the greatest ever! If I start to watch news stuff it seems like I go deeper and deeper into the videos that trigger the strongest emotional responses. Same with the Tech bubble, OMG Apple or Google did what!?!
- Siira 6y agoWell, the M1 is spectacular, so the algorithms are working correctly.
- wil421 6y agoIt works both ways. I remember antennae-gate and bend-gate blowing up at the time. I had both phones and never had an issue with either. If I believed YouTube both my phones were garbage and going to break. Can’t wait for my M1 air to come in.
- mxcrossb 6y agoI kind of wonder how much of this is intrinsic to human behavior and how much is based on media cues from our formative years. It seems really easy: play the right music, say things ominously, flash pictures. The people producing these videos aren’t experts on human psychology. They know how to manipulate with film. And maybe it’s because we spend our lives watching media, and we learn that certain cues make something reliable.
- ddevault 6y agoA good video which goes over this is The PewDiePieline: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pnmRYRRDbuw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pnmRYRRDbuw This should set your YT recommendations on a path for more relevant content if your interest is sustained. There is a lot to unpack with respect to how radicalization happens on YouTube and elsewhere.
- loughnane 6y agoi've got a preteen son who spends time on youtube, and I can't block it with pihole because there are tons of really awesome things on there. Currently he's geeking out on animal facts. What I've done as a bit of a middle ground is to use ublock to strip away the recommendation sections and comments. He can still search and watch whichever videos, and even look at all the videos on a particular channel, but at least he's not getting sucked down a rabbit hole. I've had the conversation with him that its not that I don't trust him rather I know how distracting those things can be and have found them detrimental even to my own attention/life. Of course he'll probably go around them eventually as he learns how things work and finds some motivation to do so, but in the meantime he gets a cleaner experience of the internet. FWIW these are the rules. They might be breaking something, but they're working alright for now. www.youtube.com###related www.youtube.com##.ytd-comments www.youtube.com###content > .ytd-rich-item-renderer.style-scope
- Cantbekhan 6y agoYou can use Google family link to force his account into parental control and force Youtube into safe mode (if he's logged in). You can also force this using DNS to prevent him from accessing non family friendly content.
- loughnane 6y agoDNS will only let me block specific domains, right? So I can't do blocking of specific channels that way (though I do use a nice big blocklist for adult content [0]) Google is a bit of a non-starter for me unfortunately. Their tools for protecting kids' eyes from content are probably great, but then their just building a catalog of my kids' viewing habits from a really young age... which I find off-putting. Maybe if that was the only way to block I'd go down that road, but there are others. [0] https://raw.githubusercontent.com/chadmayfield/my-pihole-blocklists/master/lists/pi_blocklist_porn_all.list https://raw.githubusercontent.com/chadmayfield/my-pihole-blo...
- OneGuy123 6y agoSaying that youtube/conspriancy theories caused his to shoot people is the same as saying that metal music or video games caused this. A mentaly ill person is a mentally ill person: it doesn't matter what triggers him because he is mentally ill and then they'll point their finger on the thing he read/listened instead of focusing on the fact that he was mentally ill. No sane person will shoot up a school because of right-wing radicalization or video games.
- prawn 6y agoQuoted further up: "He said after being assessed by the psychologist and psychiatrist, there was no evidence the terrorist suffered from any mental disorders or psychiatric conditions, or that he showed any clinically significant cognitive impairment. The psychologist determined he displayed a range of traits akin to a personality dysfunction, but not to such an extent as to constitute a personality disorder..."
- pjc50 6y agoThe report is huge, but a couple of sections that might be of specific interest are https://christchurchattack.royalcommission.nz/the-report/part-6-what-public-sector-agencies-knew-about-the-terrorist/bruce-rifle-club-allegations/ https://christchurchattack.royalcommission.nz/the-report/par... : someone visited his rifle club beforehand and reported various red flags to the police - literally, Confederate flags, "militia" uniforms, racism https://christchurchattack.royalcommission.nz/the-report/part-9-social-cohesion-and-embracing-diversity/hate-crime-and-hate-speech/ https://christchurchattack.royalcommission.nz/the-report/par... : a discussion of the existing NZ (and international!) laws on hate speech and incitement, and suggestions for tuning them.
- nz-throwaway 6y agoI read the section of the report on the rifle club which you linked, and thought I should point out that it concluded no report was ever made to the police. The confederate flag claim was also retracted, although the person then claimed they had seen confederate stickers. It was established some club members wore camouflage though, and one member said there might be occasional racist comments. It's definitely not the kind of group I'd ever want to be around, but it seems some of the claims may have been exaggerated or fabricated, and the person who made them does not come off as very credible in the report.
- kypro 6y agoI've been on this journey myself, not that I'd ever harm anyone, but I was definitly radicalised by some of the far-left areas of YT when I was younger. I lost a number of friends because I was so convinced I was morally correct and they were wrong on topics like immigration and capitalism. I'm aware of a few cases now where subscribers of TYT have killed people, but it's hard to know how direct those conncetions are. I know for me TYT definitely misled me and caused me to believe everyone who didn't share my views were evil and I have wondered before what I might have done had I been a violent person. I don't really know what the answer to this is. I know for me YouTube was also part of my deradicalisation process. Listening to people like Sam Haris allowed me to shift into the centrist I am today. Given the very low numbers of people who people who commit violent acts like these part of me wonders if we exaggrate the problem. Young men have always been fairly poltically radical. I think it would be incorrect to assume radicalisation is any higher today because of the internet. These types of events have happened for a very long time. I know often findings like this are followed by calls for censorship, and it does bother me today when I see content online obviously lying or misleding people about news stories to push a certain narrative. Still, given how poor of a job YouTube and factcheckers have done at trying to combat this stuff (as they often also have their own political agenda) I'm personally not convinced censorship is the right answer.
- sleepysysadmin 6y ago>I've been on this journey myself, not that I'd ever harm anyone, but I was definitly radicalised by some of the far-left areas of YT when I was younger. I lost a number of friends because I was so convinced I was morally correct and they were wrong on topics like immigration and capitalism. I can sympathize. It's worse off in Canada. We literally watched far left stuff in school. Not once did they ever show anything even marginally conservative. >I'm aware of a few cases now where subscribers of TYT have killed people, but it's hard to know how direct those conncetions are. I did not know that. Are you refering to Armenian Genocide or like TYT channel has created violent antifa type people? >I know for me TYT definitely misled me and caused me to believe everyone who didn't share my views were evil and I have wondered before what I might have done had I been a violent person. I too saw many of their videos years ago and they made lots of sense. They quite wrongfully portrayed Republicans as all nazis and KKK. Or at least a minimum of racists. Mind you, I'm not American nor do I live there. I don't particularly care about the republicans. For all I know they are all racists. >I don't really know what the answer to this is. I know for me YouTube was also part of my deradicalisation process. Listening to people like Sam Haris allowed me to shift into the centrist I am today. I followed Sam before TYT era mainly during the Hitchens and Dawkins time. Sam is very smart but I've been listening to him lately and boy is he ever deranged on Trump. I suppose every president has the Clinton Crazies equivalent. It's very interesting to see Sam not rational about Trump. Everyone is vulnerable to this radicalization. The interesting thing, the very first republican president. Lincoln. He has a policy of like Ben Franklin. "Speak ill of no man, but speak all the good you know of everybody." Yet he had a derangement like no other. Ended up creating a civil war and getting assassinated. >I know often findings like this are followed by calls for censorship, and it does bother me today when I see content online obviously lying or misleding people about news stories to push a certain narrative. That's completely happening. Even wikipedia has politically sided. https://larrysanger.org/2020/05/wikipedia-is-badly-biased/ https://larrysanger.org/2020/05/wikipedia-is-badly-biased/ >I'm personally not convinced censorship is the right answer. It's definitely not. Here in Canada we absolutely have extensive censorship. VPNs are becoming increasingly popular for Canadians.