4 ms·
One pedestrian death due to cars occurs on average every ~200 million car-driven miles. Is that really bad? (the math is based on # of US miles driven in 2017
by dekhn 6y ago
One pedestrian death due to cars occurs on average every ~200 million car-driven miles. Is that really bad?
(the math is based on # of US miles driven in 2017 divided by the number of car-caused pedestrian fatalities in the same year)
- lr4444lr 6y agoIt's the loss of agency to machines, not the raw numbers that scares people. Why do you think so many people are unduly spooked after airline accidents due to mechanical or computer error?
- waterhouse 6y agoI would say that, when I think about it occasionally, I am kind of scared by the possibility that someone will hack into all the self-driving machines (from a particular vendor) and make them all do something terrible at once—before anyone has time to deploy countermeasures.
- contingencies 6y agoIt went as an unspoken, unquestionable assumption that telephony was the right model for data networking. - Van Jacobson Maybe a single 'driver' agent in a free-moving ground vehicle in close proximity to vulnerable actors and objects is not the right model for scalable, efficient, safe personal transport?
- colechristensen 6y agoIt’s the fundamentally different kind of danger from machines. They make mistakes we can’t understand. I can understand a person being distracted, reacting slowly, not seeing me, etc. I can also mitigate this risk. Crossing the street I can make eye contact with a person and be really confident that they aren’t going to run me over. Walking in front of a robot? I have no internal model for the kind of mistakes they make. It seems equally likely in any circumstance that they’ll make the mistake of running me down, and there is nothing i can do to avoid it.
- jfoster 6y agoYou do develop an internal model for the behaviour of machines, though. Examples: Elevators where the doors take extremely long to close on their own. Elevators where the doors close too soon after opening. Elevators where the limb sensors are not very responsive. Cars that take a couple of tries to start in cold weather. Automatic doors that are a little bit slow to open. Etc.
- gotostatement 6y agobut those dont happen at 60+ miles per hour
- jfoster 6y agoOkay, let's use another example: lifts don't move until the doors are closed. If the lift thinks the doors are open, it won't move. If it did, it would be an out of control situation just as quickly as a car misbehaving at 60 mph is. The expectation is that autonomous cars must be cautious.
- gotostatement 6y agomy point is when we develop expectations and mental models of how machines work, we can use those to adapt and feel safe and in control. but that's less possible when the machine is typically moving at 60 mph and the mistake can happen without warning
- jfoster 6y agoLike elevators where the brakes fail. If it's infrequent enough, we tend not to think about it even if it does still happen from time to time.
- gotostatement 6y agoI see your point but for me at least, my gut feeling is the autonomous cars are just scarier because they're moving at 60 miles per hour. Maybe it's irrational but this whole discussion isn't about rationality its about gut feeling
- letitbeirie 6y agoWhich is ironic, because this is the kind of automation they've been building into planes for years and consequently air travel is safer than it's ever been. 737 Max fiasco notwithstanding - it's worth mentioning that MCAS had nothing to do with flying the plane, only making it feel more like the 737NG to its human pilots
- sofixa 6y ago> it's worth mentioning that MCAS had nothing to do with flying the plane, only making it feel more like the 737NG to its human pilots Not entirely true, the original issue is that the engines are bigger and the center of gravity is moved forward ( because the 737's are too low), thus the planes tend to stall. MCAS is there to correct the stall so that they feel more like 737NGs, but the issue is forcing bigger engines on an obsolete design.
- mrguyorama 6y agoHow much machine learning and black box decision making does autopilot in a plane do? My understanding is none, or nearly none. VNAV follows GPS waypoints with well described, manually designed behaviors for things like climb rate, bank angle, etc. Autoland isn't machine learning either, and has such a large list of requirements to be allowed that it's basically like designing a self driving computer for a train.
- grumple 6y agoThere’s one death per hundred million miles driven. One per million would mean one in 2 drivers kill someone in their lifetime.
- dekhn 6y agocorrected- thanks. I hate being off by two orders of magnitude.
- arcticfox 6y agoIs that right? That seems phenomenally bad. I feel like I have normal American driving habits and I drive a standard 10k miles per year... So I'm going to kill a pedestrian every 100 years? Assuming I drive normally for ~50 years, 500k miles, I have a 50% chance to kill a pedestrian?
- dekhn 6y agoonly assuming a random naive model. how careful you are and how dangerous the location also matter.
- thotsBgone 6y agoYeah, but it's also only counting pedestrian deaths.
- vincentmarle 6y ago25%
- Dylan16807 6y agoDid they change the number? The comment says one pedestrian death per 200 million miles right now, which is in the right ballpark and gives you a chance of 0.25%
- dekhn 6y agoyes I updated the number. Sorry about that.
- akira2501 6y ago1 out of 6 traffic fatalities is a pedestrian. Roads are designed poorly, ice exists, cities are built on steep hills, and people walk at night on the side of county highways.
- jfoster 6y agoPedestrian deaths are not the only bad thing that can happen when driving.
- lmm 6y agoMotorists are IIRC the third-biggest killer of young people.
- jeffbee 6y agoDepending on what you consider young, it's the #1 cause for ages 15-24, #2 for ages 5-14 in the US.
- marcinzm 6y agoI mean only counting the 5000 pedestrian deaths ignores the 137000 emergency room visits by pedestrians due to cars. Many of which probably involve massive suffering and lifelong disability. It also ignores the 38000 car occupants that die every year due to accidents. And the 3,000,000 injuries to car occupants each year of which 2,000,000 include permanent injuries. So cherrypicking the smallest number seems very disingenuous to me.
- z3rgl1ng 6y agoPretty terrible that it takes that long; Uber managed to do it in just over 6 million miles! </s>
- deegles 6y agoThat is true, but what if it was the same car (software) killing every pedestrian? Right now every situation is unique, but being judged based on who wrote the software is the worst case scenario for self-driving regulation IMO.