27 ms·
Good idea. Fighting it only makes the product more valuable, and the cartels more powerful. In the Netherlands we have really good experience with legalisation
by GekkePrutser 6y ago
Good idea. Fighting it only makes the product more valuable, and the cartels more powerful.
In the Netherlands we have really good experience with legalisation. Cannabis is legal and hard drugs (or substitutes) are provided to long-term addicts only. It drives prices down, reducing black market profits and thus the power of cartels. Promotes legal vendors to abide by rules (or they'll lose their license) and makes it possible to have checks on the products to make sure they're safe, not mixed with real toxins. And the lower street price reduces crime around drugs (like theft, addicts stealing to pay for their hit)
Banning drug use by force is a US pipe dream. It's impossible. All it provides is a pork barrel for drug agencies, weapons manufacturers etc. It escalates the price. They haven't made a dent in the 40 years of the war on drugs. When the demand doesn't cease, all you do is make the product more expensive and the ones that provide it more powerful.
PS: I never used drugs of any kind (except alcohol ;) )
- YorickPeterse 6y ago> Cannabis is legal It's technically illegal by law, it's just condoned/tolerated under certain regulations. There have been plans to make it fully legal, but it's not really going anywhere if I'm not mistaken.
- intricatedetail 6y agoCorrect. Cannabis in coffee shops comes from black market and is not regulated in any way. Government basically gives organised crime tax free market of a highly desirable product.
- roywashere 6y agoIn most of the USA cannabis is much more allowed than in The Netherlands nowadays!
- joejerryronnie 6y agoIn the Bay Area, I can roll into a high end dispensary that feels like a Beverly Hills wellness spa. The breadth of product is amazing and the associates are super positive and knowledgable. Almost feels a bit bougie :)
- redisman 6y agoYes the EU is much more stuck in the 70's on the war on drugs than the US. I still respect the Dutch for moving on it first but the experience in say Oregon or Colorado is on a whole another level and slowly making its way through most of the states. https://www.mpp.org/states/ https://www.mpp.org/states/ for a state-level overview, it changes quite a bit every year
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> In most of the USA cannabis is much more allowed than in The Netherlands nowadays! Given what I've seen in the US, I would think legalizing/decriminalizing psilocybin (truffles in NL) to be way more beneficial for Society as a whole. At least offer it as a service for mental health issues rather than drown people in SSRIs and every anti-depressent known to man. Denver, Oakland, and Oregon now are the only ones where its not met with extremely harsh punishments. And taxes from Cannabis is actually helping create the infrastructure for drug abuse treatment and mental illness in OR, something that Portugal had done much earlier when it decriminalized all drugs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- emsy 6y agoThat’s not quite right. Cannabis in the Netherlands is decriminalized. The production is downright illegal, but it’s not pursued by the law enforcement. Other than that I agree with the rest of your comment.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoYes but it's a range... You can make something 100% legal, or just remove the huge penalties. It's the harsh penalties that attract the worst people because those are the only ones willing to risk them. It hardens the entire trade.
- Semaphor 6y agoI always found it a bit hilarious, what’s the de facto difference between something being legal, and it being decriminalized to the point where you have stores selling it? Not a rhetorical question.
- jmccaf 6y agoNot a rhetorical question. 1 concern with the growing cannabis industry in the united states is the limitations on banking and finance for cannabis. The harmful side-effect of a state-legal cannabis industry but denied access to banking can lead to holding too much cash on hand and robberies like : https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/11/04/person-shot-by-police-after-oakland-marijuana-business-robbed-officers-injured/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/11/04/person-shot-by-police...
- EpicEng 6y ago>Good idea. Fighting it only makes the product more valuable, and the cartels more powerful. Yes, but those cartels can still offer more than the government is offering (or use other, nastier means of persuasion) and their primary market doesn't live in Columbia. Not sure this will help all that much.
- Spivak 6y agoBut this is true of every industry and having to compete with above-board drug prices makes their product less valuable. The risk of dealing with a black market seller has to come with a deep discount to make it worth it. When they’re the only game in town that risk is just part of the normal cost.
- throwbacktictac 6y agoRight, the foreign demand is not going away. I only see it causing the price to increase. But sure enough, there will be organized chrime getting dope to where it needs to be.
- saiya-jin 6y agoWhile I love how NL handles drugs, its not legal there, citing wikipedia [1]: Cannabis in the Netherlands is illegal, but is decriminalised for personal use. Recreational consumption of the drug is tolerated, and it is available in coffee shops. Much better compared to pretty much useless decriminalization-only approach some trump as holy grail - while miles better than punitive imprisonment of consumers like in US (or half the world), it still keeps all money flowing through drug cartels and very bad quality of potentially lethal substances. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannabis_in_the_Netherlands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannabis_in_the_Netherlands
- GekkePrutser 6y agoYes but it is effectively legal. Legalisation is a range from black to white. It's not fully white but 'gray'. In the Netherlands this is a very typical thing, it basically means it's legal but the government don't want to admit it to avoid causing international incidents or making a legal statement. I'm pretty sure it would have been fully legal if other states (Belgium, Germany) hadn't objected to their citizens crossing the border to get their drugs. But the coffee shops operate legally, their supply chain does not. It still means you can check for quality at the shops (and there have been no real issues there). As it's a commodity it drives down the price and thus the profits of the cartels. Some municipalities were even considering growing their own, using unemployed people working there on employment schemes. But it was shut down by the current government I believe.
- bzb6 6y agoComparing Colombia to the Netherlands is not appropriate. The results will be completely different.
- misja111 6y agoThe Dutch government makes a difference between soft drugs (e.g. Cannabis) and hard drugs (e.g. Cocaine), and for good reason. While most people don't get into trouble from using Cannabis, cocaine usage can wreck people's life. Unfortunately I have had to witness this a couple of times in my circle of friends. While criminalising hard drugs is not ideal, legalising them and thereby making them more easily available will have a devastating impact and destroy too many lifes.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoLike Alcohol? I haven't looked at the stats but I'm assuming alcohol has way more addiction than any other drug. I think the original posters point was that people are doing the drugs anyway, making it illegal may put a slight dent in usage, but it doesn't stop people from doing the drugs. And the number of lives ruined, the cartels, the massive police required, and the side effects from the war of drugs are much worse than if all drugs were decriminalized. The cartels are destabilizing entire governments in Latin America murdering police and journalists making entire regions inaccessible. It's real bad.
- anonfornoreason 6y agoI have friends who are alcoholics and definitely have negative impacts in both actions and health, but it's more of a slow boil. I've had friends that went down a very very fast spiral (1-2 years from normal to streets) when using hard drugs. Alcohol is harmful, but cocaine/meth/opiates are at least an order of magnitude worse.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoSo your friends did the hard drugs anyway even though they were illegal? I think you kind of support the case of why not make them legal.
- anonfornoreason 6y agoSorry, not intending to have my reply read as a support one way or another, just wanted to make sure to draw the distinction between alcohol and hard drug use. I see some people advocating for complete legalization claiming that alcohol use has terrible effects and is legal, so other drugs should be as well. I can only imagine those people haven't watched what a year of meth can do to a person, or that cocaine use is strongly correlated to other hard drug use as well, etc.
- mikepurvis 6y agoFor another data point, cannabis became legalized in Canada in 2018 [1]. I'm not a user of it myself, but I have a number of friends who are and one who is for pain management, and according to them, the rollout of licenses for legal storefronts has been pretty disastrous. Understandably, that's probably a transitional pain, and may be more of a bureaucratic hurdle than something germane to cannabis. But all this to say that changing these kinds of things takes a lot of careful planning; you can't just flip a switch to solve the problems of prohibition. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannabis_in_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannabis_in_Canada
- R0b0t1 6y agoThis is a good point, but in Canada's case it was self inflicted. They had a strong desire to limit the number of people in the market for, I think, very opaque reasons. Assuming it's just so politician's friends can become rich by being first movers.
- pmoriarty 6y ago"the rollout of licenses for legal storefronts has been pretty disastrous" Disastrous how?
- mikepurvis 6y agoInitially there weren't enough of them in many areas of Ontario [1], with a suspicious oversupply in others (for example in the Niagara region near the US border). Now there's a concern that the market has swung the other way and saturated in some parts of the country [2]. There's also been some weird ownership questions with former Toronto Police chief Julian Fantino who spend a decades-long career busting people for pot and opposing legalization only to have a come-to-Jesus moment about its medical benefits just in time to start a business around it and cash in. [1]: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/cannabis/article-mapped-ontarios-cannabis-store-shortage-isnt-ending-any-time-soon/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/cannabis/article-mapped-onta... [2]: https://www.retail-insider.com/retail-insider/2020/06/canada-could-become-over-saturated-with-cannabis-retail-stores/ https://www.retail-insider.com/retail-insider/2020/06/canada...
- pmoriarty 6y ago"Cannabis is legal" Not only is cannabis not legal in the Netherlands (it's "illegal but tolerated"), but in recent years the conservative Dutch government has been successful in closing down a lot of coffeshops (ie. shops that sell cannabis). The Dutch used to be a lot more tolerant in the past.
- capableweb 6y ago> The Dutch used to be a lot more tolerant in the past. And before that a lot less tolerant. And before THAT, a lot more tolerant. And back and forward, for many many years. Amsterdam has a rich history of going between liberal and more close minded, and will probably continue doing so.
- wobbly_bush 6y agoThat's interesting, what is the driving factor behind the inversions? Is it the typical two groups with opposing political views or something else?
- jjd33 6y agoDon't know about historic but current is US gov and "lobbying" industries paying massive amounts to have drugs banned. Why should you be allowed to use the safe Cannabis that doesn't have any side effects and is dirt cheap to produce instead of the overpriced overly toxic and overly marketed biochemical agent developed by for profit companies.
- taneq 6y agoThe same intergenerational pendulum that drives so many human social trends?
- vonadz 6y agoMoney?
- s_dev 6y ago
- MarkLowenstein 6y agoI like the cut of your jib. Also a never-user, but I've always thought that criminalizing the manufacture and distribution of drugs was the lazy way to combat the problem: fewer people to catch, bigger effect on the problem per arrest. It misses the mark of who's doing something really wrong though. I like to refer to dealers as "legitimate businessmen" for fun, because it's largely true. Of course dealers enforcing territory via violence are real criminals, but those problems would evaporate if the trade were no longer illegal. How do we combat the real toll of drugs on people's personal well-being then? A lot of them lead to broken lives. You could ban use, but that's hard to enforce and infringes on liberty. Instead, I would like to see a policy where your access to social safety nets is taken away when you're a user. You want to risk it all to get high? Go for it but don't leave us with the bill and having to wring our hands that you ended up homeless.
- mLuby 6y ago> Instead, I would like to see a policy where your access to social safety nets is taken away when you're a user. You want to risk it all to get high? Go for it but don't leave us with the bill and having to wring our hands that you ended up homeless. I understand the appeal of this posture; it appears to maximize individual liberty while avoiding the moral hazard that comes with a collective safety net. And it kind of works for celebrities and the rich, who can fall back on personal saving, (medical) professionals, and treatment centers when they enter a death spiral. But it is definitely not a solution for the vast majority of our economically fragile citizens, who make such poor long-term financial decisions that we had to institute all sorts of mandatory retirement contributions and taxes to keep people out of the poor houses. At that's not even considering how addiction disrupts long-term decision-making ability. TL;DR: Most people are bad at long-term planning, and are even worse when addicted, so the solution cannot involve only long-term consequences.
- Nuzzerino 6y ago> Banning drug use by force is a US pipe dream. It's impossible. Fine, but I have yet to see decriminalization policies (in the US) actually result in less usage, only less incarceration. You have to actually implement policies that solve the drug problem rather than ignore it. Many drugs are understandably bad ideas to opt-in for. If people are still using them, then they don't truly believe this. If you simply decriminalize drugs without also implementing measures to educate on this point, you're going to have a greater number of people who believe that using these drugs are a good idea. When you have a nation of junkies, there are immeasurable costs and other consequences. And these consequences have further reach than the cartels.
- capableweb 6y ago> Banning drug use by force is a US pipe dream. It's impossible. All it provides is a pork barrel for drug agencies, weapons manufacturers etc. It escalates the price. They haven't made a dent in the 40 years of the war on drugs. When the demand doesn't cease, all you do is make the product more expensive and the ones that provide it more powerful. After many years on this planet, I've reached the conclusion that when bodies of people decide over other bodies of people, they don't always have their best intention for them, even if they tell you so. The War on Drugs has not been good for anyone except for the people who been waging it. If you're in the business of making weapons, you need a threat. If there is none, you need to make up one. If you're low on criminals, make more stuff illegal. Bam, now you have a lot of criminals, and some of them armed, even better. The dream of "War on Drugs" is not to stop drugs. It's to make money will proclaiming you're against drugs.
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoIf you can own both sides of a conflict then your profit potential is huge. This is pretty much impossible unless you're a government or a corporate with government-sized revenue and tendrils into government. Wasn't the Iran-contra thing funded by selling crack to poor, predominantly African-American neighbourhoods in the US? Selling out their own citizens for foreign policy, or is that conspiracy theory?
- capableweb 6y agoApart from Oakland Tribune at one point writing about that the US government was selling drugs to fund arms in other countries, I don't think the whole "selling crack to poor" thing has been factually proven (yet). That doesn't take away the fact that they sold weapons to an embargoed country in order to fund right-wing paramilitaries, which is horrible in it's own, but drugs doesn't seem to have been involved as we're seeing with The War on Drugs.
- rollulus 6y agoCannabis is not legal in The Netherlands and I could only wish our policy was as sensible as you suggest. To quote [1] “Notably absent from toleration of drugs is its production, particularly the cultivation of cannabis. This has led to a seemingly paradoxical system where coffee shops are allowed to buy and sell soft drugs but where production is nearly always punished.” [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_the_Netherlands https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_the_Netherlan...
- dr_dshiv 6y agoAt the beginning of the covid lockdowns, they closed down all the coffeeshops in the Netherlands. That lasted ONE day before the authorities quickly realized it was creating a windfall for the illegal drug dealers. So, they simply went to take-out only.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brnt 6y agoIt is a myth the Netherlands are handling drugs well. Reports on 'ondermijnende criminaliteit' are muffled away, but meanwhile agencies and police are reporting that this industry is something the size of the Italian mafia and are every bit as criminal (and are in fact well connected internationally and often inventees of said Mafia). Maybe this is overlooked because urban users are far from the illegal labs and most killings, but things are nowhere near a 'good experience'. Legalisation of weed has only attracted the worst of the worst and police and 'opsporingsdiensten' don't have the resources to stop the trade, pollution or shootings. Check any reputable publication for articles, e.g. 1. https://www.groene.nl/artikel/een-industrie-die-over-lijken-gaat https://www.groene.nl/artikel/een-industrie-die-over-lijken-... 2. https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2019/12/17/italiaanse-maffia-experts-nederland-is-naief-a3984134 https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2019/12/17/italiaanse-maffia-exper... 3. https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/ondermijning/ondermijnende-criminaliteit https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/ondermijning/onderm... 4. https://www.ad.nl/binnenland/albanezen-verdringen-mocromaffia-op-de-drugsmarkt~a9bb0199/ https://www.ad.nl/binnenland/albanezen-verdringen-mocromaffi... 5. https://www.telegraaf.nl/nieuws/125305/nederland-narcostaat https://www.telegraaf.nl/nieuws/125305/nederland-narcostaat
- throwa20201203 6y agoPlease forgive the nuisance but would you mind noting -- how can we check what you mean by "reputable"? The reasons I'm asking: current media climate; long history of white-supremacist thinking in that area of this space-rock; etc [edited to add:] Also, as mentioned elsewhere in this thread -- the Dutch government has been taking a certain kinda turn. I'm also asking as someone whose family has been affected by the opiate epidemic in the US. I'm someone who's concerned about drug policy, first domestically but also globally. I want harm reduction. I'm in the middle of a career change and may be focusing on this going forward (if I can find out how). So I promise you, I'm not trying to beg-the-question, I'm legitimately curious about your comment and just trying to deal with the language barrier.
- brnt 6y agoYou can check reporting of the Social Planbureau, Politie, of which some gets through to rijksoverheid.nl. Then there the usual suspects of publications that still maintain dedicated investigative journalists such as De Groene Amsterdammer and FTM. NRC and Volkskrant on occasion. De Telegraaf is an unusual exception to the pattern because their journalism is afwul, except their crime reporting (it sells so they pay for it). You can also checkout where journalistic prizes go. Keywords are ondermijnende of ontwrichtende criminaliteit.
- czbond 6y ago> Banning drug use by force is a US pipe dream. It's impossible. Is it though? If harder drugs were legal, wouldn't harder drug use be much more common? Cannabis is one thing, the perceived impact to oneself is relatively low. Meth, a hard, illegal drug - is growing in some areas radically; so are some prescription drug use. There is a large group of citizens who don't try things because they are illegal (because they don't want to bring legal trouble) rather than not trying those things because they are bad for health. (Humans are fairly bad at rejecting things that are bad for them - but good at numbing them). eg: Alcohol, smoke, caffeine, soda, refined sugar.
- vb6sp6 6y agoDrugs have been illegal in the US for a long time. They are still here and, as you noted, usage is going up for some things. The "war on drugs" is over. Drugs won. Other countries practice "harm reduction" while the US is still trying to punish people for their "moral failings".
- simonbarker87 6y agoIt’s a totally fair assessment however, imo, many of the trouble that drugs cause for society are caused by the illegality and stigma. Addicts less likely to seek help, more likely to be arrested, loose their job, steal for money to pay exorbitant prices due to its illegal nature, develop health issues that are a drain on resources, relapse due to bad social situations from the above and overuse because of poor quality control. I have a dream of a regulated, taxed and controlled industry from which the profits are used to fund rehab, drug education and social programs to help communities. Is it aggressively progressive? Yes! Is it a bit a scary? Yes! Is it potentially better than the current situation? I think so. I’ve never used drugs. I don’t drink alcohol and haven’t for over a decade (never had a problem, just choose not to) and I don’t drink caffeine - I don’t say this to make myself out to be a saint (my wife can provide a detailed list of my flaws) but I don’t see the system that we currently have as optimal and think we should try something new. Let the down votes commence.
- icameron 6y agoIt certainly is impossible to stop drug use with force. Telling Americans not to do something they want to do has never worked. Not in the British colonies, and even today with wearing masks during a pandemic: there are some people willing to throw punches rather than be told to wear a mask. Something about personal freedom, liberty to pursue happiness, its engrained in the psyche of the population. They won't do what you tell them to. That being said, I think you over estimate the number of people who don't use hard drugs simply because its illegal. There is also a stigma, financial cost, health conscious reasons, or just don't like the effects or side effects.
- honksillet 6y agoIt strikes me that, at least in the west, you could legalize cocaine but you probably would not find anyone willing to produce it because of the liability from cardiac sudden death.
- steve76 6y agoSo I can here looking for news on the NIN visual cortex prosthetics. I got sucked into this instead. Addict someone to drugs. Face criminal charges if you want to call yourself an USA citizen. Simple as that. Otherwise, we talk about if it's okay to ex-parte kill the drug dealer who's OD'ing my kid. Repealing prohibition didn't end crime at all. Gangs, first thing they do is buy the bar or a strip club. I hate those people. They ruined my life. If they get to poison my family and make billions and flaunt it. I get to try to cook up something with CRISPR, and use them to reverse hemianopia from a stroke due to their poison campaign. Only reason I write this is I heard that keeping secrets is bad for you. It's a form of reversing the development process and creating a separate self. Only reason my life is over and I can't pursue what I want is because I'm taking care of a blind former heavy drug user. I was one myself so I'm not blameless. Only reason he's a drug user was because his parents were in battles you wouldn't believe in a war my nation was dragged into by your horrible horrible world. No amount of money or drugs will stop a drug user. The mania of drug use puts schizophrenia or bipolar to shame. True monsters who not only should be locked up, but are the root cause for why we have prisons and asylums in the first place. America's common portrayal is made by people who want our blood, want to take a shot at the king of the hill. Won't work. America's true character is really one of precision. Sun up, sun down, no mistakes. Perfection. We get to do that because of self-evidence. Not only does it need to be popular or be good and fun, but it has to stand on it's own. Legalize drugs, and what you're really doing is making drug dealers a protected class. Addict and OD each other with immunity. We should be raising the next generation with an accurate representation to the world, that it gets ugly and cut throat quick, and also raise something better because sooner than you think we'll need them to take care of us. Ten years, that's about all you get, then it's someone else's chance.
- suifbwish 6y agoPlot twist: the cartel stands to benefit a lot from hiring lawyers to lobby for keeping drugs illegal, same with banning firearms. Making something legal which was once a black market item means no one needs them anymore.
- briffle 6y agoSo does the country, if they start taxing it. They they will be heavily interested in officials demanding bribes, when they are tracking the value chain to make sure the state gets it cut
- cm2187 6y agoAnd at the same time trying to restrict or ban the consumption of tobacco or alcohol! That being said I am in the camp of legalising it all. Not to fight drug dealers. But because how can people be trusted to vote and decide on the future of the country but not trusted to decide on the future of their own life. I don’t believe in nanny states that tell you how to live your life. If people aspire to become a junkie, it’s their life, they only have one, they do whatever they want with it as long as they don’t bother anyone else.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoThis seems like an unrelated tangent
- greenkey 6y agoThanks for providing an example of the false altruism and anarchistic attitude of libertarianism: never did drugs, doesn’t mind if others hurt themselves and society. Might as well say “Columbia, go fuck it up.”
- vivekd 6y agoWhy can't we do both, ban drugs but provide a place addicts can go to get cheap regulated legal product with a doctor's note?
- chiefalchemist 6y agoI should start by saying, I'm not a drug user (sans alcohol) and I don't have a dog in this race either way. To me, it's simply an interesting topic to discuss. I'm not so sure Amsterdam is an accurate reference point. 1) Size. Was Amsterdam spending $1B fighting drugs? 2) We're not talking about cocaine being legalized, we're talking about the gov getting in the coke biz. The latter is a significant change in paradigm. 3) What are the unintended consequences? When that $1B spent on "fighting it" stops, what happens? Jobs lost? Etc.? Note: I'm not suggesting it's a bad idea per se, only that it's more complicated than "X works in Country Y."
- stevespang 6y agoSpot on.
- FpUser 6y ago>"...Banning drug use by force is a US pipe dream. It's impossible." I am all for changing the law. This particular argument is however weak. Bunning murders is just as impossible. We are not going to legalize murder however, are we? The law should be changed because of other reasons, not because of inability to enforce it 100%.