6 ms·
UN votes to remove cannabis from strictest drug category
- bitxbitxbitcoin 6y agoThis has been a long time coming.
- nkozyra 6y agoBut still in Schedule I with cocaine, heroin, methadone, morphine & opium. Isn't this kind of silly at this point? I'm not into weed (it's always weird to feel the need to append this disclaimer) but for God's sake at this point I think pretty much everyone recognizes where it lies on the harm spectrum and we still treat it like a deadly narcotic. The baby stepping toward doing something that seems to extraordinarily black-and-white - particularly in countries that have laws that allow cigarettes and alcohol - is really quite absurd.
- Scoundreller 6y ago> I think pretty much everyone recognizes This “vote” was 27-25. The 27 with a brain would best ignore this UN committee entirely. And stop any funding to it too.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cmdshiftf4 6y ago>The 27 with a brain would best ignore this UN committee entirely. And stop any funding to it too. Anyone with a brain realized it's best to ignore the UN as an entity quite some time ago. I guess this time around the strongly worded letters will be what? In support of asking people to perhaps (please) reconsider their legislative approach to or classification of cannabis?
- throwaway894345 6y agoI tend to be pretty interested in opinions that go against the grain when they're interesting, but when it's just "anyone with a brain"--that's just rhetoric and not even very artful rhetoric at that.
- cmdshiftf4 6y agoIs it even going against the grain? The trope of the UN and their strongly worded letters has existed and been popularized for at least as long as I can remember. Is it really "against the grain" to simply make a call to their ineffectual, flaccid and outright farcical nature? And if one really wants to debate their farcical nature, one need only look at their most recent candidates for election to the Human Rights Council. Or their recent Universal Periodic Review where some of the worst modern assailants on human rights lined up for the 2 minutes hate in the name of virtue toward the USA. If someone is willing to defend the UN and prove they're anything but a farce, I'm all ears.
- hansjorg 6y agoThis is one way the 27 can influence the 25. What do you think the UN is?
- Scoundreller 6y agoI don’t see the 25 changing their stance because they lost a vote. This committee exists to take away people’s rights, not to give them any. I look forward to a UN vote on mandatory mask requirements (will never happen).
- free_rms 6y agoThe UN isn't a government, it's a meeting forum.
- Scoundreller 6y agoNot a government, but they do vote on where to send troops and step in when governments fail and decide who gets sent food, who gets loans.
- free_rms 6y agoIn rare cases, when no major or regional power is interested, they do that as the humanitarian backstop, yes. I'm pretty sure East Timor is the only case of their stepping in for a government. Could be wrong? Other examples?
- bigbubba 6y agoFrom what I have gathered from Wikipedia, East Timor has not been governed by the UN since 2002. However the UN still governs the Cyprus Buffer Zone, part of the Golan Heights, and Kosovo. In the past they have also governed Western New Guinea, Cambodia, and part of what is today eastern Croatia. Their administration of Cambodia in the early 90s seems particularly full fledged: > The United Nations Transitional Authority in Cambodia (UNTAC)[3] was a United Nations peacekeeping operation in Cambodia in 1992–93 formed following the 1991 Paris Peace Accords. It was also the first occasion on which the UN had taken over the administration of an independent state, organised and run an election (as opposed to monitoring or supervising), had its own radio station and jail, and been responsible for promoting and safeguarding human rights at the national level.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The 27 with a brain would best ignore this UN committee entirely. Several of the 27 (sufficient to deny any of them a majority) voted against other loosening recommendations on marijuana, so I'm not sure that voting to move it from “like heroin” to “like cocaine” means much.
- enriquto 6y agoDrug classification does not depend on the harm they do, but on a complex net of economic and political causes. There are very harmful drugs that are legal and regulated (like alcohol) and also many substances that are not explicitly regulated, regardless of how harmful they may be.
- nkozyra 6y agoSchedule 1 is specifically classified as: "contains the substances considered the most addictive and harmful."
- enriquto 6y agoThe name does not mean anything. What is the official name of North Korea again?
- nkozyra 6y agoI have no idea what this is supposed you mean. You told me: > Drug classification does not depend on the harm they do I'm telling you that's explicitly the opposite of how they intend to classify drugs.
- enriquto 6y agoWhat I mean is that: what they intend and what they say to intend are two completely different things.
- leetcrew 6y agothat's also true of schedule II. the key difference between I and II is whether there is any accepted medical use.
- Retric 6y agoThat’s not quite it either as opioids and pot have medical uses. The list is in effect arbitrary. (a) Schedule I shall consist of the drugs and other substances, by whatever official name, common or usual name, chemical name, or brand name designated, listed in this section. Each drug or substance has been assigned the DEA Controlled Substances Code Number set forth opposite it. (b) Opiates. Unless specifically excepted or unless listed in another schedule, any of the following opiates, including their isomers, esters, ethers, salts, and salts of isomers, esters and ethers, whenever the existence of such isomers, esters, ethers and salts is possible within the specific chemical designation (for purposes of 3-methylthiofentanyl only, the term isomer includes the optical and geometric isomers):
- colonwqbang 6y agoThere was a story some time ago about a high-profile politician in my country. She had shared a link to a parody newspaper article about teenagers at a party who died from "marijuana overdose". From her comment it was obvious that she didn't understand that the article was a fake, didn't understand that nobody ever died from a marijuana overdose.
- emteycz 6y agoContrary to poular belief, you can get "marijuana" (cannabidiol) overdose, albeit it's rare. It manifests with vomiting, abdomen cramps and feeling of serious sickness, which could be fatal (other drugs that can cause a fatal overdose often are not fatal by itself but by the secondary effect of suffocating with vomit or other). I'm speaking from experience. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK482175/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK482175/
- boogies 6y ago(Not that you can’t die from a Dihydrogen Monoxide overdose as well https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication.)
- boogies 6y ago(Not that I'm for recreational drug legalization, I may get downvoted to death¹ but I don’t actually think Prohibition was necessarily a bad idea, perhaps just badly implemented — it should have been phased in over decades like the Founding Fathers had hoped to do with slavery, and a local issue.) ¹Edit: interesting, about ten minutes after my higher post and 4 after this, this still has 1 point but its parent lost ⅓ of its peak 6.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> it should have been phased in over decades like the Founding Fathers had hoped to do with slavery The founding fathers were a mix of people who thought slavery today, tomorrow, and forever was the plan, people that wanted it gone ASAP, and everything in between. The compromise they came up with was to lock on it for a few decades absolutely plus give enormous power advantages to the people that economically depended on it to protect it going forward; there might have been some who hoped, or at least expected, it would be phased out over time after the lock in period, but for the most part even they would have been hoping future generations might overcome the barriers they set up that made they difficult, it's not like they built any foundation for it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aphextron 6y ago>Isn't this kind of silly at this point? I'm not into weed (it's always weird to feel the need to append this disclaimer) but for God's sake at this point I think pretty much everyone recognizes where it lies on the harm spectrum and we still treat it like a deadly narcotic. Not many people realize this yet, but weed is already legal in the US. With the legalization of "industrial hemp" [0], you can now buy cannabis sativa flower in all 50 states 100% legally. The law requires that it contain less than 0.3% THC by mass, so the strains you can get are selectively bred for that, but it actually isn't a big deal. CBD, and all the other cannabinoids in cannabis that aren't THC still absolutely get you high. You can also create extracts and cook with it for all the same effects as "regular" (high THC) weed. It's essentially like being able to buy beer but not liquor at this point. [0] https://www.brookings.edu/blog/fixgov/2018/12/14/the-farm-bill-hemp-and-cbd-explainer/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/fixgov/2018/12/14/the-farm-bi...
- bigyikes 6y agoMore like the difference between beer and kombucha, no? Liquor would be more akin to THC concentrates. I don’t think the effects of CBD are comparable to THC with respect to getting “high”, though I don’t know much about the other cannabinoids. Are you speaking from firsthand experience?
- jgrowl 6y agoI've tried CBD before and it mainly made me tired and slightly headachey. I can confirm Delta-8-THC at least will definitely get you very high. It feels slightly different than D9 but it is honestly hard to describe exactly how. Some describe it as being better for people that get anxious on d9 but I have also heard the opposite. I have seen some reports of people having really bad times from eating a ton of candies. Similar problems as with normal edibles, so regulators will feel compelled to step in. Mixing in a little bit of cbd or other cannabinoids seems to enhance the experience and make it more like normal flower.
- aphextron 6y ago>"I don’t think the effects of CBD are comparable to THC with respect to getting “high”, though I don’t know much about the other cannabinoids." It's not just about CBD. CBD is one of hundreds of cannabinoids contained in whole-flower cannabis sativa. The synergistic effect of them is what causes the effects of marijuana. THC is just one of many. >"Are you speaking from firsthand experience?" Absolutely, from someone who used medicinally for years in California.
- Reedx 6y ago> Isn't this kind of silly at this point? Yes. Fortunately we're almost there. In the US we have majority support (68%) and is just a matter of time before it's fully legalized. https://news.gallup.com/poll/323582/support-legal-marijuana-inches-new-high.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/323582/support-legal-marijuana-...
- Scoundreller 6y agoNo evaluation of how it got there in the first place and what other mistakes were made and continue to be made? Nobody can expect the “UN Committee of Narcotic Drugs” to be anything but a political tool.
- wait_a_minute 6y agoThis is great news. Should never have been on there to begin with.
- paulhallett 6y agoIt's slipping and sliding faster and faster. I'm keen to see the end of this stupid episode in history. The plant has so many positive and environmentally-friendly uses that it is completely absurdity to keep it banned.
- Scoundreller 6y ago> Wednesday's vote therefore does not clear U.N. member nations to legalize marijuana under the international drug control system. Canada and Uruguay have legalized the sale and use of cannabis for recreational purposes, but many countries around the world have decriminalized marijuana possession. I’ll add that Canada has faced zero consequences for ignoring this useless committee. I encourage all other countries to do the same.
- dbliss 6y agoYes, society has not crumbled here in Canada.
- ttul 6y agoIn fact, just about nothing changed, except that I have noticed teenagers seem less interested than ever in cannabis.
- nkozyra 6y agoThat's an interesting - and to me unsurprising - side effect. Weed is such a generally low-key anodyne that is basically tantamount to alcohol in effect. Take away the mystique of its illegality and it suddenly becomes a lot less interesting to teenagers.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoI was in Uruguay when cannabis for recreational use was legalized. The result was that downtown Montevideo was drenched in the smell of smoke, sometimes enough to make a passerby start coughing. Generally the smell of cannabis products doesn't bother me, but I know that many people find it rank and would prefer to avoid it. I did think it was odd that while some countries are gradually attempting to wipe out tobacco smoking in public – you can smoke somewhere theoretically, but not in the park, on your balcony in a block of flats, or (if children could be present) in your own home or car – a change had been made in Uruguay that only increased the amount of public smoking.
- FpUser 6y ago
- grecy 6y agoIt's so refreshing to have it completely normalized in Canada now. Like gay marriage (legal since 2005), it's just another thing that is perfectly common everyday, and nobody thinks it's a big deal or has to expend energy constantly fighting for the right.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> It's so refreshing to have it completely normalized in Canada now. Is it really completely normalized? Like are senior members of society such as judges, doctors, military officers, teachers, politicians, etc completely comfortable smoking cannabis in public or would that still cause some surprise if they were that casual about it? Because I don't think that is even the case with tobacco - people shamefully hide that even though it's always been legal - let alone cannabis? I think the only drug which is completely normalized is alcohol. They serve alcohol at state dinners and expect most people will want it. I doubt they serve cannabis.
- grecy 6y agoIt's really a lot more normal than I expected it would be so soon. It's very common to see people standing in public smoking weed, while it's almost always illegal to drink alcohol in public. Friends in Toronto don't even buy a bottle of wine for a Friday night dinner with friends anymore, they buy weed. Just the other day I was with a group of people who went out of their way to hide the beer cans they were walking with as a Police car drove past. They were openly smoking a joint the entire time. > Like are senior members of society such as judges, doctors, military officers, teachers, politicians, etc completely comfortable smoking cannabis in public or would that still cause some surprise if they were that casual about it? I don't think it's common to see people like that drinking alcohol in public, and weed feels kind of the same now. From a legal standpoint, anywhere you can smoke a cigarette, you can smoke weed.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> illegal to drink alcohol in public Huh? Canada has bars, pubs, restaurants, with people drinking in them in public all the time. > I don't think it's common to see people like that drinking alcohol in public, Here's Trudeau publicly drinking alcohol at an official function. https://toronto.citynews.ca/2017/11/08/the-wednesday-news-briefing-an-at-a-glance-survey-of-some-top-stories-68/ https://toronto.citynews.ca/2017/11/08/the-wednesday-news-br... I doubt there's a recent photo of him smoking a joint? Let alone smoking a joint while working and representing the country? What about finishing off a meal with an edible? I imagine your Parliament has an official bar on premises for members? Does it serve cannabis or just alcohol? Nonsense.
- ronlobo 6y agoThe vote was actually quite close, 27:25, which means there are still 25 people that don't get it. At the end of the day, the rulers realized that there is a huge market and billions to be made in this industry.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> there is a huge market and billions to be made in this industry. What canada has found is that this giant market is illusionary. Overall cannabis use has not increased after legalization. The same amount of money is being spent now as before. Yes, there is a slight tax income, but the reality is that people are getting it from the same people they used to. Everyone buys from friends and family just as before. So the government, and all those investors, are not seeing the predicted profits.
- pmoriarty 6y ago"the reality is that people are getting it from the same people they used to" I've read that the Canadian government mandated that legal cannabis be limited in potency, so that in order to get high potency cannabis people are forced to go to the black market. Could such potency limits be what's keeping the Canadian black market alive?
- sandworm101 6y agoNo idea. Never been in the market myself. I do hear that the commercial stuff is too expensive. And why pay full price for a plant, a weed, you can grow in a closet? Everyone just knows someone who grows more than they can use themselves. They then sell it to friends for next to nothing.
- sharpneli 6y agoSo wait. According to UN cannabis was more strictly limited than cocaine? Based on perusal on the drug categories before this change one could get prescription of cocaine but not cannabis. This is absolutely hilarious.
- scns 6y agoWhen you smuggle cocaine and get caught, you can be sentenced for tax evasion, since cocaine is used as a local anaestethic for eye operations.
- wincy 6y agoThe thinking goes that cocaine has use as a medicine for end of life care (milk of the poppy and all that). I worked with a guy who used to be a pharmacist that would mix it for end of life patients. They got raided by the DEA once, despite being above board and not breaking any laws. Marijuana is seen as having no medically accepted use, therefore it’s more illegal than cocaine. This just happens to work out for those with more money who are more likely to do cocaine than they are schedule 1 drugs like marijuana and crack (which is basically refined cocaine)
- nerdponx 6y agoMarijuana is seen as having no medically accepted use, therefore it’s more illegal than cocaine. Except at this point it's obvious to even the most arrogant "evidence-based" medicine advocate that marijuana is indeed medically useful, and moreover that it is neither highly addicting nor dangerous, and that Schedule 1 classification for it makes absolutely no medical or legal sense.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The thinking goes that cocaine has use as a medicine for end of life care (milk of the poppy and all that). “Milk of the poppy” is obviously a stand-in for opiates (derived from the opium poppy), not cocaine. But, yes, There is a history of cocaine being used with opiates as a pain treatment, especially in end-of-life cases. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brompton_cocktail https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brompton_cocktail
- pizza 6y agoSorry but I'm having a hard time understanding this. It's been removed from schedule IV, but remains in schedule I.. Schedule I seems to me to be the strictest category. AFAICT they just removed it from schedule IV, which.. doesn't seem to be the strictest drug category?
- jedimastert 6y agoFYI for those in the US: the MORE act, which * decriminalizes marijuana, * removes it from the schedule system entirely, * appears to just duct tape it to existing tobacco laws, and * reinvests the funds in communities disproportionately effected by the "war on drugs" just passed the House Rules Committee and goes up for vote in the house some time this week. The question is whether this will ever get through the senate
- badconvincer 6y agoNot with connie
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ehsankia 6y ago> The question is whether this will ever get through the senate Is it really though? I assumed it was 100% for show, to have something they can use in campaign ads. I see 0% probability of it coming to the senate. So the House is just passing a bunch of laws that look good on their resume.
- tyre 6y agoEven if Democrats win the two GA senate seats and are therefore the majority (50 + VP), this will not pass. As a country, we are not there yet. 2022 Senate races are far too important to be trying to get ahead of where the country is. You lose suburban moms.
- vmception 6y agoAlso, everything in Congress right now gets erased on January 3rd at the end of the 116th session.
- free_rms 6y agoThe country is actually way ahead of the politicians on this stuff though. Red states are getting there ahead of blue politicians. I think it's more of a generational thing.
- neom 6y agoIf I was established in the cannabis industry or looking to start something in the space, I'd pay attention to the countries that don't currently have federal legalization but voted to remove it: https://jedgar.netlify.app/pics/weed.jpeg https://jedgar.netlify.app/pics/weed.jpeg
- carlob 6y agoNitpick: federal only applies to countries like the US or Germany, which are federations, I think the term you were looking for is national. As to your other claim I'm not so sure I agree with you: Italy has decriminalized all drug use a long time ago, but legalization of cannabis seems at least a decade away. In the current political climate it's ok to say that addicts should not be jailed, but there is still a lot of moral panic around distribution.
- neom 6y agoI knew that as well! I was sitting there thinking, federal doesn't make sense but I can't remember what the right word is. Thanks for that. :)
- Sigmoid 6y agoRecreational marijuana use is a net negative on society. I've seen so many people in my life become addicted to it. It hurts to see it portrayed as cool in modern pop culture and it hurts to see people who want to legalize it ignore the long term down sides. It may not cause liver damage like alcohol, but it still has the same dark impact on your psyche.
- pizza 6y agoI don't really disagree with you that it can have its downsides but I think that attaching legal consequences to its use doesn't help people who need help. Imagine if you had to go to jail if you were an alcoholic.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hu3 6y agoWhy is this post already relegated to page 2 of HN despite having 129 points within 55 minutes of being posted? my guess is that it got flagged to death.