13 ms·
Post PC
- ryukafalz 6y ago> They also don’t see performance along new dimensions which devices offer with glee. For example connectivity to cellular networks (still missing in even the fanciest laptop but available on my watch.) What? Laptops with cellular connectivity have been available for years.
- disposekinetics 6y agoI have never wished my laptop had cellular connectivity, I have always used a portable hotspot for that.
- ryukafalz 6y agoPortable hotspots are nice, sure - I do have one. Still feel like it'd be more convenient to have cellular connectivity built right in though; you always have some connectivity then provided you're not too remote. I've considered switching to Google Fi solely because they provide data-only SIMs associated with your normal plan that I could then pop into a laptop. (Rather than making you pay twice as most providers do.) Haven't been able to justify it yet though, I'm on a pretty good grandfathered plan at the moment.
- lumost 6y agothe extra price per device that carriers charge makes this cost prohibitive. I'd be very interested in a laptop with cell service if I had a shared data plan across N personal devices.
- ryukafalz 6y ago> I'd be very interested in a laptop with cell service if I had a shared data plan across N personal devices. My understanding is that's what Google Fi does: https://support.google.com/fi/answer/6330195?hl=en https://support.google.com/fi/answer/6330195?hl=en They seem to be nearly the only ones, at least that I've found. (But I'd be glad to find more!)
- Jaruzel 6y agoHere in the UK we're starting to see data only SIMS with 100GB+ per month limits for only £20 p/m. To me this seems that the era of 'always connected' laptops is almost upon us.
- SahAssar 6y agoSo you have wished for it, you just used another device as a bridge to get it.
- jiri 6y agoI have (and had) laptop with slot for sim card for years but I never bothered to buy a sim card. I have gigabit ethernet port at work, at home, fast low latency wifi everywhere ...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"But I'm also willing to bet you're reading this on a phone." How much are you willing to bet? What is interesting about this website is that it isn't accessible via https, archive.org nor search engine cache. These increasingly rare holdout sites cause me to take note of just how much I have had to change the software and configurations I use in order to accomodate the rise of manadatory TLS use (at least on sites posted to HN).
- StanislavPetrov 6y ago> "But I'm also willing to bet you're reading this on a phone." Chuckled a little as well as I read this on my PC.
- simonh 6y agoIn a bet on total readership split, you would lose.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 6y ago> How much are you willing to bet? I bet if (post-facto) they got $1 for each person reading on a phone and paid $1 for each person reading on a not-phone, they would come out ahead.
- Metus 6y agoThe data for the website I work on shows four out of five people on mobile and one out of five on desktop. So I certainly would take your bet.
- alwillis 6y ago"But I'm also willing to bet you're reading this on a phone." Web use from phones surpassed desktop several years ago. Anyone with a general purpose news site can see from their server logs/Google analytics they get more traffic from phones than PCs. https://leftronic.com/mobile-vs-desktop-usage/ https://leftronic.com/mobile-vs-desktop-usage/
- onli 6y ago> PC cameras are comical in comparison. PCs usually do not have cameras. Laptops do, sometimes. But they are not meant to take photos - would you carry your laptop around for that? The article does not get the facts right. There is huge R&D investment on the side of the big PC hardware manufacturers, just look at the big ones, AMD, Intel and Nvidia. There are also really nice Windows/Linux laptops. And great peripherals, with big changes over the years, just compare modern cases like a Lancool II 215 (which isn't even expensive) to what was common a decade ago. And of course the PC market did not grow as much as the smartphone market in the last decade - smartphones started from zero (well, add a few years), while many people that need a laptop or a PC do have one already. Nonetheless the available market numbers for PC components and systems are not as bad as articles like this make it seem - and that was true even before the pandemic. Writers like this just always forget that when they want to paint a negative picture of PCs in favour of smartphones/tablets or when there is another round of "consoles will end PC gaming", which was never true in the slightest. There is no need for a closed off hardware platform like the Mac to save the PC.
- EricE 6y ago"There is huge R&D investment on the side of the big PC hardware manufacturers, just look at the big ones, AMD, Intel and Nvidia." Those are the only significant sources of R&D for PC hardware. None of the big vendors - Dell, HP, Acer are NOT doing basic R&D. Crap, HP is where good technology goes to die or whither away. All the stuff from DEC flushed down the toilet including Alpha (amazing processor - loved our NT Alpha systems back in the day), StrongARM (how ironic), Compaq (Still have my Personal Juke Box PJB-100 - first hard drive MP3 player with a solid lead on Creative and their awful thing, years before Apple and the iPod[and the PJB guys came from DEC now that I think about it]), Palm - don't get me started on Web OS. Itanium? Talk about making a bad partner choice, Intel. Didn't pay attention with Alpha? Then again Intel got StrongARM from HP and then pissed it away too. But I digress... The problem with the PC vendors is they are all pulling parts out of the same bin of least-common-denominator parts. Apple no longer is. We haven't seen the chips aimed at desktop use where battery life and thermal management will be far more flexible. I don't think Apple will focus on one single aspect like single core performance (which they are crushing all but AMD's newest with a 10 watt mobile part - 10 watts vs 50 watt desktop parts!) but overall system integration. Hardware accelerators. Neural Engine. ML cores. Stuff like that. Stuff we haven't even thought of yet. There is much speculation that Rosetta 2 got specialized hardware assistance which explains its ridiculous performance, esp. compared to the original Rosetta. Why not? Apple owns every transistor. M1 runs Intel code faster than the machines they replace. Apple can add what they want - and leave out what they don't need. Not just in the CPU but ANYWHERE in the system now. I think people are dramatically underestimating just how powerful having full vertical control really is. I suspect we are going to see it in a BIG way when they do release the desktops. Remember they really didn't need to do this processor transition; the only reason to totally disrupt their ecosystem is if the benefits DRAMATICALLY outweighed the disruption. They wouldn't commit to replacing all Mac's, including the Mac Pro, unless they thought they could carry the performance difference through all models. It just can't be marginally better. There will be no hackentosh with Apple Silicon. If Apple follows through and the desktop performance scales to what we have seen with what they introduced on their entry level hardware I guarantee you very few people are going to care AT ALL that these Mac's don't run Windows or really old software - especially in professional settings where computers aren't a hobby but tools to earn you money - and time is something you can't make more of. Needing less time is a competitive advantage. Religious debates will go out the freaking window in a heart beat if these new Macs are as dramatically different from everything else as I fully expect them to be. Otherwise why bother with Apple Silicon? If you can't have such a stark difference that detractors will just look silly, then why bother? But let's say they aren't embarrassingly better in performance and instead stay above M1 performance but not embarrassingly so (say multicore doesn't scale that well) they will still be the best Mac's made and still best the majority of PC's out there. Also just because the M1 Mac's don't support PCI Express or GPUs doesn't mean no chips will. Many people didn't think we would see Thunderbolt - yet these chips have it. And with AMDs latest graphics cards, I really don't care about Apple's rift with nVidia any more.
- leoc 6y ago> The term Post-PC was first coined by MIT scientist David D. Clark in 1999 and was quickly adopted by both Microsoft’s and Apple’s former CEOs. Up to a point, Lord Copper. See (once again) Jobs' discussion of the "Digital Hub" concept at Macworld 2001 San Francisco https://youtu.be/AnrM4n6S3CU?t=2585 https://youtu.be/AnrM4n6S3CU?t=2585 . This January 2000 Fortune interview https://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2000/01/24/272277/ https://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2000... is also relevant. It also turns out that Walt Mossberg described the Newton as 'a sort of “post-PC” device' in 1993: http://allthingsd.com/19930812/the-apple-newton-messagepad-review/ http://allthingsd.com/19930812/the-apple-newton-messagepad-r... .
- amelius 6y agoFunny thing is that an Apple computer or any smartphone deserves the title "Personal Computer" more than my Linux PC (which has multiple accounts which can be used simultaneously). I think we'll see more Personal Computers and devices in the future. For example, Oculus Quest is only usable with a personal Facebook account, so I would say it's a PC by definition.
- michaelmrose 6y agoMaybe you simply misunderstand the P in PC. PC's have offered multiple user accounts historically because they were expensive machine that might be used by multiple people. Most devices at this point are liable to be single user but aren't less personal for having a function you don't need. In fact even the iphone has a guided access feature https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202612 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202612 presumably partially so you can hand your kid the phone in a game and they can't accidentally share all your photos or spend your money.
- amelius 6y ago> Maybe you simply misunderstand the P in PC. Ok, what does the P stand for in your opinion? > In fact even the iphone has a guided access feature Imho, this is a much weaker form of device sharing than e.g. Linux accounts, where every user is treated equally.
- numpad0 6y agoP means you occupy all CPU time on a tabletop machine as opposed to normal computers or mini computers for which you share literally single CPU with multiple other users over VT100
- michaelmrose 6y agoA personal computer is one which regular people can own and control. At the dawn of the PC era this was a novelty with the contrast being very expensive systems that many users access over dumb terminals that weren't available to the general public.
- mst 6y ago> For example connectivity to cellular networks (still missing in even the fanciest laptop but available on my watch.) What? Lots of laptops have a sim card slot. My fairly long in the tooth Thinkpad Helix 2 does and so far as I can tell so do lots of the modern Lenovos. A quick google suggests that many Dell Latitudes do as well. I wonder if the author is accidentally conflating "fancy laptop" and "MacBook". Edited to add: I was getting 12h+ on thinkpads going back as far as 2005, the "all day battery life" thing isn't that new to me either though I'm sure the M1 based machines would last 18h+ given a similar level of use so it's still not at all shabby.
- protomyth 6y agoVerizon was selling cheap HP laptops with cellular years ago. We bought 120 of them for one grant.
- p1necone 6y agoI think this is one of those things that's more likely to be found in cheap devices, or devices intended for poorer markets - similar to dual sims in phones. It's something that's more useful in areas with poor internet connectivity.
- BatFastard 6y agoInterestingly enough in the past 3 years, I have purchased 4 phones, 1 tablet, 1 watch and one iMac. However I have upgraded 6 PCs with new graphics cards, SSD drives, motherboards, and processors. My children have gone from phones to PCs are their main method of consuming content. It just richer on a PC than anywhere else.
- novok 6y agoAt first the only computers you could use were trains (mainframes) Then they became buses (mini computers) Then they became pickup trucks (desktop PCs) Then they became vans (laptops) And now finally, they are sedans & SUVs (smartphones & tablets) One day, the motorcycle and electric scooter will become popular (watches, AR glasses) The vast majority of car owners although, given the choice, will buy a sedan or an SUV. Pickup trucks are popular for some subcultures and some forms of professional work, and will always be needed and will never go away. Mainframes / trains have morphed into datacenters, but are functionally similar. None of these form factors will go away, except maybe minicomputers, but the vast majority of the populace will move onto the smallest safest thing, unless they need the extra space that a pickup truck gives them :)
- michaelmrose 6y agoThis is a well thought out analogy but by the same token even though it might be nice to shrink the form factor even to watch size if you could but a lot of the space required isn't the machine at all it is screen and keyboard in which the pickup truck or van style input has an enormous advantage.
- whywhywhywhy 6y ago>For example connectivity to cellular networks (still missing in even the fanciest laptop but available on my watch.) Most "Fancy" PC laptops have cellular >PC cameras are comical in comparison. Microsoft's cheapest ($400) Surface device has 2 1080P cameras, on 5MP one 8MP. Great cameras actually, company I work for uses them for all their tutorial video recording, looks so much more professional than the current MacBook Pro camera. Don't think this writer has any experience outside of the MacBook ecosystem, it's only Apple who are woefully trailing behind in these areas. I fully expect them to catch up by Q2 next year but to pretend these things haven't been standard for years in the rest of the laptop ecosystem is silly.
- mdoms 6y agoYeah this is a post written by someone who hasn't touched a non-Apple PC in years.
- alkonaut 6y agoFwiw I have a fancy (ok expensive/powerful but not “fancy” like a surface) Dell and its camera is terrible. I’m guessing it adds around $3 to the BOM of a $3k laptop. I have seen similar crap on similar models from HP/Lenovo. This pandemic hopefully changes this for new models once everyone does video calls and notices this.
- necubi 6y agoLaptop cameras are terrible because they are embedded in screens, and laptop screens are very thin. It's a physics issue, not a cost one. The Surface can have a better camera because the screen is the thick part (although this makes it a much worse as a laptop).
- franga2000 6y agoMy laptop screen is about as the same thickness as my phone (OnePlus 3), which has a front-facing camera that is unimaginably better than the one in my laptop. The border on the top of the screen is also wide enough to fit it and in fact the camera inside of the laptop is only marginally smaller than the one in my phone (I've unfortunately had to take both apart enough times that I'm quite certain of this). It's definitely not a physics issue. Just like the painfully slow barely USB 2.0 SD card reader that laptops include, despite costing a couple grand and having a 20Gpbs link literally right next to it, it is a cost issue.
- Causality1 6y agoEvery time I try to use non-PCs like I use a PC I run smack into one brick wall or another. Let me give you an example. I wanted to relax while playing a game and listening to a podcast. My phone has plenty of horsepower for doing both. Oopsie, there's a problem. I can't hear my podcast over the game,and android has no way of setting the volume of different apps to different levels unless the app includes its own internal volume control. Mobile devices are littered top to bottom with this sort of "I can run but not walk" horseshit.
- simonh 6y agoYou just need to choose the right phone. This works fine on iOS, especially if the game offers in app audio volume selection, although some games deliberately block other audio sources. It’s a per game issue though, not a limitation of the system.
- ryukafalz 6y agoThe fact that this requires in-app volume controls, or that an app can block other audio sources, feels like a limitation of the system.
- simonh 6y agoWhat desktop OS provides per application volume controls, outside the apps?
- nzentzis 6y agoBoth Windows and Linux (via PulseAudio) provide this. I'm not as familiar with the Windows side of things, but on Linux I can also redirect each application's sound to different audio devices.
- ryukafalz 6y agoYup, this is extra useful when I'm using e.g. an external USB headset for calls. I can have media played through my speakers while using the headset for calls, regardless of whether or not the application supports this itself. (Admittedly VoIP applications generally do.)
- brundolf 6y ago> But what about the Mac? The Mac is the PC from the company that more or less defined the Post-PC era. Would it not be the first to be sacrificed for the new future? This to me is one of the really big but less talked-about implications of Apple Silicon. 12 months ago - before M1, before Big Sur, before the Mac Pro reboot, before the MBP 16 - the Mac had atrophied. Hardware quality had gone down, the software felt neglected (the UX update in Yosemite felt like a half-hearted skin). The Mac felt like a side-project. It felt unimportant to Apple; there was speculation that it might be turned into an iPad with a keyboard, or be dropped altogether with the all the new energy surrounding the iPad Pro. Apple seemed like it might just exit the workstation business completely. In the past year that trend has been turned on its head. First they fixed the keyboard and refreshed the MBP form-factor and internals. Then they came out with the radically-powerful (and expandable!) machine that pros had been asking for for years. Then, most importantly, they came out with a huge financial commitment to the future of the Mac, making it a seriously compelling workstation again, and the cherry on top is a new UX that, for the first time since OS X (nearly 20 years ago!), looks like it was designed cohesively from the ground-up. No matter how you feel about Big Sur's design choices, it shows that Apple cares about the Mac again. And they're just getting started with the new silicon. For an ecosystem that asks a lot in terms of commitment, it is hugely encouraging to see such an unambiguously renewed focus on this product line.
- shmerl 6y ago> Apple cares about the Mac again I don't think Apple cares about macOS users though. It's a huge difference. The way Apple drops support for existing things easily drives people away from them.
- cocoa19 6y agoI wish this was true, but everyday I see more dev shops moving from windows to mac than the opposite. I don't see as many moving to linux. Moving applications to the cloud and the slow deprecation of old windows apps made this possible.
- 6y ago
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago> What Apple is doing once again is ratcheting up the bar for the PC to make sure it’s the top choice for creative professionals. This just isn't true, unless one means laptops. Creative professionals, as I understand the term, generally need all the power they can get (video, audio etc.) The Apple machines are nowhere near the top of the line from this perspective. If you care about CPU/watt then the M1 looks pretty awesome. If you care maxCPU, the M1 is currently not particularly interesting.
- alwillis 6y agoThe Apple machines are nowhere near the top of the line from this perspective. All of the benchmarks and testimonials are showing a $699 Mac mini running on a M1 beats a $4000 iMac Pro and pretty much all Intel desktops. Apparently Hollywood doesn't agree with you; a new Mac mini is faster than the Mac Pros they've had for years: "Hollywood thinks new Mac mini 'could be huge' for video editors"—https://appleinsider.com/articles/20/11/12/hollywood-thinks-new-mac-mini-could-be-huge-for-video-editors https://appleinsider.com/articles/20/11/12/hollywood-thinks-...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThe new mac mini will be much better than the old mac mini. I have no doubt that for some it will be a game-changer: the ones who will never use anything except a mac but ran into performance limitations with the intel-based models. But for people who do video editing on ThreadRippers and such, the new Mac Mini is a little, not-too-fat nothingburger of a machine. The fact the the "$4000 iMac Pro" was woefully overpriced and underpowered doesn't change that. Hint: I can run a faster Mac in a VM on my 16 core threadripper than I could ever have bought from Apple.
- alwillis 6y agoBut for people who do video editing on ThreadRippers and such, the new Mac Mini is a little, not-too-fat nothingburger of a machine. Um, no pun intended but this isn's an apples-to-apples comparison. Most ThreadRipper CPUs cost more by themselves than does the entire Mac mini. A 16-core ThreadRipper starts at 180 watts and costs more than the Mac mini at $699. Duh—it's supposed to be faster. On the other hand, the Mac mini and the other M1 Macs are entry level machines that put almost all Intel and some AMD processors to shame, running at 20-24 watts TDP—so cool that the MacBook Air doesn't need a fan and the one in the MacBook Pro is silent. From the AnandTech review [1]: "The M1 undisputedly outperforms the core performance of everything Intel has to offer, and battles it with AMD’s new Zen3, winning some, losing some. And in the mobile space in particular, there doesn’t seem to be an equivalent in either ST or MT performance – at least within the same power budgets." That's pretty good for entry-level, consumer hardware. The professional level processors should make things quite interesting. [1]: https://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-tested/7 https://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-teste...
- duopixel 6y agoI hope that some day Apple revives the idea of the PowerBook Duo (https://lowendmac.com/2007/apples-first-subnotebooks-powerbook-duos-and-2400c/ https://lowendmac.com/2007/apples-first-subnotebooks-powerbo...) in which you could dock your phone to something akin a brainless iMac: a screen, mouse and keyboard. Your main computer is always your phone, which you can slide into different form factors (tables, laptops, desktop PCs).
- pbronez 6y agoWorks on Android, check out https://nexdock.com/touch/ https://nexdock.com/touch/
- shmerl 6y ago> The software and hardware efforts are uninspiring because the talent has moved elsewhere. Really? I find AMD's efforts in desktop CPUs and GPUs quite interesting. Same goes for example for Mesa, radv/aco, dxvk, vkd3d-proton and etc. Quite inspiring projects and they are all about Linux desktop use case for the most part (especially gaming). PC ≠ Windows.
- kylewins 6y agoPost PC First thing that came into my brain was Post Political Correctness. I thought this was going to be JUICY... :(
- FpUser 6y ago>"But I’m also willing to bet you’re reading this on a phone." I am reading this on my PC on one of 2 4K monitors. I use phone for a phone calls, off-line GPS and couple of specialized off-line apps.
- globular-toast 6y agoI've been taking PCs for granted my whole life. My school did actually have Acorn/BBC Micro computers but I was too young to really take advantage of them. The only reason they had them was I went to the worst school in one of the most deprived areas of the UK. The school had already acquired its first PC by then and after I left I never saw anything but PCs in other schools. Our family computer was a PC and I remember my dad installing a modem and a CD burner and probably other things (I later upgraded the memory from 32MiB to 64MiB and the hard disk to 20GB). It was so exciting. But I just thought that was how computers were. I didn't realise that this was just how the PC is. I got a smartphone, but I got it as a phone, not a computer. I got a netbook, but even that can be tinkered with within reason given its form factor. But I never stopped using my PC. It makes me quite sad to think that this might go away. Microsoft already tried to cripple the PC with UEFI. I feel like the whole PC market is mainly propped up by gamers right now. I don't game but I'm thankful that I can still take advantage of the hardware. Imagine how boring it would all be with disposable appliances and wireless networks. I'll have to move with the times. It's my job. But I'll have to find a new hobby.
- simonh 6y agoIt's true that Mac revenue exceeds that for iPads, but on the other hand Apple sells almost twice as many iPads as Macs. So from a business perspective the Mac might win out, but as a cultural phenomenon arguably the iPad has a much bigger impact. Already at work iPads with keyboard cases often outnumber laptops in meetings. That shouldn't be surprising as people already have a full computer at their desks. My eldest is in 6th form (highschool) and is a gamer, so she has a decently powerful laptop in her room and her daily carry at school is an iPad and Pencil. When she goes to university we'll consider a keyboard case to go with it. If you don't have a use for a powerful laptop, a skinny M1 Macbook Air is certainly very tempting and together with a powerful phone could cover some people's needs fine. I think the takeaway is that we now have a very granular, highly flexible set of devices available, covering a huge range of different combinations of use cases. It's not just about the individual tool anymore, it's about the right toolkit to meet our specific set of needs.
- pjmlp 6y agoI have been in post PC since 2006. Working on laptops with docking station has been a fact since then.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoIf measured by that, then yeah same, pretty much all companies I've worked for have made laptops mandatory - it saves a ton in insurance cost and break-in risk. There was one exception where we worked on desktop PC's at a bank, because they were very reluctant about developers taking code outside of their premises. Less of a risk of burglary as well because of better locks and a full time security staff. They slackened that policy off a bit after risk analysis and making full disk encryption mandatory at least.
- pjmlp 6y agoOn similar cases we had to work on virtualized desktops, Citrix, or EC2 instances, after being in the customers VPN.
- gandalfian 6y agoI can't make a WhatsApp call from my windows pc or control my tuya WiFi thermostat and it's ilk. It's the day's of near guaranteed "windows compatible" that have suddenly ended, and an era fading with it.
- jeroenhd 6y agoMicrosoft is working on implementing Android userland in Windows 10, so you might soon be able to. You're still limited to WhatsApp's "one device per account" policy, but that's more of a WhatsApp issue than a Windows issue. As for the Tuya thermostat, the terrible IoT landscape is to blame here, not MS. With IPv6 support any device in your home can be controlled by any device you own, except that IoT manufacturers are not capable of securing their devices and would much rather pull everything to their own private little cloud, letting them permanently pull the plug on their old hardware whenever they feel like it. There's very little preventing Tuya from making a Windows application, but they just choose not to. I can make Telegram calls from any device with a microphone and/or camera just fine and there are plenty of IoT devices that can show a web interface to control the heat. It's all about the vendors you choose. The Windows/PC ecosystem has nothing to do with vendors' mediocre design decisions.
- varispeed 6y agoThe evolution seems to be like the devices are getting smaller and aim to take over as many things they user otherwise had to do as possible and once that is out of the way, the next step is to control an individual. Once individual life completely depend on the device, you can exert control over human by various means. Suddenly big tech companies will be able to tell people what to do and if they don't they'll get excluded from the "society". We need to stop this in its tracks.
- g8oz 6y agoYou know what 2000's era cliche has really come to fruition? "The Network is the Computer".
- MrBuddyCasino 6y ago> The software and hardware efforts are uninspiring because the talent has moved elsewhere. The creativity, R&D budget have gone the same way. Then what have Intel, AMD and Nvidia ben doing the last few years? We've got increased core counts, more IPC, massive graphics cards chips with specialised cores for AI, raytracing and fast memory. It started with gaming and birthed the deep learning revolution. Those may not be entirely new paradigms, but the advances, especially recently, have been large. There are now so many new chips launching at the same time (XBox, PS5, Zen3, Big Navi, Ampere, M1) that you can't really buy them at reasonable prices because the production capacity has become a bottle-neck, and demand far exceeds supply. This is not what decline looks like.
- tabtab 6y agoPC's are still the preferred business platform and I don't see that changing any time soon. PC's may not be "cool" or "sexy", but they run the world. Their gaming power also helps the platform's support. Mobile conventions essentially cripples the UI's when productivity matters. Mousing and large-screen-oriented UI's are simply more productive on average.