10 ms·
It's not you, nor is it your age. We've given up on protecting our freedoms, and our devices aren't really our own anymore. And you have people like the die ha
by echelon 6y ago
It's not you, nor is it your age. We've given up on protecting our freedoms, and our devices aren't really our own anymore.
And you have people like the die hard Apple apologists / enablers that think it's fine you can't build stuff for iPhone without going through Apple.
We're about to enter a trusted computing dystopia. You won't be able to run software on your laptops or desktops, and everything will be tracked.
The web was the perfect platform and would have been utopia. Google sunk their claws in and neutered the browser, removing the concept of the URL, forced media companies to use AMP, and crippled ad/tracker blocking.
Silos like Facebook rank content that isn't hosted internally lower, so the open web has atrophied.
And iPhone has a shitty browser so it can favor apps.
I don't hate computers. I hate the grifters and gaslighters that have taken the good parts away and told us our way of thinking is the problem.
- andmarios 6y agoI would add games to this list. Most games for iOS or Android these days are pay to win. Sure, they may not be as important as the things you mention, but when you start hating something that its main purpose is to be fun, is very telling of the situation.
- Guvante 6y ago> I would add games to this list. Most games for iOS or Android these days are pay to win. They are also free to play and usually not in a minor way. Some of the latest Gacha games have a dozen hours of storyline (or more) before starting the infinite grind. > when you start hating something that its main purpose is to be fun People have hated games forever so that isn't much of a barometer. Not commenting on whether P2W is more problematic but people have been listing forever the things that got in the way of their fun.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoOn that topic, if you're looking for games that don't form such abusive relationship with their players, 'StavrosK is maintaining a list of "no-bullshit games" for both mobile platforms: https://nobsgames.stavros.io/ https://nobsgames.stavros.io/.
- andmarios 6y agoWas looking for something like this. Thanks so much!
- blub 6y agoWhy do you feel the need to pick on Apple when: a) their updates require consent b) their telemetry is less invasive than Google's or Microsoft's and at least they explain what they're collecting in most of their apps and allow one to turn off some things c) they do offer power user options such as allowing kexts like the one from Little Snitch. https://www.obdev.at/support/littlesnitch/245913651253917 https://www.obdev.at/support/littlesnitch/245913651253917 d) generally add functionality ?
- MrStonedOne 6y agoBecause most windows/android users would love to jump to apple for their privacy friendly and user-unhostile approach to updates but resent the idea that they would have to give up their app freedom to do so. So i can either install any app i want into my factory installed spyware ridden forced updating android phone and windows desktop machine, or give up the ability to control what software I can install my machine in order to gain privacy by switching to apple. We want both damn it. And in my case I'll begrudgingly take windows and android over apple, but I don't like it.
- blub 6y agoYou can AFAIK install what you want as long as you're willing to pay for a developer cert. But it's easier to just think of iThings as appliances with lots of cool use cases instead of general computing machines.
- turbinerneiter 6y agoI mean, you literally are not even mentioning the option that has exactly what you want defined as it's core values. Whenever I hear all this lamenting about Apple this, Microsoft that, Google rablerablerable ... we have been told about all of this sine at least 1989! I'm full-time, work and private, on a Free desktop OS since 10 years +. Just put your money and effort into the Free alternative.
- MrStonedOne 6y agoI have a rooted and custom rom android phone running an official lineage os release It still can't make phone calls without cycling airplane mode between calls. The one before that would crash if I paired a bluetooth device while connected to one already. Both of them bootloop at the power off battery charge screen, which basically means i couldn't turn my phone on while plugged in, and unless its a fast charger, the act of repeatedly booting up keeping the phone screen on ends up draining power faster then it can charge. So. Tell me again about these free and open options.
- badarticle0 6y agoIt’ll be awful just like that car dystopia where no one changes their oil, and the recycling is handled in an organized way. Your way of thinking is the problem. You’re a minority of users and not entitled to mass production of goods that fit your intentions alone. Reality moved on as physics obliges it to do. Go buy a Dell and install Linux. Go buy an Rpi. When did MS or Apple ever cater to open source opinions on computing? Did a golden age end or were you all distracted and simply forgot these companies were awful back then too? Better juice those stocks gains though!
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago> We've given up on protecting our freedoms, and our devices aren't really our own anymore. And yet TFA's entire point seemed to apply equally to a self-built machine running any OS (including any Linux) that you could name. So this really seems to have almost nothing to do with Apple or MS.
- rdiddly 6y ago> We've given up on protecting our freedoms... Wow, putting it like that makes me realize it's just part of the larger societal trend toward authoritarianism. I guess this is one of those 'Stallman was right' moments.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt is - in fact, it's kind of the main thing Stallman was writing about all these years. It didn't click for me until few years ago; as a young programmer, I was thinking in terms of "good vs. evil", then "idealists vs. pragmatists", which are wrong frames of mind. Once I learned to think in terms of market incentives, Stallman's arguments became somewhat obvious. RE the wider trend toward authoritarianism, I'm not yet sure I see it clearly, at least outside the privacy space. But I do feel trends towards taking away end-user control and turning everything into a service, which are very much market-driven, though perhaps they also are a subset of authoritarianism.
- nbzso 6y agoYou are on to something important here:) If you want to know how we are will be "happy by owning nothing" read this "masterpiece" of socialized corporatism https://www.amazon.co.uk/COVID-19-Great-Reset-Klaus-Schwab/dp/2940631123 https://www.amazon.co.uk/COVID-19-Great-Reset-Klaus-Schwab/d... .
- freedomben 6y agoJust the sheer number of people calling for Twitter, Youtube, Facebook, etc to censor others is remarkable to me. I came of age during a time when we on the left believed fiercely in personal freedoms, especially freedom of speech. We would blast music that would say things like, "F--k you I won't do what you tell me." [1] Now the same left I loved can't erupt in protest fast enough when social media aren't censoring idiots. We used to all know that censoring of anybody was wrong, but also that it didn't work. Censoring was what corporations and authoritarian states did to people, and we hated it. That's just one example of the change people have gone through. [1] https://genius.com/Rage-against-the-machine-killing-in-the-name-lyrics https://genius.com/Rage-against-the-machine-killing-in-the-n...
- joe_the_user 6y agoInstalling Linux, Mate, Firefox, clearing cookies, learning tricks to use or get around biases, etc. I can make my computer more or less "mine". Mine in the ways that are worth it to me. But your point is well taken in that the way the computer and the stream of data isn't owned by the average user has a serious impact on society. The way the Youtube algorithm pushes people towards extremism is the most extreme, obvious example. People with the weakest filters seem like they're the victim of this stuff. But overall, the problem is the situation doesn't teach people to have filters.
- johnisgood 6y agoYeah, this computer is more or less mine, in all fairness. My phone, much less so.
- visarga 6y ago> But overall, the problem is the situation doesn't teach people to have filters. Filtering and ranking (and their visual presentation to the user) are the most prized aspects of Google, Twitter and Facebook for their impact in advertising and activism. Everyone wants attention, attention is money and power. Attention is the value system on the internet. So of course they don't want to share it, not even with the user. But we want to have a say about content evaluation as well, we have our own values. Perhaps the best way to neuter Google, FB and Twitter is to spin out the ranking/filtering/presentation part and make many of them. I don't care about the indexer too much, it can stay in one piece. But for ranking and filtering I'd like to select other settings than they allow. Maybe settings proposed by EFF or other NGO's I trust more than a for profit company. It used to be that we only had the option of a few channels to watch and newspapers to read. You could switch but they would be very restrictive in the choice of content. Internet gave us freedom and a high variety of options, but now ranking and filtering take them back. They want to take choice from us and impose theirs.
- sneak 6y agoI know how to take these steps, too, but it's not possible on cutting edge hardware. You're mostly stuck on slower lower-res stuff that's usually made out of plastic. All of the really good hardware is cryptographically locked to software that you can't alter.
- johnisgood 6y ago> and our devices aren't really our own anymore. This is the case with virtually everything these days. Stallman is/was right about this. You only rent the movies on Netflix, the games on Steam, the books on Amazon Kindle, and so forth. Everything could be taken away from you for absurd reasons. Who would have thought that your account could be disabled for reasons that it could get disabled today? It is not going to get better. You cannot even play a single player game offline, without running Steam. Torrents/Warez will never go away thankfully. Screw DRM anyways.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoAt least with music, you can still generally buy and download: I’m unaware of any legal way to do the same for high-resolution video.
- johnisgood 6y agoYou sure? Up to the platform, but generally it is not the case I think. I mean sure, I paid and downloaded albums from Bandcamp before, but I use YouTube the most for music. I do not use Spotify, or Apple Music. No idea if you can download songs from those platforms. I do use SoundCloud and YouTube. I must use youtube-dl to download music from those two places. SoundCloud gives the uploader the ability to allow the downloading of the uploaded song, but in many cases it is not allowed, so youtube-dl it is. Then you can also find torrents and download your favourite bands' music in FLAC format. youtube-dl is amazing. It supports a lot of platforms, and you can download entire playlists by just using the URL to the playlist itself.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoThe iTunes Store still exists and has a decent selection as does Amazon Music MP3 downloads, not to mention a bunch of smaller players like Qobuz that have FLAC and other audiophile formats. If you want to buy legally and download, it’s still possible for like 90% of the artists and genres I care about.
- na85 6y ago>We're about to enter a trusted computing dystopia. You won't be able to run software on your laptops or desktops, and everything will be tracked. This situation is entirely the fault of web developers at large tech firms who have been pushing "the web as app publishing platform". It used to be that you'd install a program and run it locally but of course javascript developers didn't want to learn C++ and here we are.
- porknubbins 6y agoI definitely prefer native to web apps but I wonder if it is fair to attribute fault to web developers actively pushing web apps when the convenience factors are so overwhelmingly against installing native apps.
- na85 6y ago>the convenience factors are so overwhelmingly against installing native apps. Citation needed. I can think of precious few applications that are better in the browser than native. MS Office and Libre Office are significantly better than the horrid google docs experience. Not a single web-based text or code editor is worth a damn. Games are better, more featureful and more performant as native than in the browser. Web based CAD is a joke. Almost every major application is inferior as a web app. Gmail on desktop is about the only thing that's better than the native experience, at least that I can think of.
- jamesgeck0 6y agoIt’s the friction of launching a new application the first time. It requires like four more clicks to run an unsigned executable on Windows, two of which are to bypass a scary “this is probably malware” dialog box.
- na85 6y agoGet your exe signed? I dunno, number of clicks seems like a weak argument in favour of web to me. Start -> type "f-i-r-e" -> click Firefox -> click bookmark in the menubar That's still 3 clicks. Doublclicking the icon on the desktop maybe but that's 3 as well. Launching a native app would be no different.
- dheera 6y agoExactly. It gives me the shivers every time an Apple fanboy tells me something along the lines of "But Apple is just the best, you don't need to modify it"
- wruza 6y agoBut it in a sense is. I am or was using linux, windows, osx, ios, android for prolonged times and yesterday I unpacked and updated my iMac'10 (job reasons) and it still kicks ass. Of course it could be more configurable and less authoritarian, but nobody sold me an alternative that feels better just out of the box. I'm a full time user of windows and android right now, if that helps with "fanboy" part. It's not that configurability lacks smoothness and fell. It just happens that best ui provider/supervisor also happens to be the most walled garden, and competition is far behind. If only a part of efforts that e.g. gnome spends on removing settings went on making gnome better looking than apple... They had a decade and became "apple minus ux/ui".
- dheera 6y agoIt isn't the best UI for me. I use Ubuntu and Cinnamon or KDE. Gnome is shit for sure.
- wruza 6y agoI somehow like both Apple and my ten+ years old XFCE installations (until they removed menu configurability in 4.6). It's not appleness of apple itself that is sad, but the fact that everyone jumped that boat of "knowing what's better for you" and then started to push it over the limit of sanity. Commercial effort is understandable, they do private business at least, but even free/open software catched that disease.
- tmd83 6y agoIsn't this really how Capitalism suppose to work. Anything that can be milked for money would be done. Reducing control/choice(freedom) of consumer will always lead to more power for the vendor leading to more potentials for money and so it will be done. An individual consumer was always be in such a power imbalance and now with the trillion or 100s of billions of dollar companies on one side the balance is ultra skewed. You have regulation as a potential recourse but then the political systems are also controlled by money and they themselves love the lack of freedom leading to more political control. And perhaps the most critical is how the social media and media is encouraging an unthinking herd mentality that is making any change in the status quo all the harder.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoSpot on. HN is interesting sometimes. So many on here make a crap ton of money, way more than most other industries, and then go on to complain about FB, MSoft, Apple, Google, etc. But they all want their money and gladly take it, many working for these same companies. No one wants to make decentralized software because there's no money in that, and no money means no fancy Tesla, or expensive restaurants, or nice condos.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> We've given up on protecting our freedoms Now "we" bloody haven't! You may have, I and others have not and will not. Decades ago people were literally fighting fascism and dying for it, these days whiners can't manage to install linux, VMs or blocklists. You chose. You can unchoose.
- vladvasiliu 6y agoI do agree with your point, in particular with the last part about the grifters. But I think this was bound to happen, just as it happens in pretty much any domain that is no longer a niche. Companies see a way to make a quick buck and move in. However, I see this as something of a new development that didn't actually remove what was before. You can still run Linux if you like, just as you could 10-20 years ago. You don't have access to UHD Netflix, but... you never had. They didn't take this away, it was never given in the first place. Granted, the fact that Apple goes downhill is, I think, a net negative for the computing world. Ditto for the tracking embedded in windows 10. Regarding Linux, there's the UEFI / SecureBoot situation, but even on "enterprise" HP hardware this can not only be disabled but I can actually load my own keys, so I don't perceive this as a threat for the moment. The deeper problem, to me, is that all this works because there are enough people who, for some reason, don't care. Maybe they're not educated enough / don't know better, maybe they actually want it, maybe they're not aware. But the fact remains that there are many, many people who buy the iPhone, who use windows 10, who use facebook, who buy echos, etc. So, aside from "doing the right thing", what incentives do these companies have to stop doing what they do? [] I actually do own an iPhone but I treat it like an appliance. I install next to no apps, so I really don't care about who can install what on it. I do care that my 4 yo phone got the latest major upgrade and it works as well as the day I brought it home. However, I am pissed that LittleSnitch is unable to filter all traffic on my Big Sur Mac. But I basically no longer use the Mac, so I'm doing something about it.
- chrisfinazzo 6y ago> And you have people like the die hard Apple apologists / enablers that think it's fine you can't build stuff for iPhone without going through Apple. This hasn't been true for several years. Yes, distributing an app requires a paid membership, but you can build and run your app on your own device just fine. https://developer.apple.com/documentation/xcode/running_your_app_in_the_simulator_or_on_a_device https://developer.apple.com/documentation/xcode/running_your... > We're about to enter a trusted computing dystopia. Tell this to the young kids coming up - I'm in my mid-30's now - and explain that there existed a time when most sites were served over plain-old, unencrypted HTTP. They either won't believe you, will be horrified at the security hole here, or both. > The web was the perfect platform and would have been utopia. Google sunk their claws in and neutered the browser, removing the concept of the URL, forced media companies to use AMP, and crippled ad/tracker blocking. In retrospect, it isn't surprising that Google - a company that makes its real money off of ads - went down this road. It stinks, but I don't know if they had any better options to protect this revenue stream in the face of tech that lets people subvert it getting better all the time. > And iPhone has a shitty browser so it can favor apps. In some ways, I do wish that Apple put more effort into the web app side of things, but the key victory of the App Store can't be ignored. If you make software easier to acquire, install, and remove, people will use more of it. With few exceptions, I would posit that most people who aren't nerds didn't use much software because these guardrails weren't there, and that they might "screw up their phone/computer." As a result of this progress, that fear has been largely eliminated, even if it means people give up some access to the nuts and bolts of how the software stack works.