11 ms·
New bike chain claims to be faster, more durable
- invernomut0 6y agoHow does it compare with the rohloff system? Anyways it seems to be significantly more expensive thus I don't think it will become widespread.
- vondur 6y agoI sure hope it's cheaper than the Rohloff hub, I can't imagine anyone buying these if they are very expensive. I thought I had read that chains and sprockets were pretty efficeint in terms of energy loss.
- maxerickson 6y agoApparently well adjusted modern gear can be 98% efficient.
- fabianhjr 6y agoThat is mentioned in the article: > All of that is working, too, with independent tests showing properly race-prepped drivetrains to be as much as 98% efficient. > That elusive 2% > As good as chain optimization has become, there comes a point where there’s no more optimizing left to do, and there are no other options but to rethink the system. Though, not as in any modern drivetrain but high-end competition drivetrains. At least I imagine it would be with really expensive solutions like Ceramic Speed bearings everywhere.
- leoh 6y agoIt's the chain not the internal hub. Rohloff can use either a chain or a belt drive. The belt drive is cheap, and works with other internal hubs (sealed planetary gear system), which are much cheaper (e.g. Shimano, others make them).
- petre 6y agoTourers buy them. Money well spent. Just change the oil every year. Less efficient than a clean deraileur drivetrain but those stay clean for about 30 minutes.
- mauvehaus 6y agoEven a muddy chain is unreasonably efficient, to the tune of maybe 85-90% [0]. Having bike toured, keeping a chain halfway clean (or at least not muddy) is not hard. Yes, I see the appeal of an internally geared hub, but marginal differences in efficiency either way would not be high on my list of concerns. [0] https://cyclingtips.com/2020/05/how-many-watts-does-a-dirty-chain-steal/ https://cyclingtips.com/2020/05/how-many-watts-does-a-dirty-...
- leoh 6y agoYou are not referring to rohloff, but the gates carbon drive, which is amazing technology. Rohloff works with either a chain or a belt.
- EarthIsHome 6y agoI enjoy the rohloff system. I use it with the gates centertrack belt drive instead of a chain. The rohloff system is quite heavy though, so I don't know if it's "more efficient" than a traditional high end sprocket-and-chain system. The rohloff also shifts the weight to the rear of the bike. Maybe the pinion gear box system might be better since its weight is low and towards the center of the bike.
- petre 6y agoIt's not more efficient than a clean derailleur transmission but less maintenance. The trouble with derailleurs is dirt.
- Someone 6y agoThis is a chain system, to transfer power from the bottom bracket to the wheel. AFAIK, Rohloff is gear system built inside a wheel hub. How would one compare those?
- stunt 6y agoYou are right. Perhaps he meant if it can be used with the Rohloff system or not. It can be used with the Rohloff system. But, I think you need a compatible chain ring since they are talking about a new tooth design requirements. The Rohloff system has the chain ring attached to the hub gear. So you presumably have to change that chain ring yourself.
- stiray 6y agoAs a guy who ignored the chain on his first bike with XTR gears and had to replace whole drivetrain - yep, I would buy this chain. No question asked, as long as they guarantee me that it wont be stretched.
- usrusr 6y agoJust accept that chains are the consumable #1 for a bike and be happy. Shimano chains are absurdly cheap anyways.
- alistairSH 6y agoThis. On a mountain bike, replace the chain every 50 hours of use, or annually and the rest of the drivetrain will last for years. Or, if you're dumb and lazy (me!), ride the whole lot into the ground and replace the whole bike every few years because #shinynewtoy!
- frabbit 6y ago50 hours of use I assume this is a typo for 500?
- usrusr 6y ago500 would be 5000 km even at just 10 km/h which would be generous (but doable) for a Shimano chain even under roadbike conditions (where this would be roughly 200 hours). Mountain bike conditions will increase wear level a lot and they'll probably be a bit faster than 10 km/h as well. I don't know if it is really as bad 50h, but I've stopped mountainbiking when suspension forks ceased to be exotic. It also differs regionally: riding muddy in a place where the air is full of corrosive ocean spray will require far more chain replacement than riding in the Utah rock deserts. If you ride a chain until it stops working you'll probably reach those numbers. But then you will have to replace the entire drive train which is far more expensive. The chain is the cheapest part and replacing the chain a bit earlier than absolutely necessary will greatly increase the durability of more expensive parts. As a little bonus you'll repeatedly get the joy of riding a new chain. Replacing at the right time is cheaper and more enjoyable at the same time.
- jandrese 6y agoHow well can these handle dirt and debris? It looks like a high precision connection which makes me slightly worried that an errant grain of sand or just an accumulation of road grime might jam up the works.
- petre 6y agoPeople concerned with dirt do not concern themselves with chain efficiency but rather stuff that removes dirt.
- ruined 6y agoreliability in adverse conditions is an important facet of any design. nobody cares about a new hyperefficient vehicle if it has to operate in a vacuum
- usrusr 6y agoThis design is specifically aimed at track cycling which is as close to vacuum conditions as you can get if you intend to run the rider on ambient oxidizer.
- Lerc 6y agoPeople keep telling Elon Musk that.
- loeg 6y agoThis design is made for vacuums. Really. Once your chain is dirty, you're well below the 98% efficiency figure they're competing against.
- leoh 6y agoGreat chain, but the Gates Carbon Drive is likely a superior technology. Europe has largely adopted it, but it is rare in the states. I have a Riese & Müller bike with a Gates Carbon Drive and it is absolutely lovely. Silent, but best of all, no grease on my pants or hands, ever. They handle dirt and dust super well (just dry off and wipe down with a cloth/no gears get jammed with a sealed planetary gear system). It also is said to last thousands of miles, if not 1e4 miles+.
- Finnucane 6y agoThe advantage here is that the chain could be made backwards-compatible with existing conventional drivetrains. The Gates drive can't be retrofitted onto older frames.
- Sunspark 6y agoWhy can't it be? My bike is a fixed gear track frame. If the threads of the sprockets are compatible with the rear wheel, then it should be able to fit.
- Tomte 6y agoThe belt is a closed loop and under high tension when installed. Your frame needs to be able to be opened to let the belt in, then your sprocket pack needs to be able to move backwards, so you can put tension on it.
- tigerBL00D 6y ago> then your sprocket pack needs to be able to move backwards, so you can put tension on it I am assuming that's what the poster meant by putting emphasis on his frame being a fixed gear one. Those normally have horizontal dropouts to put tension in the chain.
- Tomte 6y agoThanks, I had no idea!
- brudgers 6y agoReduced chain width has significantly changed bicycle drive trains over recent decades. Bicycles have many more usable gears. A manufacturer who pushed a non-standard chain heavily would wound cycle shops. Standardization facilities keeping parts in stock.
- alistairSH 6y agoI'm not sure that's true. SRAM already went with their own non-compatible design with their latest road groups (AXS road). Bottom bracket "standards" have proliferated over the last 20 years (all 8 of the bikes in my garage use a different system). Hub spacing is non-standard too (100mm/130mm QR, 100/135 QR, 100/135 TA, 100/142 TA, 110/148 TA, Superboost, DH, and a few other niche standards). Even within a brand, there's no guarantee shifters and detailers are compatible. Basically, the industry has "standards" but only keeps them long enough to develop the next. Gotta keep us buying $5000+ bicycles somehow.
- ip26 6y agoIt's true that bikes are a pretty sad story when it comes to standards. I think axles is going to settle down soon though. QR seems to be on the way out and standard TA for road with boost TA for mountain seems like the direction we are headed... (Disc brakes in particular are not a good match for QR)
- alistairSH 6y agoTrek is already moving to SuperBoost on their trail bikes. This appears to be DH width, but retaining the 12mm/15mm axles (vs thicker used in DH). It's a mess. And really annoying for anybody who breaks parts a lot - while almost everything is still available in some form, the newest best stuff is often only available in the latest standards.
- brudgers 6y agoI'll cop to $5000 bicycle unfamiliarity and preferring to own one bike at a time. I guess the era of standardized chains is past. So I stand corrected. Thanks. My current bike a late model Brompton, I am familiar with the extents to which other bespoke components is possible and a deliberate choice over something by Bike Friday.
- usrusr 6y agoI really don't get it: what power are they claiming to be transferring on the side of the tooth that isn't engaging with a roller chain? Also note that this is only for track bikes with a perfectly straight chainline (technically speaking it would also work for internal gear hubs wish are increasingly driven by belts in the upper price range). The shifting chain that is deployed diagonally more often than straight is an entirely different beast, in theory much worse in efficiency and durability. Pretty much all practical durability limits stem from compromises done for that diagonal capability for sitting. Which basically goes ruthlessly against all mechanical engineering rules, like the old adage about how bumblebees were supposedly unable to fly. Yet even they work quite well, given that challenging background they work just awesome and track chains already work better than that.
- lostlogin 6y agoInternal hubs are amazing and so great to use, until you get a puncture. It’s such a nightmare and I went through so many of those dumb proprietary nuts that strip so easily. Bikes like the Cannondale Bad Boy have got me thinking, what if the single fork was at the rear? Then you could have an internal hub and change the tube without the extra suffering. Yes, the loading at the read would be significantly greater, but if it were possible it would make internal hubs much better.
- mpol 6y agoI don't think internal hubs are amazing :) Derailer systems only absord energy in the chain and bearings, and a well maintained system can maybe lose 1.5% of energy. Internal hub gearing can lose around 15% energy. The shop keeper won't tell you this, he just wants to sell you a bike. If he starts talking difficult things, buyers might just go to the next shop to buy what they had already chosen.
- lostlogin 6y agoI got it for free as a hand-me-down so I do think I can be fairly objective about it. I’m surprised to hear the energy loss is that high. It was paired with fast tires and that bike could move quickly. The downsides of having to adjust and maintain the wheel position were not a worthwhile trade off though, but it was so close.
- colechristensen 6y agoReading through there is something very noticeably absent: any claims of increased efficiency. If you spread pressure out offer wider areas, you don’t get less overall friction at least in the first order approximation of friction you find in first year physics. What it looks like is an attempt to make something better that improves metrics which aren’t necessarily coupled to better overall performance.
- carlob 6y agoGiven a conventional chain can be up to 98% efficient then the maximum increase in efficiency is 1/.98 - 1 = 2.04%
- buzzerbetrayed 6y agoIs 100% efficiency physically possible? Or are they just trying to get as close as they can, knowing they can never truly reach 100%?
- wishinghand 6y agoAs long as there is friction, no.
- robotresearcher 6y agoNever 100%. Friction anywhere will prevent perfect efficiency. Also any compression, flexing or twisting of the components, which can be very, very small for hard steel at these low forces but not quite zero.
- yoz-y 6y agoWouldn’t a vélocipède be 100% efficient (in transferring motion of legs into motion of the wheel)?
- colechristensen 6y agoA percentage of a percentage is an odd way to express a change, and at that picking the non-loss side as basis. One could say increasing efficiency by 1% equivalent to reducing existing losses by 50%, both of those are reasonable bases, making it a percentage of the existing efficiency feels off.
- Cactus2018 6y agoGears! - But Were Afraid To Ask (MiniLathe) - This Old Tony https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-XOM4E4RZQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-XOM4E4RZQ
- Lev1a 6y agoGreat channel about machining stuff with mills, lathes etc. with some comedy mixed in while also being very informative. Also I found that watching machining of all kinds of stuff is strangely relaxing to me.
- pengaru 6y agoUnless I'm mistaken, the efficiency gain is from shortening the length of the pivoting pins to just what's required for connecting the conventional outside chain links to the saddles. In a conventional chain the pins cross the sprocket teeth and must rotate across that entire width; more frictional loss. In this design the saddle seats on the tooth, and just the relatively short pins linking the saddle to the outside chain must pivot.
- at-fates-hands 6y agoSide note: I used to work in a bike shop for about ten years. One time had a guy come in who worked with Kyronics. We all made jokes about freezing dead people - but he said you can apply Kryonics to a wide array of stuff not just dead people. One of the many things some of the team riders were seriously considering was having their cranks, chains and frames frozen since its supposed to alter the molecular structure to make them stiffer and more durable. I'm not sure they did it, but it was a topic of constant conversation for weeks afterwards.
- TwoBit 6y agoIf that technique made any bike part better, Shimano, Campagnolo, and SRAM or whoever was around at the time would have been doing it.
- coryrc 6y agoCryogenic hardening is a established procedure: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_hardening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryogenic_hardening
- bigbubba 6y agoApplied Science found that cryogenic treatment of steel drill bits made them last twice as long: https://youtube.com/watch?v=hAxi5YXTjEk https://youtube.com/watch?v=hAxi5YXTjEk
- rconti 6y agoCryogenically freezing auto brake rotors has been a thing for awhile, but I forgot about it until you mentioned it here. It's probably fallen out of favor as I don't hear much about it. But the claims may well be true. On the other hand, when I only replace brake rotors every 60-80k miles, I don't much care. https://frozenrotors.com https://frozenrotors.com
- vaccinator 6y agoit does look more durable with all the the added metal but how could that make it faster? but either way, I never had durability issues with my bike chains (including motorcycles), specially when you can adjust for "stretching"
- SirZimzim 6y agoHigher efficiency means more power from the cranks is going to the wheels. But this looks like something primarily for high power situations right now where those tiny gains matter more. Durability wise it will be great for ebikes as they eat up drive trains more so this should reduce cost of ownership in the long term.
- kazinator 6y ago> They’re soon going to be used in top-tier UCI track races. And that is where this monstrosity will stay, until they find a way to fit it into a 6 speed derailleur system to make it viable for $60 bikes sold in Walmart, and eventually an 11 speed derailleur system.
- rdiddly 6y agoI'll tell ya what I see: no rollers. Pins rubbing (wearing) both sides of the tooth. Including the back side, which will never exert any forward longitudinal force on a chain unless it's made of magnets. I also see a highly suspect FEA diagram on the right, where teeth not even engaged still show non-zero stresses (lighter blue, not the darkest blue), indicating that the color/stress scale has been changed compared to the baseline on the left. So it's not an honest comparison. Add to that the fact that this is a 'better mousetrap' that requires you to first replace all the mice in the house, and I guess I'm a bit (to use one of Bike Snob NYC's favorite words) nonplussed.
- ComputerGuru 6y ago> I guess I'm a bit (to use one of Bike Snob NYC's favorite words) nonplussed. JK Rowling taught me that nonplussed is apparently a part of the daily vernacular in the UK.
- rdiddly 6y agoI like how it can mean either 'confused' or 'unimpressed' which in certain situations can almost be opposites of each other. But both apply to me with this chain system!
- switch007 6y agoI (a Brit) was confused by the apparent use to mean "unimpressed" but I stumbled upon this: > Note: The use of nonplussed to mean "unimpressed" is an Americanism that has become increasingly common in recent decades and now appears frequently in published writing. It apparently arose from confusion over the meaning of nonplussed in ambiguous contexts, and it continues to be widely regarded as an error. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nonplussed https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nonplussed
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoWell I (a Brit) have only ever understood it to mean 'not sufficiently impressed to know what to say'; in a sort of bemusement or indecision as to one's reaction. A sort of confusion as to how unimpressed one is. The Collins dictionary I have to hand doesn't capture that nuance though. I actively try to avoid USAmericanisms, except for "y'all". Go figure ;o) [That last phrase is a USAmericanism, used for amusing intent.]
- matsemann 6y agoHow is the shifting? Sounds a bit too rigid. Smooth shifting is probably more important for performance than those last promilles.
- canofbars 6y agoIf it can't bend you could use it with a gearbox which is how belt drive bikes work.
- analog31 6y agoThere's no shifting. These chains are for single speed drivetrains, e.g., track bikes, but also possibly single speed freehub and internal gear hub bikes. This could be one of those things that starts its life as a performance upgrade for competition use and either does or doesn't make it into the world of everyday cycling.
- FpUser 6y ago>"This isn’t just some lab experiment, either. They’re soon going to be used in top-tier UCI track races." As long as it is not an absolute crap pros would use whatever equipment their sponsor tells them to use. Chain durability for pros does not matter and whatever the difference in friction are really negligible. >"ability to transfer 25% more Torque" Any decent chain will handle way more torque than cyclist can deliver so what's the point. >“four times increase in system lifetime” I believe it when I see it. Also how much more this puppy gonna cost and cyclists would need to change chainrings and sprockets. This much troubles for the sake of chain? Sorry but I have my doubts.
- Theodores 6y agoThis chain is a nice idea but a solution in search of a problem. Right now it is track bike and e-bike only, so not even for hub gears. The track market is miniscule and we'll catered for. Then the e-bike market does not need a 2 percent gain in chain performance. The enemy of the chain is dirt. Real world cycling in the 1950s had hub gears and a big case to keep the dirt out. Then derailleur gears aimed at the sports market dropped the chain case. This made sense for cyclists with a team car behind them.
- forest_dweller 6y agoEvery so many years I see a post like this where they claim to have improved the drive chain of bicycles and they really never go anywhere, mainly because they aren't compatible with other kit. I've built and repaired quite a few push bikes over the years I am still using fairly standard shimano kit. The problem with exotic equipment is that even decent shops might not be able to repair it and it normally requires specialised tools. I mucked about with Campag and some other exotic kit and it is always a PITA as you always have to go hunting around for parts of ebay after a few years because threads and tapers on things like bottome brackets aren't compatible.
- FridgeSeal 6y agoAs a mountain biker primarily, chasing marginal gains on chain improvements seems strange to me. Chains are a wear item, and small gains in the efficiency are going to be lost pretty quickly after the first few times it’s been ground through mud, sand and grit, which will take all of one ride.
- matthewowen 6y agoThis is being marketed to track cyclists who have none of those issues. More generally, novel drivetrain products often seem to take off early in the tt/tri world which also don't really have to deal with those issues. It's also worth noting that anything that all else being equal, improved efficiency goes hand in hand with better longevity. As an example, applying a hot chain wax is a winner in terms of watts, but it's also cheaper in the long run.
- emcq 6y agoYou can't really make all things be equal and get increased efficiency and longetivity for most cases. The trade-off are explicitly made to have reduced longevity to have better efficiency. Take tires for example. A low rolling resistance lightweight XC tire will have significant advantages over a dual casing 2.6" DH tire. The XC tire will smoke a DH tire but not have better longevity on dirt. The XC tire will be slower on some DH tracks and the DH will be slower on XC. If you ride a DH tire on a road it will ironically wear down more quickly than a typical XC tire, and you can shred an XC tire in one day on technical DH.
- CalChris 6y agoThere is an easy and straightforward way to make this chain successful. Put in on a team bike that wins. 2% is quite a bit in a peloton. 2% of 2% is Biopace.
- bagacrap 6y agoit's only for single speed drivetrains
- CalChris 6y agoYes, all of their examples are single speed but I can't find anything in the article or site that specifically says that. Moreover, in their competitive critique of belt drives they complain that belt drives can’t be used with derailleur gears. https://www.newmotionlabs.com/articles/blog-post-title-three-nccsm https://www.newmotionlabs.com/articles/blog-post-title-three... Still, single speed. Get on the podium with track racers. BTW, my skepticism is very tempered. I still think Biopace was a good idea and could be made to work. I think this is a good idea and I still think it could work. But it has to, you know, work. It has to demonstrate and provide that efficiency rather than just claim it because modern chains are pretty darned good.
- supernova87a 6y agoTrucks use a solid driveshaft to transmit power to the rear axle. Is there any merit to using that idea for bikes? (with a geared transmission?)
- ggm 6y agoTolerance high need. Stretch or fracture.. no longer optimal. Current chains.. been working for over a hundred and fifty years and we all know how to fix em and oil em. So for the 2% improvement hero, sure. For me? Less sure. (I ride a clunker i put a Brookes leather saddle on, now it fits my bum cheeks I'm good)
- kenned3 6y agoWhenever i see things like this, i immediatly think "Audiophile". you know, the $238 "Directionally balanced" Ethernet cables, or the "low oxygen" copper. Once people take their hobby too far, you will end up with things like this. For $2K you can buy our (exotic and unnecessarily expensive metal) chain, which reduces friction to 0 and lasts forever. I ride a fair amount (150-200KM a week in the summers) and am always surprized to see everything on a bike is measured in grams, except the biggest impact, the rider itself? Sure i shaved 4g on my $400 waterbottle holder.... but when i weight 80KG.. and have another 2kg of water with me, does that 4g really matter?
- iambateman 6y agoIt’s not odd for a professional rider to optimize to that level, though. The article spent most of the words focused on high-performance racing.
- loeg 6y agoThis is more like "random concept car" / F1 than audiophilia. The idea here, if it is sound and measures well, is basically only useful to track racers (because they race single-speed bicycles). Current chains are extremely efficient, and mostly compatible at the same nominal width (expressed as 10-speed, 11-speed, 12-speed). And they are very cheap. People do spend absurd money shaving grams on bikes, but this product is not really in that space. It requires an IGH or a single-speed and isn't compatible with any other high-end drivetrain components on the market. That's a non-starter even for the people spending $15k on a bicycle. Here's a better "audiophile" example in vogue in cycling at the moment: ceramic bearings. These cost a lot more than high-quality steel bearings and quickly become less efficient than steel ones because the hard ceramic bearing destroys the softer steel races.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoIt can also have industrial applications if their claims are true. That's a bigger market than a single bicycling niche.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fnord77 6y agowish belt drives would catch on more. (yes, I realize the frame needs to be split to remove the wheel, but in the newest designs this doesn't seem like too big a deal)
- jl2718 6y agoThis makes me think about removing every other sprocket tooth and then milling down the attack angle on the forward side so that the two rollers would both seat on either side of one tooth. I think the point of this design is that the link transfers compressive force forward as pressure if both sides are engaged. The loss in a chain is nearly all in the roller as it engages with the first tooth in the front chain ring. Most of the force is being transferred from this first tooth, and it presses directly on the roller, which is also rolling into its seat position on the tooth. So a better design would have the roller get seated on the teeth before the force gets transferred to it, and then have no rolling until force transfer is done, then roll off gently. A new chain on a new chainring engages at the bottom of the tooth, right where it seats, and the torque of the chain ring rolls it up the forward tooth ramp until the tangential component of the force pressing into the contact point equals the pedal force. This happens on all points engaged on the sprocket. So you get a lot of rolling, but that’s over a lot of rollers. As the chain wears, it gets longer, so the teeth catch early from the tip, and it rolls all the way down the tooth while the entire chain tension is all on that first roller. This particular design has no rollers at all. It will still stretch because it has the same pin-plate interface, and it seems that a modest stretch may render it inoperable, but I’m not sure.
- mikewarot 6y agoChains stretch, thus any sprocket system will inevitably end up concentrating the load on the last link or two of contact. There are systems that actually could produce less friction, however they can't handle ANY contamination, thus ruling them out. Your best bet is to look elsewhere. I would try reducing the contact friction as the links engage. To do this, I would recommend using BAM coatings on the chain and sprockets. It has lower friction than Teflon, AND is almost as hard as diamond. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_magnesium_boride https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_magnesium_boride
- stjo 6y agoMaan I thought hn had a lot of 1M/year salary software developers, but just look at the amount of bike engineers.
- throwaway189262 6y agoChain wear is caused by bad lubrication. Both lack of lube and grit in the lube. You can use a bike chain with 25 horsepower if you put it in a sealed case half filled with oil.