7 ms·
A Kid, a Minor Bike Accident and a $19,000 Medical Bill
- moonbug 6y agoAmerica, fuck yeah!
- Jipazgqmnm 6y agoLand of the free.
- lawn 6y agoHow is it possible that stitches and anesthesia can cost $19,000? That's absolutely insane and such a bill could easily ruin the entire family. I know it's said every time these stories pop up, but I'm sure glad I live in Sweden and not in the US.
- zwirbl 6y agoThe jaw surgery I underwent some years ago could have been paid like 5 times for this in central Europe. Absolute insanity
- eb0la 6y agoAt this price levels, I bet there is a whole market in the US for do-it-yourself medicine (aka. snake-oil-selling). For Europeans, this is shocking, I wonder if people in Asia or Africa have similar financial troubles if they ever need medical assistance.
- cabaalis 6y agoI paid $2,000 last year for a hospital emergency department to superglue a cut on my son's head, it took 10 minutes. Next time, I'm going to glue it myself.
- peteretep 6y agoI tend to work on the basis that Thais get paid about a fifth that Americans do, and this would have cost you $200 by an American-trained doctor in a world-class hospital in Bangkok. If you’re actually poor, social security would cover it.
- Yuioup 6y agoThat's why the US political system is broken. Companies lobby representatives for incentives and breaks and in the end you get something like this. It's dysfunctional.
- rightbyte 6y agoThe worst part is actually this: "The hospital received less than half of what it originally billed, based on rates negotiated through his health plan." If you don't have an insurance the rates are even more of a joke.
- mattmcknight 6y agoEveryone should get to pay the same price as Medicare. That simple change would fix a lot of problems.
- codegrappler 6y agoAnd bankrupt most hospitals. It’s very common for hospitals to lose money on Medicare patients
- ryanbrunner 6y agoSomehow the entire rest of the world manages to provide health care (almost always with private providers) at a significantly lower price. It's possible you might see more non-profit vs. for-profit hospitals, but is that such a bad thing?
- mattmcknight 6y agoYes, the Medicare price would rise somewhat as it would no longer be subsidized by other insurers and the uninsured.
- geogra4 6y agoIts been said before by some I went to high school with that now has a PhD in public health that America's Healthcare system is first and foremost about paying insurers and everything else is just considered a loss
- mattmcknight 6y agoIt's the hospital that wants 18k, not the insurer.
- adwww 6y agoWhy does a non-profit hospital even remotely need 18k for that though? What is inflating costs so much?
- zrail 6y agoHospitals must stabilize anyone who walks through the ER door by law, no matter their ability to pay. They do not receive any funding for that mandate, however, so they have to make up the cost across their patients that do have the ability to pay. The stitches don’t cost $18k, but the ten people who walked in prior with no insurance and a broken leg or heart palpitations do. Edit: to be clear I’m not defending this awful system.
- RealityVoid 6y agoHighly skeptical of this explanation as this would mean about 90% of the US population is going bankrupt on the regular. No way this is true. Most likely just perverse incentives.
- Ekaros 6y agoPerverse interaction with insurance companies. Insurance companies have list of prices for operations. If the hospitals rate is higher than their price they have negotiated only to pay their list price. On other hand if the hospital price is lower they only get that much. So logical result is that hospitals maximise their prices to always be above what insurance is willing to pay. And then they can just negotiate lower rate for someone promising to pay in cash, which could be fraction. That is my understanding from Europe. From outside the logical way would be to mandate single pricing structure and ban any direct discounts.
- raxxorrax 6y agoIf only lawyers can make justice work, you have a rule of law in the worst possible sense. Not only a US problem though.
- klunger 6y agoUnless you are already quite rich, you just are a a bike accident or diagnosis away from bankruptcy, a life of financial stress and misery and even death in the US. It's terrifying. I'm an American who has been living in Norway for 8.5 years now. I am never moving back, unless there are some serious system changes which will realistically not happen in my lifetime.
- johnjungles 6y agoCurious, what’s better? Also do you have similar levels of job opportunities as NY or SF?
- throwawayffffas 6y agoBetter, is your insurance actually paying, without trying to weasel out of it. Also better, is not being charged almost half the median annual income for stitches.
- lm28469 6y agoLiving in NY or SF only affects a small subset of Americans. Getting universal health care affects almost 100% of people living in Norway. There are good job opportunities pretty much anywhere when you're in tech, you don't nee to make SV money when you don't live in SV. > Curious, what’s better? Parental leaves, more vacations, less working hours per week, better life/work balance, free health and education, &c. People who never experienced both systems can't understand the impact it has on your life, I'm not talking going in vacation in EU/US, I'm talking working/living for extended period of times. You can't escape the matrix if you don't know you're in the matrix. The US is like Disneyland or Vegas, if you can afford the top level shit you'll have a good time, some would argue even a better time than anywhere else, if you're on a budget be prepared to be treated like cattle.
- danielovichdk 6y agoAs a native scandinavian I am happy for you. I really am. Good for you and your family.
- asdasdasfasgasd 6y agoThe "resolution" says they "only" have to pay 2.000$ in deductibles and copay now. Just for comparison: a fully-fledged broken leg operation costs 3.000€ for non-insured people in Germany. Isn't insurance supposed to bring things down to 0$ instead of copays that still surpass the actual cost?
- arethuza 6y agoI don't even know what deductibles and copays are! Edit: Of course I could Google it, and I have a vague idea. But the idea of even having to think about money for things like a kids accident seems completely foreign to me. Edit: It does rather explain why the founder of the UK NHS called his book "In Place of Fear"
- markdown 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l-47Y0-W7v8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l-47Y0-W7v8
- LoSboccacc 6y agoin Italy it costs to me about 300eur every month for work life to potentially have partial coverage at some point in the future if something happens. I suspect your 3000 cost is skimping on a lot of taxes that are subsidizing the actual costs.
- speedgoose 6y agoIf something happens to you, or your partner, your mom, your children, your friends, on even your neighbors that you don't really care about but don't want them to struggle because it's nice to live in a society with healthy people around you.
- LoSboccacc 6y agoI didn't try to pass a moral judgment on the issue and I like the socialized system we have, for the most part. but confronting cost without taxes is trite and tiresome. I'm going to pay north of 150k eur to subsidize healthcare thorough my life, and being in the upper tax brackets (which start at some ridiculously low point) I also have to copay each service on top of already being paying more taxes for it. and when I see the "but ambulance rides are almost free here in x european country!" and the likes well no, they aren't, it's people that just didn't factor the actual costs in, because it's sunk in other taxes.
- Kelamir 6y agoStitches and anesthesia for 18,000$... Can't say that's cheap.
- johnchristopher 6y ago> The insurer paid $7,414.76 of the cost, and the Woodrums owed $1,853.45, which represented their share of the deductibles and copays. Wait, what ? $1,800 for stitches and local (I suppose) anesthesia ?
- bitL 6y agoNote to myself: always bring Loctite to bike trips to seal any wounds without stitches. $5 vs $20k
- rightbyte 6y agoI'm not sure if you are joking. Can you glue wounds with like whatever superglue?
- dagw 6y agoYou can in an emergency, but it's not recommended. There is special medical glue that is non-toxic, more flexible and designed to come of the skin easier.
- bitL 6y agoPartially joking; this was used in wars to stop bleeding before a doctor could arrive - it saved quite a few lives. There are friendlier glues now though.
- noud 6y agoI'm too European to understand why this makes any sense. I think the problem is not really that the insurance doesn't want to pay the bill, the problem is that $18,933.44 for stitches and anesthesia makes absolutely no sense at all. Therefore, the resolution is not to negotiate with your insurance and tell them exactly what happened so that you can split the bill. The resolution is to negotiate with the hospital about the costs of stitches and anesthesia. In Europe (Netherlands in my case) the insurance usually pays everything (part one of the solution), which forces the insurance to negotiate with the hospital about prices (part two of the solution). Keeping most simple interventions low in costs.
- me_me_me 6y agoI have read about this. The hospital charge as much as they can, because some patients are unable to pay. This way they make up the difference (or make more). The idea is that you go to the billing staff and threaten that you will go bankrupt and will not pay anything. Then negotiations begin. Rich pay cuz they don't care, suckers get conned, and poor gets their credit destroyed. Classic USA. It is another 'american' system akin to tipping only taken to extreme.
- artembugara 6y agoI'm not American but go bankrupt will affect your entire life in the US.
- ryanbrunner 6y agoI don't think they were saying to actually go bankrupt, just to threaten the bank with the possibility of getting nothing out of you.
- me_me_me 6y agoif you are poor and cannot afford anything then yes, you go bankrupt and good luck with getting a credit for an icecream. But otherwise you use bankruptcy as a bargain card. Because nither side wants to go there.
- 6y ago
- NikxDa 6y agoThis must be the freedom thing they keep celebrating!
- Tepix 6y agoAll in the name of stopping socialism. Meanwhile, the people keep lowering taxes for the rich until you have a civil war with all those people who have plenty of guns, but nothing to loose.
- adwww 6y agoAre insurance and healthcare companies trying to milk the system dry for the last few years before inevitable reform? Because that's what these sort of prices look like - you see it in tech when a service is clearly on the way out, but still has a handful of enterprise customers left who are unable to migrate away quick enough.
- 0xFFFE 6y agoIf you are charging someone 19k USD for a simple cut wound something is seriously rotten in the system. For comparison,in India, one could get this all done for less than 50$ including the medicine, this is without the insurance. People don't even use medical insurance for such trivial things. Heck, you could get this done for free if you have a Govt hospital nearby.
- nix23 6y agoIt's probably cheaper to study medicine and make your Dr in cuba and do the operation/stitches yourself..plus your a doctor now.
- eb0la 6y agoCuban doctors and nurses had great reputation some time ago. Probably you're getting more than what you think studying there ;-)
- nix23 6y ago>nurses had great reputation some time ago They still have: https://www.france24.com/en/20200517-young-cuban-doctor-helps-with-italy-s-battle-against-covid-19 https://www.france24.com/en/20200517-young-cuban-doctor-help... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/nov/25/sicily-asks-cuba-to-send-medics-as-italy-fights-second-covid-wave https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/nov/25/sicily-asks-cu...
- bhickey 6y agoOutrageous billing aside, the problem here is that the insurer can foist expenses on its policyholders rather than pursuing third parties themselves. We'd see abuses like this evaporate if insurers were compelled to do their own recovery. Think a third party is responsible? Ok, sue them.
- ChrisKnott 6y agoImagine going in to a police station and reporting a robbery. The officer is sitting at cash register and rings up your account and quotes you $8,000 to investigate the crime. This is how absurd it feels for a British person to see $ values assigned to medical treatments like this.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI would greatly prefer it! The problem with the USA is not that medicine is not socialised, it's that the price is inflated because of government / insurances plays. Imagine all the money savednot paying for public officials! I've lost money as the metropolitan police was completely useless. They had information, proof, arrested the guy, and then let him go. He ran away to Dubai and came back operating the same scheme under his second name. Reported it again to the same detective with location of the office and info from newly scammed people I contacted. They dismissed the case. I lost only 2k, but other victims (landlords being scammed by a fake agent) lost tens of thousands. Tried going to court but there is not a physical person with asset in the UK to persecute so I will likely won't get anything. Wasted 500£ more with this. The government doesn't have any incentive stopping crime, it just relies on the good will of policemen and their limited resources. If people complain because there is too much crime, they just have one more reason to increase taxes and do nothing.
- reallydontask 6y ago> The government doesn't have any incentive stopping crime, it just relies on the good will of policemen and their limited resources. If people complain because there is too much crime, they just have one more reason to increase taxes and do nothing. This made me laugh out loud, so I guess you managed your objective (I'm referring to your nick)
- me_me_me 6y agoI am not sure if that was a joke post or another libertarian purist. I swear, the pure communism is more believable as a system that could work than pure libertarian. Any we all know pure communism works only for ants.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kar1181 6y agoWhen we lived in the US my daughter tripped and opened up her chin on the kerb. My wife having no idea what to do (go to Urgent care) went to the ER... She had 5 stitches and was in and out in about 90 minutes. A plastic surgeon did the stitches and at one point there were 8 folks in the room. She has no scar and the experience was very good. We had full insurance, and when the bill came, it was ~$4500 of which we had to pay roughly $990 ourselves. Still not sure how to feel about it - that's a high price for a few stitches, but if I had a choice of going to a UK hospital for free, or paying a grand to know my daughter will be perfectly cared for, assuming I had that grand, I'd rather pay. Not everyone has that option though and that's the problem.
- cj 6y ago> if I had a choice of going to a UK hospital for free, or paying a grand to know my daughter will be perfectly cared for, assuming I had that grand, I'd rather pay. Is the implication that UK hospitals provide lesser care than their (costly) american counterparts?
- PeterisP 6y agoI would assume that while a broken chin would get reasonably fixed in UK, it would not involve "at one point there were 8 folks in the room.". I'm not a doctor so I can't be certain, but it seems plausible that in UK they would get adequate care but in USA they would eagerly "overprovide" services that are nice but carry a hefty extra cost.
- dagw 6y agoIn the UK you would never have a top surgon and 8 doctors and nurses dropping by to makes sure everything was OK for something as trivial as stitches. You'd have one person who would get you in and out as quickly and efficiently as they could. Whether that qualifies as 'lesser' is up for debate.
- kar1181 6y agoNo - the only implication is that the UK wouldn't use so many (costly) resources for something as minor as a few stitches on a 3 year old. But as a parent, it is YOUR 3 year old so you want the absolute best for them. The end result, I believe, would have been exactly the same had it happened here or in the US. Just I had a lot more confidence (at the time) seeing just how much was being done to ensure there was no scarring.
- Dansvidania 6y agoI love how the article basically says "in the end all was solved and the family only had to pay 2 grand". I am so glad I am an European.
- ryanbrunner 6y agoYeah, honestly, even $2,000 is absolutely outrageous for a procedure like this. This pretty clearly to me would have a pretty disastrous effect on preventative medicine - if each doctor's visit has the potential to cost you thousands, of course you're going to reserve it for emergencies only.
- bwc150 6y agoThis was a $2000 deductible/copay, which is capped annually. So it's not $2000 per treatment, more like $2000 per year where you need services beyond the basics. And meanwhile, having that high deductible keeps the monthly premium expense low
- apta 6y agoYou're paying much more than that in taxes per year.
- Dansvidania 6y agoInteresting point, although income taxes including health insurance where I live can be as low as 12%. If you mean more than $2000 than that's correct, of course, although I am not sure weather it is relevant. I imagine it varies depending on state and profession, but what's the average in the US? do you reckon it offsets the possibility that slicing yourself up while riding a bike could put you in serious money trouble? I doubt it :)
- LoSboccacc 6y agoimportant to notice this is not the medical bills they showing, but the claim rejection, and the claim rejection is "we require additional information" we don't know what information was on the claim, but judging but the long list of "professional services" it's indeed too vague to be itemized against their policy if that was the description provided. or in short this piece is presenting a very biased view by withholding a lot of information required to come to an understanding.
- NDizzle 6y agoIt ended up being $1.8k. Would have been much less if they didn’t call the fire dept (did he call 911?!) over a bike wreck. That’s the part a lot of comments are leaving out. A stretcher trip. Ambulance? Helicopter parenting.
- galoisgirl 6y agoIn my country, you call 112 and they inform you on how to proceed. They decide whether an ambulance is necessary. The decision is made by a trained professional, not a panicked parent. You can call 112 when your cat is stuck on a tree.
- dagw 6y agoWhy shouldn't you call 911 for an accident? You aren't trained to triage these sorts of situations, the people answering the 911 call are. If you call, explain the situation, and they respond by sending an ambulance, then surly that indicates that an ambulance was necessary.
- Tepix 6y agoI had a very similar accident while on vacation in Portugal in 2018 (i did go to the hospital in a rental car, however). I first went to a small local clinic. They stopped the bleeding and bandaged me for free and sent me to a larger hospital. There i got stitches. The hospital bill (which they handed me) was 50€ ($60), which my insurance paid. Look at it this way: $18,933 is more than Apple would charge! ;-)
- mping 6y agoI always wondered what would be the cost around here, happy the doctors got you fixed.
- kioleanu 6y agoJust a comparison, because we were in the exact situation in Germany and this is how it went down here: - my son broke his hand falling on the playground, we drove to the nearest hospital that handles kids (which happened to be a private-owned hospital). - he received the necessary medical attention and his cast, based on his insurance card - we are insured in the public system, but the insurer is a private, for-profit entity - we did not pay anything. There are co-payments, but not for children. However co-payments are like 5 EUR for a prescription or 10 EUR for a day of hospitalization. - a year later, we received a letter asking us to detail the exact circumstances of the accident, because they want to see if they can defer the payment to another insurer. For example, if he fell from a faulty piece of equipment in the park or if somebody pushed him. On the letter I had a link on which I could fill the form in online. Did it, explaining that the equipment was in order and we were even the only ones in the park and it was simply and unfortunate accident. - that was that edit: alongside with our employers, we are paying ~1300 EUROs per month (2 people, child is co-insured autoamtically) for health and care insurance to the insurer. What was nice was that when my wife wasn't working, she was also automatically co-insured on my contract for free.
- bwc150 6y agoSounds pretty similar to the linked story, except they got a trained staff of firefighters and EMTs show up on scene and a ride in an ambulance. He also didn't pay anything at time of service. Yes, he had to pay $2000 copay/deductible eventually, but we don't know what his monthly premiums are. I pay close to $0 month, but have a high deductible, for example.
- gerardnll 6y agoAs a Spaniard (maybe even European) I'm astonished every time I see one of these news. I can't even understand it. I'm so happy I live where I live.
- drtillberg 6y agoHe showed up at the hospital 'uninsured' in an emergency and the 'nonprofit' doctors marked up their fees 110%. Let's call this what it is. It's a racket and unethical.
- chewbacha 6y agoI’m a little confused, this talks about it as a bill, but at the top of the document it says “This is not a bill” As you read further, it’s a denial along with a questionnaire. It’s scary but they were not asking for the money, just verifying liability.
- robert_foss 6y agoGoFundMe based healthcare at its finest!
- Yizahi 6y agoGood thing that there were no "leftist" "communists" to prevent that story from happening in the first place. The Market (tm) will self regulate.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 6y agoIs there a site out there that can link you up with reputable doctors in Canada and Mexico who take cash and who do high quality procedures at a fraction of American prices? I know of people flying to India or Turkey for procedures, but do we have anything of the sort in North America to avoid the transoceanic flight?
- markvdb 6y agoExhibit 98343553578 of the US healthcare system being a mess people drown in. The open question is how to peacefully, durably and quickly transition from this mess to decent healthcare for all.
- eb0la 6y agoIt's complicated (to be polite). US people is used to pay a lot of taxes for nothing. This looks like taxes will go sky high (which shouldn't).
- ramtatatam 6y agoBlimey I thought my tooth surgeon is expensive... Where I live fitting in titanium implant (which is a surgery on its own rights) costs 1/10th of what they paid...
- danielovichdk 6y agoRemember when an american friend visited Copenhagen and collapsed due to the heat. He got so scared of the potential bill that he fled the hospital and took with him a machine that gave him oxygen. The staff later found him and the machine, and kindly laughed at the incident because the system is free here. The american was stoked about the whole thing and could hardly believe he didn't have to pay a cent. Funny guy this one
- cik 6y agoSomething is very wrong with this type of health care, the root costing in crazy. For baselining, Nevada has ~3.09M people, making it roughly 1/4th the population of Ontario (Canada). Sure, there are other (single payer) concerns at play - but the cost difference is crazy. Let's assume this was a >10cm (the largest cateorgy) gash on the face or neck. The provider bills $417 (1). Assuming this is a nighttime emergency, and that the doctor traveled for this (and only this) event, the billing cost is $136.70 (2). Assuming the doctor needed an assistant, for an hour to complete this (extremely unlikely) there is a further billed cost of $60.04 (3). The cost of an overnight bed in Ontario is ~$320-500 (4). Finally, the cost of the ambulance (the only thing one would pay for) is $45 (5). This ignores costs such as gas reimburrsal, parking, etc; they can occur, but are rather low. If one is Canadian, the total cost is $45, the cost of the ambulance co-pay. Visitors to Canada would pay an SUBSIDIZED maximum of $646.70, outside of the cost of the ambulance. For fun, let's inflate these five times - just in case all of the billing codes are wrong, that's still under half (prior to currency conversion) of the cost in the theoretically more efficient / for profit system. Sources 1. https://www.dr-bill.ca/ohip_billing_codes/66/integumentary-system-surgical-procedures https://www.dr-bill.ca/ohip_billing_codes/66/integumentary-s... 2. https://www.dr-bill.ca/blog/ohip/anaesthesia-ohip-billing-codes-cheat-sheet/ https://www.dr-bill.ca/blog/ohip/anaesthesia-ohip-billing-co... 3. https://www.dr-bill.ca/blog/ohip/anaesthesia-ohip-billing-codes-cheat-sheet/ https://www.dr-bill.ca/blog/ohip/anaesthesia-ohip-billing-co... 4. https://www.grhosp.on.ca/care/visitors/billing/room-options https://www.grhosp.on.ca/care/visitors/billing/room-options 5. http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/public/publications/ohip/amb.aspx#:~:text=Ontario%20Residents,a%20resident%20of%20Ontario%2C%20and http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/public/publications/ohip/amb....
- anti-shill 6y agoyeah, it sucks, but can we admit that we have no power over what happens in healthcare? Everyone here is talking about the problem as if we can actually make positive changes. But I don't think we can. I don't think obamacare was an improvement for most americans. Congress is bought and paid for by the lobbies, and no matter who we put into office, nothing about healthcare is going to get better, and it will probably get worse. First we have to understand the problem and admit what the problem really is. The problem is that we have no control over our government, and there is no path in making that better. Can we please just admit that?
- jrs235 6y agoMy son was involved in a go kart accident 6 months ago. Still haven't gotten the bill or know how much I'll be expected to pay because insurance (vehicle and medical) are trying to figure it out. I heard the hospital bill is north of $30,000. This was an ER visit, two night observation room, anesthesia, debriding wounds and stitches. The U.S. is going for broke.
- jrs235 6y agoMerry Thanksgiving! Checked the mail today! Got the bill. Hospital bill says ~$31k, insurance adjustments ~-$28k... I owe $3k. Now to look at the EOB and see how that $27k of adjustments breaks down between discounts (maximum they allow for billing) and what insurance is paying after discounts.
- RickJWagner 6y agoA personal injury lawyer faces a shockingly high medical bill? There's some good to be found here.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoPeople act like “how could it cost this much?” - very clearly it doesn’t and the legal regime and history of the US has led to 3rd party actors negotiating behind the scenes between healthcare providers and patients. Wage controls in WWII led to the concept of employer-provided health insurance. It all went downhill from there for obvious reasons.
- tpoacher 6y ago"Out of a bill of $19,000 [...] the Woodrums eventually only had to pay $1,900. Happy ending." Meanwhile in Europe: "$1,900!!??? WTF!?"
- mickotron 6y agoHealthcare cannot be delivered for profit and still put patient outcomes first, period.
- senectus1 6y agoI split my thumb in two with a rusty manchette a few years back. I had a night in emergency, surgery under general. Plus an overnight stay for plastic surgery reconstruction, plus pain killer drugs and an extra visit after a few weeks and the whole thing cost me less than 2k. (and almost no scarring and full functionality returned.) This is in Australia.