25 ms·
Can't believe all the Apple apologists here. Bribing public officials is a crime, period. It isn't an "unfortunate situation" or anything else that people are c
by paxys 6y ago
Can't believe all the Apple apologists here. Bribing public officials is a crime, period. It isn't an "unfortunate situation" or anything else that people are calling it. It also doesn't matter who initiated the bribe. The employee, and potentially the company itself, absolutely need to be charged and prosecuted for it.
- giantg2 6y agoWhy the company? Seems like it was just this individual.
- jkaplowitz 6y agoThe individual was arranging a donation to be provided by the company, which only didn't happen because of the investigation itself. That is, the bribe would have been paid by Apple.
- giantg2 6y agoBut it probably had no idea that it was part of a bribe. How could it?
- thatguy0900 6y agoWho would have to know before you would consider "the company" as knowing it? This was a chief executive doing it
- giantg2 6y agoI'd say if the company was benefiting instead of just the individuals.
- jkaplowitz 6y agoThis was to indeed benefit Apple, by arming their security team.
- giantg2 6y agoArming someone for employment is under a different permit from the CCW listed in the story. CCWs would not benefit Apple.
- rkt88edmo 6y agoIt absolutely benefits them. Nearly all executive protection teams are concealing. There is no public concealed carry of firearms in CA outside your property without a CCW. There is no parallel professional license that will allow you to do so in public. This is part of what lead to this weird situation for Apple.
- giantg2 6y agoConcealed or exposed, you need a BSIS license as an armed guard (executive protection) in CA.
- rkt88edmo 6y agoNo one is debating that, and the BSIS standards are absurdly low and they are available to everyone. There is no taint in the process for BSIS issuance that has been raised.
- giantg2 6y agoAnd this article isn't about bribing for BSIS licenses, it's about bribing for CCWs. So if the BSIS license is the one needed for professional carry, the CCW is moot from the company's perspective. Edit: Never mind. CA is super stupid.
- zepto 6y agoHead security guard is not exactly a ‘chief executive’.
- jkaplowitz 6y agoAnd head security guard is very different from head of security. The laws attributing liability to the company don't only apply to actions of chief executive - Apple head of security would definitely qualify.
- jkaplowitz 6y agoThis article discusses the two circumstances under which US states may attribute criminal liability to a corporation: https://law.jrank.org/pages/744/Corporate-Criminal-Responsibility-American-standards-corporate-criminal-liability.html https://law.jrank.org/pages/744/Corporate-Criminal-Responsib... Either of these standards would probably apply to a head of security who commits the crime as part of seeking concealed carry permits for an Apple security team.
- giantg2 6y agoCCW is the wrong kind of permit for armed employment. There's a different kind for that. The CCWs would only benefit the individuals, not the company.
- jkaplowitz 6y agoMaybe the news article was being informal, or maybe they specifically wanted to carry concealed and not open. It still seems like whatever was being requested was on behalf of the security team he was overseeing as his primary job duty at Apple.
- giantg2 6y agoIt's possible the journalist was wrong, but I believe the BSIS issues the professional license, not the sherriff. Open or concealed doesn't matter when it's for armed employment - the license from BSIS is what's needed. So it seems this was for personal CCW. Edit: Never mind. CA is super stupid and requires a state license to carry a firearm for employment but would then also require a license from the sheriff to conceal it.
- jkaplowitz 6y agoAs discussed in the other subthread, CCW and BSIS would both be needed for concealed carry executive protection in California.
- 6y ago
- Someone 6y agoIndeed. I think this wasn’t a matter of Apple or the employee paying a bribe, but of the employee receiving one in exchange for stealing hardware from Apple. I read the story as: - Head of security team contacts police to get concealed carrying permits for his employees - Police officer says “if Apple gives us 200 iPads, that can be arranged. On top of that, you’ll get $X”. - Head of security team agrees, signs of for the Apple hardware, and receives a bribe. If so, Apple was the only one paying, but the company probably wouldn’t have known about that (possibly, multiple employees would) If this were the police asking for iPads in exchange for permits, I would call it extortion, not bribery.
- paxys 6y ago> If so, Apple was the only one paying, but the company probably wouldn’t have known about that (possibly, multiple employees would) If an Apple executive was the one running the entire thing, how is the argument that the company wasn't aware of it? What even is "the company" at this point?
- giantg2 6y agoWas it for the benefit of the company or individuals? Approved by the board?
- Someone 6y agoThat’s a gray area, but in this case (200 iPads worth about $75,000 versus a company that has a net income of over a hundred million a day, thousands of employees (even disregarding those working in their stores) and top-level execs that, probably, make over $75,000 net every week), I think it’s a safe bet it didn’t go really high up the chain. Of course, that can change if it turns out Tim Cook knew about this. That would surprise me a lot, though.
- paxys 6y agoThe requested permits were for Apple's security team.
- giantg2 6y agoAs a condition of employment, or personally? Most states have separate licensing for armed employment.
- bsder 6y ago> Why the company? Because you don't just randomly cough up a couple hundred anything from a company like Apple without it appearing on the books somewhere. If it didn't appear on the books anywhere, then it sounds like Apple gave this department a quite significant "petty cash" fund and used this guy and department to do unsavory things so that the higher-ups can have plausible deniability. Yeah, the company needs to get hammered, too.
- giantg2 6y agoMost of these companies do have charity/donation programs. How do you tell which are legitimate vs a bribe like this?
- bsder 6y agoA legitimate "charity/donation" request will get transferred to the "charity/donation" department with appropriate paperwork. A bribe like this will get buried into somebody's "untracked cash" account. The problem is that this is "Standard Operating Procedure" for "Security" departments as they're generally ex-police themselves. That's why they didn't think anything of it.
- giantg2 6y agoI didn't see the part about it being buried instead of through official channels. Did it have that in there?
- bsder 6y agoIf this went to the proper channels it would IMMEDIATELY get flagged for conflict-of-interest. All these big company "security chiefs" run in the same circle. It simply became known that the easiest way to get your CCW was bribery. They already got folks at Facebook. Now Apple. They're going to get more. And I love the quote that this is about the rivalry between "Rosen and Sheriff Smith." As we have repeatedly seen, even when the DA and Sheriff hate each other, the DA doesn't go after the police. If the DA is making a move, the Feds are already involved behind the scenes forcing the DA to move. I suspect this fell out of some Federal security contract or a Federal security clearance background check for somebody.
- crazygringo 6y agoI don't see any Apple apologists here in the comments. Who are you referring to? All I see is the fact that the Apple employee didn't initiate the bribe, the sheriff's office demanded it (extorted it) and the employee was put in the unfortunate immediate situation of either not getting their lawfully permitted license, or paying the bribe. At the end of the day it's bribery so of course the employee deserves to be charged (and Apple if it approved it in any way), but the sheriff's office officials deserve much harsher punishment quite clearly.
- pmoriarty 6y ago"the employee was put in the unfortunate situation of either not getting their lawfully permitted license, or paying the bribe" ...or immediately going to the FBI.
- giantg2 6y agoThese permits in CA are may-issue, not shall-issue. The sheriff can deny for any reason (of course they aren't supposed to ask for a bribe).
- wolco2 6y agoWhy give police the power to decide these permits? Power corrupts
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAgreed, this makes 0 sense to me. There should be an explicit list of reasons for which police should be able to deny these permits, and the police should have to show their evidence as to why they believe one of these reasons apply.
- Spooky23 6y agoThe problem with this is pretty obvious. When some scumbag like a pimp or similar without a conviction goes for a permit, you end up in a situation where the police are enabling certain types of undesirable behavior. IMO, discretion for this sort of thing should be with a judge, not a cop.
- ohazi 6y agoI disagree. I dislike Apple's practices as much as anyone, but when the #2 person at the sheriff's office is the one soliciting the bribe, you have a problem with the police department that even Apple cannot be expected to fix. You can argue that they should have gone straight to the DA, and you might even be right, but the only way for this problem to get fixed is by cleaning house at the police department, not by scolding Apple for trying to work with corrupt officials. Keep in mind that it's incredibly rare for any DA to go against the police, so this case is already unusual. We'll have to wait and see if they actually have the evidence / wherewithal to see this one through rather than just settling out of court for a slap on the wrist. Edit: I actually agree with the comments suggesting that Apple and similar companies will learn from this experience and will use it as an example when trying to ensure that it doesn't happen again, and in that sense, it's important that they be punished too. I think the point I'm trying to make is that, on a moral level, the police department comes off looking way worse than Apple here, and their punishment should be higher. Police are given a special position in society where we essentially trust them to conduct themselves professionally and uphold the law fairly. When that trust is misplaced, the checks are slow and unreliable, and corrupt cops can cause a whole lot of mayhem while we're waiting. So if you're going to go after police corruption, you'd better hit hard. It's really, really bad for society to have police who are so comfortable asking for bribes this openly. It's also bad for companies like Apple to feel like they can just pay the bribes to grease the wheels, but it's a different kind of bad. It's a "We should punish Apple to discourage a tragedy of the commons" kind of bad, while police openly asking for bribes is a "betraying the public trust" kind of bad.
- ubercore 6y agoYou won't be able to convince me that Apple could not have brought this to light in some way. They definitely share a hefty part of the blame.
- themodelplumber 6y agoAgree. Also Apple security are in a long term beneficiary position with any given law enforcement entity, especially one which effectively controls the limits of Apple's personal security measures wrt firearms. To me this seems it would make the "or else" really difficult to think past. What can they do? If they detonate the leadership structure of some department by going on the offense, what is the likelihood they hurt their own ability to work with LEO types in the future? That would be a really hard position. But maybe there are details we just don't have here.
- throwawaygh 6y agoA private citizen of limited means paying a bribe is somehow reasonable because there's a huge power imbalance. Refusing to pay a bribe is also a refusal to participate in a racket. Local police can be extremely petty and extremely violent [1]. If a police officer told me he'd let me off for a bribe, I would probably pay it. I wouldn't be paying to get what I want. Rather, I would be paying to avoid the appearance that I disapprove of the bribery (and the possibility of resulting reprisal). E: And, of course, I would report that bribe as soon as it was safe to do so. And, of course, I'm referring to a scenario where I, as an individual private citizen, am told to pay money to a person with a gun who controls my immediate safety... which, importantly, brings us to the second half of this comment: But this isn't that. A high-level exec at one of the world's most powerful companies paying off a local LEO for a permit instead of, IDK, contacting the State or the Feds, is beyond inexplicable. [1] https://oklahoman.com/article/5666549/woman-recognizes-attackers-voice-in-threatening-messages https://oklahoman.com/article/5666549/woman-recognizes-attac...
- bilbo0s 6y agoWas going to upvote you, but I think even a private citizen of limited means failing to inform the Feds is an unforgivable offense against our society as well. Knowing about public corruption, and not reporting it, is tantamount to racketeering. No matter how much power you have.
- rmk 6y agoThere are plenty of extenuating circumstances. For example, if you were a spouse of a corrupt law enforcement officer who's already facing domestic violence, would it be racketeering if you did not report your spouse's conduct? I am willing to bet it wouldn't (you have a credible fear of being assaulted, or worse yet, losing your life if you did so). This is why things like anonymous tip lines and whistleblower laws exist. You are encouraged, in general, to report misconduct. But there are very specific situations where it's illegal to not report misconduct.
- randallsquared 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- robcohen 6y agoI would agree if California was a shall-issue state for CCW, but it's a may-issue state. Essentially it's arbitrarily up to the sheriffs department if you can get a CCW. Personally, I chose to live in shall-issue states.
- kmonsen 6y agoThat is just bullshit. May issue does not mean may according to bribe.
- giantg2 6y agoHow do you explain denials in a may-issue system if the individual meets statutory requirements?
- tshaddox 6y agoDoes the driving test requirement to receive a driver’s license mean that driver’s licenses are may-issue?
- giantg2 6y agoNope, that's also shall-issue in most states. If you meet the statutory requirements (passing the test, age, etc), then they must issue the license.
- tshaddox 6y agoBut the test is necessarily subjective. The instructor can determine, for instance, whether the applicant drove recklessly during the exam.
- giantg2 6y agoSort of. I kind of hate that reckless driving law since it is somewhat subjective. Each state should have case law about it and allow you your due process rights to challenge it too. But yeah, I can see in the context of the test that it could be a problem. If you record the test, then you should be able to challenge it (sad it sometimes comes to that). I'm in a similar situation, actually. I had a trooper lie in court and even admit to it in the complaint investigation, but the investigator (another trooper) said it must be a misunderstanding. I'm curious how intentionally lying to cover up your mistake (exculpatory evidence) is a misunderstanding as a civil rights violation under Brady v MD, but I also don't want to get 'suicided'.
- altdatathrow 6y agoIs it still a bribe when the public official initiates it? I hope they all get into trouble but I do wonder, when faced with a corrupt public official who is withholding government-provided services, at some point does that not simply become the necessary payment as opposed to a "bribe"?
- TuringNYC 6y agoIt was be entrapment, but still a bribe. There are lots of cases like it.
- geofft 6y agoIt's always a bribe. In places without a fully-functional rule of law, it may also be the necessary payment (i.e., the payment of bribes may be expected to conduct business or get through a checkpoint or whatever), but it's still a bribe. It's actually pretty common for bribes to be requested by the official - the first answer at https://www.quora.com/What-should-I-do-if-the-customs-officer-at-an-airport-in-India-asks-for-a-bribe-rather-than-making-a-legal-customs-receipt-for-the-goods https://www.quora.com/What-should-I-do-if-the-customs-office... has a description of how this sort of thing usually works.
- mlindner 6y agoIf California had reasonable laws around guns then they could do this stuff completely legally. You don't need apologism to protest the ridiculousness of this.
- underseacables 6y agoTechnology is a lot like politics: Only the people you like are doing good.
- randyrand 6y agoI also pay bribes when I feel threatened for my safety and the person i’m talking to has the tools i need for my safety and demands rent. The only people in the wrong here are the police .
- paxys 6y agoWe are talking about a high-ranking Apple executive who needed concealed carry permits. This guy literally runs a private global army. Let's not pretend he was scared for his life. He just chose to do what was easy for himself and the company (pay some pocket change) rather than take any possible legal route.
- mike_d 6y agoHe was in charge of the executive protection team. They are armed because leaders of well known companies face constant threats and are kidnapping targets (Apple would obviously pay countless sums to get Tim Cook back safely for example). The Bay Area and New York are notorious for withholding permits because it creates artificial scarcity, and off-duty cops are the only ones able to fill the demand.
- sfkdjf9j3j 6y agoThat's not what happened here though, there's no competing off duty cops protecting Apple's executives.
- rkt88edmo 6y agoThat's exactly what's happening. Just because Apple/the head of security doesn't want to pay off duty/retired police who have CCW permits because of their LEO jobs, it doesn't mean that isn't completely relevant to the CCW issuance situation.
- solinent 6y agoI don't know if it's just a bribe either--who knows what they did to those iPads, I'm sure information from the police could be used for political gain.
- SCAQTony 6y agoThanks goodness (and Darwin) that there was NOT a mass shooting at Apple Park headquarters. I hope the employees that secured these weapons illegally are let go.
- giantg2 6y agoThe permit does not secure the weapons, it allows them to be carried in public. The weapons would have been secured separately.
- baryphonic 6y ago> Can't believe all the Apple apologists here. Bribing public officials is a crime, period. Apple or no Apple, no one in America should be deprived of their Constitutional rights. I'm more concerned that authoritarian states like California can get away with depriving the people of our explicit rights under American law than I am with people paying bribes just to exercise those rights.
- systemvoltage 6y agoWhat is unconstitutional about prosecuting people of crimes that they commit by bribing officials? I’m not following your logic.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pageandrew 6y agoHe's referring to the Right to Keep and Bear arms only being recognized in those who can afford to bribe the local Sheriff. California's gun laws are pretty blatantly unconstitutional, even without the bribery.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoYes, I would also like to be able to carry around my own personal nuclear warhead. Just in case.
- mike_d 6y agoBay Area Sheriffs withhold a constitutional right in the issuance of permits, which results in something of value being created that they can hold for political or financial favor. Even if you disagree with concealed carry, 2/3 of the counties in CA will issue you a permit no problem that allows you to carry statewide. There is no reasonable argument for not issuing permits here.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
- closeparen 6y agoIt looks like the iPads were for the department, not the guy's personal use. It's a little bit dubious given that it's the same agency asking for and receiving the benefit, but money is fungible. Suppose the Sheriff had insisted on iPads for some other department, like the schools. Governments do stuff like this all the time. In fact constituents get mad when they don't. The Planning Commission is considered derelict in its duty if it just gives away a building permit without getting something good from the developer in return (park, street cleaning program, extra BMR units, promise to use union labor). SFMTA considers corporate philanthropy, coverage of unprofitable neighborhoods, and low-income discount programs when deciding who gets the permit to run scooters in San Francisco. If it is bribery when a government agency asks a permit applicant to spend a bit on the agency's mission, then there's a lot more to prosecute all over the Bay Area.
- kennywinker 6y agoIt's almost like the system of permits for concessions is actually a corrupting force in cities! In my city many development projects went ahead because of various promises (low income housing, cultural venues, etc) and the developer didn't follow through in any meaningful way - i.e. a theater was built, no shows ever took place there. Or low income housing was transitioned to market rate housing within 5 years. But at least these things happened in public, through a semi-transparent process of development permits with public consultations. The process is semi-fixed, the incentives are off, but it's not a straight up bribe behind closed doors.
- closeparen 6y agoWhen it's the commissioners driving the negotiation, the sunlight angle is true. Often, though, it's the activist group which rallies speakers against the project and then negotiates with the developer privately. The developer makes a donation to the activist group, and then members appear at the next meeting to withdrawn their objection. I've seen the tail end of one of these in 3 or 4 of the ~25 planning meetings I've watched.
- Spooky23 6y agoNooooo. You’re making up stuff about things you don’t know about. Accepting gifts is always an issue in government, and often a serious crime for the employee, regardless of who benefits. Accepting or demanding compensation for official action is corruption, regardless of the beneficiary. Negotiating public contracts, seeking public benefit, or enforcing requirements related to permitting is not bribery or corruption. You may not like poor people, public access to urban space, or union labor, but community standards based on law are not corruption. Officials administrating the permitting process have discretion to act. The appointing authority ultimately controls them, and the people ultimately hold them accountable.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoReminds me of the incidents with people working in security for other tech companies, e.g., Uber^1 and Ebay^2. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24227437 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24227437 2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23537357 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23537357
- jauer 6y agoThis was likely for Tim Cook's personal security detail. Basically every high net worth or highly visible tech CEO has a PSD (really high end folks have a counter-kidnap team on standby).
- newacct583 6y ago> Can't believe all the Apple apologists here. Bribing public officials is a crime, period. This is absolutely true. Soliciting a bribe, as a public official, however, is a much (much!) worse crime. And that seems to be what happened here. Absent more detail, I think I'm willing to buy that Moyer was just a normal corporate executive faced with trying to work around a corrupt bureaucracy. But yeah, more detail could change that.
- flowerlad 6y ago> Bribing public officials is a crime, period. In some countries, seeking bribes is a crime, but giving in to a demand for bribe is not. That seems fairer. When you became a public official you agreed to perform your job dutifully. If a public official refuses to perform his job unless a citizen provides him with a bribe, then it seems like the citizen was forced into bribery by the public official. How is it then fair to hold the hapless citizen responsible for the crime?
- ip26 6y agoI think the idea is not to hold the hapless citizen responsible; instead you want to force the hapless citizen to report the solicitation.
- caycep 6y agoit's not clear exactly what happened in the article - did Moyer work w/ the sheriff's office to extort Apple for the permits?
- dboreham 6y agoHmm. From the article this wasn't a payment of cash to an official. It was a donation in kind to the police dept. I don't know any more than is reported in the article but I will say that some years ago I was subject to a similar "offer". Much smaller in scope, and the official wasn't in law enforcement, but similar enough in essence. At the time I thought it a little weird but also assumed "that must be how things work here". I passed because the cost wasn't worth the benefit to me. I certainly did not think that I should go inform the police that this official had solicited a bribe.
- mxcrossb 6y agoIt’s a reminder that most people think that as soon as the system isn’t fair or someone does something bad to you, it is now ethical for you to use any means to get what you think you deserve.
- mlindner 6y agoIt's actually a reminder that most people think that when the state violates their fundamental rights they have a right to get their rights back by any means possible.
- hedora 6y agoAfter going through the process of building a house in CA, I believe we should decriminalize offering of bribes, but not solicitation of bribes. $100K’s of dollars (>> 10% of the total project cost) have been extracted from us by various bureaucratic processes that are outside what is explicitly specified by the law. I am confident that this would not have happened if we were well politically connected, and had friends that worked at PG&E. I honestly don’t know if we were “just supposed to know” that we needed to make some specific charitable or political donation or something like that, because no one has explicitly solicited a bribe from us. If it were legal to offer bribes, I could go online, and search for information on who to pay off, and to what ends. Even better, California could fix the law to eliminate these gray areas. In the Apple case, they could move from “may issue” to “shall issue”. In my case, there could be bounds on permit review durations, and also the cost / benefit of “environmental” regulations: if some ask is too expensive homeowners could “buy credits” by doing something else that would be more effective for the same amount of money. To be clear, the money they extracted from us for “the environment” will substantially increase our carbon footprint, impact on local wildlife and on the watershed — we planned to voluntarily spend that money to mitigate those impacts because we’re extremely concerned about the environment. Now, we’ve been forced to waste it in low impact ways. I’m not upset that we were forced to spend the money. I’m upset it was wasted.
- ridaj 6y agoCan you be more specific? The experience I had with house construction permitting in a big California city was completely above-the-table and reasonable.
- kbhn 6y ago> I believe we should decriminalize offering of bribes I too would like to erode confidence in our public servants.
- ip26 6y agoIt's become far too difficult for public servants to extort me, something needs to change.
- 6y ago
- alsetmusic 6y agoAs a huge fan (with ink on my skin since 2000) and as a former employee, I’m deeply disappointed. I’m sad for the company’s employees who have to live with guilt by association. I know that the people there believe in what they do and their work has been tainted. For shame. Slightly offhand, I wonder how this will alter Apple’s security approach down the line. Not whether they believe in security, but the right road to get there if there’s a shakeup.
- briandear 6y agoThe fact that a bribe is necessary is the problem. The second amendment guarantees the right to keep and bear arms and the “may issue” vs “shall issue” permitting process is a direct affront to that right. Anyone that meets the legal requirements for a permit should be entitled to one. It shouldn’t be up to the discretion of a public official to anoint chosen ones based on their own personal feelings. Either requirements are met or not. But a public official shouldn’t be evaluating “need.” That’s not the Jon of the public official. That would be like a public official deciding one media outlet should be allowed to publish and another one denied. Equal protection is violated. Two people with identically clean backgrounds should not have one person awarded a permit and another denied. To get a drivers license, you don’t have to prove a need to drive: you pass the test and pay the fee and you are good. And unlike driving, keeping and bearing a firearm is constitutionally protected.
- disown 6y ago> Can't believe all the Apple apologists here. Really? HN has been a den of Apple, Microsoft, etc worship for a while now. In another thread on the frontpage, people are encouraging people to buy Apple TV. It's partly the social media PR teams these companies hire, it's the advertising and it's also the type of people HN attracts. It's sickening but what can you do.
- gvfdabgea 6y agoyes; a forum for computer enthusiasts filled with people enthusiastic about computers.... what has this place come to indeed
- bergstromm466 6y ago> yes; a forum for computer enthusiasts filled with people enthusiastic about computers.... what has this place come to indeed Oh sure, there's 0 difference between proprietary black box software and free/libre open source... give me a break. Tech's Great-Man theory has society idolizing Silicon Valley monopolizers: "In the movie Steve Jobs, a character asks, “So how come 10 times in a day I read ‘Steve Jobs is a genius?’” The great man reputation that envelops Jobs is just part of a larger mythology of the role that Silicon Valley, and indeed the entire U.S. private sector, has played in technology innovation. We idolize tech entrepreneurs like Jobs, and credit them for most of the growth in our economy. But University of Sussex economist Mariana Mazzucato, who has just published a new U.S. edition of her book, The Entrepreneurial State: Debunking Public vs. Private Sector Myths, makes a timely argument that it is the government, not venture capitalists and tech visionaries, that have been heroic. “Every major technological change in recent years traces most of its funding back to the state,” says Mazzucato. Even “early stage” private-sector VCs come in much later, after the big breakthroughs have been made. For example, she notes, “The National Institutes of Health have spent almost a trillion dollars since their founding on the research that created both the pharmaceutical and the biotech sectors–with venture capitalists only entering biotech once the red carpet was laid down in the 1980s. We pretend that the government was at best just in the background creating the basic conditions (skills, infrastructure, basic science). But the truth is that the involvement required massive risk taking along the entire innovation chain: basic research, applied research and early stage financing of companies themselves.” The Silicon Valley VC model, which has typically dictated that financiers exit within 5 years or so, simply isn’t patient enough to create game changing innovation." [1] [1] https://time.com/4089171/mariana-mazzucato/ https://time.com/4089171/mariana-mazzucato/
- satisfaction 6y agoBeing an Apple apologist is one thing but being an apologist for corrupt government officials is reprehensible. I side with the underdog in this case.
- La1n 6y agoBoth can be bad you know.
- satisfaction 6y agoIndeed. When Apple become extortionist you go to another handset maker, when the government becomes extortionist you either pay or go to jail. There is a scale of Evil.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- garmaine 6y ago> It also doesn't matter who initiated the bribe. Well, it does make a legal difference as entrapment would invalidate the legal case against him. (I have no evidence this is what happened here--just pointing out a poor choice of words!)
- smokey_circles 6y ago>It also doesn't matter who initiated the bribe. What a silly thing to say. Whether or not you initiated a bribe does not defend your participation in it. True But ignoring the balance of power for, what appears to be, a reason to hate on Apple is just daft. Shockingly so. A police offer demanding a bribe is not the same as a police officer accepting one. Just ignores the entire social dynamic of humans. Power dynamics are the central theme of human relationships. This is just a weird form of victim blaming, though not for a moment am I suggesting anyone is innocent here. The Undersheriff should be crucified as a means of deterrence. You can't have positions of power occupied by those seeking to corrupt them. Which, I think, is not far off your argument, you just want to seem to needlessly drag Apple into this. They weren't involved, beyond their employee basically stealing their stock. Is that somehow their fault? Should we charge them with criminal negligence for trusting someone? That's not going to have long term consequences for whistleblowers at all
- fortran77 6y ago> Can't believe all the Apple apologists here I know for a fact Apple used to have "astroturf" campaigns to keep forum postings about them positive. Perhaps they still do.