11 ms·
The other option Apple had here was notifying people their battery was bad, not hiding the throttling, and letting people buy new batteries for a reasonable pro
by marcosdumay 6y ago
The other option Apple had here was notifying people their battery was bad, not hiding the throttling, and letting people buy new batteries for a reasonable profit.
- arcticbull 6y agoIt's not bad though, it's normal, and functioning as expected at that part of the age curve. You can avoid this by reducing performance for the entire time you owned the device so nobody noticed, I guess, but that's all.
- stale2002 6y ago> You can avoid this by reducing performance for the entire time you owned the device so nobody noticed, I guess, but that's all. Or you could notify people of the situation, and sell replacement batteries. That would have been the best solution.
- arcticbull 6y agoAgain, the battery is not defective, it is a certain number of years old. That is how batteries perform at a certain age. Batteries are consumable parts like tires and ink cartridges. It's like returning an ink cartridge at 50% capacity because it's only got half the ink left. Yes, that's the point, that's what cartridges do. This feature is designed to always get the most out of a battery. Is that really something to complain about? I guess this is where it's a perspective issue. - You're saying that a new battery starts out at "100%" and that after a year or so, Apple throttles is down to "80%" because it can no longer keep up with how it came out of the factory. Apple designed a function that reduces the performance of a system that's defective to hide the defect. That would be strictly negative. - What I'm saying is that the battery starts out at "120%" out of the factory (which you can confirm, when you buy a new mac check out the Batter mAh vs. design rating in System Report) and eventually drifts towards "100%" over time. Apple designed a system that allows you to get that extra 20% at the start, when it's available. That would be strictly positive.
- Nullabillity 6y agoAn ink cartridge at 50% still performs about the same as at 100%, it's just got less life in it. A better comparison would be an unevenly worn toner cartridge, where someone keeps going "I don't see the problem, it prints just fine on the sides!".
- stale2002 6y ago> That is how batteries perform at a certain age. Ok, and customers should still be informed of whatever it is that you think the situation is, and they should be allowed to purchase a replacement. > This feature is designed to always get the most out of a battery. Is that really something to complain about? They should have still told the customer and allowed people to buy a replacement. > I guess this is where it's a perspective issue. No. My perspective is not that. Instead my perspective is that the consumer should have been told about that, and offered the ability to buy a replacement.
- Retric 6y agoThis issue impacts literally every phone ever sold. Manufactures can hide it any number of ways, but a new battery is always better even if your phone is exactly 1 day old. That’s what continuous degradation means.
- stale2002 6y ago> This issue impacts literally every phone ever sold. No, actually, most phones did not release an update like this, deny the situation, and then also refused to let people purchase replacement batteries. The issue is that Apple did this update, did not tell people about the whole thing, however you want to describe it, and then also did not allow people to buy replacement batteries.
- arcticbull 6y agoAll that tells me is that other phones aren't getting the most out of new batteries, and are instead limiting themselves to the performance of an old battery. But yes, I agree, they should have permitted replacements - in fact replacements should have been permitted at home. Batteries deserve to be user serviceable.
- greggman3 6y agoLet's imagine it's a electric car. The car goes 70mph when you buy it. Suddenly it only runs at 45mph. You want to buy a new battery to fix it but the car company refuses even though you're willing to pay. Why should you have to put up with a car that only goes 45mph when it went 70mph when you bought it? What part of this is hard to understand. I don't want a phone that runs slow.
- arcticbull 6y agoIt's different in that the electric car is marketed as capable of achieving 70mph, Apple does not market iOS devices in terms of performance. No promises were made in that regard - at all, IIRC.
- webmobdev 6y ago> Apple does not market iOS devices in terms of performance. Come on dude, stop bullshitting. Every Apple device promotion shows how it is faster or better than the previous device or its competitors. Even the new Apple ARM processor touts how it is equal or better than other processors.
- Dylan16807 6y agoConsumer expectations matter. People would be rightfully mad if cars changed in performance after you test drove them, after all, even with no explicit promises. And Apple does advertise benchmarks on their slides.
- mft_ 6y agoDon’t customers have a reasonable expectation of roughly consistent performance of their device? And to your point, car companies don’t market their cars using ‘achieving 70mph’ as a feature. It’s just a reasonable expectation of performance. They might mention the top speed, but that’s more of a specification than a marketing feature in most cases.
- arcticbull 6y agoSure, but the performance of your car degrades as the tires bald, does it not? Fuel economy changes, cornering, maximum acceleration off the line.
- conk 6y agoOr apple could make the device a few mm thicker and put in a larger battery that’s able to produce enough current for a reasonable product life.
- mft_ 6y agoSame problem would have occurred, just a few % later.