15 ms·
M1 Mac Mini Teardown
- harpastum 6y agoLooks like the site is down. Here's the archive.org mirror: http://web.archive.org/web/20201118135839/https://egpu.io/forums/desktop-computing/teardown-late-2020-mac-mini-apple-silicon-m1-thunderbolt-4-usb4-pcie-4/ http://web.archive.org/web/20201118135839/https://egpu.io/fo...
- rvanlaar 6y agoNow that I see egpu on hackernews I know why the site was slow ;-)
- sairamkunala 6y agogoogle cache link: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?source=hp&ei=cDq1X43HLZW6rQGa976YCA&q=cache%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fegpu.io%2Fforums%2Fdesktop-computing%2Fteardown-late-2020-mac-mini-apple-silicon-m1-thunderbolt-4-usb4-pcie-4%2F&oq=cache%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fegpu.io%2Fforums%2Fdesktop-computing%2Fteardown-late-2020-mac-mini-apple-silicon-m1-thunderbolt-4-usb4-pcie-4%2F&gs_lcp=CgZwc3ktYWIQAzIICAAQsQMQyQMyAggAMgUIABCxAzICCAAyBQgAELEDMgUIABCxAzICCAAyAggAMgIIADIFCAAQsQM6CwguELEDEMcBEKMCOgIILjoLCC4QsQMQyQMQkwI6CAgAELEDEIMBUH5YyAxggw9oAHAAeACAAVuIAYwEkgEBNpgBAKABAaABAqoBB2d3cy13aXo&sclient=psy-ab&ved=0ahUKEwiNv-uXsYztAhUVXSsKHZq7D4MQ4dUDCAY&uact=5 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?source=hp&ei=cD...
- daniel-thompson 6y agoThis returns 404 for me.
- osy 6y agoOne thing to note is that the JHL8040R is a TB retimer not a controller. The difference is a controller “speaks” the TB protocol and exposes USB, PCIe, and DP signals to the (typically) PCH and/or Intel CPU. They’re typically 10-20W and, from personal experience, absolute shit to work with (buggy firmware). A retimer is a < 1W part that just strengthens the TB signal coming from the outside world and cleans it up so the controller (integrated in the M1 here presumably) does not have to deal with a weak or noisy signal. Important to note that Intel plans to integrate a TB4 controller in their future (mobile?) processors but seems like Apple beat them to it. Also it’s unclear if M1’s integrated TB controller is TB3 or TB4 (you can have a TB4 retimer drive only TB3 signals).
- realityking 6y agoAccording to Apple's tech specs is Thunderbolt 3: https://www.apple.com/mac-mini/specs/ https://www.apple.com/mac-mini/specs/ Aside: I''m sure I had read before that the M1 Macs come with USB4 and Thunderbolt 3. However the tech specs say it's USB 3.1 Gen 2 and Thunderbolt 3.
- jeffbee 6y agoThe marketing site clearly says USB4. """With two screaming-fast Thunderbolt / USB 4 ports, two USB-A ports, HDMI 2.0, Wi-Fi 6, and Gigabit Ethernet, Mac mini is up for anything and everything."""
- coder543 6y agoThe tech specs page you linked says both things: "USB 4 ports with support for [...]" "USB 3.1 Gen 2" It's rather confusing. Is USB 4 just another name for USB 3.1 Gen 2 with Thunderbolt 3 support? I wouldn't put it past the USB IF to come up with something like that, but I don't think that's correct here.
- vvhn 6y agoUSB4 is essentially a branding strategy around the USB C connector which with tunneling various standards (USB 3.2 , thunderbolt ) and speeds. Some are required and some are optional to get branded as USB4.
- jsmith45 6y agoOne could alternatively describe it more as a rebranding of thunderbolt multiplexing layer. For those unfamiliar: USB4 does not specify how to interface with specific non-host devices like USB 3 and older did. Instead it is a multi-protocol tunneling (think multiplexing with routing) system, that allows tunneling USB3.2, Display Port, and optionally PCI-E (i.e. what thunderbolt is known for). It also specifies a requirement of support for different alternate modes, like display-port alternate mode (non-tunneled), and optionally thunderbolt 3 alternate mode. (Thunderbolt 3 runs at a different rate than USB4, among a small list of other differences, not counting the additional features specified in USB4). Hubs are required to support the otherwise optional thunderbolt 3 alternate mode and USB4 tunneled PCI-E, thereby making every USB4 hub a valid Thunderbolt hub, both for classic thunderbolt (TB3), and for USB4-based thunderbolt (i.e. using PCI-E tunneling in USB4, which I assume part of the updates made in TB4) Hubs will also support plain USB 3.X from a host, since USB4 is just a negotiated alternate mode over USB3. Thus USB3 can be used unencapsulated if only the hub supports USB4; Fully encapsulated if Host, hub, and device all support USB4; or partially encapsulated, like if the host and hub support USB4, but one of the downstream devices only supports USB3. The hub becomes responsible for encapsulating/unencapulating the tunneled USB3. In a similar way, a hub can support connecting a classic thunderbolt (TB3) device to a hypothetical host that only supports USB4 PCI-E encapsulation. The upstream port and downstream ports are independent, so one can use the TB3 data rate while the other can use USB4, and the hubs are required to pass the PCI-E data through a PCI-E switch, so everything just works. (Especially since talking TB3 is deliberately nearly the same as talking USB4, other than link speed). Obviously, USB2 is of course supported as well, in parallel to all other modes since it has separate data lines. But USB4 is not all perfect. For example every USB4 port on a host must support display-port output. That is not really a huge problem on say a laptop, but it is a pain on enthusiast PC building, since it means motherboards will need a display-port passthrough socket in order to support that requirement. And undoubtedly there are or will be many non-compliant devices out there that break the whole intended it-just-works approach.
- nix23 6y agoIs that website hosted on that Mac Mini? It's slow as hell :-)
- _ph_ 6y agoIf it were hosted on a M1 Mini, it would be much faster :)
- nix23 6y agoHaha yeah that's true. BUT still no 10GbE :-) Man...HN really has zero Humor...it's like talking with a bunch of Java-Dev's..let's see how much they have this time.
- codezero 6y agoYou're mostly right, but you can get away with a lot of humor if it's not quite so low effort, but fwiw, your joke would have been better if you pointed out the 10gbe deficiency - I didn't realize that was a thing, but I also think it's pretty clear at this point that all these models are meant for lower end consumers, so the top-of-the-line needs are absolutely not in this round, and we're all well aware of that at this point.
- nix23 6y ago>your joke would have been better if you pointed out the 10gbe deficiency I think it's more funny that when you make a joke about apple, the apple fanboys act more like the guy in the famous 1984 TV-advertisement, really grumpy truffles ;)
- czzr 6y agoMaybe, but downvoting low effort jokes is common on HN, no special assumptions about apple required.
- 6y ago
- nwah1 6y agoGiven that they claimed the Macbook Air is fanless, I was wondering if this one would be. Since it isn't, that seems disappointing. Not that I was going to buy one.
- yawnr 6y agoLol what do you mean claimed? The Air is indeed fanless, the Mini and Pro both have fans. None of this is a surprise.
- nwah1 6y agoSometimes when people say the word 'claimed' they are not expressing skepticism but are instead being precise. In an E-Prime sense, for instance.
- rovr138 6y agoWhy is it disappointing?
- vbezhenar 6y agoSome people love fanless solutions. No need to worry about dust.
- rovr138 6y agoIf it has a hole, dust will find a way. My RPi's are fanless and I have to clean them. Not often, but I've cleaned them more than my laptop (which, to be honest, I've never cleaned).
- noiv 6y ago> ... to worry about dust. and noise.
- nwah1 6y agoAnd moving parts make a system less durable. And cooling itself requires energy.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoInteresting that they're still using the old 150W power supply when Anandtech measured the entire system's maximum power draw at 37W IIRC. It makes this first generation of ARM Macs feel kind of lazily cobbled together. It'll be interesting to see future designs where the M1 wasn't just retrofitted but is a first class citizen.
- spijdar 6y agoPurely speculating here, but Thunderbolt allows for pretty substantial power to be sent bidirectional. It's conceivable that the excess power could be used for that or some other peripheral. I know I can charge my MBP off the excess power from my Dell w/thunderbolt 3, with a similar power supply discrepeny (only ever measured 50-60W used in system, but power supply is rated for 110-120W IIRC) Or, they're just being lazy/economical and reusing old stock.
- kevindong 6y agoTo play devil's advocate, why bother designing a new PSU when you can just slap in the existing one and be perfectly compatible? The efficiency differences with a 37 W max power draw is negligible.
- yborg 6y agoIt's also a proven component with an established supply chain. A new PSU has to go through worldwide certification testing, etc. Why incur additional cost for a low-volume product?
- wffurr 6y agoFor the Mac Mini, I'd rather see it grow the ability to use more power than get smaller. More RAM, more cores, more GPU, more ports, eGPU capability. It's already a fairly convenient size that you can buy server racks and brackets for. The new system design I want to see is an update on the 11" MacBook Air or the 12" MacBook. I'd like to see if they can get a clamshell with good battery life and decent performance under two pounds and just wide enough for a full-size keyboard. The 11" MacBook Air is still my favorite laptop I've ever owned; I'm sad they discontinued it and didn't refresh the design. Maybe it can come back with an M1 or M2 chip, though.
- PowerfulWizard 6y agoSomething I was personally wondering about is how the DRAM was added to the M1 'chip'. This image shows clearly: http://web.archive.org/web/20201118042108/https://egpu.io/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/2020-m1-mac-mini-unboxing-processor-thunderbolt-4-controllers.jpg http://web.archive.org/web/20201118042108/https://egpu.io/wp... I guess they must be using much higher density for their 16G than a typical 16G SODIMM for example. I'm not fully understanding why the memory chips need to be on the M1 package if they're using the same package as all other memory.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoCloser to the core, better performance.
- PowerfulWizard 6y agoYeah, I'm looking at the rationale for HBM which looks physically similar and it seems to be closeness and the ability to have more wires. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Bandwidth_Memory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Bandwidth_Memory But the HBM photos have the 'interposer' layer and look to be using bare dies, the M1 looks to not have the interposer and to be using the DRAM package. I'm not fully convinced with why the DRAM needs to be on the M1 but there must be a reason. Apple's marketing site says their 'Unified Memeory Architecture' uses a 'custom package' so maybe the DRAM package appearance is the same but the interface is not.
- AnotherGoodName 6y agoI wonder if this will become the norm for all CPU manufacturers at some point. If they put 64Gb directly next to a high end CPU and that made it 10% faster all around i suspect it would be a pretty popular choice despite the lack of upgradability.
- stickyricky 6y agoI think for the most part upgrading RAM (capacity-wise) has been pretty stable (for my uses at least - programming and games). I've been on 16gb since...well as long as I can remember. Every time I upgrade I'm jumping from DDR2 to 3 to 4 and probably soon 5. So its not like I keep the sticks anyway. Even when I stay on DDR4 I have to upgrade because the speed of the RAM is too slow to feed the processor. Its unfortunately rare for me to not have to buy RAM with a new CPU.
- arberx 6y agoHN crashed egpu.io
- koreanguy 6y agoError establishing a database connection resources smashed
- rewsiffer 6y agoIs that the SSD soldered directly to the board? If so, that's a big disappointment considering the amount of free space in there.
- vetinari 6y agoIt is soldered to the board since 2016 (on portables), so no surprises there. Since T2, it is only flash chips anyway, the drive controller is inside the T2. So yes, make sure your backup procedure is good.
- mmastrac 6y agoThey nuked the lifeboat connector as well that was potentially useful for actually recovering data if your SSD died. If you lose your CPU, you now lose your SSD.
- kube-system 6y agoIs losing a CPU a common enough failure-case that it makes sense to implement fail-safes for? I would think that's pretty low on the list of likely causes of failure.
- mmastrac 6y agoI mean it's more than CPU - losing power regulators, or anything else that causes your machine not to boot to a DFU mode. Watch Louis Rossman's channel for long enough and you'll see how many possible failure modes there are. My 2014 MBP died a few years back of power regulator cause, but I was able to pull the SSD and image it in the case that they were unable to repair the device.
- Mindwipe 6y agoAs noted below, it's a lot more than the CPU. I lost three Macbooks in two years from USB controller blow outs, which is a known issue because the part they used is lousy, and it took out the entire storage with it. I had some backups thankfully, but I know people who have lost everything.
- Damogran6 6y agoHoly crap there's a lot of dead air space in that teeny tiny case.
- dylan604 6y agoI would love the same comment to be true about the MBP. Add a couple of mm to the thickness. This would allow for useful ports be added to the body, and then fill the remaining space with battery.
- kgermino 6y ago> This would allow for useful ports be added to the body, and then fill the remaining space with battery. More ports would be nice (I'm hoping but doubting that we can get some more ports on the pros once the cooling system can be smaller) but the 16" is already pretty maxed out on the battery front so don't expect any changes there.
- dylan604 6y agoI never expect anything other than to be disappointed in Apple hardware. I'm a different animal than their target demo. Small is not cute to me. Smaller means I'm sacrificing something. I can sympathize with the move from USB-A to USB-C. We had to learn the same with the transition from ADB->USB and/or SCSI->USB. The one thing I feel is inexcusable was the removal of the SD card reader. What does "maxed out" on the battery front mean to you? Every laptop/iDevice comes with a different battery design/shape. Laptop batteries should be like water looking to fill every crack and cranny with more space to store electrons.
- micv 6y agoThe 16" MBP has the biggest lithium battery you can have and still fly on US planes: https://www.tsa.gov/travel/security-screening/whatcanibring/items/lithium-batteries-more-100-watt-hours https://www.tsa.gov/travel/security-screening/whatcanibring/...
- batt4good 6y agoVery interesting to see how they bailed on using an IHS over the two dram modules ON the processor die! I love how you can see "reach" engineering solutions in apple products, it's clear that they realized the ram would be too large to fit under an IHS and just decided to go with what ended up in the M1 Mac Mini. Very much hoping apple starts allowing even third party nvidia drivers again for latest gen GPU's...
- ralfd 6y agoWhat does IHS mean?
- jakemauer 6y agoIntegrated heat spreader, I believe.
- mark-wagner 6y agoYes, and if you look at the at the IHS it looks like it was intended to cover the RAM, but couldn't, so they just chopped that part of it off.
- rowanG077 6y agointegrated heat spreader
- spijdar 6y agoUnfortunately it looks like they're taking the opposite approach, and phasing out even AMD drivers, with eGPUs apparently (?) not supported on M1 devices. It seems they want to phase out all non Metal APIs. (Which is to say, I bet the return of eGPUs on mac will only happen if apple releases a discrete Metal-based GPU) It makes sense, so far as it means they can further integrate hardware solutions they make themselves and not deal with a higher level driver interfaces. Otherwise they'll be limited to incorporating features present in all supported vendors.
- 6y ago
- baby-yoda 6y agois it apparent from the teardown if there is a limitation which prevents 10g ethernet from being included in this model? pcie lanes or something similar?
- yborg 6y agoApple obviously has sales numbers for 10g on the existing consumer products that offered it. I imagine it hasn't been a big seller.
- baby-yoda 6y agomy impression was always that the 10g was primarily offered to satisfy whale-customers like MacStadium. I recall seeing somewhere they accounted for estimated > 50% of Mini sales (although I may be completely embellishing that number). anything else just gravy.
- robin_reala 6y agoNot sure, but if you still need 10G you can get comparatively priced ($100 option vs $150 product) TB3<->10G adapters: https://www.sonnetstore.com/products/solo-10g https://www.sonnetstore.com/products/solo-10g
- baby-yoda 6y agothat is reasonable, thanks for sharing.
- saagarjha 6y agoAny idea why this is so large?
- STRML 6y agoCould be worse, see https://www.amazon.com/CalDigit-Connect-10G-Thunderbolt-Ethernet/dp/B07RH7VPDF/ https://www.amazon.com/CalDigit-Connect-10G-Thunderbolt-Ethe.... Looks like the controller generates significant heat, so there's a tradeoff between active cooling or increased thermal mass.
- ehejsbbejsk 6y agoI expect Apple to role out its own gaming console by 2nd or 3rd gen. There’s so much potential here. One of the most underrated Apple announcements in a very long time. I haven’t been this excited for Mac since they announced OS X!
- gorkish 6y agoUh, AppleTV? Apple may very well beef up AppleTV and market the gaming angle of the device a lot more than they currently are, but given their history with Pippin I think your claim they will pitch a new dedicated game console type device is unlikely in the extreme.
- ehejsbbejsk 6y agoI was thinking more in terms of iOS apps and games eventually making their way into Mac Mini type of system ($6-700 range). They already have the ecosystem with tons of developers. It would not surprise me if Apple has 5nm GPUs in the works that can surpass Nvidia and AMD by a significant margin. I am also very interested in what they do with Mac Pro.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoIt's worth noting that $6-700 would make a theoretical Apple game console more expensive than the top-of-the-line models from Sony and Microsoft, which are themselves the most expensive consoles in recent memory. The Apple TV 4K already costs $180/$200 without a controller, which could easily set you back an additional $60. Combined, that's more than half the price of a disc-less PS5, and very close to the cost of a Nintendo Switch.
- Hamuko 6y ago>very close to the cost of a Nintendo Switch The Nintendo Switch is pretty deceptive in its pricing. You buy it and quickly realise that you need to spend a lot more money. Internal storage is limited, so you need an SD card at least. Then if you plan on carrying it around, a screen protector is pretty much a requirement. And if you are planning on carrying it around, you'll also want a case for it. And if you don't plan on carrying it around and are only docking it, you probably want a Pro Controller since the included ones are not really that good for couch play. And after you've accessorised yourself, you're now stuck with the most expensive game library, with first-party titles pretty much never dropping in price. Want to buy a first-party launch title for the Nintendo Switch? That'll be $50-60 for Breath of the Wild. Meanwhile Horizon Zero Dawn, which is an acclaimed first-party title pretty much the same age as BotW, is available for $20 or less. Even cross-platform games might be more expensive on the Switch due to the cartridge costs.
- whalesalad 6y agoSo funny how the heat spreader looks like someone just snipped a portion of it off during assembly to make it fit with the dimms there.
- skavi 6y agoThe A12X looks like this as well IIRC.
- dmitrygr 6y agooriginal source is down. archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20201118135839/https://egpu.io/forums/desktop-computing/teardown-late-2020-mac-mini-apple-silicon-m1-thunderbolt-4-usb4-pcie-4/ https://web.archive.org/web/20201118135839/https://egpu.io/f...
- CapriciousCptl 6y ago> As soon as the M1 Mac mini arrived, I tore it down to confirm a few things Apple didn't make clear. All M1 Macs come with Thunderbolt 4 ports. I think there's some nuance and technicality to this, because even though the ports themselves could meet Thunderbolt 4 specs under different conditions, they don't in the current configurations. Apple deliberately calls these "Thunderbolt / USB 4" ports, leaving out the version number from Thunderbolt. One of the requirements of a Thunderbolt 4 port is it can drive 2 4k displays, which Apple is very clear it cannot in the current models. So, that alone makes these not Thunderbolt 4. I don't think anyone's tested the rest of the Thunderbolt 4 features to know which ones are and aren't present. https://newsroom.intel.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/11/2020/07/thunderbolt4-comparison-chart.jpg https://newsroom.intel.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/11/2020/...
- kristianp 6y agoLooking forward to a macbook teardown.