13 ms·
DEA Pursues Vast Expansion of Patient Surveillance
- pstuart 6y agoTo hell with the DEA.
- jdally987 6y agoThis, short & sweet, to the point. Should be top comment. Seriously. The other Orwellian agency installments are at least iffy with some potential justification for their existence, but I struggle to think of any way my life would be worse if the DEA were to just... not.
- megiddo 6y agoAll the responses are about legality or process. I mean, if we're going to defund the police, you can't pick a better target than the DEA. Just get rid of them. They represent everything that's wrong with moral policing. In an ideal world, they would be defunded, the department's charter revoked by congress, and every employee investigated for criminal activity. See if they like a taste of the same bullshit they dish out to the rest of the country.
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoAt the risk of a reddit-style comment: "Yes please." Honestly just reverse the drug bans, treat them life public health problems, and disband agencies like this. Nothing good has ever come out of giving government agencies this kind of power and this kind of mandate.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>I mean, if we're going to defund the police, you can't pick a better target than the DEA ATF wants you to hold its beer. Seriously though, there's at least a few old farts who don't hate the DEA. The ATF has far fewer people who don't hate it.
- notRobot 6y ago> The DEA is interested in its agents having “unlimited access to patient de-identified data” on re/filled prescriptions, daily supply, payment type, dosing information and gender, among other characteristics, until at least 2025. ...
- proverbialbunny 6y agoIf it's okay for the DEA to get this information without a warrant so can other agencies get it.
- pjc50 6y agoHaven't they noticed there's a pandemic on?
- CamperBob2 6y agoWhat they've noticed is that the trend toward cannabis legalization has left entire departments within their agency with little or nothing to do. This is anathema to any government bureaucracy, including the DEA. Accordingly, they are now looking for new ways to justify their budget.
- mtgx 6y agoJust when marijuana is about to be legalized at the federal level. This can't be a coincidence. They will no longer be able to arrest people for marijuana, but now they can arrest them for dozens or hundreds of other drugs. Seems like a net "win" for the DEA.
- m0zg 6y agoHow 'bout we do something about that Chinese fentanyl, DEA, would that be too much to ask?
- Pirgo 6y agoFirst of all, problem with fentanyl is that it's ~100x more potent than morphine, or ~20x times more potent than heroin. While many people read this as "it's got 100x times stronger high", it doesn't mean that (actually it has shorter acting high, more adverse side effects and slightly less enjoyable high compared to heroin). It's just means you need 20x times lower quantity for comparable effect. Given that into account, you need 20x lower quantity to smuggle. It's physically impossible for ANY agency to control millions and millions of postal shipments containing small amounts of contraband. It's one thing to push 100kg containers of heroin, and whole another game ordering 50 grams from Dark web. It's incontrollable in that way. Second, what you're basically asking for is MORE WAR ON DRUGS. Addiction is public and mental health problem, and should be approached as such. DEA is the last agency you should plead for help in times of crisis such as this opioid one. Harm reduction programs are proven as best way to tackle such problems, proven time and time again around the world. Third, calling fentanyl "Chinese fentanyl" is reminiscent of recent declarations of "Chinese virus". It's fentanyl. It doesn't have nationality.
- m0zg 6y agoIt's made mostly in China right now though, so it's quite literally "Chinese". Proof: https://www.dea.gov/sites/default/files/2020-03/DEA_GOV_DIR-008-20%20Fentanyl%20Flow%20in%20the%20United%20States_0.pdf https://www.dea.gov/sites/default/files/2020-03/DEA_GOV_DIR-... And yeah, I do think that not preventing its import is doing a tremendous amount of harm. If you want to call this "war on drugs", call it what you wish, but I think everyone would be better off if the arrows in that PDF were eliminated.
- La1n 6y ago>It's made mostly in China right now though, so it's quite literally "Chinese". Proof: It doesn't say that at all, it says that most of the _import_ into the US is Chinese made fentanyl. It does not touch at all on US made fentanyl.
- renewiltord 6y agoOh interesting. I've been pretty lowsec on telling my medical practitioners about my drug use. Looks like this is for keeping tabs on people who buy prescription drugs. It's not about searching your records for illicit drug use. I guess I stick to what I'm doing now.
- La1n 6y ago>I've been pretty lowsec on telling my medical practitioners about my drug use. Also a good idea because physicians are less likely to prescribe you the same as someone else who doesn't use illicit drugs. They often make no distinction between someone telling them they use LSD once a year, or someone who admits they use opiates recreationally.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoMy provider requires random urinalysis and an expansive privacy waiver. (And everything is recorded in a state registry that is available to local government agents) In the US, it is good practice to be careful with what you say to doctors, especially about drug use because patient-doctor privacy is mostly a myth these days.
- DanBC 6y agoThis is an odd proposal. Most importantly: we need to start treating drug addiction, and long term pain, as the public health emergencies they are and we need to stop criminalising drug addicts. > Diversion investigations involve, but are not limited to, practitioners and mid-level practitioners who write prescriptions for no legitimate medical need and/or outside the scope of legitimate medical practice, or sell prescriptions to drug dealers or abusers; pharmacists who falsify records and subsequently sell or abuse the drugs; pharmacists who fill prescriptions that they knew or should have known were illegitimate; employees who steal from inventory and falsify records to cover illicit sales; prescription forgers; and individuals who commit armed robbery of pharmacies and drug distributors The US does massively over-prescribe opioids. There have been doctors who were careless in who they prescribed to. There have been "pill mills" https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/oct/02/opioids-west-virginia-pill-mills-pharmacies https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/oct/02/opioids-west... But they don't need patient ID to track that down. They can use supplier data. I'm also struggling to read the document. It's written in a specific, jargon heavy, way. Use of the word "subpoena" every time they mention patient data is a little bit reassuring, but it's still not great. > CLIN 2001 Unlimited access to patient de-identified data, to be identified via subpoena, for class 2 to 5 prescription data which includes pharmacy, medical, and dental data. Fixed price per license per month I'm still ploughing through the 60 pages to try to get my head around it.
- DanBC 6y agoSo, task one talks about encrypted patient identifiers. This makes it sound like they're not going after patients, but are targetting pharmaceutical companies and doctors. Task 1: Provide and maintain data on a minimum of 85 percent of all prescriptions for Schedule/Class II through V prescription drugs (additional non-controlled items may be requested for possible scheduling actions) written and/or filled in the United States and trust territories: a) Prescription data shall include, but is not limited to: • The number of prescriptions filled, • The number of new prescriptions filled, • The number of refills filled, by date filled, • The name of the controlled substance • The days’ supply for the patient (e.g. 5 days, 15 days, et.), • The prescribers name and DEA registration number, and specialty • An encrypted patient identifier to whom the prescription was written • Date prescription was dispensed • Payment Type: cash, government payer, commercial payer • Dosing information: quantity and days’ sup --- Here's the patient information they want: > Patients • Number of instances of more than one Schedule II prescription for the same drug, and written within three days of each other by different prescribers • Number of instances of more than one Schedule II prescriptions for the same drug and written within three days of each other by the same prescriber • Number of instances of more than two patients, with the same address, receive the same drug in the same quantity from the same doctor on the same day. • Number of early refills Opiate and Benzo combine • Number of early Schedule II • Distance between patient and pharmacy • Average distance between patient and pharmacy for a combination of Opiate, Benzo and a muscle relaxer. • Distance between patient and pharmacy for Schedule II • Distance between patient and prescriber • Distance between patient and prescriber for Schedule II • Number of Opiate and Buprenorphine combinations • Number of Paid “cash” Schedule II • Number of Oxycodone 30 MG and 15 MG within five days overlap • Number of times Opioid Cough Syrup exceeds 90 day supply • Number of Oxycodone 30 MG and Hydromorphone 8 MG within five days overlap • Average MME Per Day • Average Total MME per pharmacy visit • Number of Opiate and Benzo combine within 3 days • Number of Opiate and Benzo prescriptions for the same person on the same filled day at different pharmacies. • Number of Opiate and Benzo prescriptions filled for the same person on the same day from different prescribers • Number of Opiate and Benzo prescriptions written on the same day to the same person by different prescribers • Number of Opiate and Benzo filled on the same person on the same day • Number of Opiate and Benzo filled for the same person on the same day at the same pharmacy They also say this: > f) Fully HIPAA-compliant. > Current pharmacy and prescription data updated on a daily basis. > Task 2: Streamline process for requesting the unmasking of pharmacy information. (PII shall be withheld or redacted unless specifically requested by subpoena.)
- refurb 6y agoMany states have already created PMP (Prescription Monitoring Program) databases where all controlled scripts for a given patient are recorded. A pharmacist can pull up a patients record to see if they feel comfortable filling a controlled script. Seems like a better solution to me than giving a law enforcement agency access to a patients medical records.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoReal story: NSA's data sharing with DEA et al in the course of illegal and unconstitutional parellel construction has showed said agencies just how much data they are missing out on... and now they want in.
- kleiba 6y agoNotice that we're talking about de-identified patient data here. There is a utility/privacy trade-off when using data containing private information: on the one hand, the patient's personal information must absolutely be protected, on the other hand, many processes could benefit from the information in such a data collection even without the knowledge of which data point belongs to which individual. If de-identification is done right, it would be a bit of a stretch to talk about "surveillance" because that's the whole point of de-identification: remove any information from the records that allows a third-party to identify the underlying person from whom the data originated. Note especially that this includes inference attacks, i.e., not only should any occurrences of names be removed/masked but also any information that would allow an informed attacker to re-infer that information, i.e., cross-link the patient data back to a specific person. The big elephant in the room, however, is the "If" at the beginning of the previous paragraph. As far as I see it, the problem lies not in wanting to establish some functionality that actually uses the collected information but whether appropriate privacy prerequisites have been put in place prior to that.
- mulmen 6y agoThat's the rub isn't it? How can anyone think US Intel/LEO agencies will settle for de-anonymized anything? Their definition of anonymous seems to be "we didn't look at it yet."
- La1n 6y agoThat if is not even an if. They ask for: Gender, Age group, Zipcode and City HIPAA already considers that too much under their safe habour rules, and k-anonymity (expert determination) can hardly be applied if you need to provide full zipcode and have a data-set that will grow/shrink over time. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/special-topics/de-identification/index.html#safeharborguidance https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/special-... edit: oh, and it seems they also ask for a "encrypted patient identifier", definitely doesn't seem kosher
- kortex 6y ago33 bits of entropy to narrow down to a single individual. ~28 in USA UID, Gender, Age group, Zipcode and City, plus of course your medication habits, is probably enough to deanonymize with a reasonable amount of confidence. Say age group is one of 8, age+gender is 5 bits of entropy. City zip is ~8. So that's 15 bits left on a good day. Throw in any off-the-shelf targeted marketing data (usally worth 10-25 bits iirc) and you might as well use SSN as the patient ID.
- ThePreacherMan 6y agoDefund. Defund. Defund.
- phkahler 6y agoOr they could just make phentanol a schedule 1 drug and get it off the market. Opioid crisis eneded.
- leetcrew 6y agomost black market fentanyl does not come from diverted prescriptions. the only thing this would do would be to prevent physicians prescribing fentanyl in cases where it's the ideal drug for pain management.
- phkahler 6y agoI dont think it's ever the ideal drug for pain management. Its fast acting and short duration, not ideal for chronic pain. Those characteristics also make it more addictive. There were drugs for pain management before and nobody complained about them not being good enough. There would not be much of a black market for it if physicians and pharma were not getting people addicted.
- leetcrew 6y ago> I dont think it's ever the ideal drug for pain management. this is a bold claim to make. it's worth having a wide range of drugs in a particular class, because they all have different side effect profiles and will affect individual patients differently. the short duration makes it ideal for use as an anesthetic, for instance. it is also safer than many of the older opioids, in the sense that the difference between an effective and lethal dose is much larger. when the short duration is not desired, this can be easily fixed with a time release mechanism. the main danger with fentanyl is it's high potency by weight. this is not an issue in a controlled medical setting, nor with the transdermal patches that are typically used in outpatient. > There would not be much of a black market for it if physicians and pharma were not getting people addicted. this reflects a misunderstanding of the psychology of addicts imo. the exact opioid is usually fungible to an addict; they want whatever gets them the most high for the least money. they probably have a favorite, but you rarely hear of people who specifically seek out fentanyl. in other words, I don't think there are many people who are addicted to fentanyl specifically.
- swiley 6y agoDoctors often talk about how hard it is to treat patients because they're worried about being attacked for using drugs. This only makes their job harder.
- inglor_cz 6y agoWhile I dislike the very idea of War Against Drugs, we (the Western world) are fairly clearly overmedicated and doctors should be motivated to prescribe less drugs, not more. Things like antibiotic resistance are no fun. The lobbying of pharmaceutical companies is corosive to good medicine. I have a few doctor friends here in Czechia; even here, in a public health system, representatives of pharma companies do their utmost to cultivate a client-patron relationship with doctors, to get them to prescribe more drugs. This year, I got off my antihypertonic medication by intermittent fasting. After 17 years no less. My cardiologist said: "OK, you do not need them anymore and you surprised me a bit, but do not expect others to follow your example. It is so normal just to take pills that people won't even try any lifestyle modification." This is a dangerous norm.
- shadowprofile77 6y agoIt possibly is, agreed, but as with all complex subjects that involve many different people who suffer through their own personal problems, in many cases, overlabeling people as too quick to prescribe drugs or seek them can also be a dangerous and highly politicized norm. I strongly suggest reading this post for an alternative perspective on how damaging over-politicization of doctor-patient relationships can be in either direction. https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/16/against-against-pseudoaddiction/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/16/against-against-pseudo...
- Zelphyr 6y agoAt the risk of seeming like I'm helping the pharmaceutical industry off the hook; there's a flip-side to the pharmaceutical companies pushing their products the way they do: people want the pills. We--especially in the West--are lazy and we think it's ok to just take a pill and be done with it. I commend you for doing the work you needed to do to get healthy! I wish more people would take that route instead of taking pills. It is so much more rewarding!
- heavyset_go 6y ago80% of all antibiotics in the US are given to livestock. The majority of infectious disease in humans originate via zoonosis. The agricultural industry is responsible for antibiotic resistance, not people being prescribed antibiotics.
- stevespang 6y agoAfter how many decades this is our WAR ON DRUGS ? The DEA going after lowest level users, after all, unlike individual addicts, the CARTELS have political clout, ability to bribe, and they certainly will pay or kill to eliminate competition
- 737min 6y agoIf the DEA feels it needs all this to find more opiate addicts, they could save time & money by walking the streets of San Francisco instead. The privacy implications are horrifying.
- api 6y agoThe drug war is collapsing. There's going to be a crunch on social security and medicare soon as more boomers retire, so the budget vultures will be circling. The DEA will search frantically for a reason to exist, something they can bring to congress to justify their funding.
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoI’d throw a party when they are dissolved. Horrible abuses of our civil rights in the name of protecting us from drugs (something they have unequivocally failed to succeed at).
- the_only_law 6y agoAfter the recent ballots in many states decriminalizing various drugs, I saw a number of memes congratulating "drugs" on "winning the war on drugs".
- da_big_ghey 6y agoI saw a joke on that the other day: After hearing about Oregon's recent de-criminalization of hard drugs, a bunch of druggies were celebrating by doing cocaine in a public park. An officer walks up to them and says, "Is that a plastic straw?"
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoSan Francisco == California Let’s not give a pass to the rest of the state. They have sponsored drug addiction as a lifestyle and decriminalized their behavior.
- 6y ago
- Dumblydorr 6y agoWho trusts the DEA with de-identified, highly personal information like drug use and all your personal info? I worked with the VA medical system and it was very hard to get de-identified data and when you got it, you had to be extremely careful and always keep the patients' best interest of privacy in mind. Do I trust DEA agents, people who signed up to actively punish and criminalize disproportionately minority and addicted people?
- justaman 6y agoI don't trust the government. I don't trust the DEA. I also don't think DEA agents [signed up to punish minorities]. You might be projecting your bias.
- staticautomatic 6y agoIf they didn’t sign up to do that then they didn’t understand the agency’s history and mission when they signed up.
- crankyoldcrank 6y agoI see you saw my presentation for university Freshman English ten years ago about the drug war and it had a big impression on you so you could make this insightful comment. Did you enjoy the Easy Star All Stars soundtrack?
- tommaho 6y agoand the institution will pass it's bias onto the workers, well intentioned or otherwise.
- oh_sigh 6y agoI don't think it is reasonable to assume that police signed up to punish men, considering a vast majority of people who get arrested and charged are men?
- Fnoord 6y agoOr, perhaps, they want to make a difference by raising the bar.
- joncrane 6y agoI know that from an ethical standpoint, the RFP is iffy, but from a technical standpoint, I find it fascinating. Basically a big RDBMS with a bunch of stored procedures. Maybe something fancy like Tableau in front of it. The hard part would be getting the data sanitized and into the DB, and access control. Probably lots of encryption requirements as well. Also note this is an RFP, so the decision to do it has already been made, this is basically the procurement of the service happening here.
- kordlessagain 6y agoAll types of revenue models will justify their actions based on the need for additional revenue. The "war" on "drugs" is a scam perpetuated by those who seek rationalization of their "job" to "fight" "drugs". Meanwhile, Oregon. There is no limit to the things those who profit from the activities will do to achieve their goals, including erroding our constitutional right to privacy and pursuit of happiness. RIP America.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoRIP democracies as we know them. Neo-feudalism is here. "You will own nothing. And be happy." Just like serfs in the middle ages.
- nelsondev 6y agoCouple comments: 1. This assumes it’s impossible to disincentivize drug usage via really harsh penalties enforced by state power. But look at China, where they have very little drug usage, due to extremely harsh penalties, and extreme social stigma. Individuals don’t get “mind expanding” or therapeutic benefits of drugs, but at least the society is not paying the cost of externalities of drug usage (see San Francisco’s Tenderloin). 2. Not all who do drugs are rational individuals with full information about what might happen if a chemical dependency is established. There are people pressured into drug usage by both legal mechanisms (Purdue Pharma) and illegal mechanisms (e.g a pimp creating a prostitute by forcing a drug addiction on that person). So the implication that there’s no bad actors, and it’s just the state enforcing draconian measures, misses very real cases of bad actors who should be stopped and punished. A legal system that pursues and removes bad actors can help society.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 6y agoCan we get a source on very little drug usage in China? From what I've read over the years, there actually is notable drug use in China for instance among factory workers.[1][2][3] Also I'm sure lots of people on HN who are more intimately familiar with the Tenderloin can opine better than I but from what I understand, drug usage in Tenderloin is more of a symptom - not the core problem. Similarly, the drugs being used openly in Tenderloin are not the ones that individuals normally tout as "mind expanding" or therapeutic. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30359871/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30359871/ [2] http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2019-06/26/c_138175718.htm http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2019-06/26/c_138175718.htm [3] https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Asia-Pacific/2015/0503/Breaking-Bad-in-China-how-meth-is-spreading-across-rural-heartland https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Asia-Pacific/2015/0503/Break...
- ngvrnd 6y agoPocket won't let me save this link. Other links work fine... weird.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chmod600 6y agoI am anti-drug-war. It's unjust and has bad results. But I'm not quite sure what we should do about drugs, if anything. It's easy to write off adults for making poor choices, but many drugs are highly addictive and addiction often starts with children. I can't say I'd be happy about a 7-11 selling heroin or meth.
- pille 6y agoI think there’s a lot of ground between the current War on Drugs, and 7-11 selling meth and heroin. But doesn’t 7-11 already sell alcohol, and even in potentially lethal amounts?
- proverbialbunny 6y ago>I can't say I'd be happy about a 7-11 selling heroin or meth. While no one is advocating for that, but it used to be like that, in that you could go to a drug store and get opioids and what not. Coca-cola used to have cocaine in it, and so on. In the past we were better off than today. People were not shooting up in the streets, yet heroin was readily available. The past is not the ideal path forward. We can do better than the past, and we can certainly do better than today. A middle ground needs to be found (a global maxima) between de-regulation and over-regulation. I personally think having to take a test so you're an informed consumer is an ideal amount of regulation, but others might disagree.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> But I'm not quite sure what we should do about drugs, if anything. It's easy to write off adults for making poor choices, but many drugs are highly addictive and addiction often starts with children. Offer drug treatment and rehab options for those who want to quit. Most people absolutely do not want to be addicts because addiction makes their lives miserable. It is incredibly expensive to seek treatment for drug addiction in this country, and there is a shortage of beds and caregivers relative to the number of people currently seeking treatment in the US. > I can't say I'd be happy about a 7-11 selling heroin or meth. That's hyperbole, but government funded clinics that supply people with cheap and uncut drugs, and a place to do them, does a lot for harm reduction in the countries with such programs.
- Stierlitz 6y agoYet anóther win for the prétend war on drúgs!
- Stierlitz 6y agoThePreacherMan 6 hours ago [dead] [–] Defund. Defund. Defund. mtgx 9 hours ago [dead] [–] Just when marijuana is about to be legalized at the federal level. This can't be a coincidence. They will no longer be able to arrest people for marijuana, but now they can arrest them for dozens or hundreds of other drugs. Seems like a net "win" for the DEA.
- us0r 6y agoJust read through everything. This isn't just a wired RFP... its supercharged. From Q&A: > Answer: The provider of the information would need to have approvals to provide the information to DEA and provide it without additional costs or approvals from the original data provider. We would need it to be able to be analyzed outside of the host environment so that we could take the results of the query and create our own reports and dashboards and provide it to the necessary individuals in the field who could use the data for investigative purposes. So... this information is required to be provided to the DEA by law... but apparently some 3rd party entity is receiving it (I'll bet this is for LexisNexus) with apparently no restrictions on how its used and now the DEA is going to pay a stupid amount of money so they can do whatever shady shit they have planned.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoIf they are using this data to go after prescribers that is probably a good thing. If they are using it to go after users I don't see how that helps the root problem.
- proverbialbunny 6y agoGoing after doctors doesn't help the root of the problem either. It just makes it harder for everyone else to get drugs when you need them. Living in a fear driven society sucks.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoI have a relative who worked for one of the largest narcotics prescribers in NJ, so I'm fairly familiar with the role certain prescribers play in perpetuating the opioid epidemic. Some of these doctors are absolutely part of the problem and barring them from medicine is the least we should do with them. Not all doctors are good people. Some care more about money than about their patients and will get patients addicted to drugs they don't need if it brings them more money.
- proverbialbunny 6y agoWould you rather have drug abusers buying street drugs or prescription drugs I think summarizes the challenge concisely.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoI would rather doctors not conspire to get people addicted to drugs in the first place. I'm not against prescription drug addicts having safe access to drugs, but we shouldn't act like prescribers are blameless either.
- proverbialbunny 6y ago>but we shouldn't act like prescribers are blameless either. I don't think anyone here is saying that. What's interesting is no matter what doctors do, 11% of the global population is addicted to drugs. I don't think prescribers can influence that. Psychologists can, but most drug addicts suffer from avoidant personality disorder, which is regarded as the single most difficult psychological disorder to work with.
- heroprotagonist 6y agoThis is ridiculous dragnetting. The DEA already have the ability to ask for specific customer records without a warrant through HIPAA privacy rule exceptions. And good luck convincing your therapist or doctor that fulfilling such requests is a voluntary act on their part. That highly televised doctor-patient confidentiality is pretty much a myth once you reach the federal level. That is bad enough, but now they want to simply take everyone's data and push it through algorithms to generate leads for more action? These guys are worse than sales people.