4 ms·
Sorry but you're wrong, dedicated 1:1 capacity scpc geostationary links will always be 492-495ms rtt ping latency between teleport and far end. Latency will ne
by walrus01 6y ago
Sorry but you're wrong, dedicated 1:1 capacity scpc geostationary links will always be 492-495ms rtt ping latency between teleport and far end. Latency will never be less than the laws of physics and modem FEC dictate, but jitter will be very low.
If you saw a lot of jitter it was because you were in an oversubscribed, contended tdma network. What was your terminal hardware, what modems were you using and what was the rf chain and modem setup at the far end (not in Afghanistan)?
Latency on terrestrial ptp microwave also does not vary. Ducting and diffraction and temperature inversions on long 6GHz links affects rsl and modulation, not latency.
In the case of starlink, each satellite is functioning as a bent pipe relay between cpe and starlink earth station. Latency will vary a ms or two based on satellite position during a pass overhead, but no more than that. The rest of the latency is the same as from any terrestrial internet customer in the same geographic location as the earth station. For instance one of the beta test earth stations is in north bend, wa, colocated with a level3 long haul dwdm site.
People in WA have been posting tests with latencies of 25-26ms to speed test servers in downtown Seattle. That's actually really, really good, considering that latency to your default gateway on a residential cable docsis3 coaxial connection can easily be 16ms on a terrestrial connection. North bend is a few ms from seattle, the brewster starlink teleport site several ms more.
In the case of starlink they are competing against 32:1 or worse oversubscribed geostationary consumer grade vsat services like viasat and Hughesnet. Starlink is far superior tech.
- definetheword 6y agoI want to take a class/course/certficate on space communications. Do you have any great recommendations? Edit: And, any really good blog series on this? so I know what to expect in such a course
- walrus01 6y agoUnfortunately I do not, I learned on the job. I would recommend learning general network engineering and study radio, microwave, physics and wireless communication stuff generally to have a good basis to begin.
- vvanders 6y agoFor the RF side of things a ham radio license is a fun thing to have. Although you do have to dig a bit to find sections of the hobby that focus more on the digital side of things.
- renewiltord 6y agoVery interesting. We once had a microwave link setup that would fail during the rain. Admittedly this was maybe 20 years ago so maybe the tech is different, but this would manifest as latency spikes presumably as there was a failure to extract signal and TCP backoff kicked in. i.e. it wasn't physical layer latency but transport layer latency. But my knowledge of networks is fairly rudimentary and old now and now that I think about it, pings would get sudden spikes in the rain too and that's just a lower layer than I'm talking about. hmm. I was also a child then so I might be misremembering.
- walrus01 6y agoThe modern tech is indeed quite different, a modern microwave ptp radio system in rain susceptible bands (11,18,23GHz, etc) will be capable of adaptive coding and modulation to change to looser modulations on the fly during rain fade. With no change in latency, but drops in aggregate Mbps capacity. Of course no amount of ACM will help if someone has engineered the link wrong, at a distance too far, antennas too small, or similar. For an example of a modern radio google aviat wtm4200.
- renewiltord 6y agoInteresting. They appear to be much cheaper (under $15k for the 4100 for the radio). Very cool very cool. Funny how in my head I've been judging a modern Monkeybrains installation by my 20 year old experience.
- vvanders 6y agoIt's not at the same level but Ubiquiti makes some impressively "cheap" gear in this space that will do 1gbps over decent distances[1]. I've mostly used their lower powered p2p links but it's amazing to see how far the tech has come. [1] https://operator.ui.com/ptp-bridging https://operator.ui.com/ptp-bridging
- walrus01 6y agoI would caution people against using the af11 or AF24 if they don't have to. Ubiquiti doesn't know how to make a serious radio. For something like the af5xhd, it's a great little thing for its price, and with good quality antennas at both ends can make a very effective bridge. But for more serious things? No. It's so bad they haven't even been able to implement snmpv2 on their $1000+ radios. The af11 is so bad it only uses a 56MHz channel mask in an 80MHz channel. No matter what manufacturer, serious ptp radios can be distinguished by two things: the presence of terminals for a direct -48vdc wiring connection and sfp/sfp+ ports. At the very low end of cost, ubnt's 802.11ac chipset ptp bridge radios are great and very cost effective, I'm talking about the powerbeam ac series, nanobeam and similar. For when you want to buy a few hundred bucks of stuff on your credit card to link a few buildings together quickly. For anyone looking at that category of stuff they should also look at mikrotik and mimosa radios.
- gamblor956 6y agoI like that some random guy on the internet is telling a guy who was in charge of the satellite internet on a military base that he doesn't know anything about satellite internet. Lost packets increase latency. And weather conditions cause lost packets.
- ffpip 6y ago> I like that some random guy on the internet is telling a guy who was in charge of the satellite internet on a military base that he doesn't know anything about satellite internet. Only on HN
- jjeaff 6y agoMore like everywhere on the internet. Just the other day, I saw some idiot on facebook try to lecture a board certified pulmonologist at one of the state's largest hospital about how covid is nothing to worry about.
- vvanders 6y agoIf you want to get pedantic, the band used will determine what natural phenomenon impacts the received signal. Even in those cases FEC and dynamic modulation will let the signal work(at reduced throughout). That said unless we're talking about lasers air refraction doesn't usually impact RF(there is tropospheric ducting but that's something different).
- walrus01 6y agoIn an example of a modern highly rain fade resistant ptp microwave system in the 18GHz band, standard fcc part 101 fdd band plan. The radios might be talking to each other in both H and V polarities, 80MHz wide channel in both, at 2048QAM 5/6 during a normal sunny day. In an extreme rain fade event they may go all the way down to QPSK 1/2 and the link's capacity in Mbps could be as poor as 40Mbps (from what is nominally a 900Mbps+ link), but the end to end latency will remain pretty much the same. Latency as experienced by users might be much worse, however, if suddenly 300Mbps of traffic is trying to be shoved through a 40-75Mbps link, for a period of several minutes or more.
- greesil 6y agoMaybe the op was using a LEO constellation? Somehow. With military birds. Doppler would cause all kinds of weird stuff to happen I would guess.
- walrus01 6y agoThe military uses a hell of a lot of iridium, but from context it really sounds to me like he's describing the low end of the COTS C/ku band ISP market. Until very recently you have not been able to move more than 2400 bps through an individual iridium link, limiting it to very low data rate IP networking and single user at a time per device. The military itself uses a lot more geostationary than you might think at first glance. They don't have their own iridium sized low earth orbit narrow band networks. There's many series of DoD satellites in geostationary, and they also lease a lot of commercial transponder capacity.