5 ms·
Elections are in the public interest and therefore should be publicly funded -- exclusively. Each registered candidate with more than a certain number of signa
by arcticbull 6y ago
Elections are in the public interest and therefore should be publicly funded -- exclusively.
Each registered candidate with more than a certain number of signatures of support should be given a budget of money and pre-paid airtime on all major networks by the FEC, and that's it. Once it's out, it's out. All other contributions (including in-kind) to political campaigns are tantamount to bribery and should just be illegal.
- roenxi 6y ago"Should" is a very easy word to throw out. Yeah, elections should be all those things. The problem is the follow up questions of "how?", "what would the unintended consequences be?" and "can we enforce this objectively when the situation gets murky?". It seems all but impossible to stop billionaires like Koch waging public relations campaigns. If nothing else they'll just buy entire media companies (c.f. Bezos and the Washington Post) and jump in to the fray Fox News style. It is pretty likely that no-money-in-politics rules would be weaponised against smaller donators. I'm sure there are a bunch of wealthy people who would love nothing more than legal tools to shut down donation-driven groups like the Black Lives Matter website.
- usrusr 6y agoIs it possible? Yes. That's exactly how countries with a post-beta implementation of democracy are doing things and it works well enough (it's never perfect). The only unknown is a migration path for the USA, so many with disproportionate power in the current system would fight that change tooth and nail.
- ramphastidae 6y agoNot impossible at all. This is a solved problem in much of Europe. Read about France’s election process. The problem is that elected officials in the US don’t have much incentive to represent the will of their constituency — only their donors. And their donors do not want campaign finance reform because it eliminates their influence. This is not a logistics issue, it’s a corruption issue.
- nugget 6y agoHow do you think Europe/France solves for the Bezos-WaPo "problem" whereby wealthy individuals can convert money into political influence indirectly by controlling media companies?
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoThe media laws make it harder to spout propaganda, and the media regulators don't allow these people to buy media, and also well funded public media organisations.
- lumost 6y agoIt's pretty straightforward to spot billion dollar ad campaigns. The FCC has carried out its duty to regulate airtime for the better part of a century.
- bipson 6y agoThere is a approximate approach in Austria. Parties are allowed donations, but they can't spend more than x on election campaigns, no matter where the money is coming from. Time on public TV is kind-of regulated. TV ads are not really a thing, mostly billboards and print. Can be circumvented though, since it requires parties to declare spendings correctly (and labelled correctly). "Oh, those fancy pens that look like merch? For work if course!" "We didn't rent this venue, a party-friend did" Difficult to enforce with all the possible loopholes.
- AlphaSite 6y agoIt does make blatant abuse hard though.
- RickJWagner 6y agoWhat about Hollywood and athletic endorsements? Would those be in-kind?
- bcrosby95 6y agoIt's an interesting question. Celebrity endorsements in the USA are big money. E.g. Kim kardashian supposedly charges hundreds of thousands of dollars for a single instagram endorsement.
- nokcha 6y ago>Elections are in the public interest and therefore should be publicly funded -- exclusively. That doesn't really follow. Why should something be exclusively publicly funded just because it is in the public interest? >All other contributions (including in-kind) to political campaigns are tantamount to bribery and should just be illegal. What about completely anonymous donations? If the receiver doesn't know who is giving the money, how could it act as a bribe?
- arcticbull 6y agoI can’t think of anything in the public interest that shouldn’t be publicly funded. I would go so far as to say that’s the only class of thing that should be publicly funded. Did you have something in mind? Re: completely anonymous donations, you mean, like Bitcoin? Generally any legitimate business has to report where it’s money came from - even if just for tax purposes - otherwise it’s a whole new crime. Remember, under my model, all contributions would be banned. Then, candidates would have to compete on platforms instead of fundraising.
- webmaven 6y ago> What about completely anonymous donations? If the receiver doesn't know who is giving the money, how could it act as a bribe? It would be pretty hard to set things up so that donations were not only anonymous, but non-verifiable (as in, it should be impossible for a donor to prove to a recipient that they were the one who donated). This attribute in voting systems is part of 'coercion resistance' (as in, if you can't prove how you voted even when you want to, there is no point in trying to coerce you into voting a particular way). In a payments system, we can call it 'corruption resistance'.
- vel0city 6y ago> Elections are in the public interest and therefore should be publicly funded -- exclusively. So me, as a private citizen, should be outlawed from making a sign on my front yard in support of a candidate with my own money? Should I be prevented from making my own website in support of issues and candidates I care about? Can I create YouTube videos with my own money to support issues and candidates I care about with my own money? This is supporting a candidate with funds outside of the public funds -- clearly illegal under your proposal! At what point is it no longer individuals expressing their own opinions in public? I encourage you to actually read the Citizens United opinion. https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/558/310 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/558/310