6 ms·
I think Apple brought this on themselves when they announced it would be faster than 98%[1] of the existing laptops on the market. They didn't caveat it with "
by jandrese 6y ago
I think Apple brought this on themselves when they announced it would be faster than 98%[1] of the existing laptops on the market. They didn't caveat it with "fanless laptops" or "laptops with 20hr of battery life", it's just supposedly faster than all but 2% of laptops you can buy today.
You say something like that about a low power fanless design and every tech nerd's first reaction is "bullshit". And now they want to call you on your bullshit.
[1] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/11/introducing-the-next-generation-of-mac/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2020/11/introducing-the-next-...
- martin_bech 6y agoI dont know if you’ve actually done the numbers.. but most laptops on the market, have low to mediocre specs. It would surprise me if more than 2% are pro/enthusiast.
- jandrese 6y agoApple didn't specify if they're counting by model or total sales, but virtually everything in the Gamer Laptop category is going to be faster in virtually every measure. https://www.newegg.com/Gaming-Laptops/SubCategory/ID-3365 https://www.newegg.com/Gaming-Laptops/SubCategory/ID-3365 As a Joe Schmoe it's hard to get good figures, but it appears the total laptop market is about $161.952B[1] with the "gaming" laptop segment selling about $10.96B[2]. Since gaming laptops are more expensive this undercounts cheap laptops, but there are other classes of laptop that are going to outperform this mac, like business workstations. There might be one way to massage the numbers to pull out that statistic somehow, but it is at best misleading. [1] https://www.statista.com/outlook/15030100/100/laptops-tablets/worldwide https://www.statista.com/outlook/15030100/100/laptops-tablet... [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1027216/global-gaming-laptop-sales/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1027216/global-gaming-la...
- wmf 6y agoI assume Apple means unit sales. It makes sense that 98% of all laptop units sold are not the fastest.
- klelatti 6y ago"Virtually everything in the Gamer Laptop Category is going to be faster in virtually every measure" I'd really suggest you look at the CPU benchmarks (single and multi core) for M1 vs Intel / AMD laptops.
- jandrese 6y agoThe only ones I've seen are from Apple, and I'm always skeptical of benchmarks from manufacturers.
- klelatti 6y ago"Virtually everything in the Gamer Laptop Category is going to be faster in virtually every measure" So this statement is made on the basis of what data?
- kuschku 6y agoOn the fact that discrete gaming laptops have higher power requirements and better cooling solutions, in turn allowing much faster CPUs to run in them. That's the most meaningful constraint for mobile CPUs today, after all.
- audunw 6y agoIf you're not going to compare Apples to Apples, i.e. if power, cooling and size is a constraint you're not going to care about at all, you might as well count desktop PCs as well. Apples measurement comes pretty close to comparing "laptops that most people would actually buy". Not sure why it's meaningful that a laptop maker can put out a model that's as thick as a college book, has the very top bins of all parts, sounds like a jet engine when running at max speed, and is purchased by 1% of the most avid gamers. Oh, and if someone puts out a second model that adds RGB backlit keyboard, but is otherwise equivalent, that should somehow count against Apples achievements, because for some reason counting by number of models is meaningful regardless of how many copies that model sold o_O
- 6y ago
- ksec 6y ago>Apple didn't specify if they're counting by model or total sales, If it was Model they would be spinning it. But they said sold in the past year. I dont know how anyone else would interpret it, but in financial and analytics that is very clearly implying unit sold. Your [1] is Laptop with Tablet, total Laptop market is about $100B, although this year we might see a sharp increase cause of pandemic. Let say there are $10 Gaming Laptop market. So 10% of Market Value are going to Gaming Laptop. Total Laptop Market includes Chromebook, so if you do ASP averaging I would expect at least 3x ( if not 4x or higher ) difference in Gaming and Rest of Laptop Market. So your hypothesis of "All Gaming Laptop" would be faster than M1 gives you roughly 3.3% of the Marketshare. Not too far off 2%. And all of that is before we put any performance number into comparison.
- audunw 6y ago> Apple didn't specify if they're counting by model or total sales, but virtually everything in the Gamer Laptop category is going to be faster in virtually every measure. This is what I don't get.. why would you ever assume they meant counting by model? That's a nearly meaningless measurement. How do you even distinguish between models in that measurement? Where do you set the thresholds? The supercharged gaming laptops are absolutely going to dominate that statistics no matter what, because there's a huge number of models, lots of which only differ mostly by cosmetic changes. The margins are likely higher, so they don't need to sell as many of a given model to make it worthwhile to put one out. Does a laptop maker even have to actually sell a single model for it to count? How many do they have to sell for it to count? Does it make sense to count models where every part is picked from the best performing bins, so that you're guaranteed that the model couldn't count for more than a fraction of sales? Counting by number of laptops actually sold is the only meaningful measurement, at least you have a decent chance of finding an objective way to measure that. And I thought it was 100% obvious from Apples marketing material what they meant, so I really don't get why anyone is confused about this.
- headeffects 6y ago> Apple didn't specify if they're counting by model or total sales, but virtually everything in the Gamer Laptop category is going to be faster in virtually every measure. Not a single one will beat it in single core performance.
- nix23 6y agoJust a Question...are they talking about their own laptops too?
- coldtea 6y agoYes. The M1 scores faster than the last model of Intel using MBP 16".
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoI suspect they're not technically saying that, since they're saying "PC laptops." But as Coldtea notes, it's pretty clear the M1-based laptops embarrass all current Intel-based Mac laptops. I'm just not going to fault Apple too much for failing to explicitly say "so this $999 MacBook Air just smokes our $2800 MacBook Pro."
- klelatti 6y ago'98% of laptops sold over the last year' not 'that you can buy' ie not 98% of all models on the market (whatever that means). And their statement will have been through all sorts of validation before they use it so it's almost certainly not 'bullshit'.
- qz2 6y agoFaster than 98% of the cheapest OEM laptop available!
- jandrese 6y agoI just had the thought that the figures could be skewed by education departments all over the country making bulk orders for cheap laptops for students doing remote learning.
- qz2 6y agoVery good point.
- sundvor 6y agoAnd there are some truly incredulously crap ones, possibly costing even less than an additional power supply for the MacBook. That statistic from Apple is just as bad as those.
- coldtea 6y agoNope, "Faster than 98% of the laptops sold, which includes many of the cheapest OEM laptop available!". Not the same as "Faster than 98% of the cheapest OEM laptop available!".
- qz2 6y agoHey if they’re allowed to miss large bits of information for marketing purposes, so am I :)
- socialdemocrat 6y ago
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoYou're misinterpreting what they say. Quote: "And in MacBook Air, M1 is faster than the chips in 98 percent of PC laptops sold in the past year.1" There is a subtle difference between "98 percent of laptops sold" and your rephrasing as "2% of laptops you can buy today". If you doubt the meaning, check out the footnote which refers to "publicly available sales data". You only need sales data if sales volume is a factor in the calculation. I also don't doubt that "every tech nerd's reaction is 'bullshit'", but only because supremely confident proclamations of universal truth that are soon proven wrong is pretty much the defining trait among that community (c. f. various proclamations that solar power is useless, CSI-style super-resolution image enhancement is "impossible" because "the information was lost", "512k should be enough...", "less space than a Nomad..", and everything Paul Graham has said, ever). Here, these nerds should have been pointed at, for example, last year's iPad Pro. Which has no fans (only -boys) and was already at that performance level (https://www.tomsguide.com/us/new-ipad-pro-benchmarks,news-28453.html https://www.tomsguide.com/us/new-ipad-pro-benchmarks,news-28...).
- refulgentis 6y agoYou're both right, but they're more right because the subtle difference you mention is the problem they're highlighting: Apple went out of their way to be unclear and create subtle differences in interpretation that would be favorable to Apple, as a company should. After the odd graphs/numbers from the event, I was worried it was going to be an awful ~2 year period of jumping to conclusions based on: - Geekbench scores - "It's slow because Rosetta" - HW comparisons that compare against ancient hardware because "[the more powerful PC equivalent] uses _too_ much power" implying that "[M1] against 4 year old HW is just the right amount of power", erasing the tradeoff between powerfulness and power consumption The people claiming this blows Intel/AMD out of the water need to have stronger evidence than comparing against parts launched years ago for budget consumers, then waving away any other alternative based on power consumption.[1] Trading off power for power consumption is an inherent property of chip design, refusing to consider other chipsets because they have a different set of tradeoffs mean you're talking about power consumption alone, not the chip design. [1] n.b. this is irrational because the 4 year old part is likely to use more power than the current part. So, why is it more valid to compare against the 4 year old part? Following this logic, we need to find a low power GPU, not throw out the current part and bring in a 4 year old budget part.
- Spooky23 6y ago>I think Apple brought this on themselves when they announced it would be faster than 98%[1] of the existing laptops on the market. They didn't caveat it with "fanless laptops" or "laptops with 20hr of battery life", it's just supposedly faster than all but 2% of laptops you can buy today. Exactly. It's a meaningless number. They also conspicuously avoid posting any GHz information of any kind. My assumption is that it's a fine laptop, but a bullshit performance claim.
- matwood 6y agoWhat does ghz have to do with performance across chips? I’m reminded of the old days where AMD chips ran at a lower ghz and outperformed Intel chips running much faster. Intel had marketed that ghz === faster so AMD had to work to get around existing biases.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoEven Intel had to fight against it when they transitioned from the P4 designs to Core. They began releasing much lower clocked chips in the same product matrix and it took a while for people to finally accept that frequency is a poor metric for comparing across even the same company’s designs. And I think Apple also significantly contributed to this problem in the mid-late PPC days with “megahertz myth” marketing coupled with increasingly obvious misleading performance claims.
- crooked-v 6y ago> They also conspicuously avoid posting any GHz information of any kind Is that information actually of any real use when dealing with a machine with asymmetric cores plus various other bits on the chip dedicated to specific tasks [1]? [1]: https://images.anandtech.com/doci/16226/M1.png https://images.anandtech.com/doci/16226/M1.png
- bee_rider 6y agoIt is good to be skeptical of that "faster" and that 2% measurement, because there are lots of opportunities to make them ambiguous. But clock frequencies are hardly useful for comparisons between AMD and Intel. They'd be even more useless across architectures. Benchmarks are as good as it gets. Aggregate benchmarks used for marketing slides are less than ideal, but the problem with marketing is that it has to apply to everyone. Better workload focused benchmarks might come out later... In their defense most people won't look at these, because most people don't really stress their CPUs anyway.
- bitL 6y agoOld quad-core 2020 Macbook Air was probably faster than 98% of the existing laptops on the market given what specs have most volume sold (<$500).
- Razengan 6y ago> every tech nerd's first reaction Every true tech nerd knows this is fucking impressive ever since iPhones started being benchmarked against Intel and every true tech nerd can tell that this is only going to get better. :)
- headeffects 6y agoYep, people who actually care about tech and hardware are applauding this. Anti-Apple and x86 fanboys are the ones doing everything they can to discount it.
- coldtea 6y ago>I think Apple brought this on themselves when they announced it would be faster than 98%[1] of the existing laptops on the market. They didn't caveat it with "fanless laptops" or "laptops with 20hr of battery life", it's just supposedly faster than all but 2% of laptops you can buy today. No, it's faster than all those laptops, not just "fanless" ones. It's actually faster than several fan-using i9 models. And it has already been compared to those. The grantparent talks about comparisons for GPUs...
- keymone 6y agoWhat % of laptops comes with Nvidia 3090 on them? Really, please, do tell me a number, I’ll wait.