11 ms·
It is great, but: 1. Just lost a few hundred Tabs from last session. Not the first time this has happened to me on Safari. ( Firefox used to have this problem
by ksec 6y ago
It is great, but:
1. Just lost a few hundred Tabs from last session. Not the first time this has happened to me on Safari. ( Firefox used to have this problem as well, they implemented multiple LastSession.json to combat the problem and it is basically a thing of the past. )
2. Fav Icons meant they are no longer showing the Tab Description once you have a dozen tabs as they will shrink to Icons Size. So you either have normal Tabs or Tabs with Fav Icons, not both. ( This is new in Safari 14 )
3. Show Tab Overview will reload all the tabs, including those that were in idle / unload state. If you are a heavy tab user you should not do this. Having a hundred tabs reload will cause hundreds of GB of Data written to your SSD. Basically shortening its lifespan.
4. AFAIK ( I could be wrong ), Extensions still requires you to have an $99/ year developer account. Some of my favourite extensions are now either paid or can no longer be used.
Apart from that, yes it is very good.
- sefrost 6y agoIn response to point 1, were you able to use History > Reopen All Windows from Last Session?
- spullara 6y agoYou can set this as the default as well.
- ksec 6y agoNope, it was blank, because the Plist files have nothing in it. And I cant rescue it either. In Firefox they make lastsession.json and lastoeesion.bak where .bak was a backup and could be restored from within UI setting. I think they also had the .bak zipped somewhere in case all things fails, you can manually restore some part of it. Although the frequency of that zip creation was something like daily so you still lose some part of tabs. There were additional guarantee they put in place so last session will never be overwritten again or blank out. But that was a very long time ago when I was still a heavy Firefox users and follows its development very closely. If I remember correctly those features development and debugging happened on Mozillazine.
- enriquto 6y ago> Just lost a few hundred Tabs from last session This is horrifying! How do you get to have one hundred tabs, or worse, a few hundred?
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agoTabs store context (history, cookies, container, etc, with tree-style tabs also parent & child tab relations) that bookmarks don't. I'm not sure about Safari (since I don't use a Mac) but on Firefox you can set up tab discarding (via extension) that unloads unused tabs. So there's a lot less incentive to use bookmarks when you can just leave a tab open forever. Really the only reason to use bookmarks instead of tabs is for synchronization across devices.
- devcpp 6y agoFirefox is so good for this even after e10s, it's not even comparable.
- ssvss 6y ago>Firefox you can set up tab discarding (via extension) that unloads unused tabs What Add-on do you use for this.
- ksec 6y agoYou can simple exit and reopen your browser. Only the focus Tab will be loaded while all others are unloaded.
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agoAuto Tab Discard[1] does it automatically after a time. Tabs can be set to not get discarded, eg when form elements with changes are present, media is playing, tab is pinned, or just whitelisting. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/auto-tab-discard/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/auto-tab-disc...
- ideologysec 6y ago
- saagarjha 6y ago> Just lost a few hundred Tabs from last session. Not the first time this has happened to me on Safari. ( Firefox used to have this problem as well, they implemented multiple LastSession.json to combat the problem and it is basically a thing of the past. ) You can restore the old plist with this to get them back, if you had it backed up in Time Machine or something. It's annoying but it's saved me a couple times.
- rsync 6y ago"Just lost a few hundred Tabs from last session. Not the first time this has happened to me on Safari. ( Firefox used to have this problem as well, they implemented multiple LastSession.json to combat the problem and it is basically a thing of the past." Everyone has a story like this - from all of the browsers. It seems like FF behaves better in this way now, but I still do silly things like rsync my home directory to a backup before every reboot/update. If I ever need these tab backups, I will have to do silly things like dissect them with JSON tools or monkey around with plists, etc. Why, Why WHY can't we just have tabs:// ? Plain text list of all URLs. Dead simple. Just pull up tabs:// and cut and paste. Or select all. Or whatever. Lose-all-tabs bugs will always be with us - and a fix would be so simple ...
- Dylan16807 6y agoI agree that it should be easier to get a simple list, but I want to note that backing up the firefox tab data is one file, and it makes its own backup whenever you update. Chrome on the other hand will deliberately reject and wipe your profile if you copy it to another computer. Also "bookmark all tabs" serves roughly the same purpose as a dumb URL list for backup purposes, even if it's awkward to edit.
- _underfl0w_ 6y ago> Why, Why WHY can't we just have tabs:// ? That's actually a nifty feature idea, but it seems like it could be easily abused with a little client-side JS for the sake of fingerprinting or analytics, unless it's treated similarly to chrome:// urls. You could probably whip up your own small browser extension to provide a simple formatted list of tabs, though.
- szhu 6y agoFound an Chrome extension that lets you do this! https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/tabcopy/micdllihgoppmejpecmkilggmaagfdmb https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/tabcopy/micdllihgo... I just tried it out -- you click a button to copy the list of tabs. If you just want the URLs and not the page titles, choose the "Compact" option.
- catach 6y ago
- SaulOfTheJungle 6y agoI can confirm point 4. I have a small, open-source Chrome/Firefox extension that has about 260 active users. I was considering porting it to Safari, but I can't justify the $99/year fee for it.
- Liskni_si 6y agoSame here. My extension these days approaches 3000 users across Chrome/Firefox, but only a fraction of those visit the donations link and send something. It just makes no sense to pay $99 to maybe get a few donations. I don't want to make this a paid extension and then spend time and money on marketing and hope that maybe I will one day break even. I just want the extension to be available to users, that's all! Is that too much to ask?
- jhatax 6y ago>> 1. Just lost a few hundred Tabs from last session. Not the first time this has happened to me on Safari. ( Firefox used to have this problem as well, they implemented multiple LastSession.json to combat the problem and it is basically a thing of the past. ) >> With Safari's switch to WebExtensions, I hope that the developer of OneTab (1) makes their extension available on Safari as well. I started using this extension on Firefox to get an additional layer of protection from an unexpected crash that corrupted tabs data. This was before the multiple backups approach that Firefox has adopted, which has all but eliminated tab data corruption. I continue using it because I like to see tabs in a list. 1. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/onetab/?utm_source=addons.mozilla.org&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=search https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/onetab/?utm_s...
- lopis 6y ago> Just lost a few hundred Tabs from last session. Honestly, if you like to live on the edge, you have to except some accidents.
- ra7 6y ago> Fav Icons meant they are no longer showing the Tab Description once you have a dozen tabs as they will shrink to Icons Size. So you either have normal Tabs or Tabs with Fav Icons, not both. ( This is new in Safari 14 ) FYI, there is a way to get around this annoying new setting. 1. Enable Preferences -> Tabs -> Show website icons. 2. Quit Safari. 3. Enable Safari Debug menu as described in https://yuriy.eu/design/2020/09/21/safari-tab-preview.html https://yuriy.eu/design/2020/09/21/safari-tab-preview.html 4. Open Safari and disable Debug -> Tab Features -> Narrow Tabs.
- ksec 6y agoOMG Thank You!.