8 ms·
I have been constantly hearing about eink getting cheaper/better for over a decade now, but the price that the author paid (2300 euros for a 32-inch screen) see
by paxys 6y ago
I have been constantly hearing about eink getting cheaper/better for over a decade now, but the price that the author paid (2300 euros for a 32-inch screen) seems ridiculous. At that price point does it make any sense to not just get a regular LCD for a small fraction of the cost? Dimming the brightness and adjusting the color profile will get you pretty close in terms of experience. The few dollars a year in electricity savings isn't relevant either.
- kokey 6y agoWhen I saw the article I thought that perhaps he found that well priced large e-ink display or pulled from a failed product, but turns out he just found a large one.
- buzzerbetrayed 6y agoThe difference between eink and LCD is big enough that it's not even worth doing without the eink. A dim LCD newspaper on your wall would look really tacky, imo. And it would very obviously just be a TV. While the eink looks amazing. I think you either have to shell out the money for eink, or don't do it at all.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- slg 6y ago>A dim LCD newspaper on your wall would look really tacky, imo. It really depends on how you do it. They sell TV's like The Frame[1] from Samsung ($599 for the 32" version) that look much closer to a picture frame and are designed for almost this exact purpose. If you are in some semi-permanent home (you probably should be before you spend $2.7k on an art piece) it isn't much work to mount it in a way that would hide the cables. From the looks of the photos in this article, the e-Ink version isn't event mounted flush against the wall and appears to be tilted downward. I don't love the way that looks given the cost. I would much rather spend half the money on that TV and a professional mounting. [1] - https://www.samsung.com/us/televisions-home-theater/tvs/the-frame/32-class-the-frame-qled-hdr-smart-tv-2020-qn32ls03tbfxza/ https://www.samsung.com/us/televisions-home-theater/tvs/the-...
- thefounder 6y agoYou compare a lcd tv with eink....apples <--> oranges.
- slg 6y agoI am comparing the use case and not the technology. I am comparing one art piece to another art piece.
- CydeWeys 6y agoThe average power consumption of The Frame is 118 W (figure provided by Samsung). The average power consumption of an e-ink display that refreshes once daily and needs a single annual recharge is effectively 0 W. Using a rough price of electricity in San Francisco of just over $0.22/kWh, The Frame costs ~$230/yr to run. I don't know if I could, in good conscience, countenance wasting that much electricity on running a TV 24/7 to show a static image that updates once daily. Yes, you'd have to be running the e-ink display for awhile to break even on the power costs, and you could save some money on The Frame by putting it on a schedule where it turns off at night, but it still seems overly wasteful.
- google234123 6y agoDamn, electricity is expensive in SF.
- jeffbee 6y agoI've seen this hack in person and it is very convincing. The way to avoid the backlight problem is to frontlight the whole scene. This embedded imac also has the cool feature of never changing if someone is looking at it. https://www.claybavor.com/blog/a-canvas-made-of-pixels https://www.claybavor.com/blog/a-canvas-made-of-pixels
- renewiltord 6y agoThat is an incredible artwork (the device). I only caught the right one on the second viewing of the light changes. However, it uses an equivalently expensive piece of hardware, right? The LG 5k from Apple is $1300.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jay_kyburz 6y agoI was in the mall just a few minutes ago, and while I was waiting for a coffee I was standing next to one of those movie-poster billboard things that have TV in them. Every few seconds a poster for a movie, or cleaning product, or some store would pop up, each had some subtle animation. They were really high res, 4k perhaps. Really nice and crisp. Anyhow, I was thinking how great the images on them were.
- 0-_-0 6y agoWith a light sensor you could adjust the colour of an LCD display so it exactly simulates the light reflected by paper. I don't understand why nobody did it before. Now you can't patent it though because this comment serves as prior art :)
- mholm 6y agoThe Samsung Frame TV does this already, to some success.
- skavi 6y agoThe comment is sarcastic I think. This has been done by many companies.
- gh02t 6y agoI've also noticed this on my Google Home/Nest Hub, where it has an effect where it adjusts the image on screen to match the color temperature of the ambient light. It makes for a really weird (albeit pleasant) effect that to my eye makes the image look more like a printed/reflective image. I've long wondered if you could duplicate that effect by replacing the backlighting in a junk LCD with something that can adjust color temperature and adding a color sensor, but haven't had time to try it.
- drone 6y agoYes, these sorts of things are common in photography workflows. There are color profilers [ex: 0] that update your monitor's profile in real time to maintain a consistent profile given ambient light changes. They're usually used as part of a larger calibration workflow, for example: calibrating your monitor and printer so that what you print with a specific ink/paper combination looks exactly like what you see on the screen. (Or, as much as is technically possible to do so.) [0] - https://www.xrite.com/categories/calibration-profiling/i1display-pro https://www.xrite.com/categories/calibration-profiling/i1dis...
- 0-_-0 6y agoThat's really cool! Thank you!
- jMyles 6y ago> A dim LCD newspaper on your wall would look really tacky, imo. In fairness, any display of a newspaper who so bombastically trumpeted the US into war with Iraq is kinda tacky.
- AntiImperialist 6y agoNot so amazing if I want the Playboy cover instead of some irrelevant fake news.
- sokoloff 6y agoThe total absence of a backlight is hard to replicate the experience of in real life. Spending $2500 on this is also not for me, but I just spent a couple minutes playing with the contrast and brightness on my high-middle Dell monitor and I couldn't get anything that was convincingly "closer to paper than to a computer monitor". Having to run a hidden wire to it is another downside, but 500 euros probably covers that job in most cases.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI wonder if one of those non-backlit memory LCDs could do the trick. (The kind of display used on the Playdate console, and I believe most Pebble smartwatches.)
- scoot 6y agoNo idea on cost, but here's a 32" reflective LCD panel: https://www.sunvisiondisplay.com/technology https://www.sunvisiondisplay.com/technology
- jeppesen-io 6y ago1. LCD does not run on a battery, like this. Greatly improves aesthetics and flexibility of placement 2. LCD will never look the same. You can dimm it all you want, but in evening you'll still have a backlight. I have Samsung Art Frame TV, which tries to do the same. It's closer than most things, but nothing like an e-ink display. It's night and day compared my (2) eInk tablets I'm fairly sure 32" and above has only been available for 3 or 4 years. With a low volume, niche product 2300 Euros is really not unreasonable, particularly in a commercial setting
- sfblah 6y agoI was interested until I saw that price. I'd rather just buy the paper and tape it to the wall each day.
- dsr_ 6y agoYour solution will be cheaper, higher-resolution, and offer you more actual utility, as the whole newspaper will be available to you. It does involve some manual work, though.
- dotBen 6y agoAnother direction to take this would be to include in a smart mirror https://www.howtogeek.com/414647/how-to-build-a-smart-mirror/ https://www.howtogeek.com/414647/how-to-build-a-smart-mirror... https://www.electricmirror.com/smart-mirror-savvy/ https://www.electricmirror.com/smart-mirror-savvy/
- _ph_ 6y agoIt is really difficult to describe the benefits of e-ink vs. even great displays. The closest perhaps is the oled of my iPhone with the automatic color adjustment. But for emulating the look and feel of paper, e-ink cannot be beaten. I just basically replaced my iPad Pro for note taking with the reMarkable 2, and it is amazing what a difference it makes. Besides the textured surface, it just looks like paper with ink on it. The iPad is great, but always looks like a screen.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vmception 6y agoonly you can answer that if it’s obvious that you shouldn’t spend $2300 consumer electronic being relegated to an art piece using almost none of the utility it is capable of, then dont do it if the answer isnt so obvious then it’s still interesting and viable
- Rebelgecko 6y agoScale matters a lot. e-ink form factors that are used in consumer products have gotten much cheaper. The smaller 2-3 inch ones (like what some stores use for their pricetags) are only a few dollars. You can find tablet sized displays for ~50 dollars. I eink is often the best choice, especially if you care about power consumption (like a hobbyist project on batteries) and a less obnoxious aesthetic (backlights in dark rooms are annoying).
- 0x53 6y agoI've thought about making an eink calendar before, but since the cost is so high I wondered if it would be cheaper just buy 31 2 inch screens and somehow connect them.
- luka-birsa 6y agoThe screens usually have at least 1-2mm border around them, plus driving complexity will go over the roof. But it's a great tinkerers project - go for it! Since our software allows tiling we've built some test large scale composite screens out of our 6" and 9" devices - I think maximum was around 25-50 screens combined in a big virtual surface, with resolution over 10k x 10k pixels. So sure, it can be done, but is a pain to setup and run.
- 0x53 6y agoThat sounds really cool. Any public links to it?
- dheera 6y agoe-Ink really does look very different. Especially if you are hanging it up in a bright, sunlit room, it is a world of difference from LCD. In fact, the sunnier it is, the better your e-Ink displays look, while the worse your LCD displays will look. Also, e-Ink displays don't emit light so they are extremely pleasing to the eye, and don't light up your bedroom at night, if you want it in your bedroom. They also can maintain an image with zero power, which is great if you're conscious about energy usage. The 2300 euro price of this display is a bit beyond my personal budget for projects, but if you're happy with 13.3 inches you can try this Waveshare display: https://www.waveshare.com/13.3inch-e-paper-hat.htm https://www.waveshare.com/13.3inch-e-paper-hat.htm Or this 10 inch version for less than half the price of the 13.3 inch one, which I have: https://www.waveshare.com/product/displays/e-paper/epaper-1/10.3inch-e-paper-hat.htm https://www.waveshare.com/product/displays/e-paper/epaper-1/... If you want a clean construction with all the electronics in one piece, another option you might consider is to hunt for used, 13.3 inch older Boox tablets, which run Android, and just write an Android app for them to do whatever you want them to do.
- luka-birsa 6y agoIf you're looking for a less hacky version that still looks good (similar to the OPs 32" display) and is simple to build upon - you can use our 13" touchless variant. The Joan line is fully productivized and you can use our hosted service to connect to any HTML source (https://getjoan.com/shop/joan-13/ https://getjoan.com/shop/joan-13/). Or if you'd like to tinker with the platform itself, then Visionect offers a fully customizable solution (https://www.visionect.com/product/place-and-play-13/ https://www.visionect.com/product/place-and-play-13/) with the same hardware. We've had a lot of people take our 6" panels and build their own Home Automation controllers. Here are the instructions: https://getjoan.com/blog/diy-home-automation-system/ https://getjoan.com/blog/diy-home-automation-system/