39 ms·
American Airlines Is Quietly Bringing Back the 737Max
- omginternets 6y agoIs there any way to know what kind of aircraft you'll be boarding when purchasing tickets? I've never paid attention until now, and the 737-Max is definitely a non-starter.
- bradstewart 6y agoEvery airline will show you the scheduled aircraft when booking tickets, usually right next to the airports and travel times. Nothing guarantees they won't change it at some point before the flight though.
- tpmx 6y agoBe aware of the alternative aircraft code 737-8, which is a bit similar to the "good old" 737-800. AA seems to show "7M8-Boeing 737MAX 8" though. See https://onemileatatime.com/american-737-max-flights/ https://onemileatatime.com/american-737-max-flights/ and https://onemileatatime.com/boeing-737-8/ https://onemileatatime.com/boeing-737-8/
- jdxcode 6y agocertainly nothing guarantees, but American did at least say they wouldn't rebook non-MAX to MAX flights
- ConceitedCode 6y agoJust curious, what would it take for you to get on a 737-Max? European and American regulators have gone over it with a fine tooth comb at this point and allow it to fly. There is always gonna be people that will say the plane shouldn't fly. Arguably the amount of attention this plane has gotten will probably make it one of the safest in the industry going forward.
- omginternets 6y agoHonestly? Nothing. The issue is that I don't have enough time to evaluate whether the shoring-up job on the Max is sufficient.
- richardARPANET 6y agoSince the plane is aerodynamically flawed by design. I'll never step foot on one.
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoBut its not?
- gruez 6y agoBut it is? I think the parent was talking about: >Travis is unequivocal in his assessment of the Boeing 737 MAX. “It’s a faulty airframe. You’ve got to fix the airframe [and] you can’t fix the airframe without moving the engines” back and away from their current position. >The root problem with the engine-forward design is “once this thing pitches up, it wants to keep pitching up,” said Travis. “That’s a big no-no,” he continued, because pitch-up on an aircraft increases angle of attack. https://www.eetimes.com/software-wont-fix-boeings-faulty-airframe/ https://www.eetimes.com/software-wont-fix-boeings-faulty-air...
- ConceitedCode 6y agoFYI - Background on the guy being quoted "Gregory Travis, a veteran software engineer and experienced, instrument-rated pilot who has flown aircraft simulators as large as the Boeing 757" I know a few veteran software engineers that are instrument-rated and frankly I'm not sure I would listen to any of them over the FAA or aeronautical engineers. Probably good for some perspective, but not exactly a great source for determining if an airplane is "aerodynamically flawed by design".
- 6y ago
- ghaff 6y agoThe short answer is no. The longer answer is that you can see the planned type of aircraft when you book your ticket which doesn't typically change. But airlines can and do sometimes switch aircraft types at the last minute up to the point where you're already at the gate. ADDED: And I'm guessing things are more fluid than usual in the current situation.
- toast0 6y agoIt really depends on the route (and the airline). Some routes I've flown are scheduled for different types throughout the day; it's not uncommon to fly on the other type. As a bonus, different types have different premium rows, if you reserve a non-premium seat and the type is changed, you may keep the seat number and get a premium seat.
- intricatedetail 6y agoIf I saw 737MAX pulling at the terminal I would have cancelled the trip, but usually airline shows plane at itinerary and you can check flightradar what planes fly that route.
- FandangoRanger 6y agoIf it's Boeing, I'm not going.
- wussboy 6y agoThis article was a seemingly randomly assembled collection of sentences and paragraphs, vaguely related to the plane and other travel inconveniences.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoWas the article pounded together by an overworked, exhausted and underpaid reporter, or put together by some kind of summarization/content generation algorithm? That is the question.
- fakedang 6y agoLikely by the Author who's clearly inexperienced in journalism.
- jonplackett 6y agoLike people need another reason not to fly right now!
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agothe 737 max is probably the safest plane in the world right now. like jack in the box was actually the safest place in the world to eat right after they were serving the ecoli burger
- chowndown 6y agoThere's a similar tenet for purchasing refurbished hardware. The supplier only wants to stomach a single RMA, so they will put in the effort to make sure the re-certified doesn't ever come back.
- lbriner 6y agoThat's not true at all. All work is a trade-off between effort/cost and reward. The person refurbishing the equipment will decide how much work is reasonable for the amount of money they are making on it. In an ideal world, we want to sell something that works perfectly and don't want any returns for sure but the truth is we never know its perfect and perfection costs money.
- chowndown 6y agoA piece of hardware that has been re-certified has absolutely been through more extensive testing than those sold as new, its a simple fact of the matter
- tuna-piano 6y agoWould you have said that before and after the first Lion Air 737 Max crash prior to the Ethopian crash? Certainly a lot of people have spent a lot of time looking into a lot of the plane's systems. But are there more fundamental issues that can't or haven't been addressed? Those same people spent a lot of time prior to certification looking into the plane...
- addicted 6y agoI don’t know much about airplane design. But if you told me that a software was so buggy that it was pulled out of market and then years were spent fixing the bugs in it, I almost certainly would not trust the resultant software more than I would have trusted a complete rewrite. If aircraft manufacturing is anything like software development (and considering a lot of the issues in the Max are software related there’s at least some of that), this does not make me confident in the Max at all.
- tuna-piano 6y ago737Max is certainly tainted now. But will that last forever? And do non-HN-aviation-geek consumers really care enough to check the model of the plane they'll be flying on, let alone make a flight decision based on the model? Certainly another crash could be devastating to the model. But was the 737Max a poorly designed death trap rushed to production or a super safe airplane with a single fatal flaw? Time will tell...
- phire 6y agoCertianlly not just a single flaw. They found and fixed multiple other flaws while checking though everything for re-certification. In my opinion, the 737Max is probably one of the safest planes right now, simply because of the amount of scrutiny it's been though.
- phkahler 6y agoWell the engine placement hasn't been changed and that was the underlying problem that lead to everything else.
- _fat_santa 6y agoTo be a bit more nuanced, it's not that the engine placement was the problem, rather it was that Boeing made software adjustments to make the plane fly like a regular 737 without training the pilots in these changes. The engine is the start of the problems
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThe fundamental problem is a lack of effective redundancy for bad sensors. They haven't fixed that. Software alone will not fix it. They've just implemented superficial procedures that don't address the real safety issue.
- msbarnett 6y ago> rather it was that Boeing made software adjustments to make the plane fly like a regular 737 without training the pilots in these changes No, this is a persistent and pernicious myth on HN – that the MCAS was some sort of “737 Emulator” intended to allow the plane’s customers to avoid pilot training. In reality, during testing it was discovered that the engines’ new position caused the stick forces to invert in some situations during flight. “The stick forces invert” means that it becomes easier to pull into an aerodynamic stall than push away from it. This fails a Fundamental Airworthiness Requirement that all commercial aircraft are required to conform with for certification. Boeing’s “solution” was MCAS – using the stabilizer trim to automatically push the plane’s nose down as it approaches a stall (and therefore putting additional force on the stick that keeps it at all times easier to push away from the stall than pull into it). The pilot training thing was just that they concealed the existence of MCAS from pilots out of fear that it would prompt calls for additional training. tl;dr the problem was that the engine aerodynamics made the plane fundamentally uncertifiable without a software hack.
- x87678r 6y agoWhat are people going to fly instead? The regular 737? Have you seen the list of how many 737 crashes there have been? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incidents_involving_the_Boeing_737 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incident... Or maybe A320 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incidents_involving_the_Airbus_A320_family https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incident...
- srj 6y agoYou need to consider accidents as a rate over miles flown.
- ravenstine 6y agoAnd also country of origin. If you look at that list, there are WAY more accidents in non-US and non-EU countries. The same is true of commercial air accidents in recent history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incidents_involving_commercial_aircraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incident... If anything, this demonstrates that air travel is unreasonably safe given the number of flights and amount of miles traveled.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- solids 6y agoYou need to exclude from that list accidents like GOL 1907, that had nothing to do with the aircraft.
- _zachs 6y ago> Through 2015, the Airbus A320 family has experienced 0.12 fatal hull-loss accidents for every million takeoffs, and 0.26 total hull-loss accidents for every million takeoffs; one of the lowest fatality rates of any airliner.[3]
- paganel 6y agoI’d take an A320 over a 737 every day, the latter seems so cramped and a little older, to be honest. Or maybe me only experiencing them on Ryanair made me think that way.
- deeblering4 6y agoI’m at a point where I just opt for carriers with Airbus fleets. I do not trust modern day American corporations nor the oversight bodies. There are too many financial incentives to cut corners.
- js2 6y agoFor years after AF447 I was nervous flying airbus. In reality, it's extremely unlikely that you'll die flying. (I'd be nervous flying a Max too, but it's not rational.)
- lbriner 6y agoThe difference with AF447 was that the aircraft at no point was defective, it was purely confusion on part of the flight crew and the issue with two pilots "in control" which the Captain absolutely should have dealt with.
- detritus 6y agoI thought the pitot tube 'failed' by getting iced up? I'm not sure of that's a common thing to happen though. Obviously the subsequent decisions were what ultimately led to the disaster.
- js2 6y agoThe pitot tubes had iced-over and it wasn't the first time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447#Pitot_tubes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447#Pitot_tu... But that's not what made me nervous about Airbus. Rather, that's when I learned that Airbuses are flown by side-sticks that aren't mechanically linked while Boeings are flown by yokes which are. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447#Side-stick_control_issue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447#Side-sti... The idea that two pilots can provide conflicting inputs without realizing it bothers me from a design standpoint.
- pirocks 6y ago
- outside1234 6y agoDoes it matter? Nobody with any sense or care for their fellow human being should be flying now.
- Schiendelman 6y agoIt’s not clear that’s true. Flying doesn’t appear to be causing covid to spread.
- aphextron 6y ago>It’s not clear that’s true. Flying doesn’t appear to be causing covid to spread. Come on now. Just because we don't have peer reviewed scientific studies confirming the fact doesn't mean common sense can't apply. You're sitting in an enclosed terminal with thousands of other people from all over the world who may or may not even be masked, waiting in multiple lines with no social distancing, and touching an endless amount of common surfaces. It's spreading like wildfire at airports without even including the actual flight itself.
- Schiendelman 6y agoI understand why common sense wants you to make that last statement, but we would be hearing that in the news. So far, I haven't run across stories asserting spread in airports.
- larrik 6y agoAnecdote! One of my co-workers appears to have gotten covid from flying.
- Schiendelman 6y agoI am sure it happens sometimes! But not enough for there to be news stories about it, like we see when groups of people that large gather elsewhere.
- holler 6y ago
- Dirlewanger 6y ago>The airline is trying to entice passengers to take a tour of the plane at selected airports. This is just so sad. One, because American clearly thinks customers are stupid enough to think that this will assuage their fears, and also because the American public is stupid enough that this will probably work for some people
- wycy 6y agoI still don't think I'd trust it. While it's probably true that they fixed the software to never again produce this kind of error, I don't like the idea of software being used to correct the fundamental physics that the airframe is dynamically unstable. While the software probably does a good job of correcting it under a wide range of normal operating conditions, can it deal with evolving or abnormal operating conditions? Will the software still be able to compensate if the pitch-up moment is artificially increased by, e.g. the roof turning into a scoop, or flaps jamming, or a small piece of wing trim breaking? Would Aloha Airlines Flight 243 still have landed safely after the roof came off, becoming a scoop, if it were instead a 737Max?
- atharris 6y agoI've said this elsewhere in the thread, but stabilizing a dynamically unstable system is half of the reason why control theory remains an active research area instead of a mathematical backwater; this kind of set up is extremely common for aerospace systems. Software is hard to get right - which is why aerospace software has traditionally faced much higher bars for verification than 'traditional' software (and is much more expensive as a result!) The same is true of hardware, which I think many HN commentators forget; the cost of a bolt or connector that is aerospace-grade is typically many times that of a conventional or automotive-grade part, due mostly to extensive testing+verification required for safety. Most of the scenarios you're describing are dealt with in a few ways: 1. Building systems with sufficient margin to account for this kind of uncertainty; even with passively stable aircraft, these margins exist. Feedback control typically increases these margins. 2. Extensive verification under a wide range of input conditions; this is more challenging (how can you enumerate every possible failure condition?), but usually boils down to some kind of Monte-Carlo sampling or worst-case analysis when those cases can be identified. Here's [0] a neat paper that does this in a more sample-efficient way. [0] https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.06645 https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.06645
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 6y ago737MAX is not nor never has been dynamically/aerodynamically unstable. Full stop. No airliner is permitted to be unstable by FAA regulations. At no point in the flight envelope will the aircraft pitch up into a stall without pitch-up inputs, thus it is not unstable. MCAS was used to augment flight stick characteristics, namely to simulate a linear relationship between flight-stick input force and pitch-up/AoA. This was, and always has been, about single-certification and pilot UX, not anything about the stability of the airplane. Having stick forces be somewhat lower than expected at high AoA does not make the plane unstable. The linear relationship is considered ideal, but many planes such as the 757 have a similar non-linear relationship. MCAS is not anti-stall. Granted, this has widely been mis-reported. The real issue is that the MCAS system was made dramatically more powerful, and thus dangerous, over the course of development. Without a concomitant change to the reliability of MCAS inputs (namely the AoA sensors), this resulted in disaster. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/as-the-faa-finalizes-the-737-maxs-return-is-boeings-jet-now-safe/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/as-th...
- ajarmst 6y agoWhat's the alternative? There was a flaw in the aircraft design, a dreadful one. Some fundamental structural issues and conflicts of interest at the FCC (that the NTSB has been complaining about for roughly its entire existence) were again highlighted. Boeing executives turned out to be as subject to lying to themselves when making difficult decisions as the rest of humanity. Other nation's certification processes turned out be inappropriately trustful of the American certification process (that's widespread through all sorts of areas, but one of the few positives of the Trump regime will be a re-evaluation of that little habit). People make mistakes. Systems (human and technological) fail. The holes in the Swiss cheese sometimes line up just enough to permit a tragedy, as issues with training and maintenance lined up with an inexcusable design flaw to allow one crash and then bureaucratic inertia and incompetence (and perhaps even a little racism) allowed a second. The reason modern commercial air travel is so absurdly, unimaginably safe is that we always, always make sure we understand these events when they lead to tragedy or even just near misses. This has happened before. If you think aircraft automation vs. pilot is a new problem, take a look at Airbus' history. The pre-MAX 737 (arguably the safest commercial aircraft in widespread use) shipped with a flaw in its rudder actuator design that took four crashes and a half-dozen near misses to finally figure out. I'd happily board one (MAX or otherwise) tomorrow, knowing that among the myriad of things that might kill me, rudder actuator failure or MCAS won't be found. Because we fix these things when we figure them out. And not just the part. The process that allowed the part to fail so tragically as well. Remember the DC-10? Even a cursory read of its history puts the MCAS affair to shame, and it ultimately killed not only hundreds of passengers but the reputation and brand of the legendary Douglas Aircraft. Know what else? Still flying. Pilots love them, although they call them MD-10s now and they're rarely used for passenger service. There's a good chance your next package from Amazon will fly on one to get to you. And when the pilots board one they can be pretty certain that even if the plane kills them, it won't be with a cargo bay door failure. Because we fixed that. What do people propose? Shut down Boeing? Let Airbus have a monopoly on commercial air vehicles? That's won't serve safety. Start buying our aircraft from Tupolev? Might want to check their record first. Want carriers to just scrap their 737 MAX tails? Right now? That's the same thing as just declaring bankruptcy. The investment in a commercial aircraft takes years of steady use to pay off, and no one in the industry is in a financial position to take that hit. Once the aircraft are deemed safe (and, trust me, the MCAS problem will be solved), they should be flown. If you really want to save a lot of lives, lobby to hold the automobile or pharmaceutical industries to even a fraction of the standards we require of commercial air travel carriers.
- dkobia 6y agoInteresting. American Airlines was also one of the first the first to not block middle seats for social distancing. Smells of desperation.
- pdx_flyer 6y agoTo be clear, the FAA is set to lift their grounding order on November 18. https://www.reuters.com/article/boeing-737max/exclusive-faa-in-final-stages-of-boeing-737-max-review-could-approve-as-early-as-nov-18-idUSL1N2HV3JK https://www.reuters.com/article/boeing-737max/exclusive-faa-...
- tistoon 6y agoThe same FAA that let the faulty aircraft to fly in the first place?
- notjustanymike 6y agoI suspect that after this year, with 5 737Max's worth of people dying a day, that this plane now falls into the "acceptable risk" category for most people.
- schainks 6y agoMy friends who have recently flown American have all complained how shitty American's COVID precautions are. Bringing the 737Max back isn't going to change bad service.
- geoelectric 6y agoOn the plus side, you won't have to tolerate the bad service for a whole flight.
- xiphias2 6y ago,,The announcement comes even though Boeing is yet to implement a software upgrade that his agency demanded. It could be two years before it’s ready.'' This is a clear case of corruption
- canada_dry 6y agoIMHO, the 737Max should be forced to serve in non-passenger service - e.g. courier shipping - for a number of cumulative flight hours (e.g. 5,000) before it goes back to passenger use. Given the huge rise in shipping during the holiday season this criteria could be satisfied by the end of the year.
- imtringued 6y agoIt's not like it's impossible to make the 737 Max safe but the problem is that Boeing took shortcuts and how can we trust them to not have taken shortcuts again?