7 ms·
You seem to be looking at it backwards. You're complaining mostly about Apple charging too much for not enough. But since people are signing up for these thin
by crazygringo 6y ago
You seem to be looking at it backwards.
You're complaining mostly about Apple charging too much for not enough.
But since people are signing up for these things in droves, Apple is making $$$$, which means Apple's strategy is succeeding.
Apple's services strategy pays off when it makes a lot of profit, not when when you feel like you're getting amazing deals on everything. Apple's never been a budget-product company, it's always been high-end.
- Traster 6y agoI'm not complaining about them charging too much for not enough, I'm complaining about their products being bad. That's quite a distinction. Apple Music isn't as good as Spotify, Apple TV+ isn't as good as (Amazon Prime Video|Disney+|Netflix), Apple's bundle isn't as good as Amazon Prime. Siri isn't as good as Alexa or Google Assistant. Apple Arcade can't compete with.. well... the Appstore. Apple is having success at pushing people who already have iPhones to buy services in the same way that Microsoft as realy good at getting people to use Internet Explorer. But Apple's success at pushing people into services revenue isn't a long term indication of strength.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoAll of these are subjective statements. I much prefer Apple Music to Spotify, and I don't think people really care that much about Google Assistant - iPhones still sell well at much higher prices than android phones.
- HighlandSpring 6y agoIt's not about what you prefer, it's about whether they can hold onto their market share in solving these problems.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoCertainly, but it looks like Apple has done well enough in that segment, ~20% marketshare. Spotify will always dominate marketshare - it has a free tier.
- ksec 6y ago>Spotify will always dominate marketshare - it has a free tier. It has nothing to do with free tier. Spotify is dominating even if you only count paying subscribers.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoAnd still they just funnel all their profits to the record labels :(
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThey funnel their revenue to the record labels, not profits. Evidently, Spotify’s product doesn’t command a premium in the market compared to the alternatives.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoRecord labels aren’t a single-faceted evil, in spite of however strongly that notion may be engrained in the Napster generation. If anything, there are more even-handed relationships between wrist and label than there ever was.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoSpotify has ~32% marketshare, Apple 18% - and considering Spotify pre-dated Apple Music significantly, it isn't that impressive. https://www.midiaresearch.com/blog/music-subscriber-market-shares-q1-2020#:~:text=Despite%20Apple%20Music's%20strong%20showing,both%20absolute%20and%20relative%20terms https://www.midiaresearch.com/blog/music-subscriber-market-s....
- hajile 6y ago
- coldtea 6y agoWell, the predictions that "they can't hold onto their market share, surely not at this prices, etc" have been going on for 20 years now...
- izacus 6y agoBut their products being bad doesn't matter - they'll make sure to cripple all the competition so the only usable service products are Apple products. They've already started embedding agressive marketing pitches into their OSes so the competition will always be a step behind. That's enough - their products don't really have to be the best. They'll win by competition not being able to surpass them due to restrictions.
- marcosdumay 6y ago> they'll make sure to cripple all the competition so the only usable service products are Apple products You mean they will risk killing their core products so they get to anti-competitive benefits on other markets? I believe you are correct, but that's risky on more than one way and isn't good for their long term bottom line.
- izacus 6y agoMy first hand experience shows that corporations aren't always rational. Especially if they're big - it's really easy to get a discrepancy between what smaller unit/team managers want (push their own team product) vs. what's benefical for the whole corporation in the long run. This is how you get a lot of seemingly dumb corporate decisions.
- cutemonster 6y ago> what smaller unit/team managers want (push their own team product) You mean they might do that although the team's product isn't any good? Good for the team, career wise, but not the company?
- izacus 6y agoYes, it's very common to get inertia where the teams scramble to justify spent time and managers refuse to admit that the product isn't good. It's amazing what you can prove by choosing the corect set of metrics.
- wmeredith 6y ago> it's always been high-end. It's always been worth it, too, when it comes to hardware (this is debatable, but obviously they're successful). The problem with their services is that they are NOT worth it. They aren't high end. Their services aren't the best. They're middle of the pack (music, movies, TV) or trailing (cloud, search, productivity software, AI). So all their finely-tuned marketing/operations machinery geared to sell "the best" don't work for their services.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI haven’t met someone yet who would call Apple TV+ middle of the pack compared to the alternatives.
- zafiro17 6y agoApple is slowly disappearing from my family's hardware portfolio, and recent software changes are accelerating it. Back in 2005 or so I converted my entire CD collection to digital, and managed it happily using Itunes. Somehow in the transition from itunes to Apple Music, Apple refused to recognize any of the tracks I created from my own, legally purchased media. My wife currently has no way to listen to any of the music we legally own, using her iphone. So guess whose next phone is going to be Android, with an SD card containing 1TB of music we own? The other advantages of iphone are not important to me, and the apps she uses are available on the playstore. For bonus points I can buy her a pretty decent Android phone for a few hundred bucks, instead of a new device costing well over a thousand. I understand Apple wants to push everyone to monthly paid services. As a customer, I DO NOT want yet another $10/month expenses - I've got a lot of those already. I just want to listen to music I already own.
- dublinben 6y agoHas syncing music from iTunes to your iPhone stopped working? It's the first-class way to listen to "the music [you] legally own" on an iPhone, and comes with no ongoing service fees.
- hanifc 6y agoIt certainly hasn't. That's the way I get music onto my iPhone today.
- crazygringo 6y ago> My wife currently has no way to listen to any of the music we legally own, using her iphone. There are so many ways to do this I can't even list them here. You can store songs locally on your iPhone, or upload them to a cloud-based service if you've got a full terabyte of them. But the idea that an iPhone can't play your music files simply isn't true. Also you can buy a pretty decent iPhone for a few hundred bucks too, that will last longer than your Android one. The only iPhone "well over a thousand" is the high-end flagship model.
- 6y ago
- gumby 6y ago> Apple's never been a budget-product company, it's always been high-end. The Apple II would like to politely disagree.
- jjav 6y agoThe Apple ][ was pretty expensive compared to its contemporaries.
- eschaton 6y agoEven the Apple I was relatively expensive relative to both competitors and its own BoM. The advantage has always been that the company attempts to make computing appliances for users who want to do something besides “compute.” Sure people infatuated with computing as a thing in itself have also always been welcome, but (unlike its contemporaries) those weren’t the only people welcome.
- m463 6y agoRelease date June 1977; 43 years ago Introductory price US$1,298 (equivalent to $5,476 in 2019)