6 ms·
> Had the Democrats put up anyone who was less divisive than Hillary Clinton then we are not where we are today. You say this like Clinton did badly: she got 2
by throw0101a 6y ago
> Had the Democrats put up anyone who was less divisive than Hillary Clinton then we are not where we are today.
You say this like Clinton did badly: she got 2.9M more votes than Trump!
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_United_States_presidential_election https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_United_States_presidentia...
Most of the voting public rejected Trump in 2016. It's just that 77K of those votes were in the "wrong" places (MI 10K; PA 44K; WI 23K).
- patrickaljord 6y ago> You say this like Clinton did badly: he got 2.9M more votes than Trump! That's because a few blue states have huge population such as California.
- humbledrone 6y agoAre you implying that each Californian should count for less than one vote?
- jessedhillon 6y agoYour (implied) counterproposal is not neutral either: you are suggesting that rurals and suburbans should be ruled by young type-As who are willing to pack themselves into tiny, overpriced apartments and make their careers a top priority well into their middle age. Why should that culture dominate? > Are you implying that each Californian should count for less than one vote? In a federalist republic, yes that's exactly what that means. The country was deliberately designed as a collection of independent states, and not a single population whose diversity is merely geographic.
- jopsen 6y ago> The country was deliberately designed as a collection of independent states, Hmm... Couldn't it be argued that this haven't really been the case since the civil war? When I lived in SF, most Americans I met weren't originally from California (not had they lived there long).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hirsin 6y agoYou're making the implicit assumption that more of those people exist than the rural and suburban types, in which case... Yes? Your comment cuts both ways - one of those groups is going to be the dominant culture and if your argument is that the smaller one should win, I don't see the reasoning to back it up.
- throwaway201103 6y agoThe electoral college moderates the effect. The big states still dominate. Just not as completely. The small states have their voice instead of being completely irrelevant. It's not that they "win" or even have an equal say.
- newen 6y agoThe coastal city culture is already dominant in all types of media and academia and large corporations.
- R0b0t1 6y agoIt's not about winning. The original motivation for the US's structure is to impede lawmaking at the highest levels unless absolutely necessary. Making laws is not making progress.
- jessedhillon 6y agoYou've assumed that everyone agreed at some point on majoritarianism, which never happened.
- smabie 6y agoNo one is implying that, that's how it works and is intended to work.
- mattmanser 6y agoIt's a historical quirk rather than intention. No sane democracy would have the electoral college system today.
- colinmhayes 6y agoI agree with your last sentence, but this is very clearly the intention. Small states threw a fit when they were writing the constitution so now we're stuck with this bullshit.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoThat’s not strictly true; the original intention was for slaveholding states to have a roughly equal voice in presidential elections without letting slaves vote. Smaller states threw a fit about counting slaves as full citizens for the purposes of representation, which is how we arrived at the Three-Fifths Compromise.
- colinmhayes 6y agoI'm talking about Connecticut compromise, which created the electoral college, not the 3/5 compromise.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoThe Connecticut Compromise created the Senate, not the electoral college. The explicit purpose of the electoral college was to give more power to slaveholding states without enfranchising slaves. The Three-Fifths Compromise is intrinsically related to the electoral college, because it instructed how to count slaves when determining how many House seats a state would get.
- beaner 6y agoOpen minded question: Maybe yes? If states don't have an ability to have a voice for themselves as states, what's the point of them at all? They gain this small but important nudge towards autonomy from the electoral college.
- sidibe 6y agoI think states already get that enough through the senate. I really think the president should be by popular vote, but don't see any way this would ever get changed.
- mattst88 6y agoIn case you're not aware of the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Interstate_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Intersta...), take a look. It's doable.
- beaner 6y agoThe senate is one mechanism, but its mere existence is not reason enough to consider it sufficient.
- Tuna-Fish 6y agoThe NPVIC[0] is actually inching closer and closer to being in force. It will still take a long time, but I see it actually possibly working eventually. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Interstate_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Intersta...
- beaner 6y agoIMO, states choosing to enter an agreement like this of their own free will, is the appropriate way to get a popular vote, if that's what the people want, while still retaining the right of the electoral college. I personally disagree with a state choosing to sacrifice its voice in such a way, but it's its right to do so, to award its votes how it sees fit.
- throw0101a 6y agoAnd? There are/were plenty of GOPers even in "blue" states, and they counted in the PV as well. Further, it is generally not states that "are blue", but rather more urban areas: * https://www.city-journal.org/html/real-engine-blue-america-12848.html https://www.city-journal.org/html/real-engine-blue-america-1... > There's a decisive break between Democratic and Republican support at a population density of 800 persons/per square mile. * https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-04-01/how-the-density-of-your-county-affects-how-you-vote https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-04-01/how-the-d...
- TylerE 6y agoYes, this is often ignored. In 2016, California had the 3rd most votes for Trump, with 4.5M. Similarly, despite losing the state 52/43, Texas contributed the 4th highest count for Hillary.
- throwaway201103 6y agoI said that he lost the popular vote. My point is that many of his 2016 votes were "anyone but Clinton." If he had a more appealing opponent, it wouldn't have been close.
- akkartik 6y agoIsn't your claim falsified by this election? This opponent was someone else. Trump didn't lose many votes. The reality that's hit me this year is that most Americans will vote for anyone who wins "their" party's primary. Everything else is rationalization.
- intended 6y agoHave not people checked and realized that trump got more votes this time ? I think he did 62.9 million last time and is at 70.5 now. More people got out and voted, and more people voted for trump than before.
- akkartik 6y agoYeah. It's all about getting us off our asses and into the voting booth. I think this also explains why more partisan rhetoric wins. It gets more people mobilized, while not really hurting you with moderates. It only hurts you with people who think. Who're a tiny minority. (I'm not convinced I'm one of them.)
- throwaway201103 6y agoI'm saying that both elections were decided based on hate of the opponent, not support for the winner. That's backwards from what it should be.
- akkartik 6y agoThat's how it's been for at least decades. Democrats voted for Gore from hate of Bush. So this is a structural problem you're stuck with. Unless you come up with a stronger force than a pandemic with 100,000 fatalities.
- LunaSea 6y agoIn reality, in 2016, abstention won the election and it wasn't even close.
- edoceo 6y agoYo, it's not just one thing. Clinton, party, absent, jerks, EC are all factors.
- pessimizer 6y ago> You say this like Clinton did badly: she got 2.9M more votes than Trump! You say this like Clinton did well. This is a sub 5% advantage over a racist game show host.
- InTheArena 6y agoAnd yet it doesn’t matter to the above posters point. You can blame the electoral college if you want, but it just means the type of demagoguery to get elected is different. Hillary Clinton had a very long history of antagonizing anytime she could people on the right. For example remember her slut-shaming of bull Clinton’s accusers, or her attack in the “vast right wing consipriacy” trying to defend her husband from the totally untrue charges from Monica lewinsky. The reality of it is that the Democrats have to appeal to more than just their base to be elected. They seem to of learned that lesson this time.