11 ms·
A 20kg hybrid drone that can fly at 50kmh for 4 hours
- jaclaz 6y agoInteresting. It is surprising to me (but probably it is some aeronautics specification/need) that its 2-stroke engine uses 95 octane+4% oil mix, it is years that using synthetic oil you can use 2% or even 1% oil.
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoI think it’s something like the engine of a chainsaw, or similar “gardening engine”, that can use up to 4/5% of oil
- jaclaz 6y agoSure, but the whole point of reducing the oil percentage in two stroke engines has been (since like 40 years) to reduce the formation of carbon in the combustion chamber and - particularly - to have cleaner spark plugs (which imply better ignition) besides better combustion. Less oil in the mix (as long as lubricating is sufficient) is better. The traditional 4-5% is for mineral oils. Synthetic (totally or partially) oils can usually go on 2% (or 50:1) and in some cases as low as 1% (or 100:1). Modern chainsaws and similar are already at 2%, see (examples): https://www.stihlusa.com/information/how-to-guides/mixing-oil-and-gasoline/ https://www.stihlusa.com/information/how-to-guides/mixing-oi... https://www.husqvarna.com/au/forest/when-working/usage/how-to-mix-2-stroke-fuel/ https://www.husqvarna.com/au/forest/when-working/usage/how-t... https://www.amsoil.com/p/outboard-100-1-pre-mix-synthetic-2-stroke-oil-ato/ https://www.amsoil.com/p/outboard-100-1-pre-mix-synthetic-2-... Ignition in an engine for airplanes/drones/etc. is - obviously - much more important than in a common 2 stroke engine (chainsaw or similar), a "common" 2-stroke engine used in ultralights is the Rotax 582 (an earlier model was the 532) check its "limitations": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotax_582 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotax_582 The 582 has twin sparks (two spark plugs per cylinder) and runs on 50:1 mix: https://www.flyrotax.com/produkte/detail/rotax-582-ul.html https://www.flyrotax.com/produkte/detail/rotax-582-ul.html
- CoolGuySteve 6y agoMight be for safety reasons, an engine seize in a flying drone would be catastrophic and dangerous compared to merely inconvenient as in most small engine applications. OTOH, piston scoring from burning oil will probably increase the chance of a lock up over time.
- adrianpike 6y agoExcept the onboard combustion engine is just to generate electricity, no? An engine sieze means you just have to land quickly.
- jlcortex 6y agoThat is true for HYBRiX, but there are other hybrid multirotors, which do not have a design well-balanced enough to being able to stay aloft on just batteries (batteries to lift a 25kg MTOW drone are heavy, so the drone needs to be very light, while still robust, to work properly.. it is tricky ;)
- sytse 6y agoFor reference, the Stihl chainsaw I just purchased had a 50:1 gasoline to oil mix. That is 2%, of course there are probably 25:1 or 20:1 engines out there as well.
- stickfigure 6y agoWild guess: The engine is an off-the-shelf part and that just happened to be the specs for whatever fit the size/weight/power/cost requirements.
- SigmundA 6y agoCould be duty cycle or cost of synthetic, either way 2-strokes are extremely dirty emission wise due to unburnt fuel in the exhaust.
- FreedomToCreate 6y agohttps://www.pegasusaero.ca/ https://www.pegasusaero.ca/ This company designed hybrid engines for retrofitting onto drones
- jaclaz 6y agoNice. Their generators are amazing, 1-1.5 KW generator in less than 3 kg, or 3 KW in less than 4 kg, really packed power. (BTW they use 2.5% or 40:1 mix)
- jlcortex 6y agoIt's because of the duty cycle of the engine, we put it at a constant rate of 12000 RPM for hours. It is not the standard setting for that engine.
- candiodari 6y agoNow if only the webpage could fly at 10 qps for 1 hour ...
- jlcortex 6y agoSorry about that! :(
- thysultan 6y agoWould it make sense to use hydrogen fuel to further decrease the weight?
- tachyonbeam 6y agoAFAIK hydrogen is hard to store, so your storage tank might be pretty heavy. It also has lower energy density than gasoline/kerosine.
- baybal2 6y agoCost-wise, no
- semi-extrinsic 6y agoThere have certainly been cost effective hydrogen powered long distance drones. One potential benefit is that you can run fuel cells, which are silent and quite a bit more efficient than a two-stroke driving a generator. OTOH, getting similar energy density is challenging, as others have said. Although you can come quite close with liquid hydrogen, if you can live with a fuel that's not storable for long times at small quantities in the field.
- Tomminn 6y agoSince hydrogen is very low density you'd pay through the nose in terms of an increase in drag and a decrease of max wind tolerance.
- black6 6y agoDoosan is currently marketing a hydrogen fuel cell powered UAS. http://www.doosanmobility.com/en/ http://www.doosanmobility.com/en/
- jlcortex 6y agoEquivalent hydrogen multirotors at this stage do not have the payload capacity of a hybrid fuel-electric drone. They might be a great solution in the future, but the technology is not there yet.
- czbond 6y agoSite is down, here is google cache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:KiJcBebRx18J:https://www.quaternium.com/uav/hybrix-drone/ https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:KiJcBe...
- SigmundA 6y agoAnyone know if it's a series or parallel hybrid? Looks like it uses electric motors out on the props like most drones which would imply series. If so interested to know the generator setup, usually thats heavy / inefficient vs mechanical drive from engine, but quad copter needs independent speed control for each prop to steer I thought.
- jcims 6y agoThere’s a few collective pitch quadrotors that use a single gas drivetrain to spin the props and servos for pitch control. Example: Stingray 500 - https://youtu.be/TnGhEInTXYc?t=36 https://youtu.be/TnGhEInTXYc?t=36 Agree with your observations. This is a big quad, 30” (fixed pitch) props and not a ton of payload...probably serial.
- pfundstein 6y agoWhat advantage would a collective pitch quad have over a helicopter?
- jcims 6y agoDunno. I imagine it's use-case dependent, quads can go faster (rc quads can hit 200mph) and are more nimble (presumably due to lower moment of inertia). I have zero clue how they would scale up though. All I know is that I'm not flying in a quad and helicopters seem to haul heavy shit pretty well.
- pfundstein 6y agoIt sounds like you have seen little of the speed and agility RC helicos can exhibit, for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PptMrBFAO-A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PptMrBFAO-A
- jlcortex 6y agoYes, it is a series hybrid, the engine acts as a range-extender. The mechanics of the aircraft are much simpler this way and therefore more reliable. We are not sure about the efficiency, though. There are no helicopters under 25kg MTOW with our flight time right now.
- bangelo 6y agowhy not just use an airplane
- tanseydavid 6y agoThere are probably additional correct answers (all depending on the use case/flight plan) but the takeoff/landing profile for a drone vs. an airplane is one answer to your question.
- chasd00 6y agoi'm sure someone out there as stuck ardupilot inside an R/C V-22 Osprey. Seems like that would be the best of both... or worst of both hah
- LinuxBender 6y agoSome people do use airplanes. Bush planes have been used for a long time to deliver things to remote places... ok, well, not oil rigs, but almost anywhere else. Some of them can take off and land in less than 100 feet. Risk of course is that a human is in it. A drone is less liability and less maintenance costs. Planes will still be used for heavier objects and human transport for some time.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoSo it can carry 10kg with the 32" propellers basically about 120 miles (call 50km/h for 4 ours so 200 kilometers) and you can refuel it quickly. That is also about $1M weighs in $100 bills. Only about $200K in 20's :-) So this could presumably deliver goods to remote places where it might be difficult, or perhaps unsafe, to drive to. Seems like there is a market for that.
- amelius 6y agoWe already have Bitcoin to help criminals move money.
- jermaustin1 6y agoWhen I buy my illegal narcotics, I never use something as volatile and traceable as Bitcoin.
- mylons 6y agoWhat do you use
- jermaustin1 6y agoI barter for my drugs. All joking aside, though, I've actually never met a "drug dealer" that accepted anything but cash.
- thisisnico 6y ago
- taywrobel 6y agoSeems to be in a similar product category as Anduril’s Ghost sUAS - https://www.anduril.com/ghost https://www.anduril.com/ghost Less capacity, but longer flight time. Seems similarly marketed towards industrial/military use tho.
- demosito666 6y agoI don't understand anything in aerodynamics, so pardon my stupid question: planes are the most wide-spread flying machines because they are vastly more efficient than a rotary-wing aircraft due to the lift generated by wings. Why then a quadcopter is the default shape for smaller drones? Is it because small wings don't generate enough lift for the drone to make a difference? But they surely provide additional stability and won't hurt at a glance.
- blacksmith_tb 6y agoNot an aeronautic engineer, but to compare to a similar mass like a bird, having wings would make the hobby-sized drones quite a bit bigger. I assume there's also the ease of changing direction / altitude that comes from having the paired motors, controlling tiny planes would take tiny ailerons and flaps (which, like you say, may not scale down effectively).
- giomasce 6y agoNot an expert, but I'd guess quadcopters are much easier to pilot. You press a button and they go that way. Taking off and landing on wings is very difficult in comparison, requires more space, more facilities, more organization.
- alkonaut 6y agoBut they have tiny wings (arms) and if they were airfoil shaped then it would give some lift in straight and level flight. Then at start/landing/low speed, they would just do nothing. Perhaps the air is so turbulent around the wings due to the propellers that wings just don't get any airflow to create lift, or would need to be much longer to be out of the way of the propellers, that it's not worth it?
- mikepurvis 6y agoAdding foldable wings would be a massive complexity and weight increase relative to the standard scheme which pretty much boils down to 4 motors + an IMU, with the rotors being the only moving parts. The closest thing in the real world to the hybrid that you describe would probably be the tiltrotor, where the same engines which supply lift can turn 90 degrees to become forward thrusters on wings: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiltrotor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiltrotor
- geocrasher 6y agoTheir page reminds me a lot of the feature drone sales pages you see over at banggood.com or aliexpress, ebay, etc. But I don't find it that impressive overall. If they want actual range, put wings on it. You'll see that all the delivery drones are doing such a thing.
- thisisnico 6y agoWould it make sense as to build such a design where wings are integrated but Tilted at an upward angle, so when the drone is angled downward to improve forward thrust, the lift is generated by the wings and the motors are used mostly for propulsion, dramatically improving efficiency and getting the best of both worlds?
- alkonaut 6y agoThat's what Amazon did with theirs, correct? It must be difficult to control or have some other drawback, otherwise it feels like such an obvious win.
- thisisnico 6y agoMaybe stability in windy conditions? or additional mobility issues at low speed.
- geocrasher 6y agoThere are a number of factors. Size, for one. Wings are big. They are also heavy. And during a vertical take off and landing, they aren't wings. They're sails.
- thisisnico 6y agoThat does make a lot of sense. I wonder, would a better design include making the arms attaching to the rotors have the same aerodynamic profile of a wing, made of carbon fibre to reduce weight. For propulsion the rotors can rotate do different angles depending on desired speed?
- alkonaut 6y agoBit rich to call it "low pollution" in their list of benefits. Depends what you put in it and what you compare it to I suppose, but per kilo transported if using fossil fuels, I doubt it compares well to an electric (assuming electric means renewable, which obviously also varies).
- jlcortex 6y agoOf course it does not compare to electric multirotors in that aspect, but its performance is much more advanced. We aim to replace combustion manned helicopters in first response applications, among others. HYBRiX can provide similar operational flight time with 100 times less fuel consumption per hour. Electric multirotors, with up to 30 minutes of flight time, are not suitable for searching missions for example.
- whatever1 6y agoThis could serve as an example of the insane energy density that fossil fuels pack.
- jodrellblank 6y agoThey do, but one of its selling points is its case "fits in the trunk of a standard car." that suggests it's a pretty big drone and I default to imagining copters that fit in a hand, size in picture[2] more than I understand what 20kg means in drone size. No wonder it can fly a long way if it's massive. For energy density comparison, check the Wikipedia list of energy density of various things[1], starts with Antimatter highest, then nuclear fuels, Hydrogen[3] at the top of the chemical fuels with ~140 MegaJoules per Kilogram, then all the hydrocarbon fossil fuels hang around 45-55 MJ/Kg, body fat comes in around 38, coal around 30, wood around 18, glucose around 15, Lithium-air battery at 9, household waste at 8, and the highlight of our modern electronics lifestyle Lithium-ion battery at 0.3-0.9, barely ahead of flywheel at 0.3-0.5. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#Tables_of_energy_content https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#Tables_of_energ... [2] https://www.armytimes.com/resizer/-965_SXAhPeD1LTlB-xZuQwJvJE=/1200x0/filters:quality(100)/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-mco.s3.amazonaws.com/public/BEXU22MH7JEKTPZMAEC3IJH57I.jpg https://www.armytimes.com/resizer/-965_SXAhPeD1LTlB-xZuQwJvJ... [3] the catch with Hydrogen is a kilogram of it is 11 cubic meters, and a lot of that energy advantage has to go into compressing or cooling it to make it usefully dense, and maintaining the infrastructure to store and transport that safely.
- jamiek88 6y agoThat actually makes me hopeful. If we can get a lithium air battery working the a 10x jump in density is possible. That’d be a game changer!
- anigbrowl 6y agoBe nice to get a price on this, I hate 'ask for quote'.
- krick 6y agoThat's impressive and really futuristic. I don't see the price tag, though.
- andymoe 6y agoOne of the interesting things about this UAV is that it’s using Ardupilot which is quite advanced and flexible and one of the only autopilots (there are like two) that use a copy left license. This means we might see more hybrid drones supported by Ardupilot.
- 95014_refugee 6y agoIt's probably the single biggest strike against it, honestly.
- ccostes 6y agoWhy is that?
- aborowie 6y agoAny successful flying platform will start with a mission that includes payload capacity, range (distance), operating costs, and weather resilience. The difference between a hobbyist and a professional is that the hobbyist builds a platform first and looks for a mission/customer after spending R&D dollars. The professional starts with a mission/customer before proceeding to R&D.
- Devils-Avocado 6y agoWhat about using methanol? It has been cleared for use powering laptops. Cleaner burning and quieter than 2-stroke petrol? https://www.zdnet.com/article/methanol-powered-laptops-cleared-for-take-off/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/methanol-powered-laptops-clear...
- MikeAmelung 6y agoMethanol has half the energy density of gasoline.
- Devils-Avocado 6y agoDo the advantages of clean and quiet burning, and perhaps a lighter and simpler engine, outweigh that?
- blackrock 6y agoQuestion for an aeronautical engineer: Can you take the engine nacelle of an airplane and rotate it vertically? So instead of being horizontal, can it be vertical, where the exhaust points down? Or does the engine need the compression and air velocity from the forward motion of the plane to compress and ignite the oxygen?
- jecel 6y agoA jet engine that needs forward motion to compress air is called a "ram jet" which is only used in a few applications even though it is so simple. Airplanes normally use either "turbo jets" or "turbo fans". These use the exhaust to spin a turbine at the back of the engine which in turn spins a compressor at the front (and also a larger "fan" in the case of a turbo fan). So the airplane can be completely stopped at the end of the runway and rev up the engine to full power to start the takeoff. A normal plane only needs its engines to have enough thrust that is a fraction of the craft's weight to overcome drag enough to keep it flying at cruise speed. So pointing it down would not lift the plane off the ground. But there have been designs with powerful enough jet engines: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryan_X-13_Vertijet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ryan_X-13_Vertijet An alternative is to rotate just the engine instead of the whole plane, and even more practical is to simply divert the exhaust of a horizontal engine downwards when needed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawker_Siddeley_Harrier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawker_Siddeley_Harrier
- blackrock 6y agoNice explanation for the layman. Thanks. The X-13 would make for an excellent VTOL drone. As would the Harrier. And I assume the F-35B would be a good candidate for one as well.
- jlcortex 6y agoHi all! thanks for sharing the news! At Quaternium we are very excited to see that our project is raising so much interest! There are already many accurate comments on this thread. But just to give you some context. Quaternium was the first company in the world to demonstrate a hybrid power system for a drone, with a flight over 3 hours back in 2015. Right now, our latest record is over 10 hours of hovering flight with HYBRiX multirotor (with an experimental setting with more fuel and no payload). A key element of this news is that the drone is <25 kg MTOW, (bigger aircrafts have obviously longer flight times). The fuel engine acts as a range-extender, it is a series hybrid, like the BMW i3. And we develop the power system, in collaboration with Löweheiser company (https://loweheiser.com/ https://loweheiser.com/) using a 2-stroke Zenoah engine that we adapt to the drone needs. Our product uses the engine on a very different duty-cycle, comparing to the standard application, so we do a lot of work on it and got a much better performance compared to other competitors. Multirotors are the most popular drones for several reasons, that some users have already mentioned. They are much more versatile because they can hover, do not need launching platforms and are quite easy to operate. They are also mechanically simpler than helicopters, reducing failure points. Our goal with HYBRiX is to being able to replace manned helicopters for aerial imaging operations, not to replace planes or fix-wings, which are more efficient for the applications that do not require hovering. As for convertible VTOLS / fix-wings, they are cool but not so versatile, because their hovering endurance is very limited, only useful for VTOL take-off / launch. That makes it possible to take-off from smaller areas than planes, but do not have a performance comparable to a multirotor. Hope this clarifies some doubts mentioned on the thread.
- varispeed 6y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the cartels were not funding research and development of such machines. I am not saying this particular one, but having an autonomous drone flying over long distance and capable of some more serious cargo seems like a dream come true (for example 100 mile radius should be enough to cross the border). If they could pair it with autonomous submarines then this opens the world of possibilities when it comes to moving the product across the world.
- skanga 6y agoAlso see the Pipistrel Nuuva V300 UAV https://www.pipistrel-aircraft.com/aircraft/nuuva-v300/ https://www.pipistrel-aircraft.com/aircraft/nuuva-v300/ The Nuuva V300 long-range, large-capacity, autonomous UAV can take off and land vertically with battery power, without requiring a runway, and can carry loads up to 300kg (around 660 lb) for more than 300km (around 186 miles)