7 ms·
Faster Growth, Fairer Growth: Policies for a High Road, High Performance Economy
- burlesona 6y agoFor others who were curious and not familiar: > The Niskanen Center is a Washington, D.C.-based think tank that advocates environmentalism, immigration reform, civil liberties, and strengthening social insurance around market-oriented principles.[3][4][5] The center is named after William A. Niskanen, an economic adviser to President Ronald Reagan. The Center states that its "main audience is Washington insiders,"[6] and characterizes itself as a moderate think tank.[7] Ref: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niskanen_Center https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niskanen_Center
- ponker 6y agoI wonder how the think tank people are dealing with the current administration. I’m sure at all levels below the top it functions normally and can ingest policy papers etc., but then the boss applies a random number generator to all outputs.
- abj 6y agoSome great, sane ideas on improving copyright law [1]. The amount of resources the current copyright laws waste is surprisingly high. "For software, the direct costs every year of defending infringement suits from so-called "nonpracticing entities" – better known as patent trolls – come to more than 10 percent of total annual R&D spending by all U.S. businesses." [1] https://www.niskanencenter.org/faster_fairer/liberating_the_captured_economy.html#Roll_Back_Intellectual_Property_Excesses https://www.niskanencenter.org/faster_fairer/liberating_the_...
- WalterBright 6y agoI've become more and more convinced that copyright laws do not promote progress of useful arts and sciences. The most obvious example is the incredible success of free and open software. Are people really going to stop writing books, composing music, painting pictures, etc, without copyright protection? Not a chance!
- WalterBright 6y agoConsider rock musicians. Suppose there were two concerts, one playing a Beatles song with the Beatles performing it (yes I know two of them are gone). Another venue is playing the same songs, just as well, but by a cover band. Which concert is going to make boatloads of money, and which will barely be able to pay the electric bill? Copyright has nothing to do with it.
- qppo 6y agoWhat if there were two albums, entitled "Beatles Greatest Hits" and "Best of the Beatles" and the former is a compilation album and the latter is a solo album by former Beatles drummer, Pete Best. If a fan buys the second without realizing it is not a compilation album, should the Beatles not be able to defend their name being used to sell it? Or profit off of it?
- jogjayr 6y ago> should the Beatles not be able to defend their name being used to sell it? Wouldn't trademark law apply there? And not copyright law?
- qppo 6y agoIn America yea, but the point is more about the notion of IP law in general I think
- jogjayr 6y agoI don't think it's possible to generalize about all IP law. There's a reason different categories of IP, with varying protections and terms, exist. It's possible for some IP law to be useful and some other to be useless or actively harmful.
- WalterBright 6y agoThink of it like open source software, and the answer will be clear. I.e. anyone can take the open source software I create and do whatever the hell they want with it. (I use the Boost license, which is the most permissive.) I encourage you to, too, if you want to profit from my work :-) I don't think there's anything special about musicians that makes them different from open source developers.
- mikelyons 6y agoIt would seem obvious to a layman that you must be "practicing" to be an "entity" that's allowed to "defend" against "infringement" This has an implicit metaphysics that remains un-examined.
- PeterisP 6y agoYour quote is about patent law, which has nothing to do with copyright law.
- WalterBright 6y ago> At the same time that the major factors expanding the economic pie were losing momentum, other powerful forces emerged that would push toward dividing the pie more unequally The framing of the issue influences what conclusions one draws. Here, the authors think of the economy as a "pie" created by "factors" that gets "divided up". What naturally follows is that if some get a bigger "slice" than others, it is inherently unfair. But a free market economy is not a pie. It's a collection of people that create wealth. Some create more wealth than others. Bob creating more wealth than Fred does not mean that Bob took it from Fred. There's nothing unfair about Bob creating more than Fred.
- justicezyx 6y agoIt's a mix. There is a pie that is growing slowly. And more rapidly, the exiting pie were reallocated. And the reallocation is more prominent because the growth is not as big as before.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bigcorp-slave 6y agoBob starts with 11 units of utility. Fred starts with 2. It costs 1 unit of utility to exist. Each of Bob and Fred invest their remaining utility in the utility market, which grows at 10% per year regardless of what either of them do. 25 years later, Bob has 109 units of utility, and Fred has roughly 12 units of utility. At the beginning of this thought experiment, Bob had 5.5x the utility units of Fred. At the end, he had more than 9x. This is a simple thought experiment that I hope illuminates something important: in an economy where there is year over year growth, inequality grows by default as a function of exposure to the market. Here, Bob starts with more and can be more exposed to the market. In this example, Bob started with 5.5x more assets - but in America today, the top 10% of households have a median net worth of $1.6m, and the 40th-60th percentile of households have a median net worth of $88k, a multiplier of 18x (note: this data is from 2016). Most Americans have little to no exposure to the market, while the richest 10% own 84% of stocks. There are many factors driving inequality, and I don’t think anyone would argue that some people are more economically productive than others. But it’s not the case that inequality in the United States is purely a function of hard work by talented people - there are very significant structural factors.
- Devils-Avocado 6y agoIf you give cash payments to poor families, you will simply get more poor children and encourage dysgenics. The solution is to encourage contraception and abortion for poor women, and remove all cash incentives for having children - replace them with just tax credits. Additionally to scale property tax payments based on the number of children in the property. Empty nesters should need to pay more tax than families to represent the needs of families for larger living space.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- NotStalin 6y agoWhy is communism being promoted on hn?
- NotStalin 6y agoThis is what the evil BLM _know_ but pretend not to know: You can double black wealth without affecting anyone else’s wealth - in fact it would be hard not to increase the wealth of all while doing it fuck marxism Black voices matter Black jobs matter Black wealth matters Black education matters Black excellence matters Black family matters Fuck marxism
- jackcosgrove 6y agoFrom what I read (there's a lot) it seemed balanced and reasonable. I did notice the well-worn calls for more entrepreneurship, along with calls to reform housing policy in places like Silicon Valley to unleash more growth. I think these two goals might be inimical. Technology companies seem to be growing into ever-larger conglomerates, gobbling up competitors from the old and new economies. What is the point of being an entrepreneur, of opening your own shoe store, if Zappos can beat you at that? The paper mentions how information technology has increased productivity among more educated workers moreso than it has done among middle-tier workers. Huge swathes of the traditional economy have been taken over by tech companies offering services at or below cost. No small-time entrepreneur can compete with that.
- Animats 6y agoNotes: On the one hand, the FDA’s foot-dragging on approving new (coronavirus) tests The first round of tests were not very accurate. Some that did get approved were withdrawn within months. As of 1940 only 6 percent of young Americans had college degrees, but by 1980 the figure had quadrupled to 24 percent. Put these together, and average years of educational attainment for American workers rose from 9.01 in 1940 to 12.46 in 1980 – for an average increase of 0.81 percent a year. Since then, however, the growth motor of rising educational attainment has stalled. Between 1980 and 2005, the rate of increase was only 0.33 percent a year, and since then average years of schooling have been more or less flat. About half the new graduates with college degrees end up in jobs that don't require them. College has hit the point of diminishing returns. The resources consumed by the financial sector have almost doubled. Good point. Finance is supposed to be a support function. It's assumed far too much importance in the US. For any agenda to improve conditions for inclusive economic growth, monetary policy is a logical starting point because its effects are so pervasive. Mess it up, and that failure alone will sabotage everything else you do right. Maybe. US policy people over-focus on monetary policy because it is one of the things governments can control. But it has little effect on what gets emphasized in the economy. The US has shied away from industrial policy. China and all the "Asian tigers" got to where they are through industrial policy, emphasizing specific sectors of the economy. Britain tried that, though, and ended up with "lemon socialism" - the government was operating all the losers - coal, railroads, etc. Nominal GDP... or, if real GDP doesn't go up, print money to force inflation. That needs more justification than they provide. Once-vibrant regions across the United States are grappling with deindustrialization, population decline, and shrinking tax bases. Meanwhile, prosperous cities have failed to properly absorb newcomers in search of opportunity, driving up rents and exacerbating urban inequality. These seemingly distinct issues may have quite different short-run policy implications, but what if they are two sides of the same phenomenon? Yet their solution involves higher density housing in the more popular cities.
- imtringued 6y ago>Maybe. US policy people over-focus on monetary policy because it is one of the things governments can control. But it has little effect on what gets emphasized in the economy. Where have you been in 2020? There was a massive government stimulus for equities. Even before that the way QE is set up it primarily benefits holders of stock, which is basically the opposite of what you want when your goal is to increase consumer inflation. Clearly the government is emphasizing wealthy parts of the economy over the average Joe and that's what's causing the economy to be so lopsided. >The US has shied away from industrial policy. China and all the "Asian tigers" got to where they are through industrial policy, emphasizing specific sectors of the economy. Britain tried that, though, and ended up with "lemon socialism" - the government was operating all the losers - coal, railroads, etc. Adding more supply in an already demand starved economy is just adding even more fuel to the fire.