3 ms·
> the pedestrian blaming at least strikes me as a bit tone deaf. Of course, pedestrians can do really stupid things. But, generally speaking, drivers have a lot
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> the pedestrian blaming at least strikes me as a bit tone deaf. Of course, pedestrians can do really stupid things. But, generally speaking, drivers have a lot of responsibility to still avoid hitting them under most circumstances
Can you explain exactly what you think a driver is supposed to do to stop a pedestrian literally just walking into your stationary car?
If you’re responsible for avoiding that, you tell me what you would have done?
- sidibe 6y agoBy making the car act more like people expect it to From the paper (which doesn't really pedestrian-blame as GP suggests) > In each instance, the Waymo vehicle had decelerated and stopped immediately prior to the contact or simulated contact in a way that may have differed from the cyclist’s or pedestrian’s expectations
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut > responsibility to still avoid hitting them They didn't hit them at all!
- Dylan16807 6y agoOkay? But that wasn't the question you asked. Part of the answer to your question is that cars should neither hit pedestrians nor do erratic things that set up a collision.
- michael1999 6y agoPeople also expect drivers to kill 20k per year. I don't think Waymo is likely to sign up to that goal whole-heartedly.
- alextheparrot 6y agoIf you’ve ever almost walked into one the failure case is really clear. They use stopping as a default mitigation strategy when something unpredictable happens - this isn’t always a good solution especially when suddenly blocking transit (Crosswalks, bike paths, railways, traffic) instead of just crossing it. This is a failure case humans can get cited for - I hit a car in the bike lane once when they did a left turn in front of me and it was legally the driver’s fault for blocking that path. It is just another characteristic they need to figure out in a complex problem.
- renewiltord 6y agoI can construct situations where this can happen. In fact, perhaps an easy analogy will help. Let's say you're at a T-junction at a stop sign. Traffic perpendicular to you is freely flowing. You drive out into traffic and stop. Someone in the uncontrolled perpendicular direction hits you. Who is at fault? They literally just ran into your stationary car. Clearly you can't be at fault. Or can you?
- pasttense01 6y agoThe "Last Clear Chance" doctrine is relevant: The “last clear chance” doctrine is a legal rule that says: 1. in personal injury cases, in which both the plaintiff and defendant were responsible for causing an injury/accident, 2. the plaintiff can still recover damages from the defendant, if the defendant had a chance to avoid injuring the plaintiff in the final moments before the accident." https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/blog/personal-injury/what-is-the-last-clear-chance-doctrine/ https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/blog/personal-injury/what-is-th...
- benhurmarcel 6y ago> you tell me what you would have done? Not stopping for no reason in the middle of the crosswalk would be a start.