6 ms·
Facebook Is a 'Super Spreader' of Election Misinformation
- unmdplyr 6y ago> When a Utah county accidentally sent out 13,000 absentee ballots without a signature line, the NewsGuard Red-rated site LawEnforcementToday.com called this a "cheat-by-mail scheme." This isn't a Facebook problem as such. It's just sensationalistic journalism. Just that Facebook as a platform helps amplfiy it. Just my 2 cents.
- arkitaip 6y agoThe algorithm is designed to propagate misinformation like crazy because that's what drives engagement and improves Facebook's metrics.
- im3w1l 6y agoCome on, you know it's not true that it's designed to propagate misinformation. The algorithm can't even tell whether it's misinformation or not.
- unmdplyr 6y agoI think it's possible. I know for certain there are techniques to identify "click-baity" text snippets. My partner is currently working on a data model now and she has already had some reasonable success. Imagine what a company that hires several 10s or even 100s of data scientists can achieve? From there on, it's just a matter of highlighting these successful matches constantly in your feeds. I wouldn't put it past that.
- rendall 6y agoInteresting idea. I see 2 potential problems. If the approach would be content-neutral - i.e. simply relying on the form of the information (eg misspellings in the title, many exclamation points, and such) to distinguish that which is more likely to be fake - then there could be a race condition where the misinformation purveyors learn and subvert the algorithm followed by the misinformation identifier incorporating the new forms of misinformation, and so on. In the meantime, true information purveyors would also need to be aware of this algorithm so as not to be falsely labeled. Think of the race in SEO for an example If the misinformation identifier uses the content of the information to label misinformation, then the identifier itself is as open to bias and opinion as anyone else
- daniellarusso 6y agoYou compared to SEO, but I was thinking about email spam filtering. Some of the best spammers have better practices than the legitimate companies sending email.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> it's not true that it's designed to propagate misinformation That was hyperbole on OP’s part. The algorithm is designed to incentivise the creation and dissemination of attention-grabbing content without considering truthfulness. That simply and directly incentivises misinformation propagation. The fact that politically-disinterested troll groups routinely get incentivised to produce misinformation for clicks is Exhibit A to how deeply Facebook promotes these mechanisms. Facebook and its employees turn a blind eye to these second-order effects because they are massively profitable. That’s as close to “designed to” as one can get without literally coding for it.
- wh1t3n01s3 6y agoThe algoritthm is driven by engagement, wich is driven by misinformation, because that’s what people click more. So then a lot of more misinformation is written to feed this need. Clearly a lot of money is involved
- russholmes 6y agoWhat Facebook's system does by design is to propagate and amplify simplistic, emotionally potent narratives. These tend to be fictional i.e. misinformation because reality is nuanced and boring. Further, this has been used by bad actors to seed social discontent and affect democratic elections. Facebook know exactly what is happening on their system and by whom.
- carschno 6y agoThe above statement only needs a minor correction: > The algorithm is designed to propagate misinformation like crazy because that's what drives engagement and improves Facebook's metrics. I would put it like this: The algorithm design causes the propagation of misinformation like crazy because it optimizes for engagement (which is Facebook's core metric).
- ElectronShak 6y agoMore accurately, algorithm simply responds to initial user engagement on the article. It is not designed to "propagate misinformation".
- ricardo81 6y agoIt's symptomatic of all platforms who rely on UGC at scale, and the business model goes on the assumption that it can't be moderated. I mean, it goes without saying how much copyrighted content sits on YouTube, Facebook et al. The fact the platform(s) generates revenue from this situation doesn't sit well with me. I'd agree it's not a problem exclusive to Facebook, but a handful of platforms.
- CommieDetector 6y agoYou are assuming that they did it by accident...
- mrkeen 6y agoYeah, it was just sensationalistic journalism, or "election misinformation". And Facebook just helped amplify or "spread" it.
- D0nMalte 6y agoThey could be more open to solutions like the optical highlighting that twitter has implemented, even if it just says "caution" it could be a big game changer
- eloisius 6y agoAnd Facebook has changed the landscape of journalism to favor drive-by clickbait journalism. Does the riverbed guide the river or did the river carve out the riverbed?
- op03 6y agoThe EPA has something called a Dose-Response Curve. Depending on what's being dumped in the river the polluter can be thrown in jail, the govt can be sued, the river can be closed off etc etc But what helps in determining damage is the curve. On all kinds of chemicals. Right now when Facebook allows ppl to swim in info sewage no one knows what the dose - response is. There is no EPA.
- eloisius 6y agoI like your analogy. Maybe it's because I'm older than last time I cared about something this much, but this time I really don't have a solution that's consistent with any ideology that I have. For most of my adult life, I've leaned towards libertarian. I don't see the free market solving this one very well. I'm also skeptical of a government-sponsored ministry of truth, though. I'm at a loss for how to "fix" the effects of social media without causing far more damage with censorship. The closest stop-gap sort of damage control I can think of is to do everything possible to remove any barriers in the way of enabling private citizens to sue for damages when social media companies publish harmful material.
- 542354234235 6y agoIt sometimes really scares me to think about. The power of algorithms combined with big data is showing itself to be scarily good at influencing behavior. It is basically exploiting quirks of our brains to get us to do certain things more (namely stay on a particular platform and engage with it). It is like those optical illusions that are made so that even if you are told what you are really seeing, you are incapable of getting your brain to “fix” the illusion. But what if almost everything around was an AI designed optical illusion that is constantly tweaked and improved until you are incapable of having an accurate visual understanding of the world around you. That is what our digital spaces are starting to feel like. But instead of just our visual centers, where we can just say “I know my eyes are playing trips on me”, it is a much deeper level of the brain, like our reward center, our values, our information processing. And in the big scheme of things, algorithms aren’t even all that good yet. They are only going to get better at manipulating us and making us want and need it. Like the study with the mice that would compulsively push a lever to deliver drugs until they starved to death. Using digital stimulus to illicit the addictive biochemical reaction in our brain instead of a drug’s more direct chemical delivery method. Or maybe I’m just paranoid.
- bbrree66 6y agoIt's all about incentives! They make money on ads, the more the better.
- smaryjerry 6y agoThis is the perfect description. Facebook amplifies your communication and I find that a perfect purpose for Facebook. No one should blame Facebook for what someone posts there for “allowing” it to be said. Facebook has had live streamed murders, that actually helps catch a killer. When Google bans a website doing illegal things, all it does it keep that website from being noticed but the activity continues. Maybe you think it limits the spread of something bad but no it just hides it. People who want to do bad things still do them. The only people who need to be protected from content are children, adults have the ability to critically think about a topic. Amplification of a message is only good. It is an argument about transparency.The phase the best disinfectant is sunlight is great because once it reaches a wide enough audience the people who can dispute the claim will appear rather than just an echo chamber.
- eloisius 6y agoI agree about sunlight being the best disinfectant, but I think social media like Facebook is a little more insidious than just "increased exposure." Facebook is designed for targeted messaging to people who are likely to engage with it. We've known about filter bubbles for at least a decade now. Amplifying disinformation specifically to an audience that is vulnerable to it is different than airing it on TV and increasing awareness. That's exactly what algorithmically curated content feeds like Facebook and YouTube recommendations do. They amplify messages to certain people who are susceptible, and there's little awareness until somebody shoots up a mosque and then suddenly we realize there's a whole subculture of people that have semi-willingly brainwashed themselves with conspiracies floating around about white people being "replaced" and think Shariah law is being implemented in Western countries. I don't think censorship of the content is the right answer. Short of calling for violence, people should obviously be free to propagate conspiracies, alternative history, whatever. The component that I am wary of is the algorithmic curation. It seems to tend towards "you like that? How about this slightly more extreme piece of related content?"
- smaryjerry 6y agoI disagree that people are vulnerable to it. I honestly can’t think of a single Facebook ad that has ever changed my mind in a topic. Adults are not vulnerable. The point is is so identify and catch the people who are posting conspiracies and getting radicalized before they do something. You can do that if you don’t see it. I doubt some random reader gets radicalized simply from reading things and never engaging in conversations. With those conversations you are now to identify people and actually prevent more radicalization. For example Facebook knows if you make a death threat, via their algorithms as well as flagging by users. Not only that but their algorithms can identify them in private messages sent, and report them to law enforcement. This may shock people but if these people don’t post on Facebook they then create heir own websites, post in chat rooms, recruit their friends. Then you are left with a completely uncontrolled website or app where these people get stuck in an echo chamber.
- bleepblorp 6y agoSee also [0], for some reporting on how Facebook delivers disinformation to the largest, most gullible voting bloc: the elderly. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24932881 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24932881 It's amazing how links I post to other HN subs always wind up with -1 karma; never positive, never zero, never -2. Always -1. I'm sure that's totally and completely organic.
- cryptica 6y agoFacebook needs to be nationalized and regulated as a public utility. It's outrageous that this hasn't already happened. How much more election meddling do they need to get away with before everyone understands that this is necessary? At this stage, all remaining Facebook investors are deeply immoral individuals. All the reasonable moral individuals have already cashed out. The government should just screw over the remaining shareholders. They deserve it.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Facebook needs to be nationalized and regulated as a public utility It is outrageous that the history and effects of arbitrary nationalisation is so uncommonly understood.
- cryptica 6y agoRailways and telecoms worked out just fine. Sure, in many countries, train tickets have been getting overly expensive under government control but high costs are not such a huge concern in the grand scheme of things. On the other hand, the break up of AT&T in the US had huge benefits for consumers in terms of lowering costs. If Facebook is nationalized, at least they will not manipulate people to serve corporate interests (that is the main threat). Sure, in the worst case, under government ownership, social media might be used to manipulate elections to give preference to the incumbent party over the other, but that is infinitely better than manipulating elections based on the financial interests of a tiny minority and allow it to drive an increase in surveillance and restrictions of public freedoms. Eventually, even the tiny minority of shareholders (the smaller ones) will end up being harmed at the expense of the bigger shareholders. It's not going to stop at non-shareholders.
- pjc50 6y ago> Sure, in the worst case, under government ownership, social media might be used to manipulate elections to give preference to the incumbent party over the other, but that is infinitely better than manipulating elections based on the financial interests of a tiny minority These are the same thing.
- sgdesign 6y agoOne thing I still don’t quite understand is how a system like this one can develop when the people developing it almost certainly are completely opposed to these ideas on a personal political level. I almost feel like it was an excess of idealism and belief in “the free market of ideas” -as well as the idea that Facebook should remain a neutral party at all cost- that led to overcompensating in the wrong direction, and the current situation.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> how a system like this one can develop when the people developing it almost certainly are completely opposed to these ideas on a personal political level Facebook pays well.
- scandox 6y agoMost people's political beliefs and ideas are simply something they wear, like a piece of clothing. If you asked them to change into different clothes for a specific purpose they will usually gladly do so without a moment's hesitation, if the purpose makes sense to them. The daily context of our lives and what we need to be getting on with is vastly more powerful than anything else.
- ahartmetz 6y agoBecause of the kind of content that drives engagement, optimizing for engagement is not being a neutral party. And censoring content costs money. So Facebook has at least two financial motives.
- beagle3 6y agoIt is hard for a person to understand something, when their salary depends on not understanding it. —-Upton Sinclair
- cheschire 6y agoSeems like you understand the situation perfectly, based on your second line.
- islon 6y ago
- harwoodleon 6y agoIt’s baked into the business model. Attention is the main material of the business, however it is gotten. It can’t change. Facebook couldn’t afford for it to change.
- throwaway7281 6y agoThat's the money line. Easy to understand, if you understand it.
- sveme 6y agoThat's actually always a good guidance: What's the business model/the aim of a company? Does it align with my own aims and wishes? It's the basic difference between Google/Facebook and Apple. Google/Facebook sells ads, Apple sells hardware. Google/Facebook need to know as much as possible about you to sell more ads. Apple does not. Obviously, these things can change.
- izacus 6y agoIf that's true, why did Apple ads start showing in iOS? There's now a promotion for Apples services in iOS 14 settings, we're getting notifications about Apple arcade things, the Apple Ads tracking setting is ON by default and split from 3rd party ad tracking settings... Not to mention their actions like political censorship (just from today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24939717 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24939717 ) Your narrative fits Apple marketing, but not their actions anymore.
- sveme 6y agoAs I said, things can change, company aims can change - and as you said, it's not clear cut anymore whether Apple is to be trusted.
- throw0101a 6y ago> If that's true, why did Apple ads start showing in iOS? Just because Apple does things besides sell hardware, doesn't mean those other things are their primary focus. "Services" make up 'only' 22% of their revenue: * https://sixcolors.com/post/2020/10/apple-q4-2020-results-record-mac-revenue-iphone-down/ https://sixcolors.com/post/2020/10/apple-q4-2020-results-rec... I'd hazard to guess that App stores, Music, Pay, and TV make up the majority of revenues—and not ads.
- Yuioup 6y agoFacebook should be taken offline a week before the election.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoSo... I shouldn't talk to family overseas during this time or find another way to do it? Or everyone not living in the US should not have facebook before an American election? It would seem to be more prudent to disallow political ads the week before. Or make it a crime to, say, spread wrong information about voting. And so on.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> I shouldn't talk to family overseas during this time or find another way to do it? A speed bump on posts (not messages or comments) isn’t a bad idea. One month before an election, there is a fifteen-minute cooldown on posts. One week before, a one-hour cooldown. One day before, three. This lets people keep talking. But it slows the reproduction rate and gives people a shot, even if a long shot, at fact checking.
- kapuasuite 6y agoThis sounds like a lot of ridiculous limits for very little, if any, positive impact.
- Sacho 6y agoIn my country, which is a tiny part of Europe, there is an election every month. There's over 100 countries with a larger population. Some of the largest countries are so large that they would undoubtedly have elections pretty much constantly. How are you going to decide which country's elections should be throttled by Facebook?
- beagle3 6y agoYou are facebook’s product. It’s ok to say “Facebook cannot sell any products for a few days” for some reasons. Lockdowns slowed covid. Facebook limits will Possibly slow riots. Ask for your money back if you are inconvenienced.
- Dansvidania 6y agoPeople spread misinformation on Facebook. Arguably, it's not Facebook's responsibility to fact-check anything. Facebook is not a publishing house (at least not the Facebook social media platform as such) and mandating that they fact check and curate their ads and content is tricky business. It requires a legal definition of truth, which is a matter complex enough to justify the existence of the whole judiciary system. Expecting that a condensation of such a system be applied to the publishing of information on any platform is wishful thinking at best. Edit: Corrected typos
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y ago> People spread misinformation on Facebook. That is misinformation. Most of it is pushed by Facebook's paying customers, not the users.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Facebook is not a publishing house Social media is a sufficiently different form of media that it will require its own form of regulation. Pointing to the publisher-editor delineation is anachronistic. Publishers never had the reach, insidiousness and information velocity that Facebook does.
- crispyporkbites 6y agoAds are different to the things people post on social media. Facebook can’t moderate and fact check ads? Why not? Because it would cost them too much of their 17billion dollar revenue? Boohoo
- albertTJames 6y agoMercer/Bannon/Trump and co. are super spreaders of misinformation. They happen to also use facebook, but I dont remember any issues of "fake news" in elections pre-2016/brexit. So no, its not inherent to the platform, only to the bad actors on it.
- jackric 6y agoIt was there pre 2016 it just didn't have this catchy term "fake news" yet. Ever heard of Gell-Mann Amnesia?
- albertTJames 6y agoDo you have any example ?
- jackric 6y agoBalloon boy
- zimpenfish 6y ago"Misinformation and the 2010 Election: A Study of the US Electorate" https://drum.lib.umd.edu/bitstream/handle/1903/11375/Misinformation_Dec10_rpt.pdf?sequence=4&isAllowed=y https://drum.lib.umd.edu/bitstream/handle/1903/11375/Misinfo...
- albertTJames 6y agoNo mention of social media, facebook or any other platform. If the argument is that there was political misinformation before 2016 then of course, it has existed for centuries. I am referring to the spread of misinformation through social media, at scale, which is the theme of the article. This was not seen at scale before cambridge analytica/brexit/trump/troll factories. Yet the platform existed for ~8years before it started.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoThe term wasn't there but the phenomenon was. Obama was probably the first candidate to win thanks to social media and facebook groups. Partisan Facebook groups post a lot and it's 50% your party's interpretation of reality, 45% outrageous claims, 5% pure fake news. I don't even think the fake news spreading is done maliciously, the groups are probably maintained by radicalised individuals who believe whatever news fit their narrative. Trump (who often retweets fake news and even retweeted a website similar to the onion, once) equally calls fake news on opposing publications. Still, I think fake news is a vastly overblown problem. Fake news is merely the scapegoat left wing media use to explain why Trump/Brexit won, even if it's represented so poorly in media. You can call it populism or far right extremism or Nazi, but outside of the rich tech community bubble, outside of universities, poor people want less government not more. The socialist message is lost on them, that's why Trump and Brexit won, despite the media coverage. If we look at similar cases, like Berlusconi in Italy 30 years ago, it's just a matter of time before Trump understands fixing the government is hard, if not impossible and get caught in some corruption case himself. The parasitical nature of the state just allow for the state to grow larger until it destroys its host. Spending in the USA is still at record highs.
- rendall 6y agoFrustrating. At the same time, I all too often see claims of "fake news" or "disinformation" that which is simply embarrassing or inconvenient for one party or the other. I'm not sure that there is a way to solve this problem that will not cause worse problems, like censorship of good but unpopular notions, or notions that are true but annoy the powerful
- cloverich 6y agoIts not fake news if its true but inconvenient, so there's a pretty firm line there. There are plenty of recent examples of legitimately fake and (intentionally) misleading content that has been propagated on Facebook, I assume anyone with any right wing friends has been inundated with it. But in addition to that, the simple protection against censoring true notions that annoy the powerful is transparency. Complete transparency with when and why and how things are blocked would be a start. Blocking clearly fake content, banning people who (repeatedly) post it, and being transparent about the reasons seems like a fair progress with a fairly clean line between it and proposed dystopian outcomes.
- rendall 6y ago"Its not fake news if its true but inconvenient, so there's a pretty firm line there." I agree that truth is a pretty firm line, but discerning that truth and agreeing on it is a very, very squishy line. Discerning what's true is arguably the most difficult task we can face, philosophically speaking No matter how many well-meaning people agree that some assertion A is false, if they are wrong and have the authority to suppress it, then they have committed the injustice of censorship. Even with the scientific method, which I believe is the best method ever invented for discerning truth, there have been many, many times that the scientific consensus has been, not only wrong, but egregiously, arrogantly wrong. Any time throughout history that authorities have been allowed to suppress what they believed to be false - and they often had excellent reasons for believing so - they invariably and inevitably suppress ideas that turn out to be true. Throwing AI at the problem is just adding another layer of misdirection. It's not going to be better this time in spite of all of the other times just because an AI decides it No, personally speaking, I think we will have a much, much healthier society if we can just learn to live with the fact that people believe stupid things and they will always believe stupid things even when you try to hide the stupid things from them. I know that I believe things that are both wrong and stupid, I just don't know which things. If everyone could acknowledge that they probably hold at least some wrong and stupid ideas, we would all be a little bit more humble about banishing other peoples' wrong and stupid ideas.
- justinzollars 6y ago"The people most responsible for destruction of the internet, as well those most blind about the destruction they’re wreaking are the journalists and activists who spent years begging Silicon Valley to regulate discourse." And the fruits of their labor? https://twitter.com/palinfoen/status/1321141294807322624 https://twitter.com/palinfoen/status/1321141294807322624
- nathias 6y agoI'm not sure why everyone seems to be so pleased with the idea that FB yields to the US partisan politics and starts curating ...
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThey are curating now, in favour of US partisan politics.
- engineer_22 6y agoNationalize Facebook.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- acje 6y ago'Super Spreader' hardly describes Facebooks reach. It's an entire (miss)information pandemic in its own right.
- NLMichel 6y agoAnd don't think it stops at the US border, this is a segment from the Dutch TV: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FLoR2Spftwg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FLoR2Spftwg Funny thing they just copy/paste the US conspiracies on Dutch politicians.
- loveJesus 6y agoHallelujah. Well, i see social media corporations are censoring in favor of their view of things. Because those in our society are divided, we can not be be a 'neutral arbiter' of truth in this world. For example, @LiveAction and other pro life accounts are not permitted to advertise on twitter, etc... If anything we can have the ability to turn off specific advertisements. I thought it would be nice to have a list of curators, who could digitally sign page content. Then have like a GPG trust chain where people can say the people they value curating. We can choose anyone who we align with their values, and we can view and search the web with information that is weighed according to our local web of trust. It could also be used to help young children as well to have some kind of firewall against bad information. And for adults I would rather be exposed to all ideas of the spectrum, which gives me the ability to fact check things for myself. I have had this idea for some time now. The idea is we get to choose our own analyzers and work together to establish the truthfulness of the web. And if i can help someone with it thanks be to God in Jesus name
- russellbeattie 6y agoThey made $22 billion in revenue this past quarter helping destroy the country. Every Facebook employee is laughing their asses off at you personally right now. "LOL! Look, HN is complaining about Facebook again! Hysterical!" They're emailing the link above with laughing emojis and dollar signs, while they customize their new Tesla order in another window. The fact is, they will all lose money if Trump isn't reelected. Every single FB employee knows this, and does their part to keep the rage machine working. No conspiracy theory needed here, it's all part of the job. If this wasn't the case, we would have a simple setting on the home feed to exclude shared links and news. One click and no more Fox News hatred from your crazy uncle. But we don't have that option. Why? All I want from Facebook is to see updates of distant relatives on vacation, or graduation photos, etc. But they don't make money if there's no anger, so oh well.
- 542354234235 6y ago> The fact is, they will all lose money if Trump isn't reelected. Every single FB employee knows this, and does their part to keep the rage machine working. I don’t understand what you mean here. Why does Trump need to be reelected? There is always outrage to be generated for clicks. There was no shortage of outrage during Obama’s term. Even things that were objective non issues, like the tan suit, was whipped into a viral attention storm. “Obama's tan suit shocks social media”. It seems like social media is just designed to promote outrage, since outrage produces virality, but not that it needs Trump specifically. Is there something I’m not getting relating specifically to Trump and Facebook?
- cloverich 6y ago> Why does Trump need to be reelected? The same reason Howard Stern was allegedly so popular. People who hate him listened even longer than people who liked him.
- LatteLazy 6y agoPeople spread this stuff. Organised funded groups from Fox news down to your local corporate or office push it. Facebook is just where they do it. At worst, Facebook encourages people stay on Facebook, but it doesn't care whether they're sharing trump memes or kittens. This is like blaming parks because people deal drugs in parks sometimes.
- grep_name 6y agoI don't doubt that facebook's algorithm results in disinformation through their quest for engagement, but does anyone know a good resource that talks about the specifics of what ideas are most spread in this way with some numbers? My issue is that I read about this often (and care about these issues), but I have not used facebook since 2010 and so I have no experience with what everyone's talking about. I feel like in order to understand I need some data to work with that is more specific than 'flagged false', because facebook is just not part of my experience right now and I don't know what people are actually saying on the platform
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIf we are going to fix this, we need real suggestions instead of just complaining about it. For example Policy proposal: Maximize the amount of people that can see a given post / news article. People would have to resubmit in substantially their own words any information they glean that should be passed on beyond that limit. E.g. someone posts a news article that reaches 10,000 people. The 10,001st gets an error saying it has already reached maximum views. One of the initial 10,000 couldn’t just copy paste what they saw, but would have to generate unique content to reinitiate an information node that would also have a 10,000 view maximum. This would not be great for national news sites, but it would reinvigorate local news, because that would be the only way for the information to spread. Decentralization is key.
- basicexploit 6y agoNot only Facebook is a super spreader of internet but the whole internet. There are so much misinformation going on that people dont even take the time to check is that true or not.
- RickJWagner 6y agoEverything is a Super Spreader of Election Misinformation. I remember when Trump won in 2016, CNN immediately turned it's theme black and ran gloomy headlines that continue until this very day. Likewise, other news sources went into spin mode, seemingly faster than they did pre-Trump. Actors and athletes became media stars not for their area of expertise but for their political opinions (which should be worth exactly the same as the bartender's but the bartender doesn't make the news for some reason.) I agree that Facebook is a huge platform for politics. The difference is that you can post your own views and you can indicate if you like or dislike someone else's opinions. I think it's actually progress.