9 ms·
> Can lab-grown brains become conscious? This is about as horrific a future as I can imagine. Humanity's worst possible achievement would be the ability to sus
by WarOnPrivacy 6y ago
> Can lab-grown brains become conscious?
This is about as horrific a future as I can imagine. Humanity's worst possible achievement would be the ability to sustain and manipulate a brain, outside of a body.
- warent 6y agoYes, it is very "I have no mouth and I must scream"-esque. Personally, I'm not really convinced that electrical activity in the brain means there's a subjective consciousness there. Yet the fact that we don't know (perhaps can never know) is enough to say that continuing with such experience is amoral and moving into the ugliest, worst side of science.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoI've front-loaded my horror fantasy with tech that can communicate with the helpless brain. I never read that particular Ellison piece. I figure this is one of those universal "What's the worst thing I can think of" tropes.
- NoOneNew 6y agoDo a quick search on Youtube, there's a recording of I Have No Mouth read by Ellison. It's ~40min long. It's so damn good but will also put you in a nihilistic funk for a while.
- NoOneNew 6y agoThere's a part of me that believes in this age of humanity, deep down we still question whether or not God/gods is/are real. Thus, we're trying to commit the most insane and outrageous atrocities to humanity, science and the natural world, just so he shows up and yells, "WTF is wrong with you people?!?!". It's like trying to get attention from your parents. If doing the right thing doesn't work, burn the house down.
- drdeadringer 6y agoI understand your point. I have two others: 1) Atheists do exist. 2) There have been insane and outrageous atrocities to humanity, science, and the natural world -- this might just be the next chapter in that saga. Either that saga continues until Humanity doesn't, God comes knocking, or a "Star Trek Federation" type scenario comes around.
- NoOneNew 6y ago>1) Atheists do exist. Duh? I'm super confused if my tongue-in-cheek comment went over your head or not. I do mention setting a house on fire to get someone's attention. I figured that's more than enough info to declare not to take the entire comment seriously.
- nkrisc 6y agoI think it was the part about "deep down" questioning whether gods are real. Many people are happy to question it, nothing deep down about it. I assume that was what they meant by atheists do exist. They way you wrote it made it sounds as if you were saying that everyone at the surface believes gods are real, but only deep down do they perhaps, maybe question it. It sounds as if you were taking it for granted that everyone obviously believes gods are real, which is of course not true, whether you meant that or not.
- NoOneNew 6y agoWow... I mean... I get you're trying to understand where the misunderstanding is. But, this smells like people not understanding the difference between figurative and literal. Like right there, do I actually think this gives off a smell of some sort, no and the fact I now have to clarify that means I literally believe humanity is already fucking doomed. This is just one large example of, "Chill out, it was a joke."
- pessimizer 6y agoGods aren't real. The point of the very witty comment is that people are subconsciously still always arguing about them: "If God is real, would he let me do this!?" Or, "If God is real, surely this will flush him out."
- bad_alloc 6y agoWell, or a great one if we could get a brain out of a messed up body into a functioning one. Probably both?
- freeflight 6y agoAll a matter of implementation: Trying to "upload our consciousness" into computers is just a slightly less macabre version of the very same brain in a vat idea.
- droobles 6y agoThis also reminds me of the Matrix except no one would be able to wake up from the dream. Could be fine if the Matrix was a comfy place to live I suppose. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Think San Junipero vs the before mentioned I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream, if the dream was fun and felt like real life your lab grown brain wouldn't really know the difference, it would just have a different perspective.
- api 6y agoTotalitarian regimes could punish dissidents and make an example of them by literally placing them in hell and televising this to the populace. Plenty of psychopaths evil enough to do this.
- chillacy 6y agoThere’s a Culture book about this: Matter by Ian Banks
- tgflynn 6y agoI think that would depend on what inputs that brain received and perhaps whether its outputs were able to affect its environment. What if that brain were interfaced to a mechanical robot that could not be affected by disease and would be essentially immortal ? We often forget how horrible having a biological body actually is, never having experienced any other form of existence.
- ALittleLight 6y agoI think a worse achievement would be a virtual reality hell where we could lock sentient minds to suffer for an eternity. Being a conscious lab brain might accidentally be bad. Being in hell would be intentional maximal harm.
- samus 6y agoDan Simmons' "The Fall of Hyperion" describes a setting where brains of suspects of high crimes are put into a jar for interrogation. The death sentence in that setting was abolished, but the alternatives were not exactly pretty. One of them was be disposal of the body and placement of the brain in storage indefinitely, while cutting off any means of communication.
- smegger001 6y agoDepends on what we do with the brains no? If we could attach said brains to adequate inputs I see no reason for it to be hellish or horrific.
- m463 6y agoShould there be outputs? (wow, lots of questions there)
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoThe scenario is being a brain in the hands of someone in power, who doesn't like you.