19 ms·
Can lab-grown brains become conscious?
- VLM 6y agoIt'll be interesting to see the mental gymnastics required to protect small clusters of mouse brain cells at all costs, yet permit as many late term human abortions as possible.
- MPSimmons 6y agoWho wants to encourage late-term abortions?
- curtainsforus 6y agoPeople who want to empower women
- purplecats 6y agothat's probably their public reasoning but unlikely to be the real reasoning. I claim I work at mcdonalds because I want to help feed the world. I work at mcdonalds because I'm poor and need to pay rent.
- VLM 6y agoThats not an edit, I wrote permit not encourage
- ceejayoz 6y ago"as many late term human abortions as possible" implies encouragement beyond simple permission.
- rootusrootus 6y agoWe do some fairly awful things to animals already, why would we suddenly get nervous about brain cells in a petri dish? Just because their DNA is human?
- MPSimmons 6y ago> To achieve this goal, Muotri says, he and others might need to deliberately create consciousness That is a very big yikes. The ethical implications of this are awful.
- yboris 6y agoI can't tell which side you're arguing for: more awful things to be done to sentient creatures, or pointing out that we should stop doing awful things to sentient creatures.
- tokai 6y agoIt might seem weird here in 2020, but you can chime in on something without arguing for any position.
- Nbox9 6y agoHave you ever worked with lab mice? It leaves you with this exact juxtaposition of seeing the fantastic progress being made with mouse models and seeing the very real suffering on such a large scale. The fact that many experiments are okay on non-human animals but not humans is speciesist. Still, it’s the line we are all most comfortable with. I’d rather not have people be experimented on. I’d rather continue to have the advances in science built on the lives of untold number of lab animals. However, the line is arbitrary.
- yboris 6y agoThank you for sharing! Peter Singer, one of the most famous philosophers (and perhaps "the grandfather" of animal rights / animal welfare movement) argues that perhaps, unless we were willing to perform an experiment on humans, we ought not perform the experiment on animals. There are so many experiments which treat animals in awful ways for virtually no progress towards the goal of improving human lives. We were far worse in the past (see Draize test) and have gotten better at not performing really horrible experiments on animals. But it's precisely because animal lives are seen as less important that we are willing to perform experiments with almost no benefit for humanity. At the moment, the largest tragedy is meat consumption - we can focus on improving lab animals' lives too, but the meat consumption is orders of magnitude worse with respect to causing suffering to sentient creatures.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> Can lab-grown brains become conscious? This is about as horrific a future as I can imagine. Humanity's worst possible achievement would be the ability to sustain and manipulate a brain, outside of a body.
- warent 6y agoYes, it is very "I have no mouth and I must scream"-esque. Personally, I'm not really convinced that electrical activity in the brain means there's a subjective consciousness there. Yet the fact that we don't know (perhaps can never know) is enough to say that continuing with such experience is amoral and moving into the ugliest, worst side of science.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoI've front-loaded my horror fantasy with tech that can communicate with the helpless brain. I never read that particular Ellison piece. I figure this is one of those universal "What's the worst thing I can think of" tropes.
- NoOneNew 6y agoDo a quick search on Youtube, there's a recording of I Have No Mouth read by Ellison. It's ~40min long. It's so damn good but will also put you in a nihilistic funk for a while.
- NoOneNew 6y agoThere's a part of me that believes in this age of humanity, deep down we still question whether or not God/gods is/are real. Thus, we're trying to commit the most insane and outrageous atrocities to humanity, science and the natural world, just so he shows up and yells, "WTF is wrong with you people?!?!". It's like trying to get attention from your parents. If doing the right thing doesn't work, burn the house down.
- drdeadringer 6y ago
- Loughla 6y agoI find this interesting: >The goal of his project, which is partially funded by Microsoft, is to create an artificial system that works like human consciousness. So we have bioethicists working on whether or not these brain cells in a petri dish count as conscious. And apparently a lively and varied debate on the subject. Is there anything comparable for computer based consciousness? Why do we believe that bio-matter has more rights than synthetic, in terms of consciousness? Is it simply the bio that matters?
- alextheparrot 6y agoI know this is slightly orthogonal to the more academic study of ethics you might be looking for, but I think a lot of good thought is happening in the Sci-Fi realm. Ted Chiang’s “The Lifecycle of Software Objects” comes to mind, or Asimov writing the “Three Laws of Robotics”.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kasmura 6y agoIntegrated information theory which is mentioned in the article is abstract and supposedly applies to any type of physical system.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoYou may enjoy this conversation between MIT Prof. Lex Fridman and famed philosopher Peter Singer on this topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=llh-2pqSGrs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=llh-2pqSGrs Lex help’s Singer realize that where you put the ‘this is deemed important consciousness’ mark is arbitrary. Some people will fight for the rights of animals, in the future that may extend to Roomba’s with higher levels of intelligence than many animals.
- harveywi 6y agoThe more important question is when can we start eating them as a food source
- autarch 6y agoAs soon at the monkey breaks out of that biolab and infects us.
- nooyurrsdey 6y agoThis sounds like it has horrific potential. It really gives me the creeps.
- inscionent 6y agoCan lab-grown brains get the creeps?
- nomdep 6y agoCan lab-grown brains be tricked into believe they grow brains in a lab and ask themselves this question?
- rcurry 6y agoShh, you're going to ruin everything.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoFinally some humor on HN! No doubt some Vulcan-wannabe will downvote you. Here’s hoping my upvote cancels that.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoYes, they can – you can make a lab environment within the normal range for human fetal development, therefore causing the brains to develop consciousness in the same way, for the same reasons. Therefore, there exists at least one scenario in which this can occur. There's not much difference between the way that brain tissue develops in fetal development and in current lab environments.
- freeflight 6y ago> There's not much difference between the way that brain tissue develops in fetal development and in current lab environments. But wouldn't the sensory input be completely missing? A fetus at least has some of these inputs as the sensory organs are developing, which is part of getting sentience. A brain in a vat has no equivalent so it would lack a lot of additional input that usually goes into forming a human consciousness/sentience.
- sl1ck731 6y agoI don't know how much we know about the brain but I think inputs could be electrically simulated. Regardless, I'm not so sure "consciousness" depends on inputs as much. The assumption is its consciousness would be similar to our own but an organism that was created in a lab might feel entirely different such that we can't really compare what it would be like to just take our brain and put it in a jar. I believe there is some phenomena related to the way people born blind visualize or think about things, but I only vaguely remember reading about such things.
- wizzwizz4 6y ago> A fetus at least has some of these inputs as the sensory organs are developing, Deaf-blind individuals still exhibit consciousness. There are people who can't smell, or feel touch, or temperature, or pain. How many senses do you have to remove before consciousness goes away? If consciousness can exist with the absence of senses (e.g. if you were cut off from your senses for five minutes), then who's to say it can't develop without them? We don't know that consciousness requires sensory input; is it safe to assume that?
- jungletime 6y agoUse the Elon Musk's neuralink electrodes to hook up the brain to a computer. Then make an experiment to see if the brain can measure something, by reacting to stimuli. If it can, then its an observer in the quantum mechanics sense, and therefore has consciousness...?
- kuroguro 6y agoHaha. Can't tell if it's supposed to be sarcasm or not, but AFAIK it's the process of measurement that causes the collapse, not a consciousness.
- xivzgrev 6y agoNever did I thought I'd be reading an article on people growing brains specifically. If these scientists let it keep growing, would it develop into a full brain? I thought if anything we'd be growing full organs like hearts and kidneys to help the crushing lack-of-donors problem.
- booleandilemma 6y agoCould it be conscious without any sensory data? I’d argue it couldn’t be.
- nchelluri 6y agoThis is the most interesting article I've read in recent memory. Thank you for posting it. > At the moment, there are no regulations in the United States or in Europe that would stop a researcher from creating consciousness. Wow. I don't know what to think.
- ls612 6y agoMany of those researchers have kids too and so spent many nights in bed trying to ‘create consciousness’ ;) Somehow I don’t think federal regulations were on their minds when they were doing this.
- nullifidian 6y agoWhy not? Just make sure that structures that are responsible for various forms of suffering are absent in the blueprint.
- nchelluri 6y agoWell, if it is as simple as you say, I agree. But I bet that "the structures that are responsible for suffering" is not clearly defined. And who is to say that these structures are not the very ones we need to be researching to find treatments for various mental illnesses?
- Veedrac 6y agoIf you had a friend that wasn't able to suffer through some quirk of atypical DNA, would that person still have rights? Would it be unethical to enslave them? (Hint: yes)
- ALittleLight 6y agoThere are such people (depending on your definition of suffering) who cannot experience pain. The condition is called congenital analgesia and, to my knowledge, they retain their rights.
- think814 6y agoThe problem is, we don't have a definition nor a test for consciousness. So these discussions usually go in circles. i am aware of three definitions of consciousness, used often without clarity: a/ consciousness = intelligence. By this definition, a lot of AI has some level of consciousness b/ conciouness = being awake and alert. A lot of studies for instance that compare MRI of alert vs unconscious humans focus on this aspect. c/ consciousness the way we humans experience the sense of self awareness ("watching a movie from inside", etc). This must be more than an illusion because for instance right now I am writing about it so that "sense" is affecting my actions. But how do you even define or test for it? It's likely you have a lot of (a) without (c), and you could have a lot of (c) with little (a). We can test for (a) but not for (c), so for now it's all philosophical speculation. Until we can define and test for (c), I don't see much progress being made here.
- fjfaase 6y ago> This must be more than an illusion because for instance right now I am writing about it so that "sense" is affecting my actions. No, it could be that (c) is an illusion of the fact that you are doing the writing, which I guess is the result of enough (a). There is some scientific evidence that (c) is 'constructed' afterwards by (a) and (b). For example (c) looks to lag about half a second behind the actual sensed reality.
- diegoperini 6y ago> For example (c) looks to lag about half a second behind the actual sensed reality I think you meant (b) lags behind, not (c). I might be wrong.
- ordu 6y agoThe most funny problem with defining consciousness is the ability of definition to mark people as conscious and everything else as non-conscious. It is bad to kill human and it is acceptable to kill animal -- why? Because of consciousness of human, isn't it? So if animals are conscious then they should have "human" rights, including access to education and medicine. Moreover, there are groups who would fight any definition which treat new-born humans as non-conscious (because from their point of view the most important property of such a definition is it is the first step to legalizing child killings). But there are theories that point to an idea of consciousness as of something acquired by humans in their individual development. It means that in some special cases child could develop into a non-conscious adult. Does it mean that it is ok to slaughter such an adult and to eat his meat? Does it mean that abortion is a morally neutral thing? At some point psychology was forced to stop using word "soul", because results of a research of a soul led to troubles for different religions, for example, if a soul is a function of a mortal brain, so a soul cannot be immortal, isn't it? Psychology mechanically replaced 'soul' with 'mind' and continued. I believe we came to a point, when psychology would need to find a new term for "consciousness", so psychologist's findings didn't lead to disastrous conclusions in a social plane. From the other hand, biology managed to research life all this time without changing terms, despite of the fact, that biology pinned life to a matter, and therefore there could be no life after death.
- jitendrac 6y agoI highly suspect it is. I think even smallest part of our brain cells have their own consciousness otherwise our brain would not be so much plastic to adaptability. Its just the point when we will prove it scientifically and decide what is the limit of our actions.
- carapace 6y agoI've heard of at least two people that want to make Daleks out of human brain organoids. (They don't call them "Daleks" of course, but that's what I hear: robots with little human brains in them kept alive by science and controlled by...? "EXTERMINATE!")
- mettamage 6y agoCurious question: do we know if completely neglected humans pass the mirror test? Because if not, then I wonder to what extent a human brain can become conscious on its own without any help from fellow humans and/or animals. There are children that have been neglected, but still had some capabilities of learning language because they weren't completely neglected. I wonder to what extent humans pass the mirror test if all they got was food, shelter, a place to move around a bit and nothing else. I'm sorry to ask this question though. While I think it's scientifically interesting, it also implies the fate of several people that have suffered it.
- Jeff_Brown 6y agoThis seems critical. It would be unethical by almost anybody's standards to do the human experiment, but the equivalent animal experiment may have been done, and seems like it would be informative. I don't expect a brain without input and output functions to be capable of consciousness. Consciousness and the sense of self are a kind of understanding. Without experimentation, understanding seems impossible.
- mettamage 6y agoI wasn't proposing an experiment, I was implying that this sometimes might happen in certain places in the world, very rarely though.
- 7thaccount 6y agoReminds me of Ursula Leguin's "the ones who walk away from Omelas" which is pretty horrifying in its own way.
- Balgair 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ones_Who_Walk_Away_from_Omelas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ones_Who_Walk_Away_from_Om... For the curious like I was. I'm sure it's an inspiration for The Giver, which has a similar ending.
- 6y ago
- Jaruzel 6y agoI have a preposition on this. If you take an existing human brain, and keep it alive in a jar (or whatever), it would probably suffer immense mental stress and almost certainly break down or die. Clearly not ethical. However, if you grow a brain in a jar, would it suffer? It doesn't know any different, and as a baby accepts it's reality as it grows up, so would the brain. I posit here that it wouldn't suffer, as living in a jar would seem normal to it. Personally, I'm not sure I'm against growing brains just because they may suffer. I do know I'm against growing brains because it will undoubtably lead to a robot/cyborg uprising that will doom all of humanity.
- das_keyboard 6y agoI just went down the rabbit hole reading the "related articles"[0][1] to this one. This stuff is completely amazing and a little bit scary: "Neuroscientists have transplanted human glial cells into mice, for instance, and found that the animals perform better in certain tasks involving learning." We already are at a point where we can grow other human organs inside animals (like human hearts inside pigs). What if we could grow a human brain inside an animal? Would it have human rights? What if we could grow a human brain out of braincells that were taken from an existing human brain (ex vivo)? Would it have some memories? This is wild... [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-04813-x https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-04813-x [1] https://www.nature.com/news/the-boom-in-mini-stomachs-brains-breasts-kidneys-and-more-1.18064 https://www.nature.com/news/the-boom-in-mini-stomachs-brains... edit: formatting
- smrtinsert 6y agoLots of important questions like this came up for me when I was studying biology in college. We should treat it like we do with undiscovered planet, tread as lightly as possible gathering as much information as we can. The thought of a some sort of human consciousness evolving unintentionally is truly gruesome horror for me.
- tgflynn 6y agoI'm wondering how scientists are able to keep these miniature brains alive when we still lack effective artificial replacements for many human organ functions that are essential for life. How far are we from being able to transplant a human central nervous system into a more robust support infrastructure than the one with which evolution has provided us ?
- ada1981 6y agoThese debates in the context of a people who still routinely get their food from factory farms and other animals is fascinating to behold.
- ryandvm 6y agoIsn't this basically what dreams are? You have self-awareness and you experience what it's like to be "you", but your brain is essentially free-wheeling its own reality because it's disconnected from all stimuli. If so, black-box consciousness seems like a harmless, if not completely pointless, curiosity.
- rolph 6y agoi cant define it but i will know it when i am.