5 ms·
This is only one of 11 vaccines now in phase III efficacy tests.[1] Six vaccines already have "partial approval", but those are the ones in Russia and China, wh
by Animats 6y ago
This is only one of 11 vaccines now in phase III efficacy tests.[1] Six vaccines already have "partial approval", but those are the ones in Russia and China, which may or may not be working, and the governments decided to try anyway. All of those provoke an immune response. Whether it's enough of the right immune response is found out in phase III testing.
Something is probably going to work. The big question is how well. A 50% effective vaccine might be an overall lose - only half are protected but more than that abandon masks and social distancing.
The Johnson and Johnson vaccine, if it works, is the easiest to use of the early leaders. One dose, and it doesn't need to be refrigerated to dry-ice temperatures like some of the others. The Merck/IAVI vaccine is only in phase I, but it's a pill. If that works and is highly effective, it will be possible to wipe the virus out worldwide in a second round of immunizations.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/science/coronavirus-vaccine-tracker.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/science/coronavirus... (or https://archive.is/D6C68 https://archive.is/D6C68)
- Viliam1234 6y ago> A 50% effective vaccine might be an overall lose - only half are protected but more than that abandon masks and social distancing. I remember a similar argument being used against face masks. (That they are not perfect, and may cause harm by giving false sense of security.) Perhaps we should be more careful about perfect being the enemy of good.
- bastawhiz 6y agoThe availability of masks is far higher than vaccines, though. You can order a box of masks on the internet and have them same-day delivered to your home. The scarcity and logistics of delivering a vaccine once it becomes available are both factors that make the effectiveness that much more important.
- dan_quixote 6y agoAnd the use of both vaccine and masks may also be sufficient to lower the average covid vector just enough to tamp it down.
- neuronic 6y agoNot happening, recent polls suggest that in Germany, 55% percent of the population is willing to get the vaccine. That isn't enough for herd immunity (at around 60%) and real vaccination rate will be even lower. There is also no chance in hell that Germans will allow a government-mandated vaccine. It's unconstitutional and there is heavy opposition to government-mandated anything throughout all of society. So we will be stuck with this virus. But you're free to get the vaccine yourself for your own protection.
- jacquesm 6y agoThat problem will solve itself then.
- LeCow 6y agoYou could make that argument without needing a vaccine.
- fastball 6y agoYes, everything is the same without context.
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoNo, that would be a different argument. If a vaccine does not exist, no one has the choice to get it, which is a very different situation.
- harry8 6y ago>That problem will solve itself then. At a considerable cost. There's a large number of people for whom the vaccine won't work when it has been taken correctly or who cannot take the vaccine because it will react very badly with their chemotherapy or whatever. This "let Darwin deal with the anti-vaxers" solution, though initially attractive, ends up being sociopathic when you dig into it.
- fastball 6y ago
- nradov 6y agoMasks and social distancing are not sustainable forever. A lot of people are going to abandon them regardless of whether a vaccine is available, so any safe vaccine would be a win even if effectiveness is low. Seasonal influenza vaccines are sometimes as little as 20% effective when the circulating strains don't match predictions, but even 20% is a lot better than nothing.