12 ms·
The Most Surveilled Cities in the World
- mpclark 6y agoThey will have missed Monaco, as they only looked at the 150 most populated cities. When I was there around the millennium it was the clear leader in police officers per head of population, so I expect it’s also doing well on cameras.
- eunos 6y agoMaybe that's because Monaco is touristy place.
- smnrchrds 6y agoWhich raises the question: should one look at cameras per 1000 resident population or cameras per 1000 people present, whether resident or tourist?
- eunos 6y agoFor most places, the number of tourists won't affect much the equation. Only in a few famous microstates, for example, Monaco and the Vatican that this skew could happen. That reminds me that I read once that Vatican's crime per capita looks very horrendous if it is based on crime/resident, but most crimes occurred are petty like pickpockets targetting tourists.
- vkou 6y agoThe reason they missed it, is because their data is complete rubbish. This is the source for their chart. [1] It claims that NYC has a mere 31,490 cameras. As anyone who's ever been in NYC will tell you, that is complete and utter nonsense. [1] https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I-WpH2KOiguKy9JTQ9zC2JxBBhH2scdbSRI8lJVjzdo/edit#gid=979494433 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I-WpH2KOiguKy9JTQ9zC...
- keiferski 6y agoI've been wondering if the combination of remote work and self-driving cars will counteract the increasing surveillance of urban centers. Does suburbanization/sprawl make surveillance too expensive to be practical?
- Ericson2314 6y agoYou'd wish, but I think there will definitely be home office surveillance in the employee contract if the economic situation of recent years continues. Suburbanization also makes satellite surveillance easier and "acustic" face to face interaction much more difficult.
- BigBubbleButt 6y agoThe self-driving cars can act as super surveillance systems by themselves though.
- x87678r 6y agoI never thought about that. If the police could quickly connect to any parked/moving car and see what its cameras saw that would be like eyes just about everywhere.
- bigiain 6y agoBRB: Going to look for that line item in Tesla's public financials... (Come on, it's not like Musk wouldn't have talked this over with Thiel, right???)
- jacques_chester 6y agoIt's worse. Every frame captured is stored somewhere. Five years from now they can track your movements by picking out the sequence from cars that drove past you.
- newbie578 6y agoIs anyone truly surprised? The future looks bleak with China set to become the global leader (it is just a matter of time at this point, especially thanks to COVID). I only hope for India to also become a major powerhouse to curb China, and for Korea and Japan to regain their footing.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoEven if the government weren't incentivized to surveil everywhere, it's a no brainer for people to install cameras around their businesses/homes/cars for liability purposes since they are so cheap now. A couple hundred dollars can reduce a lot of headache, and I don't see that incentive going away anytime. I assume every car will have a dash cam, a house will have a doorbell cam or similar, and every business is monitored everywhere. And cities/states will have license plate readers on police cars/roads.
- bigiain 6y agoI am a little surprised and quite saddened that Sydney ranks 8th out of non Chinese cities. All of a sudden I'm _way_ more predisposed to wearing a mask in public 100% of the time. And a hat. and sunglasses - even at night... :sigh:
- cmdshiftf4 6y ago>The future looks bleak with China set to become the global leader We get what we deserve. At least two generations have stood by and allowed the West and its influence on the world stage to be degraded and eroded without so much as batting an eyelid. When one steps back and looks at what they've facilitated, one starts to see some reality in the "strong men create good times, good times create weak men, weak men create bad times, bad times create strong men" cycle often touted.
- Barrin92 6y agoI guess the point of the post in particular is the London outlier but honestly I've always found comparisons of CCTV with 'surveillance' in a meaningful sense of the term pretty cartoonish. Obviously living in London is not like living in some police state. The same goes for China even. Public camera surveillance I think mostly does what it's supposed to do with very little intrusion into people's daily lives, in contrast to old school police stops and frisks. Travelling I've had more bad run ins with corrupt cops in Bulgaria than I had in Beijing.
- donaltroddyn 6y ago.
- baby 6y agoNot saying that surveillance is right, but I've lived in London for a year and a half and never felt this way, I don't think I've ever talked to someone who felt this way there, you must be a very paranoid individual. I will say this though: having lived in both Beijing and London, I've always felt ultra safe (and I lived in London during some terrorist attacks). On the other hand, I lived in SF for the same time and I never felt safe there, avoiding walks at night, avoiding public transport for the most part, avoiding some streets, etc. I also lived in Chicago and I felt much worse there (at least in SF I could still take walks).
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoNot to discount your feelings completely, but I’m always a little skeptical when someone says a place “feels” safe or unsafe. Do you have reason to believe you actually were less safe in San Francisco compared to London?
- baby 6y agoMy first two weeks in SF I took the bus twice, the first time a group of kids started slapping random people, I was prepared to fight and protect my SO but they didn't get to me; the second time some guy just ran and took a girl's phone, she grabbed to it for what seemed like a full minute, screaming and shit, then finally let go... I was paralyzed, especially after the event of the previous week, after that I vouched not to ever take the bus again in SF. After that some homeless people screamed at me, some tried to punch me slowly (easy to avoid), I got used to it with time but it's still not a nice feeling to take walks. I wouldn't let my SO walk alone at 3AM through the streets for example (while I would have no problems with that in London or Beijing).
- gorgoiler 6y agoIs there a distinction between privately run and state run CCTV? Do Ring doorbells count in the survey, or is this just for the cameras that are monitored directly from the state police bunkers?
- Scoundreller 6y agoIunno, but if anything, state-run CCTV has a lot more accountability in most countries than anything private run.
- jaywalk 6y ago> Where possible, we have only included public CCTV cameras, including cameras installed on public buildings, cameras used by law enforcement, cameras installed on public transport, and traffic cameras with surveillance capabilities (i.e. automatic number plate recognition). However, in some instances, it may not be clear what cameras are included, meaning some private camera figures may also be included in the totals. We believe this may be the case for London and Sydney. https://www.comparitech.com/vpn-privacy/the-worlds-most-surveilled-cities/ https://www.comparitech.com/vpn-privacy/the-worlds-most-surv...
- sschueller 6y agoI don't think even Orwell thought people would actually pay private enterprises to install listening devices (Amazon Echo etc.) and cloud connected surveillance video (Ring etc.) devices in their homes.
- cmdshiftf4 6y agoAh, but Orwell had no idea how much convenience we can get in return for shedding our privacy and learning to love the state.
- winrid 6y agoI question the accuracy. When I was in Korla, Xinjiang, there were exponentially more cameras than I noticed in the rest of China. Cameras that wouldn't let a gate up unless they got your picture going into public places like malls or airports, cameras every few miles or so on highways, A few cameras for each road at an intersection, to name the interesting ones.
- Out_of_Characte 6y ago"Comparitech researchers collated a number of data resources and reports, including government reports, police websites, and news articles, to get some idea of the number of CCTV cameras in use in 150 major cities across the globe. We focused primarily on public CCTV—cameras used by government entities such as law enforcement." They seem like VERY vey rough estimates. China probaly has the most surveilled city in the world. But effectiveness of camera's is a much more important factor. I've heard of many places in china where you are forced trough gates with photocamera's or active surveillance. China is more than likely to have the most fake camera's in the world as well. https://www.comparitech.com/vpn-privacy/the-worlds-most-surveilled-cities/ https://www.comparitech.com/vpn-privacy/the-worlds-most-surv...
- winrid 6y agoIt's entirely possible that it's correct. Was just surprised not to see that city on the list, but I also didn't go to other cities on the list.
- asdjklqwwq 6y agoEvery single person on earth knows you can't access the internet in Xinjiang. So cut the shit off. Propaganda Tool Man
- winrid 6y agoWhat? I visited family there. They have big cities there.
- throwawaysea 6y agoI, and many people I know, have been the victims of property crimes and other crimes several times over in Seattle. The understaffed police force (meaning per-capita officer counts well below median) are unable to investigate these crimes and so perpetrators are never identified and arrested. This is because violent crimes take priority and so there simply isn't enough staffing to devote time to other crimes. Surveillance and facial recognition could help our police force effectively put this limited staff to use, so that criminals face consequences and crime is deterred. I have no problem using technology to enforce existing law effectively, just as I have no problem with cops using cell phones or vehicles to do their job. I do find the dystopian extent of how these technologies are used in China (e.g. social scores) to be unacceptable, but we can institute the right regulations around these technologies to prevent broader abuse while still retaining the benefits (a cheaper and more effective police force).
- jacques_chester 6y agoBefore the pandemic, you were probably caught on camera committing several crimes. Nothing serious. Some jaywalking, maybe, or perhaps you stood on private property without knowing it, or you were smoking a few centimetres too close to an entrance ... there are dozens of possibilities. Hundreds. Now: you are T-boned by a car running a red light. The driver is the son of a police captain. You want to press charges, but suddenly, you are being indicted for dozens of crimes. It took all of minutes for the police to pull out every single time you were in public for the past 7 years and, thanks to the wonders of AI, not much longer to narrow down to the forty or fifty occasions during which they have you on record as committing a crime. Are you still sure you want to press charges against the captain's son? Or should bygones be bygones? Because it will be hard to press charges and fight dozens of charges in court, one at a time. In fact you will be in and out of court for years to come. Or not. Who knows?
- throwawaysea 6y agoIf we have the ability to detect a crime at low cost, we should detect the crime and apply the law uniformly, and dispassionately. It should be applied as often as possible. Either the law exists and is enforced, or the law should be repealed. In your hypothetical scenario, if I have crimes I've "already committed", then those should have already been brought up. But that's sort of my point as well. I think we can come up with the regulations to avoid the situation you describe. It may involve what I suggested above, updates to statutes of limitation, etc.
- Out_of_Characte 6y agoCamera's dont 'surveil' anything untill a crime has been committed. Only then do people search for active camera's and hope it was pointing the right way in daylight or good enough infra. China esp will boast camera's everywhere as its a dictatorship but with thousands of camera's that may or may not work its like finding a needle in a haystack. Every country has a different reason for camera's and china especially has a different purpose in mind. Its not like their courts or policeforces are working on the basis of innocent until proven guilty. Being surveilled isn't the goal here, its instilling fear of possibly being surveilled (Which is highly likely). Once you've fooled the population into thinking everything they do will seen by the highest authority, that's when you're closer to the holy grail of true power.
- hammock 6y agoIsn't this argument essentially how the NSA justified mass surveillance before Congress, weasel-wording their way around the definition of "collection"?
- hellolleh 6y agoI do not mind being surveilled by public cameras as I do nothing illegal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- neom 6y agoHere is the data they used: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I-WpH2KOiguKy9JTQ9zC2JxBBhH2scdbSRI8lJVjzdo/edit#gid=979494433 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I-WpH2KOiguKy9JTQ9zC...
- vkou 6y agoAnd it's not very good data - as I mentioned in another post. The methodology for gathering it is second-hand, and wildly different across the different surveyed cities.
- borg_ 6y agoHow is cutting off at "150 most populated cities" relevant for this comparison? Out of the 150 cities, 39 or 26% of them are in China making the candidate pool quite imbalanced to start with? Going by the same data, we could also claim that: "The Safest Cities in the World" Qingdao China 7.42 Wuxi China 7.84 Hefei China 11.03 Nagoya Japan 11.21 Nanjing China 13.31 Ningbo China 14.75 Ji'nan China 15.79 Suzhou China 16.63 Dalian China 17.53 Fukuoka Japan 18.59 Xiamen China 19.09
- justatdotin 6y agoyep. I live in a very small city (<80k) that is being abused as a test case for hyper-surveillance, including geofencing and cctv tuned to phone activity.
- girvo 6y agoOh man, where is that if you don’t mind me asking? That’s horrible
- kiddico 6y agoThey look to be located somewhere around Darwin Australia judging from their blog posts. Seems like an okay city to line with cameras judging by the wiki page : "Darwin has had a history of alcohol abuse and violent crime, with 6,000 assaults in 2009, of which 350 resulted in broken jaws and noses—more than anywhere else in the world, according to the Royal Darwin Hospital."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- toomanyrichies 6y agoI'm surprised that Urumqi (the capital of China's Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region) doesn't show up on this list, given how serious the CCP takes security there [1]. Maybe the study's authors simply didn't have access to data for that region. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/10485129 https://www.bbc.com/news/10485129
- ladberg 6y agoI've had an IDF soldier tell me that the old city of Jerusalem is the most surveilled place in the world, but I guess that wouldn't show up on this list because it's only a relatively tiny section of a much larger city (and who knows if they did their research on that or were just boasting).
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoLooking at London, here is a chart of knife attacks 2010-2019: https://www.statista.com/statistics/864736/knife-crime-in-london/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/864736/knife-crime-in-lo... Other random comparisons: 2019 murders in London (population ~9 million): 149 2019 murders in Houston (population ~7 million): 140 2019 murders in Chicago (population ~2.5 million): 490 It seems difficult to assess the impact of surveillance cameras on crime. There are many factors that would impact it. It may be more instructive to look at the 'solved crime' rate. Does the % of convictions positively correlate with the number of cameras?
- vkou 6y agoThe last time this appeared on HN [1], this chart was (rightfully) called out for being unsourced, garbage data. This chart continues to be unsourced, garbage data. Look at the source for it - it is this spreadsheet. [2][3] The primary source for all of China's figures in that spreadsheet is this [3][4] puff piece. Now, the astute reader will notice something strange with this data. Somehow, the primary source [3][4] for the spreadsheet claims that camera/capita in China is similar to the rest of the world - yet, for some reason, the spreadsheet - and the subsequent article claims that all the major Chinese cities have an order of magnitude more cameras than the rest of the world. Garbage in, garbage out. The methodology for gathering the per-city statistics was wildly inconsistent (There is incredibly obvious undercounting[3] happening for nearly every datapoint that's not in China), and the end product is completely worthless - unless you are, of course, using it to reinforce pre-existing biases. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20737023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20737023 [2] https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I-WpH2KOiguKy9JTQ9zC2JxBBhH2scdbSRI8lJVjzdo/edit#gid=979494433 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I-WpH2KOiguKy9JTQ9zC... [3] You can tell this spreadsheet is utter garbage, by looking at the entry for NYC in it. It claims that NYC has 31,490 cameras in it. I've visited NYC twice, and I've probably walked past more cameras than that in the ten days I was there. [4] https://www.360kuai.com/pc/9d0f97d8eb6ea1d8f?cota=3&kuai_so=1&sign=360_7bc3b157#ch=youlike https://www.360kuai.com/pc/9d0f97d8eb6ea1d8f?cota=3&kuai_so=...
- kmlx 6y agothis comment should be at the top.
- dhbanes 6y agoI live in a very well known city of approximately 34,000 residents and nearly 1400 CCTV cameras. I wonder how many cities fly under the radar in this regard.
- dazhbog 6y agoI live in China as a foreigner, I didn't lock my apartment for 3 years. In the first year I didn't even have a key since my flatmate lost it. I can literally walk in my neighbor's flat if I accidentally exit on the wrong floor. All their doors are wide open 24/7. Sometimes, small kids playing in the corridor open my door (the only reason I might lock the door hehe). Delivery guys leave all the boxes outside the front door. People leave their macbooks and bags unattended in coffee shops. Surveillance surely plays a role in all this, the question is how much. How much is surveillance vs. the upbringing of an individual.
- fiblye 6y agoThis is somewhat common throughout east Asia. Setting a phone or purse down to reserve a table is something I've in Korea, Japan, Taiwan, and even Vietnam. There's less of an idea that criminals will be deterred from crime because of surveillance, but that nobody is crazy enough to want to steal a phone or just walk into someone's house. A lot of people here just can't imagine the thought process behind committing crimes like that.
- fomine3 6y agoNo locking at home is common on some rural area in Japan, but I believe almost all people locks home on non-rural area. Stealing from house is a common thing in news.
- tsjq 6y agoOh. The pro-CCP pro-firewall pro-surveillance fanbase is here !
- hammertime420 6y ago"China's actually a free and loving country.."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nunorbatista 6y agoNo Wuhan on the list? I guess we'll never know who ate the bat.
- anonzzz 6y agoI work at a place that has tons of CCTV cameras monitoring the bird droppings and the comings and goings of people throughout the day. When crime occurs, we review the CCTV footage. We often capture footage of people behaving badly and even breaking the law. We curse under our breaths at the terrible acts these people have committed. Next we try to identify the people. This is the hard part. Normally, we have no way of identifying the people captured on film. Perhaps if our company permitted us, we could upload this footage to say, Youtube and let the hive algorithm attack and identify. Until then, our film will end up on a hard drive until forgotten about and deleted. When the cameras are all doing facial recognition we should worry. Until then, I think, there is a certain degree of anonomity when captured by CCTV surveillance cameras.