16 ms·
I like the More in Common Project. But it overlooks the disproportionate representation of the extremists in our institutions. This happened at my alma matter e
by rayiner 6y ago
I like the More in Common Project. But it overlooks the disproportionate representation of the extremists in our institutions. This happened at my alma matter earlier this year: https://freebeacon.com/campus/northwestern-law-administrators-confess-their-racism-in-online-diversity-session https://freebeacon.com/campus/northwestern-law-administrator....
They also voted to abandon entrance exams at my magnet high school: https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=4979 https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=4979
It’s not comforting to know that only a tiny minority of people are standing up and declaring themselves “gatekeepers of white supremacy” when that person is the Dean of a school or a School Board Superintendent. Just because folks fighting the culture wars might be few in number doesn’t mean they don’t have their hands on a lot of levers.
- throwawaycltr 6y agoI wasn't able to find the details about this course the faculty participated in but I wouldn't read too much into it. For some of these you must describe yourself as a racist and apologise for your evil. Suggesting that perhaps you're not that bad means it's even worse than we feared. I don't think someone who really was a "gatekeeper of white supremacy" would describe themselves that way.
- charlesu 6y agoBeing racist isn’t the same as being evil. Just about everyone, to some extent, is racist. I don’t see how that’s an extreme claim. Humans are a social species. We have in-groups and out-groups. Often times the most salient marker for whether someone is in your group is whether they share certain phenotypes or language. There’s nothing weird about that. It’s expected. It’s our default setting. But it does lead to treating some people differently than others. That’s racism. In racism training, you simply acknowledge that by being human, you are racist. You can’t cure it anymore than you can cure alcoholism. It’s always with you and if you care to not be racist, you have to be aware of that. Why is that claim uncomfortable?
- zozbot234 6y agoWe may tend to prefer in-groups as humans, but there's no reason why one's "in-group" should be defined by race. Indeed the whole notion of 'race' itself is largely artificial, historically- and locally-contingent, and thus so is racism. If the claim was that as humans, we're all naturally driven to be more broadly biased and perhaps intolerant towards some others, that would be far more defensible.
- charlesu 6y ago> We may tend to prefer in-groups as humans, but there's no reason why one's "in-group" should be defined by race. I agree! There’s no reason in-groups should be defined by race...but, at least in the United States, it was quite literally legislated in law for centuries and formed the basis of a slave state and then segregation. So it seems like race has historically been one way we define in-groups and out-groups. Based on current events, I’d argue race is still pretty important to a lot of people. Otherwise our politics wouldn’t be...whatever you want to call them. > Indeed the whole notion of 'race' itself is largely artificial, historically- and locally-contingent, and thus so is racism. Race is socially constructed but it’s definitely real. Racism is also real.
- ByteJockey 6y agoThe claim is uncomfortable because the word "racism" has a connotation in some circles of basically being a klansman (or at the least of actively hating people based on nothing except for their race). Admitting said claim for those people does not feel like acknowledging the system we live in against their will or that they have unconscious biases. It feels like acknowledging a serious character defect, worthy of ostracism, being fired, and possibly having a mob show up at your house. Now, I'm not a prescriptivist. I acknowledge that language evolves, but it does not evolve the same way in every place at the same time. It tends to evolve in a particular place and spread out from there. The particular definition you're using has not spread to the entirety of society yet. Your pitch could really benefit from some localization to the various sub-dialects of the english language if you'd like less push back in the future.
- valboa 6y ago
- charlesu 6y agoIn the first link, some administrators took part in an anti-racism training and in the second a school got rid of an entrance exam. What’s extreme about either of those things?
- barry-cotter 6y agoThe first describes a quasi-religious ritual in which all participants ritually affirm that they are unworthy sinners, racists. Those who believe get the satisfaction of publicly proclaiming their sin, signaling their superiority over the outsiders. Those who don’t believe have their faces rubbed in the fact that other people have the power to make them lie in public about who they are and what they believe. It shows who is in charge. The second is the destruction of an institution. A school for the gifted and talented with no mechanism to keep out those who are neither rapidly becomes just another school. Once the City University of New York was one of the major public research universities of the USA. Then it moved to open admissions. Now it’s nothing special. In contrast Berkeley instituted affirmative action which allows for different standards for different ethnic groups. It’s probably the top public university.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoThe first link is obviously against such training (as judged by links below): I can't tell the screenshot is what it is. I highly doubt the information. The second is obviously an opinion piece as well: Being more inclusive isn't "ruining an institution" nor is changing things. It isn't like entrance exams are perfect.
- donohoe 6y agoThats an over-reaction. The first is not religious in any sense. It appears to be an acknowledgment of the bias's we all have as humans. We all have bias's, unconscious and conscious - its part of being human. In that sense we're all 'racist' to some degree and its important to acknowledge that so as to overcome it. As far as the second example cited I think more information is missing before jumping to a conclusion.
- cabraca 6y agoI know those diversity sessions... They claim everyone who is white or passing as white is racist. I had to "confess" that i'm racist and promise to do better or it would have consequences for my career. Sidenote: I volunteer at a refugee center and took in a syrian family. Literally hitler, i know. A colleague got fired because he wouldn't confess and left the session. So even if that Dean said he is a racist, he's probably not unless you warp the definition of racism.
- zozbot234 6y agoIs there any real proof that these diversity sessions actually help people work in diverse environments? The way you describe this, it reads like a really, really weird cargo cult where just confessing to one's supposed racism will somehow make you more open to people of differing backgrounds. How exactly does this help?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _iyig 6y agoIn the manner of all business consulting, it 'helps' by letting management say, "Look, we hired a consultant! We care deeply about ____ and have given it our best shot. If any problems related to ____ arise in the future, blame the consultant." In this case, the blank is diversity and inclusion.
- michaelt 6y agoDemanding people declare they are racists sounds very strange to me - I'm not sure that would help things much. But I've also seen some people do some pretty oblivious things in my time - like ordering company tee-shirts for their mixed-gender team, but only getting male sizes. Or evaluating every interview candidate's communication skills and cultural fit based on a conversation about rock climbing and craft beer. And other stuff managers might need to get good at aren't taught at home or in college. If you get performance complaints about an otherwise-good employee who is fasting during Ramadan, what's the right way to address that while respecting privacy and being fair to the complainant, complainee and the company? I can understand why an employer might want their employees to have a bit of extra training, above and beyond what college and life experience have already taught them. At least for the employees destined for promotion to senior positions.
- secondcoming 6y agoThey sound like people who've been through a re-education camp.
- UncleMeat 6y agoI’m one of those “extremists” who went to TJ and supports the end of the test. What can I do to convince you that I’m a real person and not a lunatic?
- barry-cotter 6y agoI don’t believe you’re a lunatic. I believe your values are inimical to excellence and that you support destroying one of the tiny number of schools that support accelerated education for gifted children in the USA. That benefits no one and harms the children deprived of the opportunity to go to a school where they are challenged.
- pessimizer 6y agoAnd how is this disagreement not only "extremism," but only "extremism" on the opposite side than the one you support?
- UncleMeat 6y agoBut you led with people like me as example of extremism in modern discourse. What makes me not an extremist but my peers extremists? It is true that we probably have somewhat different values. I don't personally value TJ having some high rating as decided by magazines and would happily sacrifice scores if I believed it was possible to better provide education to gifted students across Fairfax County. And I do believe that the test makes it harder for FCPS to do this well, though it certainly allows TJ to select for specific kinds of students that make it score well in magazine ratings. I also believe that it is not good to separate students into many strata earlier in life and believe that the lottery limits the effect of wealth and other inequities on young kids. You may believe that we should reward students who studied their brains out in school, did test prep on weekends, and joined clubs so they could round out a resume. Those are different values and that's okay. It is also very likely that we have different opinions about the expected outcome of ending the test. I believe that it will make it easier, not harder for students to access high quality education and recognizing that there are so many students that could succeed at TJ will encourage FCPS to allocate more resources to magnet programs so there can be more slots for these students. I also hope that this will demonstrate the need for a humanities-focused alternative, which currently does not exist (the humanities education offered at TJ is atrocious, IMO). I also believe that moving away from strict testing as the primary mechanism for excellence will help TJ recover some of its creative side that is so valuable for young learners. The creativity available during 8th period has been slowly crushed under the weight of standardized learning processes over the last several decades. A lot of the skills I learned during 8th period are no longer made available to students in order to serve the almighty test score. I hope that admitting smart students who aren't bound to testing will help this. It is also very likely that we have different opinions about the ability of the test to separate students into strata. I do not support destroying TJ. I believe that this makes FCPS education better and encourages more TJs. We disagree. That's fine. But you list my peers among extremists and you claim that I intend to sabotage quality education. Why is your position not extreme?
- shadowgovt 6y agoThe 'Founding Fathers' in the US were landowners, merchants, and publishers. This is a common pattern.
- ineedasername 6y agoThat school appears to be abandoning the exam in favor of GPA. I certainly don't know their own data on the utility of the test vs. GPA in predicting student success, but I do know that data with respect to college admissions: HS GPA is consistently as good or slightly better than standardized test scores. Even if the balance is tilted the other way for this particular magnet school, it's quite inflammatory to claim this initiative is in any way similar the destruction of 1,500 year old religious icons by an extremely violent group of religious extremists. The people who "rearranged their lives" to try to get their children into the school are also in no way entitled a spot. If this school is doing an excellent job teaching students, and that absolutely appears to be the case, then more energy should be spent on expanding those same opportunities to a greater number of people, not worrying about the speculative incremental decline in quality that might be incurred when switching from one set of entrance criteria to another.
- iguy 6y ago> but I do know that data with respect to college admissions: HS GPA is consistently as good or slightly better than standardized test scores. The data I've seen says the reverse, that SAT is a better predictor than GPA, but both together contain more information. https://senate.universityofcalifornia.edu/_files/underreview/sttf-report.pdf https://senate.universityofcalifornia.edu/_files/underreview... > then more energy should be spent on expanding those same opportunities to a greater number of people, not worrying about the speculative incremental decline in quality that might be incurred when switching from one set of entrance criteria to another. Making all schools better is a noble goal. But I thought the point of selective magnet schools was largely to gather selected students in one place. It's not so much that you give superior teachers to some, it's that a whole class of kids who are all into math (or whatever) can be taught more, faster, than an average class.
- lliamander 6y agoGPA seems much more likely to be entangled with various aspects of privilege than SAT. For instance, I attended a HS where GPA was graded on a 4.0 scale, even for advanced placement and college credit classes. The consequence is that you had a bunch of "Valedictorians" with perfect GPAs that attended spitwad classes. Other schools I've seen grade on a 5.0 (or even a 6.0 I believe) system, to differentiate. I would also suspect that GPA is more easily influenced by parental involvement than SAT (or just a plain IQ test).
- shadowgovt 6y agoAs the product of another of the Governor's Schools in Virginia, I've been in favor of the move away from admissions tests to increase diversity opportunity. A lot of students can't afford $100 for testing, and GPA should be a fine proxy for student performance. Give it a few years to see if the drop-out rate changes.
- danans 6y agoThe event described in that article about Northwestern was voluntary, as were the statements of that Dean. Statements of that sort are meant to be acknowledgement that systemic racism is universal and perpetuates through us at the individual level, and usually in ways far more subtle than police brutality or the use of racial slurs. One of the most anti-racist things that one can do is acknowledge the racism in themselves, and keep that in mind and in check when making decisions that affect others. Never trust when someone says they are absolutely not racist - it's something we all struggle with because of our shared conditioning. A Dean saying they are racist and a "gatekeeper of white supremacy" is just acknowledging that through the power of their position, thet exercise a system that furthers white privilege. If anything, that Dean should be applauded for confronting and acknowledging their own role in racist systems. All the same, I can acknowledge that part of me becomes somewhat racist when walking through a less white part of town at night (and I'm not white).
- rayiner 6y agoIt doesn't matter if they were voluntary. They were hostile and cult-ish. This was a Zoom meeting attended by hundreds of students, many of them not even American and most likely unfamiliar with how academics are defining those words today. As a non-white person I would have been extremely uncomfortable sitting through that. We can talk about systemic racism and implicit bias without the theatrics and personal confessions of responsibility.
- danans 6y ago> They were hostile and cult-ish. Hostile to whom? People who deny the existence of systemic and institutional racism? > As a non-white person I would have been extremely uncomfortable sitting through that. Why? I ask because I'm also a non-white person who has sat through just those kind of discussions. They weren't "comfortable" - no introspective discussion of racism is - but they certainly were not hostile because the participants came with charity and a desire to understand themselves and the context better. The tone of any conversation, defined by the attitudes of those who participate, has a great deal to do with the way people experience it.
- bosswipe 6y agoSpoken as a skilled cultural warrior that knows which weaponized stories to deploy to generate outrage for their side.
- oblio 6y agoMaybe you're aware, but your first source is far from unbiased. I'm not even American but I've found the more pompous a thing is named, the more likely it is to be Republican backed. I guess it's their penchant for drama :-)