10 ms·
This is a classic "Damoclean sword" conundrum. The ability to digitize and aggregate the data, and maybe even subject it to some kinds of AI, might result in m
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
This is a classic "Damoclean sword" conundrum.
The ability to digitize and aggregate the data, and maybe even subject it to some kinds of AI, might result in massive improvement in therapy.
Mental health treatment has come an incredibly long way, just in the last couple of decades. It's even more amazing, when you look at how it went a hundred years ago. Some of the reasons are because of the ability to study treatment methodologies and outcomes.
But having the data in a place that can happen, is very, very risky.
People with mental health problems tend to be treated as "disposable people" by a lot of folks. I guarantee that the first thing the hackers did, was find a way to "dehumanize" the people in their data. Having the people as "data" went a long way towards that.
But people will die as a direct result of this breach. That's not hyperbole. It will happen. Some people will commit suicide, some will avoid treatment, causing all kinds of collateral damage, and some may actually kill other people, because of this.
I have a lot of close, personal experience with people suffering from mental health issues, and this is about as bad a nightmare as you can imagine.
It will reverberate around the world.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"Mental health treatment has come an incredibly long way, just in the last couple of decades." Personally I am not convinced about that. Or do you mean that from an academic perspective? Because in the real world, the therapy method I have mostly seen, was and is keeping people calm with pills.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoUm...I have close, personal, and intimate relationships with many people that suffer from mental illness, and have had this for decades. I do a lot of "extracurricular" work, trying to help folks get back on their feet. So, not academic. Personal. > Because in the real world, the therapy method I have mostly seen, was and is keeping people calm with pills. I consider that offensive. It's a fairly classic "strawman" argument that is used to "dehumanize" people that suffer from mental illness, and also dehumanize people trying to help them. I know many people that would be in very dire straits, if not for medication, therapy, and many years of hard work. I'm pretty upset by this, and by the reactions. I am not a therapist. Just someone with "skin in the game." These aren't "data points." These are people, and chances are good that we all have folks in our orbit that have mental health issues.
- meritganset 6y agoTo be fair, you made a claim that "mental health treatment has come an incredibly long way". And the only evidence you have offered to back that up is a vague personal anecdote. The poster was simply providing their viewpoint on the state of mental health that differs from yours. I understand these things can cause strong emotions, but you don't do yourself or your stance any favors by letting it get the best of you here.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoTo be fair, even though I am not, myself, a therapist, I have been dealing with them for decades. It's not "vague, personal anecdotes." It's real world experience. But you are right. This is upsetting, and seeing the way that it is being treated by people that I respect, otherwise, is upsetting. This is the last I'll say anything.
- airstrike 6y agoVague personal anecdotes doesn't mean they are not from the real world. You're taking someone else's valid criticism of the state of the therapy methods available today and taking it personally as well as unwarrantedly attributing it to a lack of sympathy. You fail to understand that the goal of criticizing the therapy method is precisely so we may find ways to improve it.
- tsm_sf 6y agoWhat makes this single point of view a valid criticism?
- airstrike 6y agoWhat makes it not valid? It would actually be great to have an answer to that instead of the parent's complaints
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
- LatteLazy 6y agoI agree. Most of the "progress" seems to be shiny press releases about wonder drugs. Then you look at the literature and discover 5% effectiveness for ideal uses and serious side effects. It's very important to "seek help" but that doesn't mean any actually exists.
- TeaDrunk 6y agoIn the last couple of decades we've dissociated autism from schizophrenia, declared homosexuality and being trans no longer a mental illness, and uncovered therapeutic techniques like cognitive behavioral therapy which has real, measured, repeat-study impact in lowering people's risk of suicide.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoThat's mostly incorrect. Only Gender Identity Disorder -> Gender Dysphoria happened in the last 2 decades. CBT is great and I personally benefited from it, but it's not a recent phenomenon and its effectiveness is very hard to evaluate. There was a meta-study analysis in 2015 that pointed at a decline in its effectiveness between 1977 and 2014. I wonder whether it's because studying anything to do with a human brain is hard and we can't trust the numbers or if it's because of changes in society that caused people's personality to shift in a direction which makes CBT less effective. Autism and schizophrenia were differentiated in 1980, so that's not in the last 2 decades. Homosexuality stopped being a mental illness in 1973 (or 1987 if you include sexual orientation disturbance), so that's not in the last 2 decades. This was a great success, there were studies that pointed at a marked decrease in suicides among people in same-sex relationship over time. Gender Identity Disorder stopped being a mental illness in 2013 but I think the issue has been politicised and the outcome doesn't necessarily make a lot of sense. I can bring a personal anecdote from a friend of mine who started using a female name for a period and wanted to perform a reaffirmation surgery, who later changed his mind. - Most kids who experience gender dysphoria before puberty grow out of it. - Suicide rates are high even after reaffirmation surgery and even in western societies, which are accepting of transgenders. Moreover, if discrimination was the cause of suicide rates, I think we would see a high suicide rate in minorities. There is way more discrimination towards people of color than towards transgender. - If Gender Identity Disorder is not a mental illness, shouldn't we be consistent and label Body Integrity Dysphoria (aka people who believe they're amputee) as diversity and approve of cutting off of healthy limbs? I'm skeptical on including this as a win for the field.
- TeaDrunk 6y ago1) I wasn't aware couple meant literally in the past 20 years and not the past handful (which to me would be anything within recent memory). 2) Transgender people do not have the legal protections that people of color do. There have only recently been laws to protect transgender people to be employed, have healthcare, etc. on the federal level- and what protections exist can be easily stripped away due to "moral disagreement" of the employer. You cannot refuse as an employer to give a black woman healthcare because you have a "moral disagreement" with her being black.
- t0mmyb0y 6y agoIn my opinion it has. A few decades ago was a shift toward jungian therapy. A massive improvement.
- artichokes 6y agoSuicide rates and mental health conditions are skyrocketing. The effect of all this push about "mental health" has been to convince more and more people to believe they have mental health problems. And adopting this label does not seem to benefit their lives.
- jimmygrapes 6y agoI believe you are correct, specifically about the label; allowing a mental health concern to be your identity, or even just part of it, can be more disabling than the problem itself. It also allows many people who would otherwise find ways to cope (healthily or not) to use the label as a crutch. "My depression made me..." or "My autism causes me to..." are not uncommon phrases to hear now.
- omgwtfbyobbq 6y agoIt can be. On the flip side, I think there are people, who have been labeled negatively (eg lazy) because of a behavioral or medical condition, and now associate the traits that have been viewed negatively with that condition.
- sascha_sl 6y agoStigma is a huge problem, especially when initially seeking help. Burnout took years to be added to diagnostic manuals, and still people are scoffing whenever someone drops out after being worked to the bone for months.
- eurasiantiger 6y agoIn Finland, burnout is not considered a valid reason for sick leave. Depression is, so people are only given sick leave if they accept that diagnosis and medication.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- totierne2 6y agoKey thing is in employment. The damage of the pills vs likelihood of an episode at work. (Work may not know if your mental health diagnosis). Once you hit retirement you can stop taking medication.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Aeolun 6y ago> Because in the real world, the therapy method I have mostly seen, was and is keeping people calm with pills. I dunno, in most common diseases going around right now the solution is to treat people with pills. How is depression any different?
- hutzlibu 6y agoFirst, well "keeping people calm" with pills is not making people healthy again. Secondly: a bacteria infection and the treatment with antibiotic is very well understood - and is actually solving the issue. The brain is not at all understood. Lifting peoples mood with drugs is not solving, why they were constant unhappy in the first place.
- robotnikman 6y agoI think the fact that we no longer use barbaric practices such as lobotomies certainly counts. Still, we have only the faintest idea of how the mind truly works.
- crb002 6y agoNot much has changed since Nellie Bly. Several are still locked up with no jury trial - just a rubber stamp by a magistrate to whatever the prosecutor asks for - the modern day equivalent being a cut and paste between Word documents.
- behringer 6y agoWe're not talking about the justice system here..
- techbio 6y agoNelly Bly was an investigative reporter who was committed to an asylum by a judge, more at linked page. In the US, for decades, jails hold many more mentally ill people than psychiatric facilities do. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ten_Days_in_a_Mad-House https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ten_Days_in_a_Mad-House
- truantbuick 6y agoNot sure you meant to imply otherwise, but just to clarify: Bly intentionally got herself committed for an undercover assignment.
- kordlessagain 6y ago> That's not hyperbole. In the 50 some odd years I've been on this planet, it has been my observation has been most every time someone says something isn't applicable to their argument at the same time they are making the argument, it is.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoIf anyone out there ever reaches that dark place of wanting to commit suicide, please remember that you can speak to someone, for free, 24/7 on these numbers for USA and UK. * US national suicide hotline: 1-800-273-TALK (8255) * UK Samaritans hotline: 116 123 You can go to one of these sites for phone numbers in other countries: * https://www.suicidestop.com/call_a_hotline.html https://www.suicidestop.com/call_a_hotline.html * https://wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_suicide_crisis_lines https://wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_suicide_crisis_lines Whatever happens, whatever you've done, I think your life is worth saving. Even if you don't. Edit: updated with lists for rest of world.
- renewiltord 6y agoThis is a pretty enduring meme (in the Dawkins sense). I wonder if it has any effect at all.
- wavefunction 6y agoEven once person saved is an effect.
- op00to 6y agoIt’s my experience that such lines are impersonal, with staffers that fail to understand and humanize the caller.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoI'm sorry you had a bad experience. My first Samaritans call wasn't exactly a breeze either (a lot of uhuh, sure, yeah). I will say -- these phone lines are staffed by human beings. Even with the best of intentions, they're just that, humans. They wont always get it right. But, when they do, it can be life changing. I'm always grateful for the kind Samaritans lady who stayed on the phone for over an hour one night.
- ineedasername 6y agoYou don't need to wonder. Millions [0] of people call it each year, and that doesn't happen without it being disseminated. Dissemination works. As further evidence (albeit anecdotal) I have noticed, especially in light of prominent suicides in the last few years, that the information posted seems to be getting more attention, with, as you called it, meme-like inclusion almost everywhere and every time suicide is discussed. This has correlated with an increase in the number of calls they receive. They have received more than 12,000,000 calls since 2005, with 8,500,000 just between 2014-2018, much faster than the increases in suicide rates. [0] https://suicidepreventionlifeline.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/NSPL-Overview-2019.pdf https://suicidepreventionlifeline.org/wp-content/uploads/201...
- jrochkind1 6y ago> The ability to digitize and aggregate the data, and maybe even subject it to some kinds of AI, might result in massive improvement in therapy. We can always say "might" but is there any evidence of this at all? On what theory would you even think it would?
- ergwwrt 6y agoTo answer your points... Some people will commit suicide... So what, somebody knows your condition? Guess what nobody is going to bully you, life moves on. Nobody is going to commit suicide. Some will avoid treatment... I would too if doctors were trying to profit off me. Remember the goal of these institutions is not to cure but to subscribe pills for life to make money as long as possible. Actually, having the courage to say "NO" to prescriptions will probably cure many
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jimkleiber 6y agoI built an app for micro-jounaling emotions in 2012 and while I've felt so grateful to be using it and excited how it could help so many people, I have also felt terrified at what might happen if such deeply personal information leaked. I tried to make it local-only, using an encrypted database and a required password, and yet I still feared that the device could get hacked and it would lead to suicide, murder, overdose, etc., if not war, depending on whose phone it was. At what point should we refrain from releasing a tool that may powerfully help people but also powerfully hurt people?
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThanks for doing that. I deliberately avoided reading this thread for quite a while, because I could see where it was going. It's pretty depressing how willing (and even enthusiastic) we can be, in dehumanizing other people. I have been deliberately vague, in specifics, because even a bit more specific could lead to people figuring out some of the identities of the folks I have known. I have enough respect for these people, and for the extreme damage that can be done, if it leaks, that I'm willing to take shots from the "Give us concrete examples, or you're a liar!" crowd. Here's an example of how tools could be misused. One of the things that I've done, over the years, is design a Web-driven, decentralized system for aggregating 12-Step fellowship (drug recovery) meetings. It's pretty much becoming the de facto world standard. In some nations (I'm looking at you, Philippines), people can be killed, just for being drug addicts. In other nations (I'm looking at you, Mexico), drug rehabs and recovery gatherings can be targeted by mass-murderers, in efforts to kill just one member. It's entirely possible that the tool I wrote could become a "murder menu" for these places, and that is not a thought that I take lightly. Nevertheless, those are "might," scenarios, and there's no question at all, that the tool has saved many, many lives. I don't think that it's being used in the Philippines, but they are considering using it in Mexico. I did my due diligence in the design of the tool. A number of compromises needed to be made, in order to ensure that it would be adopted by its intended user base, but it's pretty hard to abuse. Also, the team that took over after I turned it over, includes a number of security experts, so I leave it in good hands. I can't tell you what to do, but, if you feel that you have done all you can, legitimately, to secure it, then you can probably confidently release it, maybe with some published guidance, outlining risks.
- feralimal 6y ago> This is a classic "Damoclean sword" conundrum. Is it though? Its only a conundrum because of the way we have organised data, with NO regard for the people the data comes from. We could have had data collected WITH consent only. The privacy boat left the port long ago - personal privacy was intentionally eroded, and this is just one example. Personally, on ethical grounds, I could never have designed a system like that, with so little regard for others, externalising private information so that a permanent record is kept. Once private data is exteralised, who knows where it ends up, even if it is in the name of some good cause (eg an improvement in therapy). Plenty of people warned of these sorts of outcomes. At this point, if you care about your privacy, you really only have the option of not engaging with the system. Or engaging as little as possible.
- monkeydreams 6y ago> Personally, on ethical grounds, I could never have designed a system like that, with so little regard for others, externalising private information so that a permanent record is kept. My bread'n'butter is patient systems. I cannot think of a way to say this that is not patronising or condescending on some level. Your suggestion will not work. At all. On any level. If we implemented a system like this people would die. Hospitals and Doctors would be sued to oblivion, and rightfully so, but only if they don't succumb to bankruptcy due to malfeasance and incompetence first. Ethically building a patient administration system requires that you collect relevant information, that is patient-centric, and that identifies fully the patient, their needs, their location and their past episodes of care. > At this point, if you care about your privacy, you really only have the option of not engaging with the system. Or engaging as little as possible. The spectrum between privacy and effectiveness with patient and clinical systems is simple and stark. If you want absolute privacy you will receive care that will be truncated, untailored, unfit and unlinked.
- Aerroon 6y agoSo, what you're effectively saying is that if you want to have privacy you can't get medical care?
- aaron695 6y ago> The ability to digitize and aggregate the data, and maybe even subject it to some kinds of AI, might result in massive improvement in therapy. This 100% is not true. We can't properly even see rates of STI increases in communities quickly, so worrying about an AI that would have IQ's at human level, which is decades away, is not relevant. This 100% could be done with written notes. Cost is the only factor. Making a therapist cheaper will save lives. I suspect electronic notes saves pennies in the dollar, compared to the other expenses of therapy.
- dmch-1 6y agoI saw a couple of comments complaining about making people into data points, and that this is dehumanising. But I do not see this. Growth of data based technologies and information surely create risks to privacy, which is another story. However, treating people data as just data is neither new nor dehumanising. Science does that with everything and that is called abstraction. Just make sure that personal data protection measures are there.
- dontbenebby 6y ago>The ability to digitize and aggregate the data, and maybe even subject it to some kinds of AI, might result in massive improvement in therapy. But do we need new therapies? CBT, mindfulness, etc - there are a lot of therapies that work VERY WELL. Especially (and this is anecdotal, from friends), combined with things like replacing alcohol with marijuana, reducing or eliminating caffeine, eating well (avoiding sugar / white bread and other carbs), and getting regular exercise. But we live in a sick society, where the above are often untenable. Therapy? That's 1:1, time intensive, and insurance abhors it if a pill can do the job. Marijuana? Illegal, or expensive and over regulated when legal. Exercise? Hard to do if you have long hours and a long commute. Healthy food? Expensive, sometimes hard to cook. (I looked at an Indian recipe book for vegetarian ideas and many of the things I love, like palak paneer, are very labor intensive). But put someone on antidepressants or other pills that are covered by insurance or purchased in generic? That's a simple solution, so it's what's used, even as patients suffer HORRIFIC symptoms going off these meds when they do not work. Imagine mustering the courage to ask for help, being given a pill that does not, and makes you have trouble doing the work that gets you insurance. And then not to mention the therapists themselves - having to find the right one, and that's if you just don't mesh and don't have a very bad experience. I'd argue a lot of what we call "depression" or "anxiety" are actually quite normal responses to a sick system in desperate need of change and people are often "nudged" by the system to do the "wrong" thing then punished for following the path laid out for them.