15 ms·
I'm not scared of nuclear, but I'm terrified of climate change. We don't need nuclear, because we have other options for firm low-carbon energy (geothermal) an
by epistasis 6y ago
I'm not scared of nuclear, but I'm terrified of climate change.
We don't need nuclear, because we have other options for firm low-carbon energy (geothermal) and energy storage of surplus and super-cheap intermittent renewables (lithium ion, flow batteries, hydrogen, methane, compressed air, liquid air...).
If nuclear could compete on cost, we should go for it, but it can't without a major tech breakthrough. The potential tech breakthroughs (SMRs) are far less technologically mature than any of our other options.
For example, we will definitely need to start producing hydrogen in order to decarbonize heavy industry (e.g. steel production, ammonia production, etc.). So we need hydrogen infrastructure because it's the only foreseeable path for several parts of our economy. It will get developed. Even this article, which is interpreted as heavily skeptical of hydrogen, sees a huge future for hydrogen on the grid:
https://about.bnef.com/blog/liebreich-separating-hype-from-hydrogen-part-two-the-demand-side/ https://about.bnef.com/blog/liebreich-separating-hype-from-h...
Nuclear will only have a future if it can solve its construction problem, and compete with more modern technologies. As it is, it's a dinosaur from the past, a legacy of a time before we had better tech. The more we learn about nuclear, the more expensive it seems to get, in contrast to pretty much any good tech.
- nickles 6y ago> We don't need nuclear, because we have other options for firm low-carbon energy (geothermal) and energy storage of surplus and super-cheap intermittent renewables (lithium ion, flow batteries, hydrogen, methane, compressed air, liquid air...). Nuclear power is a zero emissions source of power. Alternative renewables (e.g. wind, solar) require fossil fuels to power the electrical grid when they are not able to generate power. The sources you mention are also substantial less effective from an energy density perspective. The amount of energy they output, relative to the energy input to construct them and the amount of land they consume, is orders of magnitude less than that produced by nuclear. Storing energy is incredibly expensive. If we were to use lithium ion batteries to store electricity, it would cost trillions of dollars to produce and maintain the batteries. This does not include the immense environmental damage that would occur as a consequence of this policy (land usage, mining, waste products, etc.) > If nuclear could compete on cost, we should go for it, but it can't without a major tech breakthrough Nuclear energy is more cost effective than alternatives. The main issue is that antinuclear activists, funded by the fossil fuel industry, have lobbied to make it cost prohibitive to build nuclear power plants by way of onerous regulation and prolonged legal battles. Countries that have reduced their reliance on nuclear power, for example France, have seen their electricity prices and carbon emissions rise as a consequence. We also know that nuclear power plants can operate for longer than previously believed — at least 80 years, as opposed to the 40 years that was previously assumed. This understanding further drives down the cost of electricity derived from nuclear energy, as it reduces the need to construct new facilities. > For example, we will definitely need to start producing hydrogen Why? Producing hydrogen is inefficient and unnecessary if you have a consistent source of energy, which nuclear provides. > As it is, it's a dinosaur from the past, a legacy of a time before we had better tech. Nuclear energy is safe, causing fewer deaths and adverse health impacts than alternative sources of energy. It is cleaner, cheaper, and more reliable than alternatives while also being far more environmentally friendly. If it is a dinosaur, then so are the transistors that make up computer processors, which are roughly as old and somehow are still the subject of cutting edge research.
- epistasis 6y agoNuclear requires a lot of concrete and steel, both sources of carbon emissions (at least until the rest of the economy is decarbonized). The other "low carbon" sources are similar, they have carbon emissions only because the rest of the economy that manufactures them produces carbon. As for cost, you are contradicting yourself when you say it's cheap (it's not), and when you say that it's expensive because of anti-nuclear activists. See, for example, France, whose new nuclear projects are not cost competitive despite having a strongly pro-nuclear regulatory situation. As for the "efficiency" of hydrogen, the only efficiency that matters is economic efficiency, and all indications point to hydrogen storage of wind/solar to be more economically efficient than nuclear. (And for the record, for energy efficiency both nuclear and hydrogen are about 50% efficient, but like I said the only efficiency that matters for deployment is cost efficiency.
- nickles 6y ago> Nuclear requires a lot of concrete and steel, both sources of carbon emissions Alternative sources of energy also require materials to produce them. Natural gas plants require similar amounts of concrete and steel but have lower energy yields. Renewable sources like wind and solar require immense amounts of materials, including heavy metals and other toxic, non-recyclable materials. Because they are far less dense (~50 watts per sq. meter versus 2000-6000 watts per sq. meter from nuclear), they have a substantially greater environmental impact. > As for the "efficiency" of hydrogen, the only efficiency that matters is economic efficiency, and all indications point to hydrogen storage of wind/solar to be more economically efficient than nuclear. Solar and wind are heavily subsidized, at least in the United States, while nuclear is subject to expensive and arbitrary regulatory burdens. There’s not a level playing field to support the argument that nuclear energy is not economically competitive. From the perspective of physics, hydrogen is necessarily less efficient than other energy sources. Generating the initial source of electricity to produce the hydrogen has a given level of inefficiency. Then actually producing the hydrogen compounds the amount of energy wasted. Finally, utilizing the hydrogen as an energy source also loses some energy. There’s no scenario where it’s more efficient to use hydrogen as an intermediary than it is to use the original source.
- jariel 6y ago"but it can't without a major tech breakthrough. " It can absolutely compete on cost, the only 'breakthrough' we need is operational fidelity. It's 'expensive' for the same reason that the AHA web site cost $1B to build when it should have cost $50M or the tunnel in Boston went 5x over budget. Also, there's the issue of liability and insurance is problematic, it needs to be externalized i.e. we need to have rules, safeguards around what happens and how people are comped. The 'modern world' is significantly harangued by our inability to build complicated things with effectiveness, Nuclear Power is just an artifact of that.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoIn theory yes; in practice, all of the existing nuclear deployments rank among the least cost effective ways to generate energy on the planet. Without a 2 order magnitudes improvements in cost, any plans towards building anything nuclear are probably futile over the course of a 5 decade run time of the facility starting about 2-3 decades from now given current and likely improvements with alternatives in terms of cost reductions in the same time span. Sub 1 $ct /kwh energy plants are very close (there have been a few solar bids in the 1-1.5 $ct range recently). I expect prices to routinely start dipping below that as early as next year. If you consider e.g. organic solar panels mass produced using some inkjet style production process, producing many TWH of solar capability might become a matter of just printing such panels by the square mile using cheap production processes that don't involve a lot of exotic materials, energy, etc. That's not feasible just yet but there are plenty of researchers playing with prototypes for this right now. So, that has the potential to deliver some order of magnitude cost advantage over the already dirt cheap current state of the art for clean energy. That's what I call a feasible path to delivering orders of magnitudes cost improvements. We have similar things in the works for energy storage. And off shore wind is also delivering nice improvements still. Hell, at with that kind of improvement, even producing synthetic fuel at ludicrously low inefficiencies could still be worth the trouble from a cost perspective over anything nuclear. And there's research chipping away at that problem as well (i.e. doing it more efficiently and cheaper). IMHO there's actually nothing stopping people coming up with dirt cheap nuclear in theory but lots of non trivial obstacles preventing us from getting there on a timescale where it matters. And then once we do get there; there's still the notion that mass producing material for dirty bombs poses some non trivial security challenges. E.g. mass deploying micro reactors all over the world massively increases the possibility that some of them end up in the wrong hands. All it takes to create a dirty bomb is some cheap explosives and some radioactive material. All it takes to depopulate e.g. downtown Manhattan is one such bomb. Nuclear safety not just about reactor failure but also ensuring the nuclear waste is properly secured for however many millennia it takes for it to degrade. Another issue is the lack of ambition on growing the energy market. A lot of projections are based on our current energy consumption patterns and seem to assume that ballpark what we currently consume globally does not need to grow by orders of magnitude. The reality is that throughout history, our ability to deliver cost improvements for energy production has always resulted in increased demand together with economic growth. There's no shortage of useful things we could do with a supply of dirt cheap peta watt hours. Unlocking that potential would create something similar to the industrial revolution in terms of economic growth. IMHO that's exactly what this century is going to be about. A few orders magnitude improvement in cost would go hand in hand with a few orders magnitude increase in energy produced. The premise that we need to get nuclear done is based on the notion that we can somehow break that pattern of it being too expensive by orders of magnitudes. However, I don't see how this could happen. Most articles I read about nuclear seem to ignore the security aspect and tend to gloss over the cost aspect or just generally even lack the ambition to do better than even current approaches in the market. So, I'll just put a stake in the ground and spell it out: anything over 0.001$ per kwh is basically going to be obsolete from a cost perspective before it is ready for the market I.e. shipping in volume and at a relevant price point for the state of the art for other technologies at that point. That's decades from now at the earliest IMHO. And that's only a 10X improvement over today, which is arguably not good enough. To play it safe, you really need to be thinking closer to 0.0001$ per kwh or better. That would be at least a 100x improvement. I can see fusion delivering this potentially towards the end of the second half of this century (earliest) but not nuclear in any of its current imagined incarnations. Certainly not in under 2 decades like this article seems to suggest: too little, too late and for too much $. It just doesn't add up. Offshore wind will have removed most gas/coal plants from the equation around that time in any case. China is currently talking about 2060. The UK is talking 2030. Nuclear does not really factor into those intentions. Wind and solar are outstripping everything else in terms of growth currently. If you break down new capacity coming online, coal and nuclear are mere footnotes (production with that is actually shrinking in lot of markets). New nuclear coming online is not keeping pace with old nuclear going offline. And there's a lot of that happening currently as a lot of 1960s/1970s reactors are basically at the end of their useful life.
- pzone 6y agoIs there reason to be "terrified" of climate change? The scientific consensus forecasts from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change show that the risks we face are manageable, and we have decades to prepare mitigation measures like improved flood management and forest management. Certainly we would like to avoid these outcomes if possible, but I don't see a reason it should keep you up at night any more than other government policy questions. https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/ https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/
- asdff 6y agoDoes crop failure, both from temperatures and loss of pollinators, famine, and civil unrest terrify you? It terrifies me.
- matthewdgreen 6y agohttps://twitter.com/zlabe/status/1319471578405466114?s=21 https://twitter.com/zlabe/status/1319471578405466114?s=21
- twojacobtwo 6y agoThat link seems to speak only of the effects of hitting the hoped for limit of warming (1.5 Celsius), while it's entirely possible that we will surpass that. Even if we do stop at the 1.5 C limit, it seems silly to say "manageable". We are already seeing massive a drop-off in biodiversity and increases in extinctions. We don't even fully know how the ecological damage we're already seeing will echo into the future, but the outcomes are almost certainly not good. Beyond the unknowns of ecological damage, the increases in forest fire and storm event damages we're already seeing are also hitting us now, not in decades. Further, from everything I have read thus far since that report was released , most of the models have underestimated the release of methane, which could mean we're already accelerating faster than previously thought. All of this also assumes that there will be a massive effort to cut emissions to 0 in a reasonable time - a big assumption in the time of Trump's America.
- Supermancho 6y ago> a big assumption in the time of Trump's America. "Trump's America" is a strange TDS moment, when you have "Xi's China", sheesh. Nothing is GOING to change.
- ekianjo 6y ago> options for firm low-carbon energy (geothermal) Energy density is a thing. Nuclear beats all other sources of energy on that single metric.
- epistasis 6y agoEnergy density does not provide any practical advantage for nuclear over other electrical generation technologies. It's like pointing out that solar runs on photons, and therefore it's "fuel" has infinite energy density. It doesn't really impact its use by humans.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 6y ago> If nuclear could compete on cost, we should go for it, but it can't without a major tech breakthrough I do actually agree on the sentiment. We should be using the cheapest form of energy with a little bit of a concession to reliability. But the problem with saying "nuclear costs more" is it is clearly over-regulated. We accept, for coal, about 3 orders of magnitude [0] more deaths per TWh than nuclear, as we have for the last 30 or 40 years†. At any point, literally hundreds of lives could have been saved moving to a technically excellent form of energy. We didn't do that. Ditto for renewables despite the terror displayed by the climate change lobby. Humanity has, when tested, shown an overwhelming willingness to go with cheap power and disregard some really quite high social costs to get there. Nobody likes that inconvenient fact, but nuclear has been grossly over-regulated when assessed against humanities choices through the industrial revolution and beyond. If we hold nuclear to the same standards all of us sitting in fossil-fuel based economies are accepting right now it would be much cheaper. If we held solar to the same standards of doing no harm as nuclear, it would be much more expensive. So yes; cheapest option please. But can we also be consistent about the standards that we hold our energy to before we make that choice? [0] https://ourworldindata.org/nuclear-energy https://ourworldindata.org/nuclear-energy † Misread the chart. Originally said 4 and thousands. Point still stands.
- epistasis 6y agoThough fears of safety has prematurely shut down nuclear in some markets, I don't think that safety fears has hindered deployment of new reactors that much. And if we are talking about addressing climate change, we are talking about new deployment because we must replace other energy sources. In places where new nuclear has been built, it has not proven to be a spectacularly desirable energy source. The entire Western world has failed at building new reactors, causing bankruptcies and state acquisitions and restructurings. Even nuclear darling France is pulling back from new nuclear, instead looking to renewables and storage, including hydrogen. China tried valiantly but is pulling back from very large scale deployment. South Korea has had some success, but that's because quality control turned out to be a scam, so who knows about the quality of the reactors they built. Russia's Rosatom has had some success, probably, but nobody trusts them. The remaining market for nuclear are where there are corrupt bureaucracies where the prospect of a massive single project makes the potential for massive bribes possible. This is why coal succeeds in India, for example. As for "doing no harm" with solar, I have yet to see any concrete examples of solar causing definitive harm. A solar failure doesn't cause massive environmental harm. The mining issues are similar to uranium mining. If solar is causing harm, I'd love to know how, but having searched for this and come up empty, and having people claim that solar causes harm and never follow through with specifics, I'm extremely skeptical of the claim. At least until there's some evidence to look into. Until we can reliably contradict nuclear and also see that it actually seems like a good financial deal (taking into account all the costs of failed builds), nobody will really want to put up money for nuclear unless it's for ulterior reasons: corruption or nuclear proliferation or subsidizing a nuclear submarine fleet or something like that.
- 2muchcoffeeman 6y agoI'm not scared of nuclear, but I'm terrified of climate change. I’ve said this before. It’s not one or the other. The fallout of climate change is potentially so catastrophic, you need to spend the money on nuclear anyway. You have to double down just in case renewables don’t pan out 100% the way we hope. You want to spend the money to maximise the chances of a working solution. Think of it like COVID vaccine trials. We’re spending money on multiple vaccine candidates in parallel.
- epistasis 6y agoWe already know that renewables are super cheap. Even the super conservative, anti-renewables IEA recently declared that solar now produces the cheapest energy in history. The only question is how to deal with intermittency of renewables. For which we have tons of options, with nuclear being a poor contender, IMHO. There are certainly some models of zero carbon energy grids that say nuclear is the cheapest way to achieve zero carbon, but I think those models have not adequately accounted for several key observations about the world, namely: 1) how storage technologies are getting cheaper far faster than anyone anticipated, by an order of magnitude, 2) how we will build a lot of hydrogen infrastructure anyway to decarbonize industrial processes that we can't electrify, and 3) how nuclear is getting more expensive every year because it relies on industrial techniques that have been optimized in the past, and where we are now losing skills. Even if we correct 3), I don't think it could outweigh 1 & 2. That's not to say that nobody should invest in nuclear, just that nobody should bother with gen 3 or 4 designs, as they are already obsolete. Look to the tiny startups, and forget about the giant conglomerates of yesteryear like EDF, Toshiba/Westinghouse, and Hitachi.
- 2muchcoffeeman 6y agoThe only question is how to deal with intermittency of renewables. And if we don’t quite solve it? Then what? This is why Bill Gates is on the board of a nuclear startup. Everyone wants renewables. But not investing in other forms of carbon free energy is simply gambling because a carbon free future must happen.
- 6y ago
- hedora 6y agoRemember that we need to put all the carbon we added to the atmosphere since the 1800’s, which will take more energy than we generated during that time window (ignoring some one time bonuses, like planting trees and olivine).
- ncmncm 6y agoWe need to take out a lot more than that, because of all the CFCs (1700+ times CO2) and HFCs (2500+ times CO2) vented. If all the HFCs currently in use were vented instead of collected and incinerated, it would produce as much greenhouse effect as all the CO2 we have added to the atmosphere. Some of the CFCs and HFCs get collected, mostly at industrial sites. Car and residential mostly leaks. At least xFCs don't acidify oceans.
- hedora 6y agoAlso: Concrete and methane from livestock.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> I'm terrified of climate change. Why? There's no rational reason to be terrified, unless you've been propagandized. Climate change is generally considered to be a gradual problem eveolving over the next 80 years, while we've had corona pandemics since 2003. People die every day of poverty and malnutrition.
- danielsju6 6y agoOh so only potentially civilization altering changes within my and my children’s lifetime... yeah no reason to be worried.
- jnxx 6y agoI am almost envious that you are dealing with worry, because I am often dealing with extreme sadness when looking at the whole situation. I have to accept that I am way more attached to life around me, and depending on it, than I would ever have admitted. And yet the civilization I belong to is destroying it.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> yeah no reason to be worried. HN has really turned into a joke - full of self-pity yet lacking in logic. How does panicking today help at all? It doesn't. How does your personal worrying help at all? It doesn't. Are you affected today? No, you're not. If all you're doing is passively reading news, then worrying is unproductive. To state what should be obvious in 2020, there is always another crisis. If mankind wants to do something about climate change, then they have about 80 years. So far no country has done anything, which shows you people's true priority. If you personally want to get involved, there's lots to do over the next 80 years. But panic, sadness and pity won't get you anywhere. The world dosn't need another hysterical Greta Thunberg.
- pfdietz 6y agoMany of the largest mass extinctions have been associated with rapid increase in atmospheric CO2, including the largest, the end-Permian mass extinction, during which the equatorial regions of Earth became too hot for vertebrate life to survive.
- akiselev 6y agoWe don't need any major tech breakthroughs, what we need is to put in actual effort, money, and political capital into trying to solve the biggest long term threat facing our species. The solution has been around for at least forty years in the form of the nuclear lightbulb reactor [1]. This research was completed by the United Aircraft Corporation in the late 60's and early 70's before it was canceled by Nixon along with the Mars program. It was under a NASA contract for space exploration so the literature was written in the context of the arms race but it is even more compelling as a terrestrial reactor as it uses a tiny amount of fuel (tens of kilos instead of tens of tonnes) and actively keeps that fuel at supercritical so if power is lost the entire thing fizzles out. This is a fast neutron design with an extremely high neutron cross section, far beyond that of any other reactor, easily allowing you to feed nuclear waste into it and very efficiently transmute much of it into fuel or more manageable waste that is then separated out by centrifuges (which are already in the design to separate usable UF6 from the neon exhaust). UAC was set to win a contract to test the reactor with nuclear fuel when Nixon pulled the plug. They even had a design mapped out for a slow neutron reactor that would have made it economically viable in the 70s. All of the technological breakthroughs in computation, material science, and nuclear engineering needed to make this happen at an industrial scale have been discovered since the project was canceled. If it weren't for all the anti-nuclear hysteria, we might have actually had someone willing to take the risk to bring the nuclear lightbulb reactor to market. Sadly, almost all of the scientists and engineers that worked on this design have passed on so the institutional knowledge is gone and our best opportunity to head off climate change remains bogged down by pointless arguments over thorium and molten salt reactors. [1] https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19710050022 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19710050022
- somethoughts 6y agoThe cynic in me says climate change is the most pressing issue of our lifetime because carbon based power production is the leading technology and competing technologies want a shot at becoming the lead horse. If we ever switched to nuclear based power production, the most pressing issue of our lifetime would immediately become managing uncontrolled radioactive waste. The carbon based and renewable based power production industry advocates will make sure of it.
- numpad0 6y ago> firm low-carbon energy (geothermal) What? No. Geothermal is proven to trigger earthquakes. Not firm or viable or scalable at all. Not even low carbon.
- petre 6y ago> The potential tech breakthroughs (SMRs) are far less technologically mature than any of our other options They're conventional reactors of 10x smaller size using LEU. Kind of like naval reactors but without enriched nuclear fuel used on military ships designed to operate for 30 yr without refueling the reactor. They can make better safety guarantees than utility scale.
- titzer 6y ago> I'm terrified of climate change. > If nuclear could compete on cost, For the life of me, I cannot understand the disconnect in thinking for people who recognize the need for bold action on climate change and then in the next breath fret about money. It's gonna cost money. It's gonna require work. It's going to not only be opportunity cost, but require us to do stuff. This is what it means to have climate change as a priority. It's a priority above money, above GDP growth, above even the standard of living. It should be our highest priority, and we should be prepared to roll up our sleeves and hit everyone up for money. It's a debt we need to pay, and there's no getting out of it. > The more we learn about nuclear, the more expensive it seems to get, in contrast to pretty much any good tech. At this point in time we need to push the dollar cost much further down our list of priorities and be shooting for what's going to avoid catastrophe and what's sustainable. (spoiler: nuclear energy is absolutely sustainable; there are literally billions of years of nuclear fuel accessible to us).
- golemiprague 6y agoMany people including me are not "terrified" but we do appreciate cleaner or alternative forms of energy if the cost is not crazily more expensive. If people who are terrified want our support to implement at least some of their suggestions they should also consider cost.
- RealityVoid 6y ago> (spoiler: nuclear energy is absolutely sustainable; there are literally billions of years of nuclear fuel accessible to us). I am a big fan of nuclear but, I'm wondering, is this true? Do we have enough fuel for current nuclear reactors to run for....how long? Someone, also on HN, said we have enough fuel for maybe 150 years if we relie solely on it. So what is the truth?
- choeger 6y agoAs with any fuel, both statements are not wrong. We have comparatively little easily exploitable resources but if we had a huge demand, we could exploit much more.
- 6y ago
- adrian_b 6y agoI could never understand what makes some people believe that using hydrogen makes sense. Hydrogen is just a means of STORING energy and it is one of the worst for this purpose. If we restrict the discussion just to storing energy as chemical energy, like with hydrogen, then almost any alternative has either better energetic efficiency or better energy density and in most cases is much better for both criteria. For example, flow batteries have excellent energetic efficiency, much better than hydrogen could ever achieve, but they have low energy density, i.e. they must be very large for a given storage capacity. For high energy density, nothing beats the method invented by the living beings a few billions of years ago, i.e. storing energy in hydrocarbons. How to make synthetic fuel has already been known for about a century, it just is not much used yet because fossil petroleum is cheaper. Instead of wasting huge amounts of money in pointless hydrogen research, all the efforts should have been directed to improving the efficiency and cost of fuel cells using some hydrocarbons and of the synthesis of some hydrocarbons from water and carbon dioxide. That these targets are indeed achievable, unlike using hydrogen for storage, which has fundamental limitations, is proved by the existence of the living beings which use their equivalents.
- pfdietz 6y ago> Hydrogen is just a means of STORING energy and it is one of the worst for this purpose. People who say this aren't thinking clearly. There are different storage use cases. For diurnal storage (daily charge/discharge cycles), hydrogen is indeed inferior to other technologies. But this is not the only storage use case. Other use cases are seasonal storage (particularly important at high latitudes) and backup storage (especially for rare events when it's both cloudy and windless over large areas for extended periods). For those use cases, hydrogen can be much better than things like batteries or compressed air (or flow batteries, or storage in synthetic hydrocarbons).
- adrian_b 6y agoHydrogen cannot be better than hydrocarbons, because the efficiency of the cycle can reach very close values for both, while storage tanks and associated devices are much smaller and cheaper for hydrocarbons. Converting the energy stored in hydrocarbons back to electrical energy can be done with the current technology at efficiencies well over 50% using Diesel engines. Higher efficiencies can be reached with fuel cells. It is true that for now, especially for room-temperature fuel cells, much more research has been done for fuel cells with hydrogen. However room-temperature fuel cells are handicapped anyway by the need for expensive catalysts. High temperature fuel cells can be made to work almost as well with hydrocarbons as with hydrogen. Their lifetime needs improvement, but it is likely that better results could have already been obtained if the research efforts in energy conversion would not have so dispersed over a very large number of directions, most of which were obviously wrong since the beginning. Right now it is indeed possible to obtain hydrogen from water with a higher efficiency than hydrocarbons, because it can be done in a single simpler step, the electrolysis. Nevertheless, in an optimized synthesis, the efficiency of obtaining hydrocarbons instead of hydrogen, also sequestering carbon dioxide as an added benefit, should have a very close efficiency, as proven by the countless bacteria that do a similar job. It is possible right now to capture carbon dioxide and store energy in synthetic hydrocarbons, then generate electrical energy from the stored hydrocarbons. However the cost and efficiency of doing that would be much less than desirable and possible. That is why I said that this would require much more R&D than now, but this would be a certain solution for the long term storage problem. For short term storage, high-efficiency solutions, e.g. flow batteries, pumped water, compressed air and so on, are better solutions.
- cnxsoft 6y agoThe difficult part about costs is finding out the real cost of generating electricity, most studies are incomplete or biased. If you don't count the cost of discarding used fuel, nuclear is suddenly much cheaper, and same is true if people don't take into account the cost of decommissioning wind turbines or solar cells, and the need for baseload.
- jnxx 6y agoHydrogen can be generated by electrolysis from excess wind power, and fed into natural gas distribution networks. This is already happening. It is possible to add a significant part of hydrogen. The advantage of this that no completely new, expensive hydrogen infrastructure is needed, it can simply added as one of many necessary steps. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0360319918337960 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03603... https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-national-hydrogen-strategy https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-national... https://www.irena.org/-/media/Files/IRENA/Agency/Publication/2018/Sep/IRENA_Hydrogen_from_renewable_power_2018.pdf https://www.irena.org/-/media/Files/IRENA/Agency/Publication... In fact, it is not even new technology, because before natural gas, gas for household use was generated from coal: https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy13osti/51995.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy13osti/51995.pdf
- jnxx 6y ago> The more we learn about nuclear, the more expensive it seems to get, in contrast to pretty much any good tech. A lot of the cost of nuclear is about bringing down risk to an acceptable level. And this is why nuclear accidents have increased to cost of nuclear plant construction: They have partly confirmed, and partly uncovered, areas in which plants were not safe enough. The Three Miles Island accident has shown that it is possible that cooling fails, with the consequence of a reactor core melting down, and having a significant aggregation of critical reactive material sitting at the bottom of the reactor vessel. As any physicist knows, an uncontrolled aggregation of fissile stuff can go boom. And this is what in fact happened in Fukushima - several times. In addition, there has been modeling since thee eighties what happens if cooling fails, and the results have been ... not so good. The pressure vessels will not withstand heat and pressure for longer than hours. Which is too little time for wide-range evacuation in a densely populated area. In addition, in Fukushima we've seen what happens if a plant loses electrical power from cooling systems. This is also a real danger in the US plants which are in some cases exposed to disasters like hurricanes or flooding. We have also seen that the storage of used fuel in a nuclear plant is a mayor hazard because it needs to be continually cooled for a long time. And on top of that in plants constructed so far, it has much less protection, so an airplane falling into such a spent fuel storage can cause a significant accident. Then, in the Japanese Monju plant we've seen that breeder reactors which are cooled with liquid sodium are difficult to keep safe in case of a fire. We also now that such breeders can become super-critical if certain things line up. And so on. So, in short, nuclear became more expensive, because we know much more what can go wrong. Whining about "regulatory hurdles" will not cut it. What is the intention here is apparently to cut down on safety regulations, which will have the result of increased risks.
- rmtech 6y ago> As any physicist knows, an uncontrolled aggregation of fissile stuff can go boom. And this is what in fact happened in Fukushima No, that wasn't what happened at Fukushima. There was no "boom" from a nuclear chain reaction there.
- jnxx 6y agoSimilarly as in Chernobyl, the chain reaction produced excess heat, and this likely caused water to dissociate into oxygen/hdydrogenium which caused the big explosion. In that sense, it was not a nuclear explosion, but one caused by an out-of-control chain reaction. If I remember correctly, there were also reports of some observations of short-lived fission products. But we still do not know exactly what happened. Roughly the same could have happened in Three Miles Island, because the reactor was melting down, but the process was stopped, possibly very little time before the reactor would have been destroyed.
- alwaysjoe 6y agoIt is my understanding that nuclear isn't particularly expensive as unlike other forms of energy, all costs (including long term storage of waist) are calculated in advance. And this is a very good thing - we have an exact number that encapsulates the entire cost of this energy for good.
- epistasis 6y agoThe problem with nuclear is that we are extremely poor at calculating this number up front, typically by a factor of 2x-5x. Construction starts based on unrealistic expectations of huge profits, then as expenses explode, the hope of profit disappears. Projects will complete if the builders are susceptible to the sink cost fallacy, or if they do not need to compete with cheaper forms of energy. And if low operating expenses is a good thing, then solar and wind and battery storage are far better than nuclear on that front.
- DrBazza 6y ago> If nuclear could compete on cost, we should go for it, but it can't without a major tech breakthrough. Fusion perhaps. But fission, patently untrue. The price of existing nuclear fission power plants is artificially high because politicians want weapons grade nuclear material, ill-informed "public opinion" and regulation. And to qualify my "ill-informed public opinion", Chernobyl's direct death toll was 31. Fukishima was zero. Yet nuclear is held to some different standard to all other energy. A nuclear accident, with zero deaths is front page news but the millions of people that have died world wide from burning or mining coal, or drilling for oil, isn't. The design of nuclear reactors is uranium based, and over 50 years old. There's no commercial incentive to make better, cheaper nuclear fission power plants because Governments won't let anyone try. Search for 'nuclear startup' and they're all fusion. Making France (EDF) or Japan (Hitachi?) compete 'on tender' to build the UK a new power station is not really competition unfortunately.
- pfdietz 6y agoThe nuclear industry hasn't been very good at making cheap reactors, but they are unexcelled at making excuses.
- rmtech 6y ago> The more we learn about nuclear, the more expensive it seems to get This is a pretty gross falsehood. Nuclear power is could be cheap and safe, but we _make_ it expensive by banning any form of innovation and by lying to the public about how risky it is compared to alternatives. The idea that nuclear is bad and costly becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy as the public incentivize politicians to ban it or regulate it into oblivion. We should not be building the same basic reactor design as we have in the 1960s and 1970s. The fact that we're stuck on big, expensive containment vessels and water is a clue about what is happening to nuclear.
- stjohnswarts 6y ago"compete on cost" when you don't consider the external damage by sources like coal, oil, etc is not a good reason. We need dependable power sources. Wind is not predictable except over long periods of time. Hydro is predictable (somewhat) mostly but it's already maxed out and destroys ecosystems as part of its damage. Solar varies quite a bit. Nuclear is dependable and completely controllable, it's also safe, no matter what its critics say. Their knowledge and reasons are 40 years old and no longer relevant with modern designs. No don't talk to me about Japan, that was a bad design even when it was "new" and horrible placement of the actual facility. The saving grace is they can dump all that excess radiation into the ocean around it when they have to.