5 ms·
Building my own PC recently after a decade on Linux/macOS made me realize how much more susceptible to ransomware PC users are at a PC cultural level. Literall
by hombre_fatal 6y ago
Building my own PC recently after a decade on Linux/macOS made me realize how much more susceptible to ransomware PC users are at a PC cultural level.
Literally every program I saw recommended when setting up my environment was available from download sites like FileHippo and Softpedia. Here's the second download link for "AutoHotkey" on google: https://autohotkey.en.uptodown.com/windows https://autohotkey.en.uptodown.com/windows - wtf is uptodown? They even train you to get used to that classic subdomain spam that malicious websites use. Another example were various driver tweaks/hacks or anything else a gamer or power user might want to do. Always from a shady mirror website that trains you to run .exes from any website that shows up in search.
It was a breath of fresh air to get WSL + Debian up and running on Windows so I could rely on apt-get.
The Microsoft Store is surprisingly bad, not having anything you're looking for, but plenty of apps that claim to be that thing or would confuse people who don't know any better.
Normal users are really being let down from a security standpoint in computing, in general.
macOS has similar issues with websites like macupdate.com, but it's slightly farther along with its much more compelling app store library. My girlfriend is a UX professional and the only few apps she uses outside of the app store is Chrome and Sketch. It definitely feels like this approach is moving in the right direction that can satisfy most people and power users as well.
And for completeness, I would think a GUI over linux repos like Synaptic is also nice for normal users. I have one not-so-technical friend on Linux Mint where I saw them using whichever GUI to grab packages.
- lights0123 6y agoChocolatey is far better than downloading installers manually, but it's just slow as every installer has to do its own thing rather than just relying on a package manager to place files where they belong. It also doesn't remember why a package was installed, so dependencies of a package aren't removed after uninstalling it.
- wink 6y agoLast I checked the dependency management there is pretty basic. Also you have the additional problem, as in my case: the software requires a JDK, how likely is it that the user already has a JDK installed without chocolatey, and if not, which one will I install (not sure if it was even possible to say "any JDK between version X and Y").
- lights0123 6y agoYeah. I'm not too familiar with other distros, but Arch has a really nice thing where packages can specify e.g. "java-runtime>=11". If the user already has a compatible JRE installed, it'll be used, otherwise the user will be prompted to pick a version.
- MereInterest 6y agoBack in 2013 or so, there was a small GUI I had made, and wanted to host the executable somewhere. (A utility for making character sheets in an out-of-print tabletop RPG, only ever used by the group I ran.) It was about two weeks between uploading it to sourceforge and there being an unexpected mirror on softpedia. I never did check whether it was virus-ridden or not. When something that was written by a single person, and maybe had half a dozen users at the very most, gets an illegitimate mirror, how can anything larger stand a hope?
- Symbiote 6y agoThose sites do have their uses. I upgraded the firmware on a hardly-used Lexmark printer, which promptly blocked me from printing as my original cartridge was old — a DRM failure. I think it was Softpedia where I found the older firmware and was able to downgrade.
- MereInterest 6y agoAgreed, there are definitely advantages to having older downloads available. Having an iOS-style walled garden is a recipe for disaster, as the blessed version can be revoked and made unavailable by either the developer or the distributer, leaving the user out of the cold. The main issue I run into is the lack of long-term reputation, and that things that scale (e.g. allowing any user to upload files) do so at the expense of trustworthiness. I'd like to be in a position where I can recommend specific sites as safe and reliable, specifically when giving recommendations to less technically adept family/friends. However, with how quickly those reputations become stale (e.g. Sourceforge being bought out, then immediately burning its reputation by adding malware to downloads), that's not something that really can be done without coupling to a hardware ecosystem as well.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoThe opposite problem, which comes from relying on a package manager + repo, is that anything you want to do that isn't in the repo (more up to date stuff, obscure stuff) is a giant pain in the ass to get. You end up having to compile it yourself from source (and it isn't like build environments don't have their own compatibility issues), or use something like PPAs (assuming they exist for what you want), or manually doing the job of a package manger to adapt a foreign package. Static executables and AppImage make this a lot better, but they are not the convention so they can't really be relied upon either. Good luck getting a package manager to install anything to a non-standard location like a removable disk. When it comes right down to it, I prefer the Windows convention of installers and zips to package management and all its limitations. Precisely because things like "Another example were various driver tweaks/hacks or anything else a gamer or power user might want to do." are easily available with that model. Distributing software on Windows is something anyone can do very easily, without relying on a third party package repo or maintainer. However, what we should really be doing, in my opinion, is something like AppImage (or NeXT Application Directories , or RiscOS AppDirs, etc.) combined with a sandbox-by-default similar to what exists on mobile, but without pops or the ability for the application to tell when it has been denied a permission.
- solarkraft 6y ago> Distributing software on Windows is something anyone can do very easily, without relying on a third party package repo or maintainer. Is that so? Last time I checked you had to choose between 3 installation approaches and then choose a 3rd party installer (all of which have bad UX) and set that up. Fragmentation exists on Windows too, it's just internal. > However, what we should really be doing, in my opinion, is something like AppImage (or NeXT Application Directories , or RiscOS AppDirs, etc.) combined with a sandbox-by-default similar to what exists on mobile, but without pops or the ability for the application to tell when it has been denied a permission. You're probably taking about Flatpak and Snap. One has great marketing but is not usable for ethical/practical concerns while I haven't had a very good experience with with Flatpak (its "runtimes" are basically extra Linux distributions).
- 6y ago
- solarkraft 6y agoEven with the source issue being the same the installation process on mac os is just extremely far ahead. While on Windows you have to give any simple tool root privileges (?!?!?!?!) for installation, with many mac apps you just drag the file into your "Applications" folder and that's it.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y ago> While on Windows you have to give any simple tool root privileges (?!?!?!?!) for installation Bit of a stretch. Most simple tools I'm aware of do not require elevation, or even installation for that matter. That said, a lot of tools do insist on elevation even when it is unnecessary. I agree with the overall point: Mac does it better with Application Directories. You don't even need to drag them to the Applications folder, they run anywhere including off of removable media.
- m463 6y agoI think things like snaps may eventually bring the same sort of nonsense to the linux world. "Because packages in the Snap Store are maintained by developers themselves, distribution maintainers cannot ensure packages meet quality standards and are timely updated." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snap_(package_manager) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snap_(package_manager)
- fanatic2pope 6y agoYears ago Linus succinctly expressed why the distribution-specific linux package manager approach sucks as a way of distributing software and is a major reason why a lot of developers hate writing software for Linux. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7SofmXIYvGM&t=359s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7SofmXIYvGM&t=359s
- GoblinSlayer 6y agotar.gz should be good enough for minimal distribution.
- m463 6y agoI remember reading and do you know what the difference is between different distributions? basically a repository + a package manager. that is what a distro is.
- GoblinSlayer 6y ago>wtf is uptodown? It's an alternative android store https://en.uptodown.com/aboutus/uptodown https://en.uptodown.com/aboutus/uptodown >Another example were various driver tweaks/hacks or anything else a gamer or power user might want to do. Never saw a driver hack a power user might want to do.
- account42 6y ago> Building my own PC recently after a decade on Linux/macOS What were you using Linux/macOS on if not a PC?