10 ms·
> I don't think you would be willing to pay the amount of taxes you would need to, to completely redo the railways haha. This premise feels wrong: The Swiss, G
by ggm 6y ago
> I don't think you would be willing to pay the amount of taxes you would need to, to completely redo the railways haha.
This premise feels wrong: The Swiss, German, Chinese, Spanish experience is that people pay to have high speed rail services, and the G20 economies in that list pay high marginal rates of taxes just fine, for this outcome.
The "you" here is conditionally the "you" of current social mores America. It by no means is the only recent experience of America, under presidents to Reagan, the top rate of marginal tax was significantly higher than at present, and people paid.
Perhaps, if Americans were made to pay more supertax they would discover sooner than you think, how few people it inconvenienced (Bezos) and how many it benefitted.
"you" might be surprised how low the increment was on your tax base, to fund the state investment your country needs, taking into account the superwealthy, and corporate tax evasion.
- unpopular42 6y agoSwiss taxes vary by location but are generally not higher than the US taxes. So it's not about paying more, it's about wasting less.
- _AzMoo 6y agoIt's about priorities. Swiss defense spending as a percentage of GDP is 0.675%. US defense spending as a percentage of GDP is 3.2%. I just picked a simple example, but you will find similar disparities across the board.
- Erik816 6y agoAnd part of US Defense spending helps defend countries like Switzerland. Maybe we still spend too much, but we also "defend" a lot more countries than ourselves, and a lot more territory than Switzerland.
- callalex 6y agoI’m failing to see how this makes it an OK justification for the grift/corruption.
- whyenot 6y agoSwitzerland is a neutral country and not part of NATO. The US has no obligation to defend them. Almost every adult male Swiss citizen has received military training. The country may not spend as much as the US, but Swiss citizens are willing to pay for their freedom in a different way. (..and yes, only men are conscripted. Switzerland is a great country, but there continue to be problems with sexism, even today)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- diffeomorphism 6y agoWhich is a political choice by the US and not about "defending" but influence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States#/media/File:Military_Expenditures_2018_SIPRI.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_...
- wahern 6y agoFWIW, Switzerland has a higher GDP per capita at $82k as compared to $62k for the U.S. Swiss per capita defense expenditures are closer to ~1/4 (28%) of those of the U.S. as compared to ~1/5 (21%) when judging by GDP percentage. (Conversely, France and U.K. have GDPs of about $42k, so they compare much worse by that metric.) But more importantly, Switzerland isn't a NATO member.
- unpopular42 6y agoThe defence spending isn't much compared to the social expenditures. Switzerland spends roughly 30% on social/welfare (and roughly 10% on transportation infra). US spends roughly 50% of its budget on social/welfare and it ain't getting better any time soon.
- monadic2 6y agoWe're talking about train tracks here not military funding.
- Aeolun 6y agoOr, you know, just spend 5% less on the military :)
- umvi 6y agoFrom what I understand other countries (especially EU) essentially contract out defense to the US for economical reasons (i.e. so they can afford to spend more of their budget on social services and less on military). If US cuts military budget it means EU will have to increase military budget by more than the US cut to make up for it.
- Aeolun 6y agoYeah, so there’s some positive externalities too ;) It’s not healthy for Europe to be so dependent on the US, as has been proven over the past 4 years.
- mafuy 6y agoEurope also does not stir up as much conflict in the world as the US does, isn't it? So they are less in need of defense.
- fraserharris 6y agoThat state of affairs is because of the Post-WWII order the US constructed via alliances & multilateral organizations, in response to being repeatedly dragged into European wars. https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2013/08/Europe-only-ArmedConflictsInternational.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2013/08/Europe-only-Armed...
- ovi256 6y agoThe biggest EU defence needs are two: securing oil ingress from the Middle East and securing resource ingress from Africa. Without the US 5th fleet, Iran or any other regional power could shut down oil ingress, pitching the EU into a sizable (-30%) GDP recession. Instability, of which there is plenty in the Middle East, could do the same. Same for Africa, with the added threat of Chinese competition for the same resources. Without those raw materials (minerals, uranium, some oil and gas) European manufacturing doesn't have a future. Hence the constant French and American interventions to stabilize various African states and their tight relations with their governments.
- inquirerofsorts 6y agoChina high speed rail growth over 9 years. It's an excellent system and I much prefer it to domestic aviation. https://miro.medium.com/max/1400/1*Jj_k4U1AwuB5Ia-9oHuJKQ.gif https://miro.medium.com/max/1400/1*Jj_k4U1AwuB5Ia-9oHuJKQ.gi...
- ggm 6y agoI had included China and edited it out: I am unsure what the effective tax rate is for their national capital investment projects. Since the primary story was about tax, I didn't want to cloud things without knowing what Chinese salary tax effects were.
- Ericson2314 6y agoIn China you can zoom out and see that wages / household income is quite depressed, both to keep the exports flowing and power the reinvestment, so the larger point stands fine.
- inquirerofsorts 6y agoThat's a fair call, I'm not sure how you'd even try start comparing it to the West, I doubt western countries can even be compared to each other that well. See people in here talk about land area and population while completely ignoring things like topography/zoning/protectionism. Building 100km of rail in Switzerland is never going to be comparable to building 100km on flat plains elsewhere.
- beaunative 6y agoMajor lines like the one between Beijing and Shanghai are profitable and publicly-traded, therefore doesn't require government subsidy. Of course, Beijing-Shanghai line is the first and only to go public, just at the beginning of 2020, and we can get their financial numnbers easily. Many other lines are not necesarrily profitable, but few of them require government subsidy besides the initial capital investment, that is their income is more than the operational cost.
- dtwest 6y agoBuilding such a network is less economically feasible in America compared to Europe or China because of America's suburban sprawl. First, it'll cost more to build because you'll need to clear out a route of suburban housing to get between any two cities. Second, the population density of the US is less concentrated, which makes getting to the station take longer, and improves the relative attractiveness of other transportation options such as cars/busses on shorter routes and planes on longer routes. It's really disappointing to me as a transit enthusiast that the US doesn't have great high speed rail service in the Northeast Corridor, but to do so would involve clearing way for new, less curvy track, and that would be extremely expensive. Even if we did it I'm not sure it would get the usage rates that occur in Europe. The issue here is sadly more complicated that tax policy.
- yitianjian 6y agoThe Northeast has a density comparable to Europe. I do agree on the culture issue, however - Americans definitely prefer cars by default. Although in the Washington-Philadelphia-NYC-Boston corridor it may be possible, if there is ever a culture of large public works again.
- ourlordcaffeine 6y agoSurely having big train stations with massive car parks just outside towns will fit well with car culture. My other idea is high speed trains where you can take your car with you, like eurotunnel but faster.
- Zach_the_Lizard 6y agoThe US actually has this. It's called the Auto Train: https://www.amtrak.com/auto-train https://www.amtrak.com/auto-train Runs from just outside of DC to Florida. In the Northeast, Amtrak has pretty much captured the NYC <-> DC market for business travel. What's holding it back is a lack of capacity and slower speeds than you'd find in, say, Europe. Why it's slow is a complex problem with many causes. It's partly due to US regulations that cause trains to be heavier, slower and more expensive than overseas. The infrastructure is also old, dating back to the 1800s in some cases, causing bottlenecks in key areas. One 1870s-era tunnel in Baltimore brings speeds down to 30mph for what feels like an eternity. Amtrak is also not super great at running the NEC. The physical infrastructure could do more, and relatively cheap changes could have a large impact.
- conanbatt 6y agoCalifornia spends 10% of an amazon to not build a train between two cities.
- atmosx 6y agoI find that perplexing about US politics in general. Any proposal on taxes and social benefits, throws off people that at a first glance shouldn't. Maybe large part of the voting base are millionaires.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThere's the old quote misattributed to John Steinbeck: > Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires.
- RajuVarghese 6y agoThere are 11 million millionaires in the US which is approx 3.3% of the population. Polls show that many more people expect to become millionaires real soon. In fact, 60% expect to become wealthy during their lifetimes. The optimism that one sees in the US is commendable but it reflects itself in the resistance to taxing the rich. After all, why would you vote to increase taxes if it is going to negatively affect you in a few years. In reality, very few actually become rich. Edit: link to a recent article on how many US persons expect to get rich/wealthy/millionaires ... https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/13/how-much-money-americans-think-you-need-to-be-considered-wealthy.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/13/how-much-money-americans-thi...
- munk-a 6y agoOuf that survey is weak - being a millionaire in the US does not make one wealthy. A lot of people end up having more than 1mil in assets by the time they retire simply due to real estate, this isn't the case for everyone but being a millionaire doesn't mean you're not still somewhere around the midpoint of the middle class in terms of income.
- RajuVarghese 6y agoThat's why I used separate terms, ie millionaire and wealthy. Being a millionaire requires that you have more than 1m as assets after taking into account your debts. That is easy but being wealthy is more subjective. Polls have shown that people consider 'being wealthy' if you have a wealthy lifestyle or in excess of USD x million. Currently x is about 2.6.
- thu2111 6y agoSwitzerland doesn't have any high speed rail services, defined conventionally. All trains in Switzerland are pretty slow, but it's a small country so it rarely matters. Also, Swiss trains are pretty expensive. You don't notice because wages are high, but really, everything in this country is very expensive compared to neighbouring countries. In most countries inter-city rail is used by commuters so governments impose price caps, if there is any political pressure to lower prices here I've never seen it.
- Leherenn 6y agoI personally would say it matters quite a bit. In most cases the train is not competitive with a car, both in term of time and money. Convenience is less clear: availability is good during peak time, but the trains are crowded so good luck taking your laptop out to work. The rest of the time, availability is still decent if you stick to the main lines and the ride is very confortable. Also, cars are not expensive in Switzerland, especially when you take into account the high salaries.