4 ms·
I think it's important to point out that the author is CEO of edisonlf.com, a law firm focused on suing IP infringers. I don't really think that cheapens any of
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I think it's important to point out that the author is CEO of edisonlf.com, a law firm focused on suing IP infringers. I don't really think that cheapens any of his advice, and heck, he may have even decided to start the Edison business after dealing with so much infringement in his toy business. Still, he's not a disinterested party and he should have disclosed this more clearly in his article.
- 627467 6y agoIt does change the subtext of the whole article. Thank you for highlighting it. It does read more like an article on "list of legal accessories you can add to a physical product to propup the chances in a IP lawsuit"... While smart, can't help but think this goes against the spirit of IP law.
- GavinMcG 6y agoI think it was just distinguishing the different sorts of IP. There's no multiplier effect; they're distinct types/instances of infringement.
- mannykannot 6y agoAs these legal accessories are a response to people who have no respect for the spirit of IP law, I, personally, am not particularly concerned by this. It has been attempts to get round the spirit of the law that has brought these accessories into existence.
- jaimex2 6y agokudos to him even more then for explaining how to keep the legal costs down.
- donmcronald 6y ago> I am not a lawyer It's hilarious to me because that seems like the type of statement a lawyer would tell you to make. It's concise and doesn't offer any information beyond being the exact truth. I read the article and wouldn't have realized he has any affiliation, so it's not like he's schilling real hard or anything. There's a couple good points too. I've never heard of a provisional patent before.
- quietbritishjim 6y agoThat is an extremely common disclaimer for a non-lawyer to give, to the point that it has its own initialism IANAL, which is slightly unfortunate but very widely understood. I think the implication is pretty clear: if need this information for a real practical purpose make sure you consult someone who actually is a lawyer.
- mordae 6y agoNope. In some countries, you'd be held liable if someone misunderstood you and acted as if they were given a real legal advice. Sometimes this also applies to other professions.
- mannykannot 6y agoI think you have a one-off error with regard to which post you are replying to.
- mihaaly 6y agoIt is interesting to see articles about how to protect your 6 years old product - being on the noble mission of training next generation of engineers - when you played with this kind of toy ca. 35 years ago. Probably the fact that it was sold out in days of launch may - at least partially - be attributed to the fact that parents knew this kind of toy quite a bit already by heart... ...and of course due to the fact that this idea is well tested by time already.
- lultimouomo 6y agoThe knock-offs he shows in the article don't just copy the flake form-factor though; they are blatant copies of the models and the marketing material. It's not just making a composable brick set; it's copying a Lego model piece by piece.
- dgudkov 6y agoTo me your comment promotes edisonlf.com more than the article because after reading the article and before reading your comment I had no idea about edisonlf.com.
- bdowling 6y ago> CEO of edisonlf.com, a law firm Their web site makes it clear that they are not a law firm, they are a litigation finance firm. As I understand it, litigation financing takes away some of the financial risk from plaintiffs and/or attorneys by allowing them to borrow against a future return from a judgment or settlement. For plaintiffs, they can get access to money when a normal bank would not loan against an uncertain recovery. For law firms, they may be able to take cases on contingency without having to advance all of the costs of litigation. Loans are non-recourse, meaning that if the plaintiff loses, then the lender is not repaid and has no way to collect. As you might expect, the interest rates on these types of loans are incredibly high.
- dmurray 6y agoI would think of it as closer to an equity investment: they provide some of the capital and share in some of the upside. And they likely provide some of the things equity investors do: strategic advice, domain knowledge, access to their network, all of which may or may not have value. In some jurisdictions they may need to structure and describe it as a loan. But a non-recourse high-interest variable-payback-schedule loan is really blurring the lines between equity and debt no matter what you call it.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoIt is literally litigation financing. As in "I don't have enough money to pay my lawyer, but my lawyer doesn't want to work on contingency, so please LEND me some money to pay upfront and I will pay you back later... if everything works out..." It's litigation financing. It does exactly what it says it is.
- vinceguidry 6y agoYou didn’t seem to grasp parent’s point. Debt and equity aren’t apples and oranges, they’re Fuji and Honeycrisp. What makes debt attractive as a lender is recourse, taking that away removes the incentive to lend without other reasons, reasons which invariably look a lot like the ones you would employ in the decision making process to take an equity stake.
- nullc 6y ago> the author is CEO of edisonlf.com, a law firm The article says "I am not a lawyer", so he cannot be CEO of a lawfirm, at least not in the US. ( https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_5_4_professional_independence_of_a_lawyer/ https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibili... )
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoThat sounds improbable. CEO's aren't owners, its just an employee role. A CEO probably doesn't practice law. There might be something around not being able to be a partner.