6 ms·
I've always wanted to know why a ball doesn't follow a beam of light if they are both following straight lines in spacetime. But even more important, if light
by phkahler 6y ago
I've always wanted to know why a ball doesn't follow a beam of light if they are both following straight lines in spacetime.
But even more important, if light beams are reversible under relativity (reflected off a mirror they will backtrack the same path) then light can not enter a black hole because its reversed path could allow it a way out. But then there's that whole thing of objects falling in appear to slow and stop as they approach the event horizon, so maybe light doesnt enter after all.
My conclusion is that you cant really understand it without serious study of under someone who already gets it.
- umvi 6y agoThe difference is that light travels through space, but not time (similar to how a vertical line does not travel the x axis, only the y axis). The ball travels through both space and time. The faster you go, the less you travel through time. Thus, if the ball were travelling at the speed of light, it would not travel through time either and would follow the same path as light.
- pdonis 6y ago> The difference is that light travels through space, but not time This is a common pop science statement, but it's not correct. A correct statement is that the concept of "speed through spacetime", which is what has to be split into "speed through space" and "speed through time" in the pop science statement, does not apply to a light ray. In more technical language, the tangent vector to the light ray's worldline is not a unit vector, it's a null vector, and the concept of "speed through spacetime" only makes sense for a worldline whose tangent vector is a unit vector.
- CamperBob2 6y agoI wouldn't say it's incorrect at all. From the point of view of a photon, no time elapses between its the origin and destination endpoints.
- pdonis 6y ago> From the point of view of a photon, no time elapses between its the origin and destination endpoints. No, this is not correct. The correct statement is that the concept of "elapsed time" does not apply to a photon; it only applies to timelike worldlines, not null worldlines. To put it another way, if your statement were true, it would mean that the origin and destination events were the same point in spacetime. But they're not; they're distinct points in spacetime. Which means that, since the spacetime interval along the worldline is zero, you can't use the interval to distinguish points on the photon's worldline. And the concept of "elapsed time" requires that you be able to do that. So the concept of "elapsed time" can't be used for a photon.
- umvi 6y agoIt's impossible for an object with mass to go the speed of light. But you can observe what happens as you approach it: Let's say I put you in a spaceship and accelerate you to 50% the speed of light toward the sun. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at half the speed of light and it takes you ~16 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took ~14 minutes to crash into the sun[0]. Repeat the experiment except I accelerate you to .99c. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at nearly speed of light and it takes you ~8 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took ~1 minute to crash into the sun. Repeat the experiment except I accelerate you to .999c. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at nearly speed of light and it takes you ~8 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took 20 seconds to crash into the sun. Repeat the experiment except I accelerate you to .9999c. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at nearly speed of light and it takes you ~8 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took 6 seconds to crash into the sun. Repeat the experiment except I accelerate you to .99999c. From an inertial viewer's perspective you are travelling toward the sun at nearly speed of light and it takes you ~8 minutes to crash into the sun. But from your perspective it only took 2 seconds to crash into the sun. See what's happening? As you approach the speed of light, the amount of time that elapses until you reach your destination approaches zero. So from an inertial observer's point of view, time has completely frozen for travelers approaching light speed. [0] Using time dilation formula from this page: https://www.phy.olemiss.edu/HEP/QuarkNet/time.html https://www.phy.olemiss.edu/HEP/QuarkNet/time.html
- shahar2k 6y agodoes that mean that velocity is constant "speed of light" and only direction in spacetime changes?
- edem 6y agoLight also travels through time it just never makes progress. It still has a 4 vector (x, y, z, t) is is just that its `t` component is zero.
- jeremyjh 6y agoLight is moving so much faster. In the same two seconds it crosses a much larger distance in space. The line is only straight in spacetime, not in space.
- Ancapistani 6y agoIf I’m understanding, a theoretical ball thrown at 1c would follow the same path as a photon?
- Smaug123 6y agoYes, although you can't actually get anything with mass to travel at 1c (subject to our current understanding of physics).
- Ancapistani 6y agoAs I understand it, the only thing that can travel at c are: * photons * spherical, massless cows in a vacuum
- lostmsu 6y agoNot sure about cows. I bet a thing traveling at c might not exactly have 3 spatial dimensions.
- rawoke083600 6y agoAgreed ! The "spherical cow", has to first become a circular cow /s
- lovegoblin 6y agoAnything massless travels at c, not just photons.
- maxcan 6y agoThey both follow straight lines but unless you have a really really really strong arm, the baseball is “moving” across far more time than the ray of light. So if it “experiences” much more gravitational effect from the larger swath of space time it covers. Using quotes since terms are more metaphorical than exact.
- pdonis 6y ago> I've always wanted to know why a ball doesn't follow a beam of light if they are both following straight lines in spacetime. Because they're following different straight lines in spacetime. Roughly speaking, if you pick a point in space and a particular direction in space from that point, there is a continuous infinity of possible straight lines in spacetime that point in that direction in space. One endpoint of that continuous infinity is the worldline of a light ray. The ball's path is somewhere in the middle of that continuous infinity.
- edem 6y agoIt all depends on your frame of reference. From the ligth beam's view nothing happens, it just falls into the black hole. In fact the light beam never experiences time as it travels with the speed of causality. From the reference of the outside observer the light emitted at the event horizon will forever try to leave it, but as spacetime itself casdades into the hole at the speed of light (at the horizon) this light will get redshifted until you can't see it anymore. This doesn't mean that the light you shoot into the hole never reaches the singularity. It just means that the light emitted at the event horizon will struggle forever to get out of the insane warp. Think about this: if you're walking on a conveyor belt with a constant speed `n` in the opposite direction and the belt itself is moving with a constant speed `n` you'll never make progress. This is what happens at the event horizon. Light beams are not reversible. If you use a mirror they won't travel back in time, they will just change course. They will never go back in time.
- imtringued 6y ago> I've always wanted to know why a ball doesn't follow a beam of light if they are both following straight lines in spacetime. Because light is much faster. Throw a ball at the speed of light and you will see exactly the same path. Lets say you shoot rifles with different calibers. Each time the bullet takes one second to hit the ground but the faster bullets travel longer distances. Light is so fast it escapes from the planet but if the planet were big enough even light would hit the ground like a bullet.