4 ms·
This appears to be the main repository for their "VPN" daemon: https://github.com/freepn/fpnd https://github.com/freepn/fpnd Some observations: * It's not act
by woodruffw 6y ago
This appears to be the main repository for their "VPN" daemon: https://github.com/freepn/fpnd https://github.com/freepn/fpnd
Some observations:
* It's not actually a virtual private network, at least by the traditional definition. They route HTTP(S) and DNS traffic only; other protocols (presumably) get routed in the clear.
* IPv6 isn't supported at all.
* I might be missing it, but I can't find any cryptographic design documents or a threat model anywhere. A quick repo search doesn't even bring up any cryptographic primitives, which makes me wonder about malicious peers.
It's good to have more competition in this space, so I'd like to be wrong (or eventually wrong, feature-wise) about all of the above. But if I'm right, this is roughly the same as using a SOCKS proxy (and maybe a bit worse, if any other peer can futz with your traffic).
- woodruffw 6y agoSome other sketchy bits, from a very quick perusal: * Shelling out[1] to some tool that may be responsible for all of the heavy networking bits[2] * Falling back on a non-monotonic clock but calling it monotonic[3] * Another sketchy shellout[4] that calls a bunch of scripts with trivial interpolation/injection bugs[5]. It's not clear if the arguments passed to those scripts are remotely controllable, but it's sketchy. [1]: https://github.com/freepn/fpnd/blob/eda6536754d35224ca773ba9c6c5c8f347821625/node_tools/node_funcs.py#L241 https://github.com/freepn/fpnd/blob/eda6536754d35224ca773ba9... [2]: https://github.com/zerotier/ZeroTierOne https://github.com/zerotier/ZeroTierOne [3]: https://github.com/freepn/fpnd/blob/eda6536754d35224ca773ba9c6c5c8f347821625/node_tools/timing_funcs.py#L12 https://github.com/freepn/fpnd/blob/eda6536754d35224ca773ba9... [5]: https://github.com/freepn/fpnd/blob/eda6536754d35224ca773ba9c6c5c8f347821625/bin/ping_gateway.sh https://github.com/freepn/fpnd/blob/eda6536754d35224ca773ba9...
- anderspitman 6y agoTo be fair, ZeroTier isn't just "some tool". It has a solid reputation. The founder (api) is actually here in the thread.
- woodruffw 6y agoThat’s good to know. That being said: it’s not clear what role it’s playing (to me, it may be extremely obvious to anybody who knows what ZeroTier actually is), and it’s not clear why it’s being shelled out to rather than consumed via some Python API.
- jsilence 6y agoWhat about Zerotier 2.0 btw? Was supposed to surface before summer, but seems to have stalled. Might actually be relevant as more people are working from home now.
- api 6y ago2.0 is still in the works, but took far longer than we hoped. We have back-ported some of its features to the 1.x branch and have a 1.6.0 beta (tagged 1.5.0) out now. 1.6.0 should be late this month. We are pushing for 2.0 by EOY. 2.0 is a major re-architecting for performance and versatility with a rewrite of the CLI and service layer (not core protocol). If we had 100% of our time to dedicate only to engineering we could have shipped it by now, but biz and other things got in the way.
- jsilence 6y agoThanks for the update and thank you for working on this! Looking forward to the upcoming releases!
- column 6y agoHi! Link [4] is missing.
- woodruffw 6y agoWhoops. I can't edit the parent anymore, but here is the intended link: https://github.com/freepn/fpnd/blob/e14e4b0cda7e7d851c1823bf226a754f8ba19b71/node_tools/network_funcs.py#L305 https://github.com/freepn/fpnd/blob/e14e4b0cda7e7d851c1823bf...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- oefrha 6y agoThese days any anonymizing proxy is marketed as "VPN". Probably because there's been enough marketing dollars spent on making the average joe equate "private internet" (whatever that means) with VPN, they'd be losing out on a lot of traffic if they market themselves accurately, and the difference is entirely lost on 99% of the potential market anyway.