7 ms·
If I was a Twitter or Facebook investor, I have one question: What did you expect was going to happen? Honestly. Did nobody have the foresight at Facebook or
by gjsman-1000 6y ago
If I was a Twitter or Facebook investor, I have one question:
What did you expect was going to happen?
Honestly. Did nobody have the foresight at Facebook or Twitter to think that this wouldn't blow up? Did nobody think, just once, that this might invite regulatory action or be in news headlines?
And if honestly nobody thought this might happen, I'd want the entire management and "safety" team replaced for having no foresight for their actions whatsoever.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoAlso in this category of "did you actually think this through": Andy Stone, of the Facebook communications department, calling for fact checks while gloating about reducing its circulation. https://twitter.com/andymstone/status/1316395902479872000 https://twitter.com/andymstone/status/1316395902479872000 (n.b. "gloating" is interpretation — if it is not the case that this is gloating then a key problem is that this tweet leaves itself very open to this interpretation.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- trident1000 6y agoThey are utilities at this point I hope they get treated this way. The monopolistic public square of debate cant have kings in charge. Also can you imagine what would happen if big tech oligopolies teamed up with one political party for a "I scratch your back you scratch mine" situation. You could have a 1 party political system for eternity and essentially remove the democratic system. The threat of big tech oppression is significant. And if you watched the movie "the social dilemma" the oppression and political strong arming by big tech is already happening in countries outside the US.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tboyd47 6y agoThey probably have been doing this for a while, and this was just the first time they got called out for it. Regulatory action has been in the works for some time. Whether or not it goes through depends only on politics. The mainstream media already doesn't like them for eating their lunch. Twitter has nothing to lose by doing this. It will damage Facebook's brand identity as being a "free speech" platform, but that's about as factual as Google's "don't be evil" brand or Apple's "privacy first" brand.
- gjsman-1000 6y agoActually, Twitter has one massive thing to lose: Section 230. Already, senators are taking this as the perfect reason to repeal or reform 230, and that would directly impact twitter. Remember how there were hearings about 230 just two weeks ago? Twitter just shot themselves and their arguments for 230 in the foot with this. Which again begs the question from an investor's point of view: What did you expect was going to happen? Did you seriously not think this would affect the 230 debate?
- tzs 6y agoRepeal of section 230 would probably result in Twitter blocking a lot more things than they do now.
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoWhich is why we need reform: 230 liability protection needs to be extended only to those entities that only remove illegal content and nothing else, period.
- tzs 6y agoSo if I ran a chess forum, I could not remove posts about horse racing without losing my section 230 protection? Or posts advertising boner pills? Once I decide to allow people to post on my forum, for any reason, I have to allow every single post that does not violate the law, or I lose 230 protection?
- likeafox 6y agoWhat's the probability that the story they're blocking is 100% bullshit? And if they have evidence or signals of that, does that weigh in to your opinion on their intervention?
- _qulr 6y agoThe majority of things on Twitter and Facebook are bullshit. How many politicians and "pundits" are allowed to blatantly lie on Twitter? Not sure why this is different.
- likeafox 6y agoIt's a newspaper collaborating with the president's personal lawyer, who is already the subject of investigations into persons in violation of the Foreign Agent Registration Act, during the run up to an incredibly contentious election after these networks - Facebook and Twitter- have already been accused of allowing rampant disinformation campaigns. If they had reason to believe that the information was part of a malicious campaign, I can see why that might spur them to action.
- _qulr 6y ago> It's a newspaper collaborating with the president's personal lawyer The President is still allowed to tweet almost anything he wants, so this is still very selective censorship.
- likeafox 6y agoEvidently Twitter feels that gives him special privileges, but they've been flagging his posts as possible misinformation for months. Clearly they're trying to find a way to navigate a difficult situation. I think they should be erring toward better control of disinformation, certainly not being more laissez-faire about a problem that is destroying the world.
- _qulr 6y ago
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThey probably expected it would go over like the Alex Jones thing or the warning messages on Trump's tweets, with a brief burst of interest followed by adjustment to the new consensus that some censorship is justified for the sake of social harmony. (And they may yet be right - there were headlines about those two things too.)
- cft 6y agoThe just consequence should be that they should be considered publishers, rather than the republishers. And thus lose their 230 protection from civil litigation.
- mcintyre1994 6y agoIsn’t the entire point of 230 to allow platforms to be moderated without being treated as publishers?
- cft 6y agoNo, the original point of 230 was to allow platforms to republish user content without bearing civil liability for such content.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoNo, the point was to allow platforms to republish user content and moderate it without bearing civil liability for the content. Case law prior to section 230 had established that platforms only had liability if they engaged in moderation, but had no liability if they did not moderate in any way. Section 230 was created to address that absurd result of existing law. Protecting platforms that engage in moderation is the whole point, platforms that don’t moderate are already protected. This is why nobody has suggested that AT&T would have civil liability for posts on Facebook even though their wires carry the post to you. Dumb pipes don’t accrue liability.
- cft 6y agoRelying on the case law is much more expensive than relying on the US Code, since 230 allows to immediately go for the summary judgement, even if somebody still files a civil case. So the then smaller ISPs lobbied for that. The moderation clause was historically added because at that time, the failed CDA (Communication Decency Act) was likely to pass (later partially struck down by the Supreme Court). so the COngress added it as the implementation mechanism for the CDA. When the CDA was weakened, the moderation language was still left in 230. These latest chilling developments make me think it's better to revert to case law.
- Arthanos 6y agoThis post has a very odd tone, as if a private company enforcing their policy to remove unverified & leaked personal correspondence of a private citizen is some unquestionable moral wrongdoing that's apparently going to blow up. Surprised to see this as at the top, on HN. National Review is a conservative wing-nut website trying to turn this non-story into fuel for their censorship culture war.
- free_rms 6y agoThe pentagon papers were unverified and leaked. More recently and less impressively, the entire world of Russia-gate stuff was unverified and leaked Would you say the same if that stuff was censored?
- jtbayly 6y agoHow in the world can anybody dispute this!?! Add WikiLeaks to the list too. People can down vote all they want, but doing so just confirms that the only way to satisfy them is for Twitter to pick sides and apply its rules evenly unfairly on behalf of one political party.
- nautilus12 6y agoExactly!
- pnw_hazor 6y ago60 Minutes 2 aired a slanderous story about George Bush based on documents they knew were unverified. And, the timing is not suspicious it is politics.
- daveevad 6y ago> their policy to remove unverified & leaked personal correspondence do you think their policy is evenly applied across their platform?
- hackinthebochs 6y agoOf course not. But how could it possibly be applied evenly? That's not an expectation anyone could genuinely hold.
- vl 6y agoPitchforks are out, once current election circus is over, they will come for FB, Twitter and YouTube. Politicians on either side are scared and don’t want such strong entities have control over information.
- lumost 6y agoRegulation of online media is all but inevitable. Historically all media sources were directly compared by individuals and groups. You used to get the paper from a news stand/paper boy and could glance at all the headlines in comparison to each other, your colleagues knew what the tabloids were running and what the different takes on the headlines were. In the radio and TV age, a small number of commentators were directly compared by channel surfers on the nightly news. We're now in an unfortunate scenario where individuals only see algorithmically curated bubbles of news and facts that reinforce their world views regardless of those facts correspondence to reality. They've elected politicians that parrot those facts and world views back to them. Breaking down these bubbles or removing the peddlers of alternate facts is required for a functional society (as well as a healthy platform). Neither of these actions is likely to be well received by all parties. History does not look kindly on governments that denied reality.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI don't have a compelling argument for why you're wrong, but it really seems like this is a weightier claim than you're giving it credit for. If social harmony is a sufficient reason for censorship, is there any basis left for objecting to the Great Firewall?
- lumost 6y agoI don't believe social harmony is a sufficient reason for censorship or that censorship is the correct approach. There are many potential remedies including. - Mandatory content identifiers tags on content/claims for unfactual or unverified reporting reaching more than X people. - Identifying frequent reporters of misinformation and identifying them as such when presenting/resharing information. - Reducing the spread of misinformation in algorithmic sources such as newsfeeds/search rankings. None of these approaches removes or censors the content, but they do identify it and help place it in the appropriate context. In the 90s I had to go looking for claims that the president had dinner with aliens every Tuesday, today such news articles are pushed via feeds.
- 6y ago