9 ms·
It's different because it was written by a major American newspaper. Twitter should not be exercising editorial control over the news.
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
It's different because it was written by a major American newspaper. Twitter should not be exercising editorial control over the news.
- Hamuko 6y agoIsn't it distribution control rather than editorial control?
- koolba 6y agoLimiting distribution to filter out what you don't want to rise to the top has the same effect as explicitly picking winners. Think of it like shooting the tires of all the cars you want to lose in a race. Sure you didn't push the winner across the finish line, but you made it damn near impossible for anyone else to even get there.
- Hamuko 6y agoYeah, but that's still not editorial control. And maybe we do actually want Twitter to pick some winners. I don't think the platform needs any more death threats, Russian-backed misinformation campaigns or other bullshit.
- rightbyte 6y agoWhat if Russian missinormation is a Russian misinformation campaigne to induce paranoia and there are no actual misinformation ... How about a straight forward algorithm for the feed instead of some hugely adbiased mess.
- hef19898 6y agoAnd this is exactly what social media does all the time, or rather their recommendation algorithms. Which, for some reason, is no problem at all. Now that the bias of these algorithms is changing, also by directly intervening, it is a big problem.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI don't think so. You could perhaps make an argument that banning all NY Post articles would be distribution control, although even then I'm skeptical. But if I picked up a physical copy of the New York Post, and found that the newsstand had snipped just this one article out with a pair of scissors, I'd call that an unambiguous act of editorial control and censorship.
- kofejnik 6y agoif a news network with a 1B viewers only gave free airtime to one side, it would clearly be in violation of campaign finance laws, among others
- davismwfl 6y agoIt could be easily argued while they are not rewriting the story they selectively choose the facts they present as "fact checked" information. In the recent past both FB and Twitter have linked to "fact checked" articles/sources that represented only the narrative they wanted you to read. If they wanted to show neutral behavior they could have linked to articles that represented both sides of an argument which would keep their independence and educate their audience better since rarely is one side 100% correct.
- iaw 6y agoThe "both sides" of an argument thing does not work when one side is intellectually dishonest and bases arguments on misinterpretations and mistruths.
- aksss 6y agoProblem is that both sides see the other as exactly this. I’m sure I can argue the point on behalf of either side selected by a coin toss. In today’s example though we have the side that dominates academia, media, big labor, healthcare, public sector workers, and big tech using that dominance to censor a story harmful to their candidate with very disingenuous reasoning.
- iaw 6y agoOnly one side has come up with 'alternative facts' and argued that conclusive science is 'still out'. I've seen hypocrisy on both sides for sure but the intellectual dishonesty is only coming from one.
- aksss 6y agoI know a dozen people who would agree with you and thirteen who would argue the opposite and cite sources. You might not be as objective as you think here.
- 6y ago
- drcongo 6y agoIs the NY Post considered a serious newspaper over there?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIt's one of those papers in the strange intersection of "mainstream tabloid". It's clearly not serious, as you can see from a quick glance at their typical cover pages, but it's also not one of the papers everyone knows is untrustworthy schlock.
- microtherion 6y agoAnd it's a paper whose headlines are more widely cited than the articles, because it's known for the catchy headlines.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoYes, it's a serious newspaper. But it is known to use sans serif fonts and hire people that went to public schools.
- throwawa3495 6y ago>hire people that went to public schools. You say this like it's an insult.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoParent was being sarcastic, insinuating that people who don't like Rupert Murdoch's decades-old propaganda empire are elitist.
- rabuse 6y agoIs information being gated by private universities, that only the elite have access to? This may have had validity in the pre-internet era, but information is everywhere now. There's nothing wrong with "public education".
- frob 6y agoThe New York Post is not a serious newspaper; it is a sensationalist tabloid. Sometimes the NYPost will report on real news, but I believe absolutely nothing they report until it is verified by the New York Times, Washington Post, LA Times, or other major broadcast outlet with actual journalistic standards.
- gotoeleven 6y agoIm genuinely curious what journalistic standards you think these mainstream outlets possess after all the Russia nonsense. Can you point to an example of any recent story where these outlets have displayed "actual journalistic standards"?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoAgreed, and I don't mean to imply any sort of endorsement of the NY Post.
- trident1000 6y agoNone of them are serious. NY Times made a big deal out of trumps taxes when everyone knows depreciation offsets revenue in real estate, its 101 stuff. You get taxed when you sell the asset which happens infrequently but in large magnitude. Most people in the industry were laughing at the gaslighting they did on that story but they fooled their little pawn readers. Just one example out of many. Every news source is full of shit even the ones that are supposed to be reputable.
- whateveracct 6y agoYou realize the real story re: Trump's asset depreciation is that he reported one valuation to the govt and one to his banks when seeking loans, right?
- trident1000 6y agoThe story headline that was coordinated and gaslight was "trump didnt pay any tax". Everything else was anecdotal, I didnt look into this specific matter because I was rolling my eyes from the start. If they cant be honest about the main story I'm not following them for the rest of the allegations.
- takeda 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Post https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Post The fist sentence has a word "tabloid" in it. It's not reputable source of news by any stretch.