15 ms·
Is wind power’s future in deep water?
- engie 6y agoBeing able to move the bulk of building an offshore turbine into a factory could lead to amazing economies of scale. It'll be an incredible assembly line to pull together 10,000 ton of materials but if we need to build hundreds of thousands it might well be worth doing. There should be a gentle stream of these things bobbing out into the sea, ready to be taken by tug to their resting place.
- usrusr 6y agoWhere do you think wind turbines are currently manufactured? Sure, off-shore makes many of the transportation issues much easier, but final on-site assembly is pretty streamlined already no matter what site category.
- engie 6y agoI hope being able to assemble the turbine & the "foundations" together in a factory brings better economies of scale than factory turbine with foundations built in situ.
- hannob 6y agoI feel somewhat put off by this headline. I mean, by all means, yes, please try that! We'll gonna need lots of clean energy. But I fear the NIMBYs will read that headline and interpret it as: "see, we're not gonna need these turbines near my house any more, the future is in deep water!" The future of wind is onshore. And offshore. And maybe also in deep water.
- 082349872349872 6y agoHas something changed? I'd always thought the cubic dependence of power generated on wind speed meant that the places people willingly live are often distinct from the places engineers site wind turbines.
- vanderZwan 6y agoI guess this is often true, but not always. For example, the Netherlands is essentially one big river-delta at the end of two of the major rivers of Europe. This makes it flat and windy. Ideal for windpower (in fact, we had an early lead on the UK in terms of industrialization with our windmills, but then they figured out how to use coalpower and took over). Also, being a river delta, the Netherlands contained extremely fertile soil that lends itself very well to agriculture (the flat landscape doesn't hurt either). Hence we're also one of the most densely populated countries in the world. And even in the Netherlands, where windmills are part of the national culture, you got tons of NIMBYs
- sradman 6y agoWaterwheels were more than competitive before coal powered steam engines took over. Still, it is a fascinating question: why wasn’t the Netherlands a fast-follower in the Industrial Revolution?
- vanderZwan 6y ago> Waterwheels were more than competitive before coal powered steam engines took over. True for most of Europe, but this essentially requires height differences, something in fairly short supply in the Netherlands ;) (see also the two articles I linked in the other comment)
- 082349872349872 6y agoI had thought coal would be in fairly short supply as well, but apparently there are corners of the country more than a few meters above sea level: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining_in_Limburg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining_in_Limburg > "The demand for coal had grown explosively as a result of increased industrialization and urban expansion, but the national governments regarded any form of interference in the extraction and sale of this fuel as unnecessary. Thus it came about that the first concessions for the extraction of coal in South Limburg were granted without hesitation to foreign firms, although most of the coal consumed in the Netherlands was imported from Germany, and Dutch investors preferred to invest their capital in foreign countries, such as in Russian government loans, American railways, and Hungarian waterworks."
- Harvesterify 6y agoWind energy is far from being "clean", unfortunately.
- Malic 6y agoPlease explain.
- sergeykish 6y agoWind turbines are beautiful, reminds me of future depicted by H. G. Wells in The Sleeper Awakes. And it is today, not in 2100. Is problem as bad as on DW documentary [1]? Installed Capacity confirms [2] but that's unbelievable. Birds would have much more problem if temperature raises 4°C. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qr5PEAK1t3U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qr5PEAK1t3U [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Germany#Statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Germany#Statisti...
- vanderZwan 6y agoWindmills do kill birds. Not as much as housecats though, so maybe we should get rid of those first. Also, you can paint one out of three windmill blades black to drastically reduce the number of birds who die from it [0] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/black-wind-turbine-blades-help-birds-avoid-deadly-collisions-180975668/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/black-wind-turbine...
- nhumrich 6y agoHa, I actually thought the headline was really clever because "in deep water" is also an idiom for "in trouble", "doomed", etc. So I thought it was quite clever that the article means actual water, with a lot of depth, but leads you to maybe think the opposite when you start reading.
- dkarl 6y agoConsidering how many more people will scan the headline than read the article, it made me uneasy. What's the effect of all those people getting a vaguely pessimistic message about wind power? Did they consider that when they wrote the headline? I guess it's possible they were only thinking about being clever.
- Finnucane 6y agoFor a minute I thought they meant it literally, that it would be an article about underwater turbines.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoWell they're a growth field too -- tidal and current based turbines.
- kaushikt 6y agoWhat is stopping us from combining tidal and wind energy sources? Especially considering we are already venturing out in the sea for wind?
- londons_explore 6y agoExtracting lots of energy from the tide usually requires natural or manmade lakes or eastuarys attached to the sea. Building those in deep water isn't really practical.
- Dumblydorr 6y agoTidal energy never panned out, it was far too expensive and no one came close to commercial viability over the dozen years of experimentation.
- usrusr 6y agoTidal streams are only strong in very specific locations. Consider a regular, straight-ish coast: the water volume difference between low tide and high tide may seem massive, but divided by the cross-section of an imaginary divider between coastal waters and off-shore waters the stream (meters cubed for tidal delta volume divided by meters squared for the cross section that the delta has to pass through) will be rather negligible. It would be very cool to have fully developed tidal generator products ready to deploy in the few places where geographic features force the delta through a tight bottleneck (anything from small bays and fjords in high tidal delta areas to the massive bottleneck of Gibraltar straight) but that's a pretty hard limited market that makes development investments rather unattractive when there are more universally applicable renewable energy sources untapped, like e.g. offshore wind.
- sradman 6y ago> What’s groundbreaking about the Hywind project, located in more than 300ft (90m) of water, is that the giant masts and turbines sit in buoyant concrete-and-steel keels that enable them to stand upright on the water, much like a fishing buoy. The turbines’ nearly 10,000-ton cylindrical bases are held in place with three taut mooring cables attached to anchors, which lie on the sea floor. > Currently the electricity they generate is often almost twice as expensive as near-shore wind turbines and three times that of land-based wind turbines.
- Aerroon 6y agoHow long would one of those have to generate electricity to make up for its own construction? 10,000 tons of concrete and steel probably cause quite a lot of CO2 pollution to make.
- cogman10 6y agoLast time I researched it, it came to about 1->2 years to pay back manufacturing energy. That was for land based turbines. Bigger turbines payed back faster. So 1MW was closer to 2 years while 3MW was closer to 1. The steel used was by and large the biggest energy cost.
- brandmeyer 6y agoSteelmaking's CO2 footprint is driven by energy costs, but concrete's CO2 footprint is driven by the chemistry of the commonly-used concrete production stages. It isn't visible in energy costs.
- sradman 6y agoPortland cement production, not concrete which consists of aggregate as well. There must be many trade offs in this design and one can imagine pure sand as ballast so the concrete plays some structural role. The sea floor anchor design and high voltage underwater cables also seem like hard engineering problems.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoMost green energy isn't feasible for today's power needs in the first world. We can't store it and they cost a lot to build in comparison to it's counter parts of coal and natural gas plants. And no more capital funding it won't fix it. Power companies hate them cause they just suck.
- adrianN 6y agoAll your points are wrong. We can store the energy in batteries, pumped hydro, hydrogen/methane, as heat and probably half a dozen other technologies. Renewables are cheaper to build than conventional power. Power companies hate them because they challenge the profitability of their existing coal plants.
- eloisius 6y agoIs gp flagged because their points were all wrong or because they violated HN rules? I’d like to see their points which you refuted rather then downvote brigaded à la reddit. Not to say I think you’re wrong or anything positive towards fossil fuels, just in principle I’d rather let someone wrong have their say and get debunked.
- adrianN 6y agoSet the showdead option in your HN settings to see flagged comments.
- eloisius 6y agoI did, and it looks like they wrote something that's just wrong, not against HN guidelines. It feels pedantic to make a stand here, but I don't think this is what flagging is for.
- philipkglass 6y agoIf you believe that a dead post should not be dead, you can click on its timestamp and then click the "vouch" link. That will bring it back from the dead.
- nhumrich 6y agoBetteridge's law of headlines claims that no, the future is not in deep water.
- epistasis 6y agoThere's huge energy potential for tethered floating wind turbines off the California coast. The costs seem to plummet far faster than even the rosiest expectations, too. A more recent auction than the Hywind project discussed by the BBC here, at Dogger Bank, has anchored turbines but is super cheap, about $50/MWh, which for the UK means cheaper than natural gas: https://cleantechnica.com/2019/09/23/uk-offshore-wind-prices-reach-new-record-low-in-latest-cfd-auction/ https://cleantechnica.com/2019/09/23/uk-offshore-wind-prices... They recently ordered 13 MW turbines, which are absolutely massive compared to the tethered 5 MW turbines at Hywind. Europe has been very quick at changing their offshore oil expertise into renewable energy know-how. The US is far behind, and though there are a few plans on the US Atlantic coast, it seems that our energy giants are determined to go down in the flames of fossil fuels rather than transition to the future of cheaper, cleaner energy that everybody else is building. They deserve their low market caps these days.
- WhompingWindows 6y agoWe also have a fractured policy landscape in the US. We have weakened federal regulations due to the denier in chief and his former-coal-lobbyist EPA director. We also have a lot of states with great renewable potential, either solar or wind, that because of their fossil industry and corruption in politics, leads to denialism and slowing of renewable progress. Contrast that to the EU, where most member states are energy importers and don't have their own fossil fuels to use. If they do, then like Germany or Poland, they still use a LOT of coal. It's easier for UK to be done with coal: they mined up all of theirs and used it already. Add these factors onto a much more literate and well-educated populace who reads about and cares about climate, and we have an EU that is leading but still not perfect. So, in general, the US has great potential, but there is definitely the most progress happening in Europe.
- dmos62 6y ago> denier in chief First time I'm hearing this reference. It's cute. > [EU/UK has] a much more literate and well-educated populace I'd like to agree that it's all well and good on this front in the EU, but recent developments like Brexit and the rise of identity politics stand as strong counter-arguments.
- DrBazza 6y agoCheck my working... The UK's national grid is currently running at about 35GW. A wind turbine, produces on average 1MW (from a potential 3.5MW with a 120m blade diameter). The turbines need to be spaced at 8x the blade diameter to be optimal, call it 1km. (edit) So at the moment, the UK needs 35,000 wind turbines to match the national grid. We'll need at least double that again to charge all electric vehicles in daily use if we get to 100% electric vehicles, e.g. only 5 million vehicles with 7kW chargers, but we have almost 30m registered vehicles in the uk. That's almost 200km by 200km of wind turbines, or 120 miles x 120 miles right now. No wonder we're putting them in the sea. I can't see all of Kent, Sussex, Surrey, Essex, London and Hampshire being covered with wind turbines somehow.
- arethuza 6y agoDemand at night is quite a bit lower than during the day and I suspect that's when most EVs will be charging - so that might help.
- DrBazza 6y agoAgreed. I used a bit of lazy maths to make the numbers match to give a simple illustration. I suspect we'll have more than 5 million vehicles charging daily, and overnight, given that there's almost 30 million registered vehicles right now. And there's also 22kW chargers as well. And year-on-year, everyone uses more electricity. Definitely interesting times ahead.
- AstralStorm 6y agoOn top of that, energy expenses for air cooling and conditioning will increase dramatically in many places due to climate change. So we probably need to triple the grid capacity. It's very hard to do that with renewables only without opening serious risks. Not impossible though. And will definitely take some long time to deploy the necessary facilities.
- aurelwu 6y ago
- scythe 6y agoOne of the most interesting potential wind sources is Lake Erie: it's relatively shallow, fresh water (less corrosion), and dotted with population centers: Detroit, Toledo, Cleveland, Buffalo, London. It's also quite windy. But I do wonder about the potential impact on fish, there or anywhere else.
- jwilk 6y agoArchived copy that works with JS disabled: https://archive.today/8LUqj https://archive.today/8LUqj
- TheHeretic12 6y agoWind power is a bad joke. In my home state, i see the things everywhere, and I know its a giant waste for one reason: steel. There are independent studies that quantify this and prove it, its been in the papers. The environmental/carbon impact of having a windmill megawatt over existing natural gas production is slim. The carbon cost of refining several dozen tons of steel and metal for the thing, ruins the benefit. The things dont work very well for the cost, and they dont last. They require service all the time. They have a crane to take the generator/transmission out of the whole thing to work on it. Whenever you consider the total "carbon cost" most of the zero emission green tech falls flat. Hydroelectric, geothermal, and nuclear are still the only commercially feasible zero carbon. Everything else is being subsidized. In place upgrades to existing fossil fuel plants is the best short-term solution. Profitable natural gas, with carbon offset trade (forestry/tree-planting) is the best long-term solution imo.
- gruez 6y ago>There are independent studies that quantify this and prove it, its been in the papers. Source? Also, there was a study[1] published recently that found natural gas polluted worse than expected. [1] https://m.huffingtonpost.ca/entry/gas-bridge-fuel_n_5f7f74f0c5b664e5babb0ea8?ri18n=true https://m.huffingtonpost.ca/entry/gas-bridge-fuel_n_5f7f74f0...
- janekm 6y agoCitation please? According to here a typical offshore wind turbine will pay back its life cycle energy cost in 0.57 years: https://www.wind-energy-the-facts.org/energy-balance-analysis-7.html https://www.wind-energy-the-facts.org/energy-balance-analysi... (0.55 for on-shore) Here is another article stating a payback time of 12.3 months: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/257564430_Life_Cycle_Assessment_of_Energy_Balance_and_Emissions_of_a_Wind_Energy_Plant https://www.researchgate.net/publication/257564430_Life_Cycl...
- sergeykish 6y agoCheck your facts [1] > The life cycle analysis focuses on the wind power plant as the basic functional object instead of a single wind turbine. Our results show that present-day wind power plants have a lifetime emission intensity of 5.0–8.2 g CO2/kWh electricity, a range significantly lower than estimates in previous studies. > Our estimate suggests that wind is currently the most desirable renewable energy in terms of minimizing CO2 emissions per kWh of produced electricity [2]. 2014 IPCC, Global warming potential of selected electricity sources [3]: +--------------------------+------+--------+-------+ | Technology | Min. | Median | Max. | +--------------------------+------+--------+-------+ | Biomass – Dedicated | 130 | 230 | 420 | | Coal – PC | 740 | 820 | 910 | | Concentrated solar power | 8.8 | 27 | 63 | | Gas – combined cycle | 410 | 490 | 650 | | Geothermal | 6.0 | 38 | 79 | | Hydropower | 1.0 | 24 | 22001 | | Nuclear | 3.7 | 12 | 110 | | Ocean (Tidal and wave) | 5.6 | 17 | 28 | | Solar PV – rooftop | 26 | 41 | 60 | | Solar PV – Utility scale | 18 | 48 | 180 | | Wind Offshore | 8.0 | 12 | 35 | | Wind Onshore | 7.0 | 11 | 56 | +--------------------------+------+--------+-------+ [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=wind+power+co2+footprint https://www.google.com/search?q=wind+power+co2+footprint [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0960148112000043 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09601... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life-cycle_greenhouse_gas_emissions_of_energy_sources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life-cycle_greenhouse_gas_emis...
- agleason 6y agoI'm curious, when wind farms do go into the ocean bed, how does it affect the ecosystem? I'm guessing it might not be a problem since I've never read about it, but it seems like it could cause reverberating problems in the ocean which is one of our biggest natural tools in fighting climate change
- taylorlapeyre 6y agoOne thing I do know is that putting tons of huge wind farms off of the coast of California would likely be a disaster for migratory birds that travel the pacific flyway down the coast, many of which are not found anywhere else in the world.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoThere's a couple of large-scale wind farms in the Irish Sea, haven't read anything about ecological impact of monopiles -- they've been used for other sea structures for a long time so longitudinal data should exist.
- sradman 6y agoSunken ships and pier pilings are generally a haven for underwater animals; this is a key principle behind the creation of artificial reefs.
- gehsty 6y agoCan’t really comment on anything above the waterline but below typically they become more attractive to marine life, basically things grow on them... if this is good or bad depends on who you talk to (eg should barren places remain barren, is increasing the amount of marine life the right thing?). I worked on a project decommissioning an oil rig d as no it nearly got canned because rare cold water coral started growing was found on the structure. Marine life is weird...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dfilppi 6y agoThey arent really defensible, so not suitable as a major source of power
- withinboredom 6y agoAs someone who used to live and sail on a sailboat by myself, this would scare the bejesus out of me in the middle of the night if it wasn’t accurately marked.
- agumonkey 6y agoAs a side effect can a network of these be used to tame floods / tsunamis ? I mean you could make them into a matrix, and use them as phasors .. much huygens corp. (let's use another kind of high grade historical figures)
- tobmlt 6y agoNice to see discussion on this topic! I worked on software to design floating wind turbines in my last job. Fun coupled dynamics/hydrodynamics here.
- julosflb 6y agoWorking also in that space, designing floaters using such tools... which software was it?