12 ms·
AT&T is selling your phone calls and text messages to marketers, how to opt out
- BrentOzar 6y agoTook less than a minute just now to opt out for all of my phone numbers. They don't give you a single yes/no switch to opt out - you have to set each phone number to "no" for each of several services - but all things considered, it was pretty quick.
- rubyfan 6y agoyou shouldn’t have to learn about this by some rando reddit post. when a company adds some new egregious monetization scheme to something that a customer has a reasonable expectation of privacy to there should be a notice to the customer.
- amelius 6y agoIn other words, it should be opt-in, not opt-out.
- disown 6y agoWell if you have credit cards and you opted out of them selling/"sharing" your data with 3rd parties, you should keep a lookout for whenever they send you a new card or an "upgraded" card or any large packet that contains a change of terms. Each time they do that, you have to call them or send them a form asking to opt-out again. That's right. Once is not enough. You have to constantly opt-out each time they send you new card agreement. If I remember correctly, you have 30 days to opt-out again or you'll be automatically part of their data "sharing" program.
- malandrew 6y agoLooks like the page is buggy. I keep getting a "Our system doesn't seem to be cooperating. Sorry for any inconvenience. Please try again later" error.
- stuff4ben 6y agoThey're getting hugged to death between Reddit and now HN. I had the same thing happen, just waited a minute then refreshed the page and was able to get in.
- conductr 6y agoYou’d think a company like ATT would build things for scale
- Nextgrid 6y agoYou significantly overestimate the engineering capability of the telecoms industry. They have very little technical skill in-house, most of the software is written and supported by their equipment suppliers (Ericsson, Huawei, etc) and the customer-facing part were outsourced to the lowest bidder years ago and never maintained again.
- dylan604 6y agoThis is typical for ATT. I get it all of the time when trying to verify my account for things like HBO Max and other networks' apps. It's very frustrating when you are wanting to watch a live sporting event they are not broadcasting and are only making available via streaming, yet you can't see it because the company that authorizes you can't be reached.
- coldcode 6y ago"This page was written by someone we got cheap and didn't check their work. Have a nice day!"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- conductr 6y ago> Our system doesn't seem to be cooperating. Sorry for any inconvenience. Please try again later That’s my experience
- wyxuan 6y agoThis is as circumstantial as it gets. I think this is happening, then I saw an ad that confirmed my original thoughts and thus this lofty claim must be true. Its similar to that Reply-All story where they looked into whether the claim that FB was listening in on people's discussion, and despite there being no physical way for it to happen, people still believed it.
- mxcrossb 6y agoIndeed we have to remember that when assessing the likelihood of a coincidence, it’s not the odds of any given event, but the odds that none of the many possible events you might recognize occur
- djsumdog 6y agoI remember that story and they really failed to make a case. With as many security experts are constantly looking at the big apps like Messenger/Insta, you think someone would notice huge packets of audio data if this was happening. I think what's much more likely is that machine learning algorithms are so good right now, they're able to determine what people are interesting in based on browsing habits and other metadata. Either that or they're using your location data and tracking what adverts people are physically seeing on signs/billboards. So you may think your app is listening to you because you get an ad for something you talking about, but you don't realize you talked about it because your brain subconsciously registered a billboard over and over again.
- nitrogen 6y agohuge packets of audio data Not that it's actually happening, but the best cell network speech codecs use ~6kbits/s, and it's probably possible to go lower with reduced speaker identifiability. You also only need to record when there's speech detected, and can delay and/or batch transmissions.
- monkpit 6y agoI don’t see why they would even have to send the actual audio bits over the wire...? Couldn’t the phone just do some work on audio and send the data after?
- dellcybpwr 6y agoHow does one opt-out when they are part of a multi-user plan and do not have access to the online account management?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- osamagirl69 6y agoI would suggest contacting your network administrator.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lights0123 6y ago> Understanding the Products, Services and offers that you, and other AT&T customers with whom you call and text and interact, might enjoy the most. We do not use the content of your texts, emails or calls for marketing or advertising. > The keyword here is content. They don't use the content of the messages and calls, just the metadata (numbers that communicated, duration, etc). That information alone could be very revealing though. https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/j9hsjz/att_is_selling_your_phone_calls_and_text_messages/g8k92n3 https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/j9hsjz/att_is_sell...
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y ago$10 says we'll find out in a few years that the content was included... and this was "just the tip" strategy.
- jchw 6y agoIANAL but that seems like something that may genuinely be a legal liability, even hating AT&T I feel a bit skeptical.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoTell you what, you can pay me your $10 out of the settlement check we'll all be getting over this.
- jm4 6y agoLook to what they do for the government now to get an idea of what they will monetize 10 years from now. Most of the crowd here is probably too young to remember when room 641A was exposed. Several years later, we had Snowden reveal even more with the prism program and bulk collection of metadata. Today, we're here discussing ATT's monetization of the metadata they began collecting and analyzing for the government. Post-9/11, the government was all about behavioral targeting to identify terrorists. Every other day, we're on here talking about Google and Facebook doing it for money. What is the government contracting for today? That's the big tech business of tomorrow.
- pavlov 6y agoAmericans like to complain about EU data protection laws because it makes it somewhat harder for your startup to handle customer data globally... But, you know, those same laws do a good job of preventing shit like this.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI kind of agree, but it seems like we ought to be able to prohibit at least the covert sale of customer data without going full GDPR. Could Americans at least try out a GDPR-lite before going all in on the more extensive provisions?
- triceratops 6y agoYou should ask your reps for GDPR because it'll be negotiated down to GDPR-lite during passage. If GDPR-lite is your opening position, you're not gonna get jack.
- lovehashbrowns 6y agoI can easily imagine the US "GDPR-lite" being something like an "independent" court that doesn't publish anything publicly except a final verdict, and companies like Facebook magically get a mix of low fines while smaller companies get absolutely fleeced on fines. And this "independent" court will mostly target Google and Microsoft while taking crumbs from Facebook. Coincidentally, Mark Zuckerberg will meet with the "independent" court frequently.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI think corporate power over our legal system is a separate problem. If we can't reign in corporations, then all hope is lost even if we magically pass full-blown GDPR (corporations will find and create loopholes, etc).
- throwaway894345 6y agoGood idea. Thanks for the suggestion!
- feralimal 6y agoMeta-data isn't count! It isn't really data. It just provides a graph of everyone you interact with. What's the problem? And anyway, phone companies have to make a buck.. Its not like we're paying them for the service!
- the_only_law 6y agoHad me in the first half
- djsumdog 6y agoDid you forget the /s ?
- fractionalhare 6y ago/s neuters sarcasm completely. In my opinion if you won't commit to being facetious online because you're afraid someone will (inevitably) think you're being serious, then don't do it at all.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoWhile I agree in general, I think HN's rules of conduct discourage posts that have even a small chance of misinterpretation. (I can't quote the specific rule, but I seem to remember this from some feedback that @dang gave me a while ago.)
- eitland 6y ago> I can't quote the specific rule, "Avoid snark" is my first guess.
- dylan604 6y agoBut if my mommy isn't hovering over my shoulder to tell me someone was making a funny, my feelings will get crushed.
- MereInterest 6y ago
- muska3 6y agoDoesn't work on prepaid plans.... Anyone know how to access this and turn it off for these users?
- mkskm 6y agoThis link was given in the thread but is limited to CA residents: https://www.att.com/cmp/ccpa/dnsatt https://www.att.com/cmp/ccpa/dnsatt
- aluminussoma 6y agoWe must not rule out the possibility that rogue apps are siphoning data for ad targeting, especially given AT&Ts Privacy Policy: "We do not use the content of your texts, emails or calls for marketing or advertising". AT&T _could_ choose to violate this policy but I imagine it would open them up to legal risk that they would not want.
- dbyrd 6y agoThey also sell this data to hedge funds who can use it to try to predict retail sales.
- fractionalhare 6y agoI'm kind of skeptical of that. Do you specifically mean location metadata (I'm aware that happens), or do you actually mean AT&T sells access to datasets which map semantic content in the call to specific brands and products? Credit card transaction data has a much higher signal for the same purpose and is just easier to work with.
- dbyrd 6y agoJust location metadata which the hedge funds overlay with known retail locations.
- RandomBacon 6y agoIs there a cell phone service that actually secures your account and data (prevents people from sim swapping, etc)?
- dredmorbius 6y agoPurism has just announced AweSIM https://puri.sm/products/librem-awesim/ https://puri.sm/products/librem-awesim/ HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24653252 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24653252
- mkskm 6y agoI'd love to use this, but it's very expensive and unclear if it works with iPhones. My T-Mobile Connect plan is $25/mo, this is four times that. Granted, this one has unlimited data rather than 5GB/mo but I don't need that.
- dredmorbius 6y agoWhich speaks to the subsidy and scale effects of surveillance capitalism.
- toast0 6y agoGoogle Fi, as a Google product, has effectively zero customer support, so I don't think an attacker could social engineer their way to a sim swap. /s, only a little.
- RandomBacon 6y agoActually, their customer service support is very good. Source: I've had to call their customer support. I had an issue with my VOIP number I ported over not working properly, they fixed it. They'll probably prevent a sim swap, but I don't know about not using my personal data.
- dredmorbius 6y agoKill your cell phone.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _mitch 6y agoDoes this include MVNOs that use AT&T's network such as Net10?
- ve55 6y agoThis is one of the many things I point to when asked questions such as "Why would you trust your VPN provider more than your ISP?"
- sarah180 6y ago"I don't trust either, but I'm confident my ISP would sell me out for 12¢ if given the chance."
- kube-system 6y agoAre you suggesting that a VPN provider couldn't do the same? Many VPN providers have been caught selling their customer data too.
- specialist 6y agoIt's my data. It's clearly valuable. I want my cut. Pay me. There are a handful of obvious, simple ways to establish and protect personal privacy: Extend property rights to all personal data. Then "privacy" is treated like every other asset, liability and protecting it is just bookkeeping. Ban targeted ads. Ban freemium. Effectively eliminates most (non-govt) incentives for aggregating PII. Require translucent database techniques to encrypt all PII data at rest. (Just like proper password persistence. Store salted hash, not the original value.) Extra credit: Federal agency for credit ratings. Hellban all the non-govt agencies.
- altdatathrow 6y agoJust wait until you find out all the trendy SaaS platforms your employer subscribes to are also having their corporate data sold.
- specialist 6y agoOf course. I should have thought of that. Ironically, now that corporations are people too, they'd also benefit from my solution. Grandpa story time: mid aughts, the company (Quest Diagnostics) that acquired us was trying to figure out how to monetize all the awesome new patient data our product was aggregating. Labs, scripts, allergies, etc. Negotiations with MS, Google, pharmas. Our Zuck and Thiel equivalents were electrified by the prospects. Us nerds were horrified. I now forget which specific ruling killed the idea. But it now occurs to me that I should have leaned in. At the time I was still trying to find, invent, steal a technical solution and had not yet figured out that's impossible.
- altdatathrow 6y agoHaha, I was not suggesting corporations should enjoy the same inherent rights as people but it’s still pretty bad. Amounts to corporate information theft sold to anyone willing to pay. There’s healthcare providers who sell patient data today still. It’s “anonymized” of course but if you want to know the history a given medication or procedure is performed on a per-patient basis, that’s all available. It’s just an anonymous identifier and somewhere someone checked a box that grants permission to resell that info, so it’s unfortunately legally acceptable under current law.
- jasonjayr 6y agoA lot of phone companies are doing this. I believe they call this data CPNI - Customer Proprietary Network Information.
- altdatathrow 6y agoSprint and Verizon and T-Mobile do this too. Sprint sells your entire app usage too, as all their hardware runs on their proprietary versions of the given OS.
- TuringNYC 6y agoCan anyone find the direct opt-out URLs for those? I've tried on two laptops and five browsers, but I cannot use Verizon's website, the auth loop spins back and forth forever. I honestly think it is purposefully half broken or half fixed so I cant cancel my account ever.
- mkskm 6y agoT-Mobile opt-out links: https://my.t-mobile.com/account/profile/privacy_notifications/advertising https://my.t-mobile.com/account/profile/privacy_notification... https://prepaid.t-mobile.com/my-profile/privacy-settings https://prepaid.t-mobile.com/my-profile/privacy-settings
- nacs 6y agoFor Tmobile prepaid, clicking the link above will take you to the main tmobile login page even if you're already logged in. To get to it, goto the prepaid link above, login, then click "My T-Mobile" in the top right, then "Notifications and privacy" then "Privacy settings".
- mkskm 6y agoThere's also another Do Not Sell My Information preference available here: https://www.t-mobile.com/dns https://www.t-mobile.com/dns
- syspec 6y agoNot on iOS
- ed312 6y agohttps://cmp.att.com/cmpportal/ https://cmp.att.com/cmpportal/ <-- this is where you go to opt out Just wanted this to be at the top in case anyone is allergic to reddit threads. Turns out my family was "opted in" even though we never gave any consent for this (and we certainly never would if asked). To quote the top reddit comment: "Get f*ed at&t"
- barlo 6y agoThanks for this! As an aside, they have a terrible UI/UX for this - it's probably on purpose. They could have easily put all of those permissions on a single page.
- ed312 6y agoIMO, the UI/UX isn't too bad (not great either). The per-line thing makes sense if you have multiple individuals on the account and want to opt in (I've never heard of such people, just saying). The toggles are straightforward although this is a rank lower in UX compared to the standard email "unsubscribe" pages, IMO. The more egregious thing is this is opt-out instead of opt-in ... probably something we need legislation to solve.
- lopsidedBrain 6y agoI couldn't actually figure out how to opt out of third-party tracking. They say I have to visit my wireless account, but not sure where to from there.
- MetallicCloud 6y agoThis post made me look into my ISP, it seems I was opted in for a bunch of nonsense as well. If anyone uses xfinity, you can opt out here: https://www.xfinity.com/privacy/opt-out https://www.xfinity.com/privacy/opt-out
- lilbaine 6y agoThank you for the link I opted out as well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kolbe 6y agoIt's erroring out when I try to change it. Feature or bug?
- etempleton 6y agoYour ISP sells your data, your mobile phone carrier sells your data and the apps on your phone sell your data. But it is anonymized so it is no big deal, right? Well, it is not anonymized enough and they sell just enough data that unscrupulous middle ware advertising companies are buying that data and then identifying user information including home addresses. I am copying and pasting another comment I made on another thread: "Companies are now promoting data services to advertisers that allow a company to install a cookie on their website and, by just having a user complete a site visit, match an IP address to a physical mailing address with claimed 90% + accuracy. Don't believe me? Check out this company: https://www.eltoro.com/ https://www.eltoro.com/. One of many companies that have recently popped up offering just such a service." This is achieved by layering user data from mobile applications and user data from ISPs and mobile carriers. Combined it is enough to do some scary stuff.
- foolmeonce 6y agoGiven that most services are unlimited, I would like more apps to maintain 10% randomized utilization.. ATT can try to find my data in the sh*t I use to bring down their network and scum bags in the desert can store my possibly encrypted 100mb/s streams indefinitely.
- pixl97 6y agoTrue random data is pretty easy to filer.... you'll never do it twice.
- foolmeonce 6y agoTrue random data is just as incompressible as cipher text so you can either save both or neither for later analysis. For searches one can derive walks and repeat them. In any case, the adversary needs to store more and more data to derive an unimproved analysis and the costs ruin their offerings.
- Balgair 6y agoRelated: Here's a giant list of opt-outs for a fair few companies: https://simpleoptout.com/ https://simpleoptout.com/
- judge2020 6y ago> DNS Error Assist > Sometimes we enter a wrong search word, or a wrong web address, or maybe the website we want is no longer in service. If this happens, the DNS Error Assist service automatically searches for similar or related terms and presents you some results that may be useful for you. Otherwise, you’ll get a “No results found” error message. Ok, I'll try to turn it off. https://i.judge.sh/early/Rose/qNw1RZCHQB.gif https://i.judge.sh/early/Rose/qNw1RZCHQB.gif Nope, it's broken.
- crystaln 6y agoHow protected are you if you use encrypted communication (Signal, WhatsApp, iMessage, ...), Safari browser with an ad blocker, and encrypted DNS (eg Cloudflare)? Also, who uses naked SMS and expects privacy??
- marketingPro 6y agoHmm wondering if I could make a bot to fake/overwhelm a system like this. Like be a rediculous demographic that doesn't exist. Bot detection is sooooooooo strong though. Especially if someone wants to stop you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lilbaine 6y agoI opt-ed out from my Comcast ISP after reading this. Next while in my Verizon account I went to my privacy settings on multiple devices, and updated browsers and I had nothing but redirect notices about not being able to connect to the site. I called Verizon, to make my concerns known and was finally sent a link via text, to finally change my settings to Opt-out. Ridiculous. Thank you for your post.
- sizzle 6y agohow do we get our elected officials to legislate against these deceptive practices?
- mkskm 6y agoThey've already started to. The only reason you can opt out is because of CCPA laws that just became effective this year.
- timewarnerscare 6y agoTo opt out of Time Warner Spectrum scaremail fill out the form at https://www.spectrum.com/policies/your-privacy-rights-opt-out https://www.spectrum.com/policies/your-privacy-rights-opt-ou... and select "Do Not Call", "Do Not Email", "Do Not Mail", and "Do Not Knock". In a few weeks you should stop receiving the envelopes that say "URGENT" or "NOTICE" with a message falsely indicating that your service could be affected.
- mleonhard 6y agoVerizon's Privacy Settings page: https://myvprepay.verizon.com/prepaid/ui/mobile/index.html#/user/privacySettings https://myvprepay.verizon.com/prepaid/ui/mobile/index.html#/... Verizon's Account Settings page has an evil dark pattern. The link to the Privacy Settings page does not appear in the menu. There is a Privacy Dashboard link which also does not contain a link to the Privacy Settings. I only found the link to Privacy Settings after submitting a request to Verizon to delete the data they have stored about me. I would switch to a mobile service provider that cared about its customers, if one existed. The options in my area are AT&T, T-Mobile, Verizon, their subsidiaries, and Google.
- musicale 6y agoThis appears to be the (confusing/dark pattern-esque) setting for opting out of "Enhanced Relevant Advertising": Allow Use of Information:[No] Restrict User:[Yes]
- adir1 6y agoThis is completely circumstantial - Did you have Amazon Alexa nearby? Or Google Assistant? More likely they "overheard" your conversation than ATT doing this.
- cmbailey 6y agoIf Verizon is your ISP (e.g., FIOS), opt-out page is here: https://www.verizon.com/consumer/myverizon/internet https://www.verizon.com/consumer/myverizon/internet Then "Manage Online Advertising Preferences" We were opted in by default. Also (they claim) you can delete previous information collected on you at: https://www.verizon.com/privacy/secure/delete https://www.verizon.com/privacy/secure/delete