11 ms·
Plan Your Route Privately: DuckDuckGo Now Has Driving and Walking Directions
- srtjstjsj 6y agoDoes the misleading "spreadprivacy" domain name really do more good than harm? It's fine to market DDG as privacy respecting, but making an astroturf "privacy advice" org is disgusting.
- the-dude 6y ago> but making an astroturf "privacy advice" org is disgusting. Why?
- nojs 6y agoI don’t get it, is it some kind of SEO hack? It’s clearly branded as DDG.
- soraminazuki 6y agoIt clearly says "DuckDuckGo Blog" in the page, so your accusation that it's deliberately causing confusion is just plain false.
- oefrha 6y agoAre you talking about the footer? A very small percentage of people would scroll all the way to the bottom especially on a relatively long page like this (5583px tall on desktop). Speaking of actually visible branding, there's a DuckDuckGo logo (without wordmark) in the top left corner and that's about it. To most people who aren't familiar with the DuckDuckGo logo, this would indeed look like the site of some privacy advocacy group. Edit: Didn't notice that the sticky header once you scroll down does say "DuckDuckGo Blog". Not sure why it can't just say that in the actual header; intentionally vague or baffling design?
- soraminazuki 6y ago> Are you talking about the footer? Why don't you look at the header? > To most people who aren't familiar with the DuckDuckGo logo, this would indeed look like the site of some privacy advocacy group. Seriously???
- oefrha 6y ago> Why don't you look at the header? And why don't you look at my comment talking about the header? > Seriously??? You seriously think more than 10% of Internet users recognize the DuckDuckGo logo? (Actually, s/10%/1%/.)
- soraminazuki 6y ago> And why don't you look at my comment talking about the header? 1. You only mentioned about it in an edit, it's disingenuous to suggest that I intentionally ignored it. 2. It says "DuckDuckGo News" even before you scroll down the page. > You seriously think more than 10% of Internet users recognize the DuckDuckGo logo? I find the accusation that DDG is engaging in "astroturfing" when they clearly identify themselves ridiculous.
- oefrha 6y ago> 1. You only mentioned about it in an edit, it's disingenuous to suggest that I intentionally ignored it. My comment was talking about the actual header in the first place. And I posted the edit about the sticky header like ten minutes before your reply. But maybe you didn't refresh the page, so whatever. If I was disingenuous I wouldn't have labelled it clearly as an edit, unlike the site which isn't clearly labeled as a corporate blog, until you scroll down. > 2. It says "DuckDuckGo News" even before you scroll down the page. "DuckDuckGo News" is only a category among many. A privacy advocacy group blog can't have a category called "DuckDuckGo News"? Hell, many people's personal blogs have Google, Microsoft, Apple, etc. categories.
- hombre_fatal 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- actuator 6y agoI have used DDG for the past five years and I like it as a hedge to keep other search engines honest but this is not in good taste. If they want a product blog, rather than using something like this as a name, they can simply do what other respectable companies do and use something like - duckduckgoblog.com - duckduckgo.com/blog/ - blog.duckduckgo.com
- Igelau 6y agoIt's a .com and the first thing you see is the duck.
- nelaboras 6y agoIt has the DDG logo at the top and speaks in "we" about DDG, not sure why it needs to be any more obvious.
- lucb1e 6y agoThe article doesn't say, but if it used an OpenStreetMap-based routing engine (which you can self-host because, y'know, open data) then the directions might misalign to the display layer which is Apple Maps. Therefore it must send your directions request to Apple. Which I guess is fine, they'll just see "some DDG user" requesting certain directions and it's definitely not the worst company they could be working with, I'm just a bit surprised that DDG went with Apple Maps instead of self hosting.
- rietta 6y agoSo much can be gleaned from the way points. Google guesses home and work with great accuracy without the need for crazy fancy data analysis.
- TheCraiggers 6y agoBut only because they can tie it to a user account. If DDG is the middleduck acting as an anonymizing layer, Apple won't be able to perform such analysis on the data. This is all conjecture obviously, it's hard to know exactly how much data Apple is getting, and if they could use something else to fingerprint users, but I'll give DDG the benefit of doubt for now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- herbstein 6y agoCorrelate navigation requests made through DDG with location data from people with less of a focus on privacy. From there you can use a social graph to narrow down who lives at a given location to a small set of people. It's a lot better than straight up telling a third party which account lives at/uses a certain location, but it's navigation is a very revealing activity no matter what.
- spiffytech 6y agoNavigation requests are very frequently home<->"place I went". Household-level driving/shopping patterns are incredibly valuable in their own right, but it's also easy for a dedicated company to tie your address to the personal identities of the residents (Apple's internal customer records, public records, private vendors whose whole business is selling this info), and then it's just profit all the way down. Hypothetically, DDG could guard against Apple having useful navigational histories for your home by seeding requests with misinformation -- artificial navigation requests Apple can't tell apart from your real requests -- but I'd be surprised if this hypothetical is actually happening.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoIt's hard to call it "private" in absolute terms when the principle of operation of the service is to send your data to a third party. Sure, it's less un-private than using the data vacuum that is Google, but it's still sharing pieces of your life with a random org.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 6y ago> If you’re using something that’s “free...,” you’re the product being sold. A lot of people still don’t realize this, or just don’t care.
- Shared404 6y ago> If you’re using something that’s “free...,” you’re the product being sold. Free as in beer, yes. FL/OSS, no.
- oarsinsync 6y agoThis statement is a lot less valuable now that your data is sold even when you’re paying for a product (eg a “smart” TV)
- newen 6y agoToo true. Corollary of "if you're using something that's free, you're the product" is "if you're using something you paid for, you're still the product". Either way, companies are incentivized to sell your data for profit.
- OnACoffeeBreak 6y agoSo true. I just had my wife and or teenage daughter watch The S Dilemma on netflix just a few hours ago. Chilling even for a techie like me. More people should be encouraged to watch it.
- nemoniac 6y agoDriving and walking but no cycling?
- diggan 6y agoDuckDuckGo seems to be a US-based enterprise (remind me again how that works with being "privacy friendly"?) so it's hardly surprising as cycling seems to be almost non-existing in most cities in the US.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoThere is less consensus on routing for cycling, no one-size-fits-all solution, because everything depends on stamina, level of comfort cycling with traffic, tire width and wheel durability. On Android, for instance, see how different the routes can be when generated by OSMAnd's in-built cycling router and when generated by the Brouter plugin (which in turn has two profiles users must choose from). No surprise that DDG doesn't want to roll out cycle routing before they can think up a UI that offers the required customizability without daunting the user.
- petre 6y agoGraphopper can give you a bike route which avoids hills, a mountain bike route which doesn't and also uses unpaved roads and a road bike route which also dorsn't but sticks to the road. It's quite good too. I used it to plan bike trips, because it also exports GPX tracks.
- 1over137 6y ago>no one-size-fits-all solution, because everything depends on stamina, tire width and wheel durability Those aren't the most important metrics. In cities at least, the most important things are: car traffic and hills. Many cyclists would rather take a slower route if there's less cars about, and to avoid biking uphill.
- a3n 6y agoWeirdness. Not familiar with the ddg maps features. Got a map and directions to where I'm going. Apple logo on the map. Fine. Clicking and zooming on the map, and suddenly I noticed I'm on a Google map with a Google url. I'll have to go slower when I have the time, and figure out if it's worth using.
- severine 6y agoWhat I'd like: - More than two points. It seems to be only start to end now. - Option to change the route manually. - Option to avoid toll roads. Great news, go DDG!
- HashingtheCode 6y agoI pity the fools who rely on these maps for real-time directions. Whatever happened to reading a map and making mental notes? What ever happened to people being able to follow street signs and using your common sense? How did we become so utterly dependent on this technology that only a generation ago was unnecessary? Driver-less cars with AI powered navigation coming to your house in the not too distant future. It will plot the most efficient course to get your meat-sack self from your house to the corner store to buy bread & milk....and you don't need to think at all about what your legs are doing. That is if you even still walk. Maybe you are so lazy you will order by the noise-polluting drone delivery service. People marvel at tech, and don't misunderstand my rant, Google Maps, Openstreet Maps etc are extremely useful in researching places, but, we should not become reliant to the point where we cannot function without them. Otherwise we are becoming mindless zombies in this ever tech-infested world of ours where we are loosing basic skills such as navigating from point A to point B. Very sad state of affairs. https://www.wired.com/2013/09/navigate-without-gps/ https://www.wired.com/2013/09/navigate-without-gps/
- Igelau 6y ago> I pity the fools I got no time for this jibba jabba!
- HashingtheCode 6y agoMr.T does not use the words jibba jabba
- ficklepickle 6y agoThis video of Mr. T saying those exact words begs to differ. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHXhGEIAXpE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHXhGEIAXpE
- HashingtheCode 6y agoNot really Mr T from the A-Team is it, but, ok, fair enough. Jibba Jabba.
- rwmj 6y agoAfter getting thoroughly sick of the full page "pop up" that Google Search and Youtube both now display on just about every visit, I switched to DDG for search and youtube-dl for YT and it's actually been great. DDG results are fine, and the !bang (!g, !w etc) makes it really easy to jump to other search engines / places if I really need it. Google have lost me as a regular customer for good.
- movedx 6y ago> youtube-dl for YT and it's actually been great I was interested in doing this too. One issue I found, however, was getting a list of my subscriptions without having to go to the website and fetch the channel IDs or video IDs for youtube-dl to then use. I also noted that youtube-dl can download from your subscriptions list directly, which is cool. I was going to put that on a cronjob and just let it milk my subscriptions on a daily basis as new videos come out. I've also been using "Clean Up YouTube", a Firefox plugin, which basically eliminates whatever you want from the UI. For me that's the home screen/trending crap, comments and just about everything. Now I only focus on my subscription feed and move on from YouTube after that. This has helped to drastically reduce the amount of crap I watch.
- aero-glide 6y agoIf you are on android, check out NewPipe https://newpipe.schabi.org/ https://newpipe.schabi.org/
- movedx 6y agoI was looking for a solution for the desktop, actually. iOS here.
- lumberjack 6y agoFYI, there are also offline and free locally running apps that you can use: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Routing#Mobile_device_software https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Routing#Mobile_device_so... I used OSMAnd and it works better than Google Maps for my area.
- im3w1l 6y agoFor me osmand works most of the time; I do find myself falling back on other services quite a bit.
- aasasd 6y agoIndeed, OsmAnd works wonders offline on phones: there's a ton of detail compared to some proprietary services, at least in some cities, and routing works fine without internet connection (with the exception of public transport when the data is not in OSM). It's not entirely free, namely map updates are limited without a subscription—though I haven't checked if it's the same with the F-Droid version.
- fuzxi 6y agoI've had constant issues getting OSMand to navigate to addresses, even after checking that the address exists on OSM. If I search for a POI, it typically has no issue finding it and routing me there, but if I enter a street address, I get nothing. Enabling online search after failing to find an address once used to work perfectly (online search uses Nominatim instead of photon IIRC), but they seem to have removed online search entirely in the last update, so now I can only navigate by POI name or cross-street. It might be better in other places, but it's a long way from replacing google maps for me.
- cacois 6y agoAccessing maps and directions through a web search, though? That hasn't made sense for years on mobile. Sad to say, they need an independent DDG Maps app to make this viable on mobile.
- goodsignal 6y agoAbsolutely agree on this. Furthermore, there's zero interactivity with the map other than zoom and pan. Maybe it's just me, but I can't click any labeled point of interest for more information. Nor can I click on a spot to set start or end locations for directions! It's surprising how non-user friendly it is at this stage.
- amelius 6y agoWith 70 million daily searches (source wikipedia), the company must be doing great. I wonder why Mozilla doesn't explore this market.
- x32n23nr 6y agoAt some point they did flirt with the idea, even invested in a search company, but then they changed their mind [0] [0] https://www.0x65.dev/blog/2019-12-11/the-pivot-that-excited-mozilla-and-google.html https://www.0x65.dev/blog/2019-12-11/the-pivot-that-excited-...
- johnchristopher 6y agoGood, I decided to finally ditch Google Maps as my usual go-to app when I need bus directions, itineraries or things like that. The app is now cluttered with too much suggestions about restaurants, places and suggestions I have no interest about on the moment. I recently re-installed Here maps (which I loved on windows mobile) and my country railway app has built-in bus data so it can help plan travels as well. I didn't saw any hints about it in the article but are they going to build an app around it ? Edit: ah, they don't have public transport schedules yet.
- hippo77 6y agoAgreed. Google Maps has just gotten worse and worse over the past 10 years, slower to load, harder to navigate.
- Liquix 6y agoOSMAnd+ has great live navigation if you care to check out alternatives.
- johnchristopher 6y agoI tried many times in the past but even though it's faster than Google maps and doesn't try to nudge me to death the UI is very cluttered (or more precisely: there are a lot of options and buttons everywhere). I think I also bought a license or a one year pass or something at some point.
- laurent92 6y agoGoogle is trying to find the saturation point where people start leaving... My annoyance is that every second trip is... back home. So with their gigawatt AI, I suppose it could have learnt. So I guess it tries to do its best to avoid me going home: typing « Home » suggests « Home Depot? home improvement? Homie restaurant? Homicide drop point? » I’m joking with the last one but Google seems to be pushing too hard to make me discover new places.
- nelaboras 6y ago
- karussell 6y agoI'll do a shameless advertisement of our open source routing engine GraphHopper as one of our main advantage over the big companies is that we do not track users. We rent our servers (not on AWS or GC :) ) and remove logs after max. 5 weeks https://graphhopper.com/maps/ https://graphhopper.com/maps/ (see our privacy policy for more details) We only keep them for debugging purposes and attack prevention. The maps layer (visualization) is done from an external company though: you can change this in the upper right corner to e.g. the original OpenStreetMap or Thunderforest. Additionally you get nice biking and hiking routes all with elevation, multiple other vehicle types like scooter or truck. And the possibility to export to GPX or using multiple via points. Additionally we try to update the road network as fast as possible (currently max. 1-3 days) from OpenStreetMap data, which is not always the case from other providers. Currently we try to revamp our UI to integrate new features like our alternative routes (you can trigger this via algorithm=alternative_route URL parameter). Now it is always important to ask the question "how do they make money?" and to understand why we can offer this all for free and even have the routing engine as open source: the simple reason is that we do not have to earn money with the end user. We created the company to push our open source projects (we also have jsprit - a toolkit for solving rich vehicle routing problems) and we try to support OpenStreetMap where we can (e.g. we are the only European corporate gold member of the OSM foundation) and do this via our growing SaaS where we sell subscriptions to many small and medium sized businesses. We do not have VC and so there is no pressure into things we don't want.
- kqr 6y agoI have only two things to say in response to this: a) I use GraphHopper with OpenStreetMap.org sometimes. It is good. Sometimes too good. Can I ask it to stick to bigger roads at the cost of other things like travel time? b) Thank you so much for bringing up the profit model and being transparent about it. Way too few people do that.
- karussell 6y agoThanks :) Do you mean preferring bigger roads for car? This is tricky as optimizing for time sometimes introduces big detours and so we consider also distance (that can take you off big roads) and so yes, we have to improve this further. At least for (small) truck we have to improve there :)
- keiferski 6y agoSomething I'd really like to see in all map apps is a "scenic" route option. Routes organized by level of traffic, nearness to parks, etc. I'm usually willing to walk/bike an extra kilometer or so if it means I'll walk through a park instead of next to a highway. Unfortunately the default/only option is always the quickest one.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoWhat does this provide over using Google Maps incognito mode feature?
- paul7986 6y agoAwesome and thanks, DDG! No longer need to use Google for all my direction inquiries. Now if you could please offer a front end email service for iCloud, ProtonMail and or other privacy centric email clients (let the user choose) and a DDG full fledged news service (it could rank news sites which are privacy centric the highest) that would rock; allow me to further separate myself from using Google & support companies who share my values in one interface!
- jhoechtl 6y agoIt is cleverly hidden that the majority of search results still comes out of Google or Bing. Of course with their blessing. It is so damn overdue to have a truly independent search engine which ranks results not based on marketing companies and paid results.
- sergiotapia 6y agoYeah how is this scalable? Are they just bleeding vc money to google/bing? If so whats the difference.
- nelaboras 6y agoI think its only bing, not Google. That said, both bing and ddg tend to give me similarly disappointing results. They just seem focused on the US and searching in any other country in English, or even dare to use another language the result quality and especially recency drops significantly.
- charliebrownau 6y agoWhy is a pro privacy site recommending DDG Instead they should be using OpenStreetMap
- kayson 6y agoI wish they had an Android app for maps. I'd love to ditch Google Maps. Does anyone know of a good, privacy-respecting alternative?
- Kliment 6y agoosmand is nice
- radicalriddler 6y agoI haven't enabled DuckDuckGo to use my location, so when I go to directions, it assumes my location is in a city near me, which I assume is based on my IP address. What's the benefit of doing this, rather than just leaving it blank? PS: Product looks really good. Really quick on Firefox, without any dumb animations like Google Maps that make it seem so much slower.
- Seb-C 6y agoThis is nice and I really appreciate the work of DuckDuckgo for privacy, but unfortunately it is not enough for me to switch from Google Maps. First, you cannot select a custom location as a target, it automatically selects a shop from a search result. I could not select my house or the closest station. Secondly, there are no public transports, so it is unusable in Tokyo.
- jdeibele 6y agoThis is cool but doesn't use my most frequent use of Google Maps or Apple Maps: checking to see where traffic accidents are before leaving. Portland has freeways running north/south (more or less) on the West side (I5) and East side (I205). Sometimes, one of them will be significantly slowed because of accidents or some other unspecified cause. After being stuck on the freeway once or twice, it's now our habit to check the route for traffic. What's normally the fastest route can be the slowest because of traffic.