7 ms·
A Coronavirus Vaccine Could Kill Half a Million Sharks, Conservationists Warn
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yostrovs 6y agoThe squalene in question that's derived from sharks has been used for decades. I've never heard of it before. Only now I do when it could be used to save untold human lives. Really?
- lambdaba 6y agoThere's some info here, I had heard of it as a supplement: https://examine.com/supplements/squalene/ https://examine.com/supplements/squalene/
- ahmedalsudani 6y agoI imagine the demand shock would be much greater given the urgency. In any case, it’s perfectly valid to think through the implications of our actions and wonder about alternatives.
- graeme 6y agoThat was my thought, but it turns out cosmetics routinely kill 2-3 million sharks per year. So instead the group is using coronavirus to bring attention to the issue. I find the ongoing cosmetics use much more disturbing, that’s a lot of sharks.
- _Microft 6y agoYou seem to imply that the use for the vaccine is something extra-objectable but the shark protection project objects to its use in general [0]. Regarding your other statements: catching 20% more sharks than before [1] sounds actually newsworthy. Furthermore you will have heard of a negligible number of all the things in existence before, no matter how well-read you are - so not having heard about something is hardly an argument for anything. [0] https://www.sharkallies.com/shark-free-products/cosmetics-what-is-squalene https://www.sharkallies.com/shark-free-products/cosmetics-wh... [1] extra demand 500,000 sharks; currently caught: 2.7M sharks annually.
- yostrovs 6y agoI have endlessly heard of the Japanese hunting sharks and whales for their soups. You'd think the cosmetics industry would have been mentioned at some point as well.
- stopthevaccine 6y ago> Really? A vaccine is not welcome. COVID-19 is the nexus of so many good things; shutting down businesses, making people stay home, giving the Powers That Be another wonderful thing to harangue and badger everyone with, mask shaming, a great campaign issue and so many others... The threat that all of these great things might eventually end with the arrival of a vaccine has turned the establishment and its fans into anti-vaxxers. Any downside to any hypothetical vaccine, no matter how tangential or far fetched, is echoed and amplified planet wide.
- dotancohen 6y agoAnd the fine article even mentions that over 5 times the quantity of sharks are killed for the cosmetic industry.
- _Microft 6y agoThe shark protection group objects to any use of shark derived squalene. The threat of even more sharks being killed serves as opportunity to focus attention on this ongoing issue.
- morceauxdebois 6y agoJust think of the long term co2 savings we could make by not stopping the virus.
- cameronbrown 6y ago"Let's save the Earth by letting loads of people die"?
- rich_sasha 6y agoBreatharianism [1] would solve global warming pretty quickly, within a matter of weeks, really. Anthropogenic emissions of CO2 would disappear. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inedia
- jedimastert 6y agoA surprising number of people hold the belief that humans should voluntarily go extinct to not destroy the planet. https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Voluntary_Human_Extinction_Movement https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Voluntary_Human_Extinction_Movem...
- JackFr 6y agoWhich is a facile, ludicrous notion on its face. Absent a human consciousness, what does ‘destroy the planet’ even mean?
- laichzeit0 6y agoLet’s be a bit more pragmatic about it: what are the typical characteristics of the “loads of people” that would be dying? Here’s a hint: it’s not the young and healthy.
- david-gpu 6y agoA society that does not protect the elderly and the sick is not a place where I want to live.
- cma 6y ago"They keep our fish stock healthy, they keep the food chain intact, they keep diseases out of other animal populations," she said. "Good luck trying to replace that when we lose them." Isn't human predation (fishing) a suitable alternative to shark predation for this purpose? I guess they eat a more wide diet of fish types.
- blablabla123 6y agoDid putting in/replacing a predator in an eco system ever work? I can only think of countless examples where it didn't
- dmos62 6y agoThere's a widely publicized example where wolves were reintroduced in a national reserve (Yellowstone National Park). The ecological effects were dramatic. Here's a quick video on it (jump to 2:35 for an even quicker viewing): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gc52l5ZcAJ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gc52l5ZcAJ0
- dmos62 6y agoHuman fishing isn't selective, not the way a predator is selective.
- taneq 6y agoHuman predation doesn't apply the same positive evolutionary pressures as apex predators. Typically predators eat the slowest, weakest, dumbest prey. Humans either target the biggest, strongest prey (if hunting individuals) or indiscriminately massacre a swathe of the ecosystem (eg. dragnet fishing).
- _Microft 6y ago"However, the extraction of shark squalene has been a more attractive option for producers as it can cost less and yield greater quantities than nonanimal alternatives." Now you've got my attention. How much larger are concentrations of this substance [0] in sharks when catching sharks and extracting it from them is easier than getting it from "[...] nonanimal sources includ[ing] olive oil, sugar cane, wheat germ, bacteria and yeast." [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squalene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squalene -- Edit: here is some information: "[...] deep-sea sharks are targeted for the squalene market because they have some of the highest concentrations of squalene in their livers, some taking up to 20% of their body weight", from https://www.sharkallies.com/shark-free-products/cosmetics-why-sharks https://www.sharkallies.com/shark-free-products/cosmetics-wh...
- twic 6y agoI don't know, but probably lower than it is in albatross vomit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stomach_oil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stomach_oil
- oefrha 6y ago> Shark Allies, a nonprofit that advocates for the protection of sharks, projects that some 500,000 sharks could be killed if a coronavirus vaccine with shark squalene proves to be effective. Already, an estimated 2.7 million sharks are killed annually for their squalene to make cosmetics, according to the group. So, why the hell not petition harder against more frivolous uses instead? This is like going after impoverished African villagers to reduce carbon emissions when Americans are driving around in big honking vehicles. (Probably not the best analogy. No interest in debating the necessity of vehicle ownership.)
- zajio1am 6y ago> So, why the hell not petition harder against more frivolous uses instead? Perhaps they did in the past but it was not newsworthy so you did not hear about that.
- DavidSJ 6y agoI'm okay with killing half a million big fish to end this pandemic.
- FiberBundle 6y agoThis pretty much sums up humanity's stupidity and ignorance given the origin of this pandemic.
- thih9 6y agoCould you elaborate? In what way? How would you proceed?
- FiberBundle 6y agoWell, my understanding is that the virus jumped from some species, which was sold under absolutely miserable conditions in a wet market in Wuhan, to humans. I find it almost comical that someone would be completely fine with more animal exploitation given that this was the reason humans were infected in the first place.
- yostrovs 6y agoJust like other theories, the wet market one has no evidence.
- superkuh 6y agoIt's more of a matter of human population expanding to cover the entire surface of the earth than anything else. There's no evidence the last SARS outbreaks in China was from wet markets. Much like there's no evidence it was from wet markets this time. Fish are very stupid animals without much brain. It is definitely worth it to kill 500k of them to help save a bunch of human lives.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoStrange, all of that seems to be wrong. It was wet markets; people are not growing populations any more; it's worth it to kill ~2 million of them for cosmetics so certainly half a million to save lives is reasonable.
- acvny 6y agoApprove. How many humans would die if they don't extract that substance?
- ThinkBeat 6y agoThere is not yet any evidence that a vaccine using shark extracts will be successful. We might be killed tens of thousands of sharks and more for a notion that it may be beneficial and in the end we killed them all for no reason. Neither of the two vaccines that are being used on a large space now contain it.
- amelius 6y agoFrom the article: > There are more sustainable squalene alternatives, said Brendl. Squalene's nonanimal sources include olive oil, sugar cane, wheat germ, bacteria and yeast.
- shekharshan 6y agoIt’s more upsetting to know that over 2.7 million are killed for cosmetics. Humans truly know how to dispense misery on mass scale.
- dotancohen 6y agoBut we only hear about it when less than 1/5 of that amount _might_ be sacrificed for human health. Stinks of agenda. Also, without context, is 500,000 a lot of sharks? How many exist in the wild? How many are needed to have a stable population? If we don't cull millions of sharks annually, what effect would that have? And what is "shark" in this context, anyway? There are dozens of fish species, at differing levels of endangerment, colloquially referred to as "sharks".
- codingdave 6y ago> Stinks of agenda. Everyone has an agenda. I don't see an agenda of conservation of our ecology as one we need to resist. Especially when their conclusion at the end is not just "Save the Sharks", but a hope that we will research other possible ingredients instead of just running with the first working prototype.
- DeusExMachina 6y agoMany agendas masquerade as "conservation of our ecology" when they are none of the sort and produce no results or even the opposite of what they claim. The fact that you like it is no reason to not look at what's behind it.
- megous 6y agoAccording to this plant based source is about 30% more expensive: https://www.sharkallies.com/shark-free-products/squalene-adjuvants-in-vaccines https://www.sharkallies.com/shark-free-products/squalene-adj... It would be kinda sad, now when governments are throwing around trillions of dollars indiscriminately, to drive more species to extinction just to save a few pennies per vaccine dose. Anyway, hopefully cosmetics use will drop while people are WFH, to offset this at least a little bit.
- jiofih 6y agoSimple: ban the use for cosmetics. Should save 2 million sharks a year if those numbers are correct.
- _Microft 6y agoAbsolutely but once you have a non-shark source for the substance, you might as well be able to replace other uses.
- hakeberio 6y agoLooking from a different angle, I can see few valid reasons for using cosmetics: 1. Cosmetics often includes medical/dermatological products which are essential for some people. 2. Cosmetics can be used not just for "vanity" but to cover big scars and other unwanted-attention-invoking skin conditions; similar to how plastic surgery may be life-saving for some folks and enable them to live a "normal life". 3. Seeking beauty/aesthetics is not a bad thing in itself I assume, though, most cosmetics are used for nugatory reasons, and we should always questions whether these above use cases really justify killing millions of animals.
- tpoacher 6y agoCounterattack: Equip Sharks with Frikkin Laser Beams (tm).
- lern_too_spel 6y agoOf the 193 vaccines in development, 5 of them use squalene (GSK, Clover Biopharmaceuticals, Seqirus/University of Queensland/CSL, Medicago Inc. and Farmacologós veterinarios SAC/Universidad Peruana Cayetana Heredia). None of those five are among the eleven that are currently in phase 3 trials. https://www.sharkallies.com/shark-free-products/could-squalene-end-up-in-a-covid-19-vaccine https://www.sharkallies.com/shark-free-products/could-squale...
- jeremyjh 6y agoThere are more than ten vaccines in mid-to-late trial stages. Maybe some use this substance, maybe none of them do. The article doesn't tell us. It would seem without that information, the rest of this content is useless.
- flcl42 6y agoIt reminds me of Rick and Morty episode, when they created cronenbergs from the humanity by applying cure which was a mix of different animals DNA. Shark included
- vaccinator 6y agoJust ban the use of this component for cosmetic purposes...