4 ms·
More than half of all whale and dolphin species are of conservation concern
- BurningFrog 6y agoIt's the nature of the modern net based news cycle that disaster stories spread far and wide, while "things are pretty OK" stories never get read. Anyway, here is the International Whaling Commission's detailed inventory of populations: https://iwc.int/status https://iwc.int/status By and large, whale populations are growing back as hunting has stopped.
- pvaldes 6y agoOnly some species. Other didn't improved in 80 years of being protected and other were extinct in our time.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoWhat whale species went extinct in our lifetimes?
- pvaldes 6y agoLipotes vexilifer
- refurb 6y agoWikipedia says it's "critically endangered", not extinct. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baiji https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baiji
- pvaldes 6y ago> Wikipedia says it's "critically endangered", not extinct. Wikipedia is wrong https://iucn-csg.org/baiji/ https://iucn-csg.org/baiji/
- masklinn 6y agoWikipedia says it's "critically endangered, possibly extinct", there have been no confirmed sightings in nearly 20 years, and a large 6 weeks survey back in 2006 turned out no living individual and declared it functionally extinct even if it wasn't technically extinct yet. Furthermore Yangtze water quality has only gotten worse since then.
- amelius 6y agoWikipedia says: > In August 2007, a Chinese man reportedly videotaped a large white animal swimming in the Yangtze. Although the animal was tentatively identified as a baiji, the presence of only one or a few animals, particularly of advanced age, is not enough to save a functionally extinct species from true extinction. The last known living baiji was Qiqi (淇淇), which died in 2002. I think the problem is that you can never really know for sure if a species is extinct. But this is pretty sad, and I wouldn't know why anyone would want to go in an argument to prove the GP incorrect.
- pvaldes 6y agoWe must take in mind that there are a second species of endangered cetacean still living in Yagtzee River, so videotaping a white animal does not mean necessarily that baiji, or even chinese paddlefish, are alive. Could be CGI or even a plastic bag. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_paddlefish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_paddlefish Even today, there are dozens of videos claiming encounters with tasman tigers, that range from CGI to dogs with painted stripes.
- slavik81 6y agoThe story of the last tasmanian tiger always makes me sad. > The last captive thylacine, later referred to as "Benjamin", was trapped in the Florentine Valley by Elias Churchill in 1933, and sent to the Hobart Zoo where it lived for three years. The thylacine died on 7 September 1936. It is believed to have died as the result of neglect—locked out of its sheltered sleeping quarters, it was exposed to a rare occurrence of extreme Tasmanian weather: extreme heat during the day and freezing temperatures at night This thylacine features in the last known motion picture footage of a living specimen: 62 seconds of black-and-white footage showing the thylacine in its enclosure in a clip taken in 1933, by naturalist David Fleay. > After the thylacine's death the zoo expected that it would soon find a replacement, and "Benjamin"'s death was not reported on in the media at the time. Although there had been a conservation movement pressing for the thylacine's protection since 1901, driven in part by the increasing difficulty in obtaining specimens for overseas collections, political difficulties prevented any form of protection coming into force until 1936. Official protection of the species by the Tasmanian government was introduced on 10 July 1936, 59 days before the last known specimen died in captivity. > The thylacine held the status of endangered species until the 1980s. International standards at the time stated that an animal could not be declared extinct until 50 years had passed without a confirmed record. Since no definitive proof of the thylacine's existence in the wild had been obtained for more than 50 years, it met that official criterion and was declared extinct by the International Union for Conservation of Nature in 1982 and by the Tasmanian government in 1986. The species was removed from Appendix I of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) in 2013. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thylacine#Extinction_in_Tasmania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thylacine#Extinction_in_Tasman...
- ironmagma 6y agoVaquita as well
- woo49 6y agothis is why nobody trusts the news. And also why global warming is so controversial. If, hypothetically, some credible scientists tomorrow did some research that showed global warming is not as bad as we thought, would that get reported widely? No way. Even if your articles are 100% fact based, selection bias in which stories to report and which to promote is a huge issue. It's why we love places like HN, also - both for the un-editorialized ranking of stories as well as the ranking of comments.
- xwdv 6y agoThere is plenty of evidence to suggest it's not as bad as we thought if you search out there. You'll never see it in the popular mainstream news though.
- matwood 6y agoPart of this is also on the readers. Science is suppose to change as more evidence comes in. But, many people for whatever reasons ignore updates unless they match their narrative. Nuance is lost.
- jhardy54 6y ago> If, hypothetically, some credible scientists tomorrow did some research that showed global warming is not as bad as we thought, would that get reported widely? Absolutely yes. It would be hard to come up with strong evidence that the hundreds (thousands?) of other papers are wrong, but extraordinary evidence would absolutely be shared widely.
- woo49 6y agoI admire your optimism. My view is that people that have bet their political or journalistic careers on a certain matter or position are very reluctant to embrace opposite facts (consciously or unconsciously). As another example - there were huge campaigns to get women to get screened for breast cancer. Turns out there is little to no benefit in doing so based on extensive long term scientific studies (very surprising to me but that’s what it is). It is taking forever for that fact to come out and it’s not even that controversial.
- Papier345 6y agoThere are plenty of really bad examples in your link. Do you think its okay to hunt down a species like a blue whale from 400k to 10-30k and say 'yeah thats okay'? There are plenty of other examples. And do you assume they grow back because of no intervention or continuous intervention? I would say its about continues intervention. Continues -> reminding people how shitty it is and that we can't accept the current state which you would say is 'pretty OK'. And don't get me wrong: Why would you even try to counter argue about something like whale rescue? Do you have the feeling that we as a society are spending too much money on rescuing and saving species versus i don't know cars? Lets give them more money, lets create jobs which are actually here to help our planet and lets do something useful once instead of writing just another backend.
- BurningFrog 6y ago> Do you think its okay to hunt down a species like a blue whale from 400k to 10-30k and say 'yeah thats okay'? This argues against something I didn't say, imply, or mean. This could be a good time for you to think about how to listen to people you disagree with in a constructive way. It's an important life skill even outside HN!
- Papier345 6y agoYou referenced 'ok news' in your comment. Thats where that one is coming from.
- dundarious 6y agoThe IWC's responsibilities are in conflict with each other. There's reasonable cause to dispute an attempt to paint a rosy picture. And are the near-certain extinctions noted in the BBC article incorrect? I don't see any reason given in your post to doubt the veracity of the BBC article's claims. So I view your comment as containing a non-trivial amount of white-washing.
- numpad0 6y agoBut what about eels and saury fish
- pvaldes 6y agoExactly the same right to be protected
- numpad0 6y agoSaury fishing is seeing historic low catch this season, price is shooting up to $60 in extreme cases from usual $1/fish. They’ll be gone much earlier than those cute whales and dolphins but there’s nothing meaningful going on https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2020/08/b67d07c2d081-japanese-households-face-high-prices-for-in-demand-pacific-saury.html https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2020/08/b67d07c2d081-japa...
- pvaldes 6y agoThey are a R type species
- AlexanderDhoore 6y agoMost of the biosphere is on the brink of some sort of extinction. We are pushing this planet to another climate regime. Prepare for the anthropocene, because it's coming faster than expected. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropocene#Biodiversity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropocene#Biodiversity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eocene#Climate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eocene#Climate
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y agoThe start of the Anthropocene is up for debate. It could be dated to the extinction of the woolly mammoth and other megafauna. It could be dated to the Industrial revolution and mass burning of coal. ( 1760-1840) IMHO, this is one plausible geologic marker at 1940-1950: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-background_steel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-background_steel
- rootsudo 6y agoI agree, interesting note about low background steel. But if it's everywhere, it's the same as counting a tree rings.
- keiferski 6y agoNot to take away from any conservation efforts to reduce or reverse these extinctions, but: is cloning a viable replacement strategy? Is it conceivable that in 100-200 years, cloning and re-introducing an extinct species will be fairly affordable (on a small scale)? Judging from this article on Wikipedia, work is underway in this field, although it hasn't been too fruitful yet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloning#Cloning_extinct_and_endangered_species https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloning#Cloning_extinct_and_en...
- pvaldes 6y agoI don't thing that cloning would be our best bet. And would be really expensive making it impractical. Specially with those huge animals. Would need incredibly complex and humongous laboratories just for trying to hold each 3000 Kg newborn. Avoiding contamination and making the embryo cameras sterile for months would be a real headache. We must forget the idea that cloning will save the day someday, be smart and use our narrow and shrinking interval of opportunity to act now.
- Santosh83 6y agoHabitats are very complex interrelationships. Even IF cloning brings them back in future, we won't have their natural habitats and niches. It's like saving the threads but not knowing how to sew them back together into a garment. That's why habitat protection is non-negotiable if we want to save Earth's biodiversity.
- faitswulff 6y agoIt’s not just the habitats that are complex, either. Intelligent mammals like whales and elephants, orcas and dolphins, actually have their own culture as well, and by culture I mean survival specific knowledge passed down between generations. Simply cloning one of these animals and dumping it into the ocean reminds me of seal conservation efforts where seals were rehabilitated and then basically dumped into the ocean and swiftly eaten by orcas. A naïve approach is unlikely to work.
- bamboozled 6y ago
- spodek 6y agoWe can dance around it all we want, but we will always arrive at human overpopulation contributing to all our environmental problems. We can fool ourselves that lowering birth rates mean lowering population. We can fool ourselves that stabilizing the population hides that we are using more than the Earth can sustain, which will lead to population collapse. We can fool ourselves that human nature requires growth yet many civilizations have stabilized populations for centuries and nations like Thailand went from 7 children per couple to under 2 in a few years purely voluntary (think the opposite of the One Child Policy, no forced abortions or sterilizations). We can fool oursleves that efficiency will lower our waste to sustainable levels. We can fool ourselves that rich nations won't feel it as much, but it will hit us just as much eventually. This community is so quick to split atoms, fuse atoms, and rocket to Mars. If we can do those things, we can globally provide the contraception and education that leads to 1.5 children per couple for a few generations, which will bring our population to sustainable.
- Santosh83 6y agoOver-population is one big elephant in the room. The other one is disproportionate and ridiculously unbalanced consumption and wealth distribution. You can never succeed in getting very poor people to care about their numbers or about the Earth.
- thebooktocome 6y agoSorry, but we're talking about whales and dolphins here. Poor people don't meaningfully contribute to the ritual overfishing of the oceans. They don't cause massive oil spills. The poor don't tend to operate the kinds of active sonar that confuses cetacean navigation. Those are decisions made by people with capital.
- Santosh83 6y agoI'm replying to the parent just above my comment who said overpopulation is the primary threat.
- sleazy_b 6y agoI’m not super educated on the subject but am I wrong to think that basically all large non-domesticated mammals will go extinct over the next few generations? It doesn't look like humans are inclined to do anything about the climate and these animals seem particularly vulnerable.
- cgh 6y agoYou are indeed wrong. Many populations are thriving. Some examples local to me: black bears, cougars, grizzly bears, various species of deer and a couple of elk herds. Climate change won’t affect these animals much, especially here in BC. They may end up migrating north a bit but bears in particular are incredibly adaptable animals.
- 411111111111111 6y agoI'm not a scientist nor have I studied ecological effects on species, but you're statement is definitely too strong. Its probably unlikely that all non domesticated animals will die in the soon (next 200yrs) future. Beyond that it's just beyond unpredictable, because the challenges of that time haven't even been identified yet.
- Papier345 6y agoWe still don't know if climate is a loos coupled or strong coupled system. Could go either way. Lets try nothing otherwise we might create a sustainable environment with healthy air, energy and more animals for nothing.
- pvaldes 6y agoNobody knows the future. Sperm whales benefit of our overfishing so they recovered really fast. Hector's dolphins are hurt by our overfishing, so they are in big trouble.
- wubbert 6y agoThe problem isn't just due to climate change. It's also due to the constant destruction and expansion into natural/wild areas.
- sradman 6y ago> By far the biggest threat is becoming accidently captured in fishing equipment and nets, which kills an estimated 300,000 whales, dolphins and porpoises a year. I suspect that focusing on this one area will have the greatest positive outcome. I’d like to see a better data-centric analysis; dolphin safe campaigns have sufficient history to draw from. Saving river dolphins in highly urbanized areas might be beyond any reasonable effort. Saving every traditional habitat, such as the St. Lawrence River for belugas, might also distract from ensuring sustainable habitats exist for each species with a broad range.
- beervirus 6y ago> 300,000 whales, dolphins and porpoises Pretty sly lumping them together like that. There are a zillion dolphins, and it’s probably almost all them getting caught.
- sradman 6y agoThere are a zillion dogs and cats in the world too but I'd rather that they didn't die prematurely due to a panicked and prolonged suffocation. Supporting a charitable interpretation of your criticism, the BBC article is much closer to advocacy journalism [1] than investigative journalism. To be equally fair to the BBC, they are accurately describing the language used in the scientist's open letter The Real and Imminent Extinction Risk to Whales, Dolphins And Porpoises [2]. Like all complex issues, trade-offs exist and we could all benefit from more critical thinking. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advocacy_journalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advocacy_journalism [2] (PDF) https://www.mammalresearchinstitute.science/s/Scientists-Sign-on-Final-01-October_MasterDocument.pdf https://www.mammalresearchinstitute.science/s/Scientists-Sig...
- beervirus 6y agoI was suggesting that the language in the letter was sly, not that the BBC was.
- princevegeta89 6y agoJust ended up watching David Attenborough: A life on our planet on Netflix. It truly opened my semi- open eyes permanently. It is a brilliant one and I urge everyone to watch it to see where we're headed. I took a pledge to go vegetarian and this time for real. There is definitely something all of us can do and I think collectively we can stop the slaughter our planet is going through.
- bengale 6y ago> "Let this be a historic moment when realising that whales are in danger sparks a powerful wave of action from everyone: regulators, scientists, politicians and the public to save our oceans," said Mark Simmonds. Even our own extinction doesn't seem to spur much effort, I'm not sure why there is an expectation whales would.
- sawjet 6y ago> > "Let this be a historic moment when realising that whales are in danger sparks a powerful wave of action from everyone: regulators, scientists, politicians and the public to save our oceans," said Mark Simmonds. > Even our own extinction doesn't seem to spur much effort, I'm not sure why there is an expectation whales would. > > "Let this be a historic moment when realising that whales are in danger sparks a powerful wave of action from everyone: regulators, scientists, politicians and the public to save our oceans," said Mark Simmonds. > Even our own extinction doesn't seem to spur much effort, I'm not sure why there is an expectation whales would. Considering the human population is at an all-time and expected to increase significantly in the next 20 years, especially in locations with poor healthcare. What are your arguments that the human population has to worry about going extinct?
- cableshaft 6y agoIf we wipe out the vast majority of the animal and plant life and drinkable water on the planet, how likely do you think we will keep our population at an all-time high? I think it's certainly possible you're right that population will keep increasing for the next, well, 10 years at least, maybe not 20, but meanwhile we're cratering our biocapacity, and we are not going to have anywhere near enough resources left on the planet to sustain that population if we keep going on our current trajectory. There's quite a few experts that say it's already too late, we've already depleted our biocapacity too much, the only way to correct for it is to undergo some form of rapid decline at some point in the future (collapse). I found this video incredibly illuminating on that point (I honestly thought we were still under the limit before watching it, not way past it already): https://youtu.be/qPb_0JZ6-Rc https://youtu.be/qPb_0JZ6-Rc Extinction may be a bit extreme, humans might be able to survive somehow, but the vast majority will not. Here's one article that discusses the possibility of human extinction. Key quote: "I don’t want to claim that we can’t survive the loss of many, many species. We’ve already proved that we actually can. We’re very adaptable. But I think the bottom line is, you wouldn’t want to find out." https://www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/environment-and-conservation/2017/10/will-humans-survive-sixth-great-extinction https://www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/environment-and-conserv...