5 ms·
Amusingly, in high school my physics teacher told the class a story about how things had become so complex that no single person could understand everything abo
by dboreham 6y ago
Amusingly, in high school my physics teacher told the class a story about how things had become so complex that no single person could understand everything about the classroom computer.
That was in 1978 and the computer was an Apple II.
- WalterBright 6y agoIt was entirely possible in those days to understand everything from transistors, to digital logic gates, to flip-flops, to clocks, to adders, to registers, to 8 bit computer chips, to assembler, to the primitive BASIC on an Apple II.
- jacobush 6y agoBut how transistors work is very sketchy to me
- WalterBright 6y agoYou really need a course in Quantum Mechanics to understand it. But a workable description is a couple pages in most electronic textbooks. MIT covers it in their first course in electronics on Youtube.
- agumonkey 6y agoQM would be ultimate foundational understanding. A transistor is a valve. Here, problem solved :D
- cinntaile 6y agoA generic course in QM won't really help you understand electronics any better. Perhaps if you have a background in electronics or if the course makes attempts to link QM with electronics but otherwise it's just relatively abstract physics.
- selecsosi 6y agoI don't know any program of study that would get sufficiently deep enough to get to semi-conductor quantum tunneling (year 2/3 class) without having some foundational E&M to motivate the QM to begin with (pure math here being a more exceptional but rare case). I think the beauty of QM at that point is that it looks and feels a lot like differential field work of EM and Lagrangian mechanics but maps to quantized numerical spaces, where jumps and little shoots like that happen all the time (spontaneous crystal domain alignment in magnets for example). If you were able to get sufficiently skilled in intro QM, it would absolutely help study in E&M. If you E&M questions are just node solving, linear algebra and difeq is all you need for E&M to solve "most" work. You do a lot of specialized versions of that in QM and as mentioned above the people doing the actual semiconductor design are so highly specialized that they are often not transferable to other problem domains and require fundamentally different approaches. Not sure any non-PHD study will really help one advance the field in a meaningful way. Study of QM i would say sufficiently enriches all physics verticals that if you are capable, it's worthy of individual pursuit, but also makes total sense to study as part of a curriculum taking place after intro E&M. Quantum Tunneling in everyday life: https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/how-quantum-mechanics-lets-us-see-smell-and-touch https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/how-quantum-me...
- cinntaile 6y agoNow that you mention it. After the QM course there was a solid state physics course where quantum effects show up and where it's applied to electronics/semiconductors.
- WalterBright 6y ago> A generic course in QM won't really help you understand electronics any better. Caltech had an elective course for freshman about how semiconductors worked up through flip-flops and registers. I took it. It involved QM and yes, tunnelling. So it's doable for mortals.
- cinntaile 6y agoYes, I can see how it would help there. I was more thinking of the situation where you take a QM course and don't apply it to an electronics problem. I agree that it's doable for mere mortals, but it might take a fair bit of time!
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoDo FETs really require QM to understand them?
- WalterBright 6y agoThe handwavy explanations you'll find in electronics textbooks are sufficient to enable you to effectively design electronic circuits around them. But personally, I found those explanations inadequate.
- amelius 6y agoYou need QM to even explain why electrons don't fall into the nucleus. So I'd say if you want to understand anything then you need QM. There's this quote which I think applies here: if you want to bake an apple pie from scratch, you first need to invent the universe.
- WalterBright 6y agoTrue, but transistors do not behave in a newtonian physics manner, whereas we do just fine understanding most physics using conventional newtonian mechanics.
- amelius 6y agoThis makes me wonder what Newtonian physics we actually use in computing?
- WalterBright 6y agoNon-transistor electronics relies on Maxwell's Equations. While not Newtonian mechanics, it is part of classical (pre-Einstein) physics.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoYou can get a hand-wavey understanding quite easily. Digital circuits use a fairly simple model, and that's not difficult to pick up. Analog circuits can use a number of more complex models, and they're more of a challenge, depending on what you're trying to do. Actually designing transistors - defining dopant levels, topology, and process steps - is a very specialised skill that very few people have. And modern PC motherboards are marvels of electromagnetic engineering as well as electronic engineering. You have GHz signals running reliably on circuit boards with multiple layers. Getting those to work is another very specialised skill. So it would quite something to find someone who had a professional-level understanding of all the levels: from silicon chemistry and quantum physics at one extreme, to electromagnetic design, to all the different levels of electronic design, to binary machine language and processor architectures, to OS design and application software, to all the various data structures and encodings that make all of the above useful.
- bserge 6y agoKind of blew my mind when I learned they are analog... I previously thought of them as one of the most basic digital components, because they're used in every digital circuit.
- dekhn 6y agoI don't know that there is anything truly digital in the universe, except perhaps quantized components like spin. Digital computers are an abstraction implemented using error control and a number of other things, but they ultimately fail like analog objects.
- tasty_freeze 6y agoMy job for the past 30 years has been designing ASICs, so all the analog stuff is not my concern. Prior to that I designed at the TTL level. I'd spend months working on some project, thinking in terms of logic an timing, and eventually we'd have boards made. We'd stuff a few prototypes and set them up on the lab bench to commence debugging. Every time at this phase I'd suffer the existential horror the first time put an oscilloscope to the circuit -- the clock wasn't square! Signals would ring, and other signals which hadn't transitioned would sometimes bounce a bit. Setup and hold times could be pretty well estimated, but it was still an estimate. Then there were phantoms that might appear on the scope or real issues that would not show up on the scope because the probe lead was enough to make what was measured not the same as what was actually going on.
- WalterBright 6y agoThat reminds me of working on the stabilizer trim system on the 757. I got used to thinking of the parts as rubber, bending and twisting on the high loads an airplane has in flight. So much so that when the hardware was finally available, I was surprised at how rigid and immovable it felt under my hands with my puny human strength.
- bserge 6y agoWay over my head, but damn it sounds interesting :D
- 6y ago
- amelius 6y agoNowadays you'd have to know how a modern lithography machine works. There's a reason why ASML is a highly valuable company. You can perhaps understand the basic ideas, but to implement them is another matter entirely.
- dboreham 6y agoWell yes, as a kid at the time I remember thinking I understood pretty much all of it except the switched mode PSU and Woz's wacky floppy controller.
- dekhn 6y agoWhat about hi-res graphics? Apple II hi-res graphics were especially wacky.
- WalterBright 6y agoWoz could understand it. After all, he invented it. He wrote the code for the Apple II. I bet he understood every aspect of it.
- mcguire 6y agoSure. It's just quantum mechanics, classical physics, electrical engineering, and computer science.
- WalterBright 6y agoQM and classical physics courses (2 years worth) are required of every Caltech student, as they are considered foundational. EE and CS are optional, of course, but not a problem to take. I admit I struggled with QM.
- falcor84 6y agoThat's a surprising example. From reading his autobiography and other sources, it's my impression that by virtue of having designed it from the transistors to the software, Steve Wozniak did in fact grok it fully.
- taneq 6y agoOk, so maybe one single person...
- p1esk 6y agoWozniak has not designed it on the transistors level, he used MOS Technology 6502 microprocessor. Though I agree he could probably understand it on the transistor level if he wanted/needed to.
- dboreham 6y agoYou misunderstood my post. The point was my teacher was wrong then and possibly similar assertions now could be wrong too.
- falcor84 6y agoAh, that went entirely over my head then.
- nullc 6y agoWhat we can understand is partially a product of how good we've become at teaching it.
- jdmoreira 6y agoExcept multiple people understand everything about the Apple II :)