11 ms·
Purism – Fund Your App
- gjsman-1000 6y agoWhen I see things like this, and aweSIM, and the not-yet-materialized Purism USA Edition (and the price tag associated with that), and the exposé by a former manager, and their unethical resale of open source software... I can't help but wonder how well Purism is doing, financially speaking. It seems desperate.
- raspyberr 6y agoWhat part of their reselling open source software is unethical?
- pigeons 6y agoThe part people objected to was when they weren't disclosing the names of the upstream projects they were branding.
- pengaru 6y agoI agree on all points except "unethical resale of open source software". If they comply with the license there's nothing unethical about it. Selling open source software is one of the valid ways open source reaches end users. Users/Consumers want to buy polished, maintained, and supported things. That costs resources to provide. From a user perspective, having a preference for FOSS software shouldn't limit your options to unsupported abandonware you couldn't pay for if you wanted. Recall the F in FOSS is Free as in Free Speech, not Free Beer.
- m463 6y ago" Many people believe that the spirit of the GNU Project is that you should not charge money for distributing copies of software, or that you should charge as little as possible—just enough to cover the cost. This is a misunderstanding. Actually, we encourage people who redistribute free software to charge as much as they wish or can. If a license does not permit users to make copies and sell them, it is a nonfree license. If this seems surprising to you, please read on." https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html
- throwawa3495 6y agoI dont care about the cost or any of the pysops from you google and apple employees. I want to see and support more free software mobile operating systems period.
- m463 6y agoActually - it would be good for google/apple employees. There is nothing worse than working at a company without robust competition. Work at a company that has to compete and it removes tons of management and mba bs employees have to deal with.
- jamil7 6y agoHow does one actually build native apps for the platform? I couldn’t really tell last time it was posted. Are they QT based?
- GranPC 6y agoThey're the same as native Linux desktop apps. For the most part they're using GTK3 with libhandy, but it's also possible to run Qt apps, or any other toolkit really.
- fsflover 6y agohttps://puri.sm/posts/easy-librem-5-app-development-screen-recorder/ https://puri.sm/posts/easy-librem-5-app-development-screen-r...
- m463 6y agoalso https://wp.puri.sm/posts/easy-librem-5-app-development-flashlight/ https://wp.puri.sm/posts/easy-librem-5-app-development-flash...
- RandomBacon 6y agoI'm 100% behind Purism and the Librem 5 project (placed my pre-order three years ago), but the "Hold My Order" seems pretty ridiculous. I don't think they should have made that an option at all. I think this is actually my first criticism of Purism/Librem. They should have just wrote something like: When the software you donated for is ready, rest assured your Librem will receive the update. Librem 5 is the only phone that gets better with age... (some marketing they've used in the past)
- bszupnick 6y agoI kind of appreciate that they gave the option. If having X app is a blocker for someone to using the phone, instead of having it sit in my underwear drawer until that app is ready, I'd rather wait for later versions of the phone and more kinks to be worked out. In my mind giving someone options isn't a bad thing.
- amosbatto 6y agoIt also gives Purism some idea where to focus its development efforts, since Purism literally has a thousand problems to solve so it has to prioritize what is truly important and what can wait.
- minimalist 6y agoThis is good! Hopefully Purism can build on their recognition to funnel resources toward FOSS-mobile applications because this will help us all. This reminds me of something else. What would be the best model for a FOSS "app store" with mechanisms for compensation? Lowering the barrier for transactions to FOSS projects really helps their survival and sustenance by individuals who cannot contribute code. Here's a very half-baked thought: One can imagine users supporting community servers (matrix, activitypub/mastodon, etc.) and applications through a cryptocurrency wallet that is loaded in the same way that people load their g--gle/a--le wallets. One can also imagine applications that can tie into this wallet to compensate publishers based on some model (a transaction API like g--gle/a--le or something like what brave is doing with the BAT). My question is what are the failure modes of such a model? For example, this still wouldn't stop the perverse incentives of: - Content publishers going for the types of bait that generate the most clicks. Clicks=compensation regardless of it's from ads or some sort of attention token. - Application developers casing addiction mechanisms that go after whales. The same loot-box mechanisms can be implemented with a FOSS game that uses a crypto wallet API.
- db579 6y agoI'd be interested in a Purism app store that charges a small fee per app "purchase". The apps would be Libre so nothing stopping people packaging/compiling etc themselves (or getting from an alternative source) but to me the convenience of having that done already and curated/integrated would be worth a couple of bucks per app and even if it was optional, just having the default be paying a small fee might give enough of a nudge in the right direction.
- greggyb 6y agoI'd be happy to use an app store that tracks active screen-time per app and disburses a monthly "subscription" proportionally to the developers of all the apps I use. I don't have any concern about the type of currency used to pay. A quick check of my screentime over the past few days shows only two apps which wouldn't benefit from this: DAVx and Syncthing. Both of these are essentially daemons I configured once, and ideally never see the app interface of ever again until I get a new phone. Otherwise, apps I benefit from are represented in the screentime of the past couple days.
- fit2rule 6y agoThis looks pretty great, and shows progress towards becoming a replacement for my iPhone - but, one question - what are these apps? Am I missing the ability to navigate to a page describing each of these apps? I can probably guess what some of them are, but doesn't it seem a little strange to have a list of apps, but no descriptions for the apps available? (On Safari, MacOS, in case its just an anchor bug..)
- fsflover 6y agohttps://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/List-of-Apps-in-Development https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/List-o...
- amelius 6y agoI think our best bet to end the duopoly of Apple and Google is to have a cross-platform language that runs on all platforms (iOS, Android, and perhaps the web). The reason is that there will otherwise be important apps that never end on anything other than Apple or Google OSes, like (for example) bank applications, government apps (for taxes, alerts, covid tracking), perhaps things like netflix or perhaps the BBC news app. Also, why would developers spend time developing for an open platform, when they can make 10X the amount of money on the closed platforms? So effectively, we need the spirit of the web, but in the app stores. (I know, this sounds a bit like embrace, extend and extinguish; but this time it's from the "good" side :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- KarimDaghari 6y agoThe power of the web is that it’s accessible from ANY platform and there’s already an app to use it which comes preloaded with whichever platform you’re in: the browser. That said, native app performance is still unmatched (but not by a long shot!) the react-native project (both by FB and MSFT) looks promising.
- amelius 6y agoThere's also Flutter, interestingly by Google (not sure what their strategy is here, as their main interest should be to keep the world's information indexable which becomes difficult when people use more native apps as opposed to the web).
- searchableguy 6y agoThey are already able to index mobile apps fine though.
- t0astbread 6y agoThis sounds a bit underwhelming but I think web apps (in the system browser), Electron and Cordova are as far as we'll get in that direction. (If you exclude projects that are technically more "elegant" but never used in the wild.)
- gaius_baltar 6y agoWhat I think is that Purism got it wrong by creating its own mobile distro instead of starting from a pure-FOSS Android (AOSP) and patching the missing things with thinks like microG, better permission system, isolation and ways to force closed source apps to behave and obey the user (app wants my address book and refuse to work if I deny it? Nice, take this randomly generated list of names and numbers! Location? Take this random place. Phone or cell ids? Take this random stuff...) Advantages is that they can start with a bunch of free apps (F-droid is nice!), do not get too far from what SoC vendors already have and can move to another distro (even running both them in parallel) once they sold a good number of devices and the business is sustainable. All while respecting user freedom even when they really need some proprietary stuff (e.g. bank apps). But, well, that ship has sailed. Let's see what we can do.
- slothtrop 6y agoEschewing Android for an actual Linux OS was the point. Alternative Android distros have been around a long time. The link addresses one point about apps: "With the Librem 5 phone you are running a full-blown desktop computer in a mobile form factor. If you plug it into a keyboard, mouse, and monitor you will have PureOS and the many thousands of applications available as you would from any desktop computer. This means that we are starting with many thousands of applications that “just work” as a desktop application" Besides web apps and dedicated apps, you can also just run anbox if you want something from F-Droid.
- gaius_baltar 6y ago> Eschewing Android for an actual Linux OS was the point. Alternative Android distros have been around a long time. Correct, but we have Android _distros_ not phones that support them well. We need to get some expensive phone from a supported list, unlock it (losing warranty in the process) and flash the distro. Not a thing we can say to even technical users who are not really inclined to HW hacking. To say nothing about the non-technical people who are the ones more vulnerable to the current mobile environment.
- 6y ago
- n_io 6y agoBeen wanting to buy this phone for awhile but it feels like every time I visit the Librem 5 page the release date is always 6 months out...
- m463 6y agoYeah, I hear you. They announced the phone in august 2017 and I ordered in september. By october they had collected $1.3m in orders. and my ship date has always been a few months out. :)
- amosbatto 6y agoCurrent shipping date is estimated at mid-to-late November 2020. It is definitely getting closer. I try to keep the community FAQ up-to-date, if you want current info: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
- NoInputSignal 6y agoIsn't part of the beauty of app sandboxing in android how it leverages the concept of users in *nix OS? IRC, each app is considered a user to the OS. Does anyone know what they mean when they say that Apps will be sandboxed? It can't be similar if the phone is running a desktop OS masquerading as mobile OS.
- weikju 6y agoThey probably mean Flatpak sandboxing, with all the implications good and bad of Flatpak.
- amosbatto 6y agoThe Librem 5 apps will use flatpack with bubblewrap. See: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#43-how-secure-is-the-librem-5-compared-to-an-android-phone https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
- zuhayeer 6y agoI'm curious how big the Purism team is? I see 11-50 on Crunchbase. If so, that's pretty impressive!
- fsflover 6y agohttps://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#85-who-works-on-the-librem-5 https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
- intricatedetail 6y agoWhat is the difference between puri.sm vs Google regarding privacy? Won't user data end up on one of their servers? Can I self host the phone ecosystem? (For example having my own app "store" or maps)
- m463 6y agoThe best way to think of it is that Google is an identification service. They make their money by identifying who you are, and creating a datastore with as much information about you and your activity as possible. This is both online data and offline data. Online data is collected directly via google services and indirectly services like google analytics, google javascript libraries, google fonts, recaptcha and more. Offline data is also purchased and stored, for example consumer credit card purchase data. Given that, it is clear that every free service they offer can be funded by data collection. Are your kids using google docs? Do your friends email you from gmail? do your coworkers use google sheets? Ok, so purism doesn't make its money from data. It makes its money from selling you a phone. This is a lot less money than google makes, because you pay it directly to them. They can't turn around and get millions from advertisers. On the other hand, because data is not their revenue stream, they don't care if you store your mail on their servers or on your own or where you get apps or even what OS you run. So there's no need for dark patterns to get you to interact with them. Yes, you could have your own store. You could have your own OS. You can create and maintain and share your own maps or data or whatever. Actually linux people have been doing this for years and years. check out nextcloud.
- fsflover 6y agoPurism is a Social Purpose Corporation, not simple purely profit driven company: https://puri.sm/about/social-purpose/ https://puri.sm/about/social-purpose/.
- amosbatto 6y agoA lot depends on what online services you are using. The goal of Purism is to provide a suite of online services at Librem One (https://librem.one/ https://librem.one/) so you don't have to share your personal data with Google, Facebook, Twitter, etc. Also see: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#4-privacy-and-security https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
- Valkhyr 6y agoI love this. As a backer who will hopefully get my phone in the next few months - and who understands that the software is an ongoing piece of work - I am happy that I have the ability to put my money where my mouth is when it comes to asking for some feature. I will probably mostly donate for battery life improvements, and other system wide improvements. If anybody from Purism is reading this, I would suggest having "Software Keyboard" as an option - in particular I would love to see the keyboard become more suitable (than what I have seen in videos so far) for terminal usage/programming without an external keyboard. Think Hacker's Keyboard on Android, if you are familiar with that. Basically shrinking a full PC keyboard into a touch keyboard.
- amosbatto 6y agoThe recent versions of Squeekboard have a full keyboard like Hacker's Keyboard in Android. See: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/squeekboard/-/merge_requests/368 https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/squeekboard/-/merge_requests/...
- bonkabonka 6y agoI didn't see an app for CalDAV/CardDAV syncing on the list. Perhaps that's so fundamental it doesn't need mentioning?
- samoa42 6y agoironically ios has this built in and one can sync contacts/calendar from iphone to $selfhosted without even touching the app-store. not so for android
- JetSpiegel 6y agoYou can install DAVx5 from F-Droid not touch the Play Store. Not outside the box, but FLOSS.
- bonkabonka 6y agoYeah, I bought the DAVx/ICSx pair (as well as CalDAV-Sync and CardDAV-Sync pair) to get Android syncing. I found it more understandable than when configuring Fastmail on iOS given the way Fastmail makes you (or made when I initially set it up years ago) use separate app-specific passwords.
- linmob 6y agoCalDAV/CardDAV exists and works through GNOME Online Accounts for Nextcloud/OwnCloud, and there is an issue to support other solutions: https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-online-accounts/-/issues/1 https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-online-accounts/-/issue...
- bonkabonka 6y agoAha, thank you for the pointer to that!
- SebastianKra 6y agoThe Purism Website failed to convince me that this project has even a chance of becoming an enjoyable alternative. Not only doesn't it show many features or screenshots of apps, the things it does show are better at demonstrating its weaknesses than strengths. For example, theres a link to a Video about running Firefox [1] that reads like a parody. At one point, the narrator says enthusiastically: "With the settings unusable in portrait, it's time to switch to landscape mode" Thankfully, they also offer an optimised browser, but the fact that they mention Firefox at all, demonstrates a lack of understanding about what users want from a phone. [1]: https://puri.sm/posts/desktop-firefox-in-your-pocket-with-the-librem-5/ https://puri.sm/posts/desktop-firefox-in-your-pocket-with-th...
- fsflover 6y agoThis phone is still work in progress, but it progresses at a fast pace. The very fact that you can smoothly run desktop Firefox with all plugins on a phone is a huge thing. There is no need to write new applications, just adapt the existing ones. If you want more pictures and videos, look here: https://forums.puri.sm/t/librem-5-media-photos-and-videos https://forums.puri.sm/t/librem-5-media-photos-and-videos. > The Purism Website failed to convince me that this project has even a chance of becoming an enjoyable alternative. Maybe this could convince you: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#11-why-buy-the-librem-5 https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque....
- SebastianKra 6y agoI carefully chose the word "enjoyable". I absolutely see the appeal, and I do want this project to succeed. I also understand, that it's a work in progress. However, from my experience, I believe that Linux is simply not enjoyable to use. Other operating systems provide advanced features out of the box, such as clipboard-history, clipboard-sync, PiP, powerful search and more. In Linux, you may need to use the command line to arrange your screens [1]. The Website should have convinced me, that this project is built by a company that cares about usability just as much as they care about privacy and openness. Instead, I get the impression that it's only for the most determined of linux users - you know... the kind that would wan't desktop firefox on their phone even if it's almost unusable. > There is no need to write new applications, just adapt the existing ones Yes, in theory this is great. But in practice, on my Surface, it never worked. The Interface was laggy, buttons were hard to hit, the touch keyboard didn't appear when it was supposed to, smooth zooming in Firefox didn't work. The difference to an iPad was like night and day. [1]: Source: Watching a coworker use Linux for the first time. I don't remember the distro.
- can16358p 6y agoAm I the only one who thinks this project will never succeed? I mean, don't get me wrong I want it to succeed, but in this ecosystem of apps/capitalism, and Apple/Google duopoly, I see no chance of an open project like this going mainstream, and the intersection between the tech enthusiasts (as I really don't think this project is aimed at the non tech-savvy) and who actually would want to replace their phone with this isn't enough (HN community isn't a good KPI for this, obviously. We need to check out the general audience) to support the costs. I'd like to be proven wrong though.
- fsflover 6y agohttps://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#83-why-will-the-librem-5-succeed-when-previous-linux-phones-failed https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
- can16358p 6y agoWell, I've read it, but didn't even convince me a bit. All the reasons that they claim for succeeding against Android and iOS are very, very niche corner cases where 99.9% of users don't care about.
- linmob 6y agoThis is great news and I like that Purism are announcing this. They had previously announced (I can't find it on their blog unfortunately) a flatpak based App Store which is hopefully soon to come. What I miss: What is the developer story here? Their team , even though it had 2 additions recently, is not very big with 9 people who focus on software. Also they aren't particularily open as to what already works and does not work, which – as the Librem 5 is not widely available yet, nor thoroughly reviewed (still waiting myself, having a PinePhone though) – is a problem. If you want to have an overview about which apps already exist, I maintain a list at https://linmobapps.frama.io https://linmobapps.frama.io. It's not very good at monitoring the actual state of the apps and does not look to good. If you have ideas on how to (or want to help) improve it, please get in touch!
- amosbatto 6y agoIf you want a list of the apps for the Librem 5, see: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#31-what-apps-will-be-available-for-the-librem-5 https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque... (in the first link, it tells how ready the software is to be used in the Librem 5, and that list is maintained by the developers so it should be up to date.) You can also try out recent images of the Librem 5 to see what apps work: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#33-how-can-i-check-the-progress-of-the-librem-5s-software-development https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
- linmob 6y agoThanks. I will check that list again (which should be linked on LINMOBapps already), there seem to be some games (and maybe more) that I have not added to my list (mostly because I just don't care about games). What I meant with "state" is stuff like: Does it crash? Is it "feature complete"? Most rating systems (including the one on MGLapps/LINMOBapps) seem to look at "does this fit the screen" more than these aspects, and it is virtually impossible to fit this all into one score.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jolmg 6y agoWould "porting" Whatsapp mean that the end result would be able to communicate with users using Whatsapp on Android, or would it just be Whatsapp on an entirely separate network, like Signal? The former is a lot more valuable to me than the latter.