6 ms·
> unblockable advertisements in our near future. Why? The user agent will still be able to choose what to display, and protocol improvements don't prevent you
by tialaramex 6y ago
> unblockable advertisements in our near future.
Why? The user agent will still be able to choose what to display, and protocol improvements don't prevent you choosing an agent that has your interests at heart.
Using secure transport means nobody else gets to decide, and I certainly have a long list of people I don't want deciding whether I see things, so that helps.
- swiley 6y ago> The user agent will still be able to choose what to display, Will it? Even on Mozilla Firefox (which fewer and fewer sites are tested against) you're pretty limited in controlling this. I have zero faith that google will keep that working in chrome
- Liquid_Fire 6y agoCan you clarify how you are limited? I can block anything I want using uBlock Origin today in Firefox. Admittedly sites could switch to rendering everything in JavaScript using canvas or WebGL. But so far no one is resorting to this, because you have to effectively reimplement big chunks of the browser. Maybe one day there will be a JS framework that does this, but then it will be easy for adblockers to target that specific framework.
- throwaway2048 6y agoChrome is also crippling adblockers, plenty of websites are already chrome only, and I'm guessing if you can ensure ad delivery, a whole lot more are going to jump on that train.
- mixedCase 6y agoThe easy way out is to choose a different Chromium fork that has your interests at heart.
- mrec 6y ago> a different Chromium fork Well, that's a depressing sentence to read. The vultures may be circling, but Firefox isn't dead yet.
- garmaine 6y agoFirefox has been a dead browser walking for a number of years now. I don’t like this any more than you, but it’s the truth.
- dont__panic 6y agoI'm not sure if this is true -- there was a dark time during the period where Google started to advertise Chrome on literally all google websites, but all of the internal refactors and engine improvements over the past 2-3 years have made an enormous impact on my user experience. And as far as I'm concerned, Firefox isn't dead as long as there isn't a viable replacement that: - doesn't update via a sketchy background process (Google Updater, or whatever they've renamed it to this month to avoid scrutiny) - allows me to customize the UI to fit my needs (tree style tabs are an absolute must for me) - allows me to use a full ad blocker like uBlock Origin instead of arbitrarily limiting the ad blocker API to advance the interests of advertisers Of course, Firefox's management is an enormous problem, from the way they've prioritized features to the recent layoffs to the enormously stupid decisions (letting a certificate expire that disabled almost all add-ons, the Mr. Robot tie-in "experiment", pushing pocket, default disabling userChrome.css, forcing auto-updates) they've made in the past 5 years. But the core of Firefox is good. I would love a startup that builds an entire business off of a fork of Firefox that's completely based on privacy, perhaps with some non-invasive monetization like: - a $5-20 one-time fee to use (with weak enforcement, a la Sublime Text's "annoy you every 5 saves" model) - a paid vs. free split where the free version of the browser adblocks ads but replaces them with in-network, verified safe ads - Linux kernel donation-style only model, with no parent corporation Because of all of the Firefox devs floating around who just got laid off, you could even snatch up some guaranteed capable talent already familiar with the code base. And the best part? They're already vetted to not be part of the management-industrial complex that's taken over Firefox these days.
- lukeramsden 6y agoHow many are Chrome only vs Chromium only? I use ungoogled-chromium[1] quite happily [1] https://github.com/Eloston/ungoogled-chromium https://github.com/Eloston/ungoogled-chromium
- stjohnswarts 6y agoHow long before they rip out open source parts and make chrome closed source or a much more limited licensing and start sticking all their proprietary network protocols in it so that you can't fork Chrome any longer. I personally believe that's the endgame for google.
- lukeramsden 6y agoThat's a valid point, and a good one. I certainly hope they don't. Is there precedent for them doing something like that before?
- mda 6y agoI don't think there a single instance of an application that Google did what you described. Why do you think it will start now? This doesn't make any sense.
- throwaway2048 6y agoGoogle has been moving open source components of android into closed source Play store components for years now.
- 6y ago
- jefftk 6y ago> plenty of websites are already chrome only What websites are Chrome-only?
- gsich 6y agoThose are not worth visiting then.
- shock 6y agoUntil it's your bank that goes Chrome only.
- freeopinion 6y agoYou either have principles or you don't. Anything else is haggling over price.
- sneakernets 6y agoMeanwhile, in the real world... As an early Linux user, I still remember running a Windows VM with IE installed, for years, just to do online banking. Heck, at my current corporate job all the Mac users (mostly the web designers) are given VMs to run IE11 to fill out their timecards, and use product management software. This is absurd, but real. I'm no stranger to having to use VMs to do basic stuff online, but not everyone else is. And, to be honest, no one should have to set up a VM to use a browser they cannot trust, just to protect themselves from stupid drive-by malware.
- colejohnson66 6y agoMost sites that “require” Chrome will render and run fine on Firefox. It’s just a matter of setting your user agent to say you’re running Chrome.
- d3nj4l 6y ago> It’s just a matter of setting your user agent to say you’re running Chrome. This is the real clincher - websites discriminating against Firefox often don't know why. I assume it's because they don't want to be liable for using their software on a browser they haven't tested on. Or it's just the good ol' Google search on Firefox mobile thing, i.e. "we'll gimp it for no particular reason!"
- zo1 6y agoI would pay for an ISP that can read my web traffic and alter it to remove ads, optimize images, filter out unwanted content, and a gazillion other things.
- dimitrios1 6y agoWhy not just run pi-hole?
- caseyohara 6y agoI don't think that will work with DNS-over-QUIC in the browser, but I could be wrong.
- JoshTriplett 6y agoIt will if your device speaks QUIC; you can configure your browser to talk to that device. But I do think it makes much more sense to make the browser just do the job directly, rather than delegating that to a separate device. Firefox continues to block ads just fine, and it'll keep doing so in a QUIC world, while protecting me even more from malicious local DNS servers. The average person is much more likely to encounter a hostile DNS server than a "helpful" one.
- OptionX 6y agoISPs are more likely to move in the direction of reading your traffic to inject ads rather than remove it.
- userbinator 6y agodon't prevent you choosing an agent that has your interests at heart I choose Dillo or Netsurf. Now how can I still use sites it can't even render because the developers have drunk the Google-aid and used some trendy framework that requires the latest version of Chrome and JS just to display some static text and images? Fuck Google and its creeping control over the Internet.
- Arnt 6y agoDo you even want to visit that sort of site?
- muxator 6y agoMaybe he wants. Once these practices become sufficiently spread, the majority of developers and content producers will never understand that an alternative is possible. Or maybe he will need it: those same developers can perfectly be contractors for a government agency whose site the user has to access. Trends slowly creep everywhere, independently on technical merit.
- swiley 6y agoWhen my brother got married his then fiance sent everyone in the wedding party this site with a form on it: It's mostly radio buttons (with a loading screen and a pile of js/css to make it pretty of course.) You fill it out, click submit and a matching suit gets shipped to your house. I couldn't get some of the controls to work and sent the support people an email. It turns out the form they built uses some special chrome only API and doesn't work in Firefox. Ditto when I submitted my rental application for my current apartment (how can you screw up a single page with a file form that badly?) The trends are definitely going the wrong way.
- trhway 6y ago> It turns out the form they built uses some special chrome only API and doesn't work in Firefox. history repeats itself (or more exactly we humans repeatedly step upon the same pile of stuff) Back then it was IE only APIs. Those APIs of course were for better and richer functionality and user experience. And we all know how it ended.
- d3nj4l 6y ago> The user agent will still be able to choose what to display Isn't one of the biggest advantages of ad blocking that it can cut your bandwidth use? I mean, if you aren't going to show the ads, why download them in the first place?
- wmf 6y agoBrowser extension ad blockers block requests before they are made which does save bandwidth. This still has nothing to do with QUIC.