13 ms·
Tesla is an immature car maker. They might have great designs but they haven't matured their processes. They haven't spent years fine tuning their QA processe
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
Tesla is an immature car maker. They might have great designs but they haven't matured their processes. They haven't spent years fine tuning their QA processes so these things slip through. One off type stuff like this and designs that are generally less manufacturing optimized designs coming from them are not surprising.
I don't see why all the fanboys get their panties in a knot when people point this out. To everyone who actually knows anything about cars or manufacturing it's kind of a nothing-burger that everyone expects will slowly go away with time.
- logicOnly 6y agoI'd hardly call it a "great design". From a specification point of view Tesla is below Kia on everything from exteriors to interiors. It's a low cost design, not a great design.
- agumonkey 6y agoare you referring to jd powers ranking https://mms.businesswire.com/media/20200624005175/en/800694/5/2020070a.jpg?download=1 https://mms.businesswire.com/media/20200624005175/en/800694/... ? I'm not a car guy and never even touched a tesla so I'm curious what's bad in them.
- logicOnly 6y agoWow that chart is telling. But I designed interior parts, so it's my own Engineering take. Tesla's were not competitive at all. The gaps between panels were so bad, you could stick your finger in it. That's not just an appearance issue, kids and adults will mess around with large gaps and put stuff inside. And features in the interior were non existent. (Especially for a luxury car)
- agumonkey 6y agoAlmost funny how they manage to sell tech and a bit of style as luxury :) I guess meaning is relative so 2020 luxury means curves, a tablet and skateboard battery pack.
- solarkraft 6y agoI'd say the he Model 3 is sold as a modern car rather than a luxury car.
- Bud 6y agoInteresting that you are just glossing over the fact that a) Tesla trounces all competition on performance and b) Tesla trounces basically everyone on safety as well. I guess that's inconvenient to mention?
- mikestew 6y agoa) for that kind of money, and lack of features, it better go fast (cornering, meh, not so much). b) You are commenting on an article that talks about a Tesla loosing its roof. That's a new one on me, and I'd thought I'd seen it all back when I was an auto mechanic.
- jcheng 6y agoIt's bad (obviously) but not unprecedented https://www.firstcoastnews.com/article/news/local/car-loses-roof-on-interstate-without-warning-its-not-the-first-time/77-baf17602-8d70-4f2c-9790-94db700a1c4b https://www.firstcoastnews.com/article/news/local/car-loses-... https://www.thecarconnection.com/news/1041062_recall-your-corvette-could-lose-its-roof--at-speed https://www.thecarconnection.com/news/1041062_recall-your-co... https://www.motor1.com/news/419197/lotus-elise-loses-roof-highway/ https://www.motor1.com/news/419197/lotus-elise-loses-roof-hi...
- jayd16 6y agoGaps seem better these days. I'd be interested to see some of the analysis on the 3 updated.
- NickM 6y agoJust my own personal experience, I've owned two Teslas (a 2014 Model S and a 2018 Model 3) and they both had a pretty good number of problems here and there. The S was particularly bad, though that is maybe not surprising since it was one of the first 50k cars the company built, but the 3 has had its share of issues as well. But the thing is, I've never had any issues that rendered the car undriveable or unsafe, and service has always been a joy to work with. Every problem I've encountered has been addressed quickly and effectively with no hassle or charge. So, I'm willing to forgive some of the rough edges, and I suspect this is why they get such good customer satisfaction ratings despite the relatively high number of issues.
- jacquesm 6y agoCars should be available, not spend time in the shop for repairs that could have been avoided. It's great that you are so forgiving but for me a trip to the garage for some small issue would eat up half a day easily and that adds up quickly when there are a number of issues.
- NickM 6y agoI mean, I agree with the sentiment, but also you're assuming you'd similarly waste half a day for a Tesla repair, and that's usually not the way things work. Tesla will frequently send a technician to a customer's home or place of work and fix issues on the spot. Even when I've had to go to a service center in person, they've included free rideshare credits for quick repairs so that I don't have to wait around, or free loaner cars for longer repairs. Back in the old days when I lived far away from a service center, they once drove hundreds of miles with a flatbed to come pick up my car, and dropped off a free loaner at my house while my car was in the shop, then came back and returned my car and picked up the loaner a few days later. (The loaner was also a nicer Tesla than the one I owned.) They really do go above and beyond to resolve issues as pleasantly and conveniently as possible.
- tyfon 6y agoI have a recent X, the panels fit together, no rattles or squeeks and the issues I've had were fixed fast. Last was the voice control button on the steering wheel that failed to work, reported it on last Thursday, they were at my door with mobile service at 9 this Monday. I did test drive a 2013 S and I decided to wait until they matured at that point but now they seem to have gotten their act together in most cases. They're actually on par with Audi here in Norway when it comes to customer satisfaction so it's not all bad [1]. Only Toyota, volvo and BMW beat them. They had a dip due to an overcrowded service department at the launch of the Model 3, but they hired a ton of people and trained them. Now this roof falling off is one area they could improve greatly, factory Q&A. There should be a bumpy test track where they take all their vehicles for a control drive before shipping them to eliminate issues like that roof. [1] https://www.tu.no/artikler/tesla-gjor-et-byks-i-kundetilfredshet/492177 https://www.tu.no/artikler/tesla-gjor-et-byks-i-kundetilfred...
- rodgerd 6y agoWell, for one example: Tesla Model 3 production was constrained based on the amount of paint their factory was consented to spray every day. When Model 3 production started climbing, customers were seeing very thin and uneven paint application, well below what's normal for a car in this price bracket, and often very light on critical areas like the sills. Owners in snow-bound places where Tesla is popular, such as Scandanavia, were reporting pain stripping within a few months of ownership. I don't know about you, but my expectation for what is nominally a luxury car would be to have paint standards better than British Leyland in the 70s.
- socialdemocrat 6y agoI really think the constant reference to Tesla as a luxury car is a bit wrong. Tesla is a tech car, modern car, whatever you may call it. There is nothing about a Tesla that suggests they are trying to make it appear luxurious. Where are the expensive materials and ornamentation? They are trying to make a futuristic car.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIt's a design that is getting sold to people who are getting starry eyed over other aspects of the car. They don't care that the fit and finish is befitting an Aveo. They care that they're driving a sexy new EV from the leading manufacturer of sexy new EVs. From the perspective of "keep Tesla relevant and financially solvent-ish" it's a great design. They know what the people they're selling to care about and what they don't and the latter isn't getting much attention. It's like how the Tacoma has been the turd of it's segment on paper for 20+yr but still flies off the shelves. Clearly the metric don't tell the whole story. In both cases there's an emotional value proposition that's doing a lot of heavy lifting. And since I know in advance that this comment is gonna piss off a hell of a lot of people here (if I had to pick a demographic that will have both a Tacoma and a Tesla in their driveway HN would be about the perfect fit) I'll ask in advance if any of those people would like to tell me why I'm so wrong.
- everdrive 6y ago>It's like how the Tacoma has been the turd of it's segment on paper for 20+yr I must know more. What's wrong with the Tacoma?
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoToyota trucks have thin sheet metal for the bodies and rust out rapidly in snow country.
- bumby 6y agoI know this was the case decades ago, but is this still an issue after using galvanized steel bodies?
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoIt is common to see a rust trail coming off the rear wiper of their SUVs made in the last ten years.
- 6y ago
- shuckles 6y agoAs someone who’s designed auto interiors, where other people see simplicity like a single touchscreen for all controls, I see an ergonomic disaster motivated by cost cutting.
- pascalmahe 6y agoI'm genuinely curious, could you explain how the touchscreen is a disaster? I haven't seen a Tesla interior so when you say "all controls" it's a bit concerning. I'm assuming you're talking only of non-driving related control...
- vidanay 6y agoI have never seen/driven a Tesla either, but I believe the only manual controls are gas, brake, steering, and turn signals. Everything else is in the touch screen UI. edit: I bit more than I originally thought, but not much. (gear selector, lights, and cruise control also have manual interfaces) https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/JO/model_s_eu_en.PDF https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/JO/model_s_eu...
- vrc 6y agoBecause of the lack of tactile feedback, touchscreens often lead to distracted driving by forcing drivers to take their eyes off of the road to carry out simple tasks. As an example, take HVAC and radio functionality -- in older cars with buttons and knobs, after a short amount of time, people can operate these functions without looking. The same is not true for touchscreens. That's not to say that there is no place for them in cars, but the consensus it's better to use a combination of touch screen (for things you don't often adjust while driving) and physical controls (for things you do). But it's generally cheaper to slap a big ol' touchscreen in cars that does everything, and change configurations in software, rather than investing in custom interior designs for each model of car. And it's not just Tesla doing this, even companies who hang their hat on safety like Subarus are stuffing more and more functionality into touchscreens[0]. [0] https://www.motortrend.com/cars/subaru/outback/2020/2020-subaru-outback-interior-review/ https://www.motortrend.com/cars/subaru/outback/2020/2020-sub...
- ivraatiems 6y agoPeople have been saying that for years at this point, and yet the quality problems remain. How much more time does Tesla need?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThe example from this article is from the Model Y, which just began shipping in March. Tesla is still in a huge rampup growth phase where their manufacturing processes aren't yet stable. I don't think Tesla deserves a free pass with these issues, but I also think they should be expected.
- ivraatiems 6y agoI disagree that "the whole roof flew off while driving" is an issue that should be expected, no matter the age of the product line.
- radicaldreamer 6y agoYup, this tends to not happen with brand new Toyota models for example...
- VBprogrammer 6y agoLet's not be totally unfair to Tesla here, plenty of cars have had similar issues. Various models of Vauxhall / Opel have been known for the bonnet / hood latch coming undone at motorway speeds and slamming into the windshield. Others have been known to catch fire randomly.
- ivraatiems 6y agoSure, and when that happened, did people say "oh, that's to be expected, sometimes cars do this sort of thing" or did they say "this is completely unacceptable and must be fixed immediately"? Tesla gets held to a separate standard, and excuses get made for it, because people want it to succeed. I want it to succeed, too, but my definition of success includes making reliable cars. (And preferably sacking Elon Musk, but that's unrelated.)
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 6y ago> fine tuning their QA processes Technically, this is QC (quality control), not quality assurance.
- ogre_codes 6y agoWhile Tesla has been making cars for 17 years, they have also been constantly scaling up. Prior to 2018, Tesla had delivered fewer than 500k cars total. By contrast, they are pushing to get 500k cars out the door this calendar year. Toyota, GM, etc are sitting on mature product lines which are growing a few percentage a year. They can roll out a new assembly line and spend months fine tuning it before turning it up and shutting down the old one. Tesla has no previous assembly line to lean on. It's pretty clear Tesla as a company values growth over delivering the best quality product. The flip side of this is I've heard a fair number of people suggest that Tesla's service is good... stupid slow but eventually good.
- ip26 6y agoIt's pretty clear Tesla as a company values growth over delivering the best quality product. Sure, I thought they had been pretty clear they felt reaching volume was critical to making BEV technology competitive (a larger revenue base over which to amortize development)
- ogre_codes 6y agoBased on the volume of posts here which seem to expect otherwise, it seems a lot of people don't understand what the secondary effects of this are.
- rbanffy 6y ago> Tesla as a company values growth over delivering the best quality product. I hope it works better for them and their clients than it worked for Boeing and the 737 MAX operators and passengers...
- nickik 6y agoBoeing has 50 layers of outsourcing. Tesla is vertically integrated and they try to control the whole process. Their QA might be bad but they have the highest safety rating in the market and are technologically the most advanced in terms of EV.
- 6y ago
- justapassenger 6y ago> To everyone who actually knows anything about cars or manufacturing it's kind of a nothing-burger that everyone expects will slowly go away with time. Tesla fundamentally disagrees with established ways of manufacturing cars and is still approaching it as a SV startup. They chase growth numbers, rush new models in production, will put home depot scrap in the cars just to keep the lines moving, and have no quality culture. Company needs to go over very fundamental philosophy changes for issues like that go away. Just the time itself is not enough. Japanese or Korean auto-markers turned around their quality over time, by heavily investing into that. Tesla shows no signs of that.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoIn fairness to Tesla, the cars are relatively simple and last a long time (as long as the batteries don't fail.) But more to the point, if competing manufacturers can't get serious about competing with Tesla, then Tesla isn't under pressure to change its practices.
- nickik 6y agoTesla is improving its manufacturing all the time. They have only turned into a mass market manufacturer in 2017. Shanghai where they could start fresh has very few of these problems. The Model Y rollout was early and much better the Model 3 already. The argument that Tesla is not investing in improving quality is simply not true. Things like casting make far more exact parts and very repeatable. It also reduces 100s of parts, less variation, less manufacturing steps and thus mistakes. They are investing in the most expensive paint shop you can buy in the market right now for their new factories and they just renovated the paint shop in Fremont (since then I have not heard of bad paint quality). They defiantly need to do more but its unfair to say they are doing nothing.
- mrkwse 6y agoAccording to the initial Reddit thread (anecdotal evidence I realise), while this is the most severe and highest profile incident, there have been quite a few reports of windows being improperly sealed. So as you say, not a one-off, but rather a flawed manufacturing procedure. I went along with a family member to a Model 3 test drive recently and it was surprising just how many little defects were there, considering the price of the car. While paint finish or panel fit isn't going to ruin a car overall, the fact the big easy-to-spot things are so clearly flawed does make one pause to consider how rigorous the QA is for the parts under the surface.
- kingnothing 6y agoOn the other side, I've owned a Model 3 for a year now and have not had any quality issues at all compared to my previous Audis and BMWs.
- bennyelv 6y agoAnecdotes do not equal data. Your personal experience with either situation says nothing about the underlying trends.
- dmode 6y agoTo be fair, the previous comment was an anecdote as well.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoI find "anecdotes do not equal data" to be unscientific. Your doctor doesn't take your oral history for fun, it's data. Now, just like a medical doctor we should weigh anecdotal data accordingly, but it's still data. Here for example we can tell BMW/Audi reportedly sometimes make production errors. Tesla reportedly don't always make significant (to the commenter) production errors. Sure, that's not terribly useful. It's still data. /bugbear
- JxLS-cpgbe0 6y ago
- thdrdt 6y agoThere are also reports of parts breaking off the suspension as a Swiss man experienced last week while driving 200km/h. Aren't these components that should be ok at least after 17 years of Tesla? After watching Rich Rebuilds on YouTube I came to the conclusion they are just not very good cars.
- austenallred 6y agoSure they are. Regardless, my Model 3 is the best car I've ever driven by a loooong ways.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoAdd harsh working conditions such as 60+ hour weeks, and it's a recipe for defects.
- fakedang 6y agoI'll have to agree. Having bought into the Tesla Kool aid last year, I decided to get myself one (S). Sure, I liked it and all, and it certainly reeks of German engineering design thanks to Holzhausen, but it's overall service model leaves much to be desired. I only realized that when my SO's Dad showed me the Porsche Taycan, that I realized how much Tesla had sacrificed, in terms of customer convenience and customer service. Tesla is no BMW or Porsche, and I don't think it can be one either - not with Musk's demanding sort of leadership. Designing a sexy car might be possible, but designing the processes behind manufacturing that with no qualms or quality issues, with a constantly changing team of engineers, is not possible. That requires time and patience and a lot of TLC, all of which Musk doesn't have. It's a good stock to ride the sucker wave on though.
- vl 6y ago>Tesla is no BMW or Porsche O, please. I own both BMW and Tesla, and while BMW is more refined car, service and quality miles better with Tesla. BMW gets obscure error codes, and then dealership lazily tries to fix it for weeks (this year BMW spent 7 weeks at the shop, last year 3 weeks). Tesla needs service, technician comes and fixes it on your driveway!
- Spooky23 6y agoYou’re comparing dumb and dumber. You can buy an equally boring looking car to the Tesla 3, say a loaded Honda Accord, and avoid the finicky bullshit that comes with the BMW.
- FireBeyond 6y ago> Tesla needs service, technician comes and fixes it on your driveway! Unless the parts aren't in stock. Then technician comes and fixes it on your driveway, 2-3 months later!
- awinder 6y ago“I only realized that when my SO's Dad showed me the Porsche Taycan, that I realized how much Tesla had sacrificed, in terms of customer convenience and customer service” Can you explain this, what compared unfavorably
- malwarebytess 6y ago>They haven't spent years fine tuning their QA processes so these things slip through. Actually, Tesla nixed essentially their entire QA for the production line years ago because it was slowing down production. I have a Model 3 so I'm not just some hater! Tesla's Customer Service is seriously bad.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThat's a great theory, until you realize that Tesla's been around 17 years, and that for a lot of their issues they really could crib notes on how other vehicle manufacturers do things. A huge amount of their QA issues around non-drive train components are solved problems everywhere else, and they've been at it for a while now.
- Leherenn 6y agoThey haven't been selling mass market cars for that long though.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThey've been making at least 10K units a quarter since Q1 2015. I'd hope that in half a decade they would have figured out how to make the body panels align and stay attached to the frame. Complaints about Tesla's fit and finish extend back to before they were mass producing vehicles, when they theoretically should have been able to hand fit them. So I really don't buy any argument about it being a problem with scaling up; they just seem incapable or disinterested in fixing this.
- lazyjones 6y ago> They haven't spent years fine tuning their QA processes so these things slip through. That's not true. Similar things happen with all car makers, but if you pick up your car from a car dealership, the dealer will quietly fix the cosmetic issues because they want to avoid a bad reputation.
- jansan 6y ago> fix the cosmetic issues because they want to avoid a bad reputation. Calling a blown off roof a cosmetic issue tells a lot about your expectations on car quality.
- rsynnott 6y ago> They might have great designs but they haven't matured their processes. They haven't spent years fine tuning their QA processes so these things slip through They’ve been around a while now, and it doesn’t seem to be getting any better. I think at this point the obvious conclusion is that they just don’t care. Like, it’s not like Toyota locks their process engineers in a basement. If they wanted to hire experts it’s just a question of money. This seems likely to go badly for them as competition heats up.
- kalleboo 6y agoIt's also a question of listening to them. If the process engineers say "to build a quality product it takes X amount of time" and Musk says "no, we need to hit X cars by next week, we don't have that time, build a tent in the parking lot and build cars in there", all the salary in the world won't help.
- rsynnott 6y agoExpert CEOs are also available for hire. Really, Tesla would probably benefit enormously from Musk stepping back and becoming president or CEO-in-name-only.
- jeffbee 6y agoIf their designs were "great" then it would be possible to make a quality car based on them. Manufacturability is a key element of design.
- dmix 6y ago> I don't see why all the fanboys get their panties in a knot when people point this out. People keep saying this but I always see way more critiques of Tesla and Elon than the opposite. My opinion on the matter is people love pushing back on whatever appears popular. Whether or not it's just a few idiots on the internet with little to no real influence and transform into the powerful strawman others love taking down.