7 ms·
I agree 100% with you. My view is even more extreme, I think we should allow anyone who passes a criminal background check to be able to get a work visa, with
by jedberg 6y ago
I agree 100% with you. My view is even more extreme, I think we should allow anyone who passes a criminal background check to be able to get a work visa, with no quotas.
But barring that pipe dream, this seems like a good interim step.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoWouldn’t that cause a large displacement of the existing labor force and significantly drive down wages?
- kbenson 6y agoIt depends. Short term and long term there's a lot of shuffling that would happen until it settled into an equilibrium (Maybe. On the other hand maybe it would be extremely sensitive to global issues). Those people all need food and housing and need to buy goods and services, so it's not like you're obsoleting an existing person's job, you're adding demand as you add supply. Whether one eventually outweighs the other is dependent on many factors. That said, I would assume that short term increased supply would lead to a tighter job market.
- Retric 6y agoThe problem beyond simple policy choices is infrastructure takes time to build. If hypothetically 100,000 people show up in NYC tomorrow there is some slack that might accommodate them. But, how do you scale the transportation network to handle even just 1 million extra people in NYC? Now extend that to every other part of the country. Sure that seems unlikely, but when millions of people are willing to become undocumented immigrants, it’s likely a more open policy would see dramatically larger influxes. Especially in response to local events like civil wars. Really, just raising the caps by say 10% every year gets the same result without the chaos.
- kbenson 6y ago> Really, just raising the caps by say 10% every year gets the same result without the chaos. Yeah, I was thinking the same thing when I was writing the above, but didn't want to get too into the weeds on what I wanted to be a short answer to the original question (I have a habit of going on...). Like many things, an immediate large change has repercussions that are detrimental and can possibly be alleviated with a measured change over time. That's how you acclimate fish to the temperature in a new aquarium. That said, it's also how they tell you to boil a frog...
- Retric 6y agoJust as an aside, the original boil the frog experiment first gave them a lobotomy. Without that they just out of the pot even with very slow temperature increases. On the other hand dump a frog in boiling water and they just die.
- kbenson 6y agoHa, nice to know, thanks. All the best idioms seem to be completely broken when you look into basis for them, so I'm not surprised. Not that it matters too much (although it would be better if they were more accurate), they do still let us express somewhat complex ideas concisely. :)
- omegaworks 6y agoManhattan's peak density was in the early 1900s. There are cities on the planet denser then NYC. The transportation networks in Asia blow the MTA out of the water. We can do it here. All we need is the political will.
- 6338363363 6y agoThe only real change you would need is to eliminate birthright citizenship to avoid birth tourism. The rest is a CoL problem which is mostly a blue state problem because they like pretty policies over effective policies. Housing's cheap to build, oil is cheap, and farming is easy if you don't hate industry. The only thing that would need help to prevent scarcity initially is probably internet availability. After that just use some of the increased tax revenue to provide support for struggling citizens.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoMaybe, but I find it hard to square the idea that someone capable of and willing to do my job for less money shouldn't have the opportunity to better their prospects at the expense of mine.
- briefcomment 6y agoAt the same time, the people in a given geography should have a say about what the companies in the area are doing. If a company decides to be anti-social with the people already in the community, I see no reason why the people in the area shouldn't object to it. It's clearly a balance, and both sides should be willing to play ball.
- mrkurt 6y agoThis is the intuitive belief, but the research doesn't really prove that: https://www.cato.org/cato-journal/fall-2017/does-immigration-reduce-wages https://www.cato.org/cato-journal/fall-2017/does-immigration... There are studies showing a slight decrease in wages, studies showing a slight increase in wages, and studies showing nothing conclusive. There's basically not enough scientific consensus to use for decision making, which means it's more a moral choice than an economic one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tomp 6y agoMaybe academic research doesn't substantiate that, but reality definitely does. This is from May 2020: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/may/19/quarantine-shortage-fruit-pickers-immigration-bill-coronavirus-britain https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/may/19/quarantine-... Basically, the UK fruit industry was worried that it might not get "enough workers" because of COVID restrictions. Which of course is brazen corporate double-speak. There are workers in the UK, like tens of millions of them. It's just that they're not willing to work for miserly wages. So there's only two options: (1) increase local wages, or (2) import cheap foreigners. Business obviously prefer the latter. ("But but but strawberry prices would increase" isn't a good argument - agriculture is heavily subsidized anyways.)
- _jal 6y agoThat language gets used in the US too. Somehow businesses forget how supply and demand works when it comes to labor, and "journalists" aren't, so much as they just transcribe whatever falls out of rich peoples' mouths and call it 'balance'. We'll be back to feudalism in a couple generations.
- mrkurt 6y agoAre you really dismissing research on the basis of anecdotal news articles? It makes total sense to question the value of the types of studies I linked to, but "the real world disagrees with research" is kind of a bonkers take.
- madeofpalk 6y agoWhat has happened in other countries that has similar systems, like the UK and Australia (to name two I have experience with)? I don’t think that happened there.
- bnralt 6y agoOur current system is kind of strange when you stop and think about it. We're OK with foreigners doing much of the labor for lower wages - as long as they do it overseas, and then ship the products here. However, if you think about it, there would be benefits to having the work be done domestically rather than requiring it be done in other countries. We could lower transportation costs of goods (and the environmental impact on transportation), we could have more flexibility in production, we could keep higher wage jobs associated with the work (management, machinists, R&D), etc. We could also have a more equitable balance of globalization - for instance, right now it's easy for a U.S. doctor to benefit from overseas manufacturing workers, but it's hard for a U.S. factory worker to benefit from overseas doctors.
- jmpman 6y agoBut then we are paying for US doctors for those US citizens. Healthcare alone in the US is more than those workers are making in their home countries.
- dudul 6y agoHow would you avoid seeing 500M indians/Chinese landing in America on the very next day? I think there is a middle ground between the disaster that are immigration laws today, and full open borders.
- throwqrm 6y ago[idea retracted; proposed a tax-based solution but maybe too distracting]
- chii 6y agoI am against taxation without representation. If it require "balancing out" (via taxation), then it wasn't a workable system in the first place.
- belltaco 6y agoI guess the idea would be that the employers are taxed, not the employee. Also, H1Bs are already taxed all the regular taxes even if they return to their country before they could use Medicare or gather enough SS credits.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y agoA side question: should representation without taxation be allowed?
- koolba 6y agoIf it was we’d lose half the voting populace.
- 6338363363 6y agoPeople have a choice of where they want to go for work. If you tax them so hard that anywhere else is better then you may as well have simply not bothered pretending like you wanted it to be easier for them to come at all.
- 6y ago
- marta_morena_29 6y agoAnd that's why you are luckily not in charge ;).
- dheera 6y agoPersonally I think there's a middle ground that's very important, which is that I think anyone who received a university degree in the US and passes the background check should be able to get an unrestricted work visa. The US should want to keep the talent it selects and trains. These are people who build the economy, generate IP, and create jobs in the long run. Not only that, but these people who have spent 4+ years in the US university education system are extremely well-adapted to life in the US and will thrive at making the US a better place. (Yes there's OPT, but it's not long enough and doesn't provide a path to permanent residency.)
- HarryHirsch 6y agoanyone who received a university degree in the US No. No. No. That would mean that anyone from the University of Oxford would be out until he got himself a masters degree from the Christian College of Lost Hope, AR. There are far too many paid masters degrees around already that serve exactly that purpose and that are good for no one except the useless college.
- jedberg 6y agoThey're not saying to exclude everyone else, just that if you are here for four years getting a degree, you should be able to stay.
- dheera 6y ago> masters degree from the Christian College of Lost Hope, AR Yeah no, screw that crap. I don't know the exact regulation framework that would accomplish my intent but you understand what I mean. I'm talking about all the people with bonafide degrees and skillsets. 4-year bachelor degrees, PhDs, MDs, and the like. These people should be treated as assets to the country. (Maybe just excluding masters' degrees is the answer, but I'm not sure.) It's dumbfoundingly stupid as a national policy to invest so much in resources to train a person and then send them back to another country instead of giving them every incentive to stay. Singapore and Australia (and maybe others I don't know about) allow international students to apply for permanent residency if they meet certain very reasonable qualifications and it works out very much in their favor for retaining talent.
- runarberg 6y agoI actually think that anyone—regardless of criminal background; as long as they’ve paid for their past crimes—should be allowed to live and work wherever they want, no quotas, no visas, no restrictions. But barring that pipe dream, yours seems like an acceptable interim step.
- shard972 6y agoIf we had that pipe dream there would not be a country left at the end of the day to argue policy over. It's quite amazing that even 6 months after 100 year pandemic people still have wide eyed beliefs about open borders as if it's a net positive.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Spinnaker_ 6y agoAsymmetric access to the work force is probably the most valuable right that most HN readers have. Why should we want to give that up? I struggle to see how your idea would be better for any Americans, except the owner-class.
- jjoonathan 6y agoI want to believe the prosperity gospel because it would mean that my moral-interest and my self-interest coincide, but it seems much more likely that it's just hustle from the owner-class. The American middle class has gotten absolutely wrecked over the last few decades while eerily similar promises about globalization have failed to deliver -- except to the owner class. I think this is just another instance of that, and I think many of us are in denial because it's much easier than acknowledging that we're next on the chopping block.
- jedberg 6y ago> I struggle to see how your idea would be better for any Americans A rising tide (growing economy) lifts all boats. Think of all the services that would need to expand -- markets, restaurants, hair salons, etc. Furthermore, immigrants contribute more to the tax base than citizens because they pay the same income taxes without getting all the deductions, they pay sales taxes and other taxes, and do not get the same benefits. It's well established that an immigrant with a job is a net contributor to both the economy and the tax base. Do this thought experiment -- so many immigrants come to the US and contribute so much to the tax base that there is enough to pay every US citizen $75,000 a year in UBI and provide universal healthcare for citizens. Now you can do whatever you want, work or not, it doesn't matter. That's why it's good for citizens.
- hnaccy 6y agoInequality continues to increase and wages for most Americans have been stagnant for decades.
- danans 6y agoYou are both correct. Immigration does increase GDP, and wages are also stagnant. The problem is that the GDP gains created by both immigrants and native born workers have concentrated in the holdings of the capitalist class (to which even many upper middle class Americans belong in varying degrees), because of low taxes and asset price inflation. As a result, public investment funded via taxes has moved to deficit spending and sporadic and selective philanthropy, exacerbating both the inequality of wealth and opportunity.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoOne interesting issue is that there are around 700,000,000 people interested in immigrating to the U.S. Would be fun to build super cities at a rapid pace over the next decade though :)
- lazyasciiart 6y agoI don't know if there would still be 350,000,000 interested after the first 350,000,000 arrive. Interesting to think about how that number would change based on America's changes.
- dang 6y ago(We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24702820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24702820.)