28 ms·
Credit where credit is due, this is a good move. The H1B program has been abused for a long time. It sounds like these changes should help make it too expensi
by jedberg 6y ago
Credit where credit is due, this is a good move. The H1B program has been abused for a long time. It sounds like these changes should help make it too expensive for the fraudulent abuse to continue.
- notJim 6y ago> The H1B program has been abused for a long time What's the abuse?
- mikeyouse 6y ago"Body shops" like Infosys and Tata Consulting that import thousands of H1Bs under borderline fraudulent applications, and then underpay these employees. Just a random link, but the contours of the problem: https://www.epi.org/blog/new-data-infosys-tata-abuse-h-1b-program/ https://www.epi.org/blog/new-data-infosys-tata-abuse-h-1b-pr...
- zerr 6y ago50k-60k is pretty normal in many places in US. Were they bringing staff in SF or NYC?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dodobirdlord 6y agoH1B visas are in theory intended to be awarded only when there is a shortage of some specialized labor and it is not possible to find enough qualified candidates within the country. If a person hired under that premise ends up making a “pretty normal” wage it’s a pretty clear sign that the process is being abused.
- AnAnonyCowherd 6y agoI work for a company that's about 30th in terms of H1B's. All around me, I see degreed engineers -- many with their Masters -- doing clerical work that a sharp high-school graduate could do. I'm not talking about a few. I'm talking about dozens. There's nothing about what they're doing that requires specific engineering knowledge. They only have to be conversant about what the actual engineers are doing. So the effect is 2-fold: the fact that his arrangement exists puts downward pressure on wages for the skilled jobs, but it also takes great opportunities away from people who would have gotten those jobs a few decades ago.
- tylerhou 6y agoSure, there are low paid H1B workers, but why is that necessarily a problem? Your link shows no evidence that they depress the wages or employment of native-born workers. In fact, there are many proper economic analyses that show that native-born workers benefit from immigration: https://www.reddit.com/r/badeconomics/comments/3pi8vo/highskill_immigration_is_bad_mmkay/ https://www.reddit.com/r/badeconomics/comments/3pi8vo/highsk...
- mikeyouse 6y agoI'm fully supportive of massively more immigration - I believe it's a net economic positive and a moral imperative. At the same time, if a program is designed to bring in 'exceptional talent' but is really just importing mediocre drones from a single country, that's not really serving the purpose of the program. Let's fix H1Bs and then work on more equitable ways to allow other forms of beneficial immigration.
- AnAnonyCowherd 6y ago> At the same time, if a program There's no "if" here.
- AndriyKunitsyn 6y agoSo, draining talent from less successful countries with a desperate need of this talent is a ‘moral imperative’ to you?
- mikeyouse 6y agoAside from all of the evidence that both countries benefit in these arrangements as people skill up and often move home later on, letting free citizens choose where to maximize their livelihoods is a moral imperative, yes.
- AndriyKunitsyn 6y ago>Aside from all of the evidence that both countries benefit in these arrangements as people skill up and often move home later on Can you please provide this evidence? I want to be educated on that. I thought that returning home is really rare for these people, and it does not compensate negative effects of the "brain drain" at all. >letting free citizens choose where to maximize their livelihoods is a moral imperative, yes People should be free to pursue whatever they want, no questioning that. However, elites of the US create such conditions that the best career path for the people from less fortunate countries is to move out, break cultural bonds and, probably, make the countries that they moved from, even less fortunate in the end - is it really moral? I think that the most moral option would be increasing investment and creating child companies in countries where these people move from, creating nice jobs outside of the US, so nobody would have to move anywhere.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- IvyMike 6y agoThere's lots of articles if you google for "h1b visa abuse", but this will get you started: https://www.infoworld.com/article/3004501/proof-that-h-1b-visa-abuse-is-rampant-in-tech.html https://www.infoworld.com/article/3004501/proof-that-h-1b-vi...
- redditmigrant 6y agoThere are lots of articles on how vaccines cause autism also.
- dpoochieni 6y agoCorrelation is not causation, but maybe you should read them.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoA majority of H1B visas are currently issued to relatively low paying consulting firms, who are then hired by big enterprises in place of their more expensive technical employees. This isn't supposed to be legal - you're not allowed to hire H1B employees if an equally qualified American could have filled their role - but due to the specifics of how the program is administered you can often pull it off with that kind of arms-length deal.
- verst 6y agoCheck this out: https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/document/data/Approved_H-1B_2019_Employers.pdf https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/document/data/Appr... Contrast that with the previous year: https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/document/data/Approved_H-1B_2018_Employers.pdf https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/document/data/Appr... You can see that the outsourcing firms have fewer and fewer approvals. Of course with this latest change it will decline more.
- balls187 6y agoThis happens to US workers too. "Bottom" performing FTE's are let go as part of annual stack ranking, only to be hired by staffing agencies, and contracted back to large tech companies. It's a way for tech companies to retain people who are necessary to perform the work, but at reduced wages.
- JohnBooty 6y agoYou're bound to the employer that sponsors your visa. Lose your job? You're effectively deported. Your employer has... well, a power imbalance over you, to put it nicely. I'm not sure how the proposed changes will play out for American workers. Theoretically, treating H1B workers better could benefit American workers: there is less incentive to callously replace them with underpaid H1B workers. On the other hand, American workers will face increased competition, it seems to me.
- menage 6y agoIf you can find another employer to take over the sponsorship, you can transfer (without having to deal with the visa quota gantlet).
- Lammy 6y agoDo you think the possibility of finding a new job makes H1B workers feel any more capable of standing up for their beliefs at work and maybe saying "No" when asked to build something evil?
- menage 6y agoIt may not eliminate it, but I'm sure it improves the situation compared to not being able to change jobs at all. I originally came to the US on an H-1B, and had no trouble transferring the visa to a new employer.
- switch11 6y agoand for that you had to find a job get/consult a lawyer to make sure everything was good do the whole change and end up in the exact same situation Situation: You are tied to ONE employer and if something goes wrong they can just end your job and kick you out I've done the change so let's not pretend it is some super easy, doesn't matter thing Also, if you have to leave US where do you have to go? If you have to go back to UK or Canada that is no big loss If, on the other hand you have to go back to China or India or AFrica then your entire family is #$@$#$%
- ajsnigrutin 6y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/04/us/last-task-after-layoff-at-disney-train-foreign-replacements.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/04/us/last-task-after-layoff...
- ponker 6y agoThe abuse is that the H1B program is supposed to be for truly distinctive skills. But the "body shops" bring people with very low skill.
- JAlexoid 6y agoNope. There's a self sponsored immigrant visa. H1B is just your regular temp.
- outworlder 6y ago> What's the abuse? That's probably about the handful of consulting companies doing shady stuff. Not the overall program as a whole.
- JAlexoid 6y agoIt's inherently abusive. You're tied to a pool of employers and have to get government permission to transfer employment. Your employer has an enormous power over you, with little recourse on your side.... as if employers didn't have enormous power over their employees as is.
- jopsen 6y agoWill an executive order (which I assume this is) actually make any difference? Doesn't it take an act of congress to make any serious headway here? Personally, I was an H1B a 4.5 years before Trump convinced it was time to leave. I was in the bay area and handsomely overpaid. I have no personal experience of it being abused, but I'm obviously privileged, having worked at reputable tech companies and coming from reasonable wealthy european country. (I was never as scared of loosing job or healthcare as my American co-workers, because I would just move home, and have access to healthcare if I lost my job) But I will say, that the lottery aspect of the H1B adds a lot of uncertainty that might discourage me from living in SF again. So lifting the caps and/or stemming abuse might be a good idea.
- jedberg 6y agoThis is a rule in the Federal Register. So it's basically like law. It's essentially how the executive is interpreting the laws that congress has passed. There is a rule that says a new President can automatically overturn all rules made in the last 90 days of the previous administration, but we're before that deadline, so this is pretty much a done deal. If the next admin wanted to change this, they have to go through the long and arduous rule making process again.
- belltaco 6y ago>If the next admin wanted to change this, they have to go through the long and arduous rule making process again. Does that also apply to rules that didn't go through that process but were rushed through with the interim final rules process? Doesn't sound logical to me.
- dpoochieni 6y agoThis certainly took a long time in planning.
- phonebanshee 6y agoOr change the law. Not particularly likely with power shared between two parties of course.
- cactus2093 6y agoGenuine question, what type of fraudulent abuse are you referring to? I see this vaguely mentioned a lot without much to back it up, but I'm open to the idea that it happens. From my own anecdotal experience, I'll admit I have found the rules to be a little ridiculous. Company needs to post a sign in the office advertising the role to any Americans, wait a certain amount of time, and only then can offer it to an H1-B candidate. Of course nobody was following the spirit of those rules, but I wouldn't call that fraudulent abuse. These were companies that needed hires and had a genuinely hard time finding people that would pass our interviews and then accept our offers. We really didn't discriminate at all in the hiring panels between American and H1-B candidates (I think we were probably supposed to discriminate more than we did, and supposed to explicitly prefer Americans?), and it had nothing to do with saving money on salaries. I recognize that the Bay Area tech boom is very unusual in how competitive it is (was?), but H1-Bs are technical visas and it's often tech companies that get the blame for abusing the system.
- pwinnski 6y agoThe abuse I've seen most often is that companies hire H1B workers and then contract them out to other companies, and the H1B worker can't change employers, and gets to watch most of what their time is billed for go to the original contracting company which often misleads the people about what they'll find when they arrive. The worker ends up with very few choices, and the companies at which the workers are working are likely overpaying for what they're getting. The only one truly happy is the "placement" company that holds the workers' contracts.
- ajsnigrutin 6y ago....or outright getting replaced by those workers: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/04/us/last-task-after-layoff-at-disney-train-foreign-replacements.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/04/us/last-task-after-layoff...
- mdorazio 6y agoAnother semi-fraudulent practice I've seen too often: find an H1B worker for a position you want to fill at a sub-US labor rate, then write a very specific job posting that perfectly fits that one H1B worker and no one else, and post the job only on the company website where no one will find it. Congratulations, you've just "proven" that you can't find an American worker to do this job, so you bring the H1B worker over as basically an indentured servant. In reality, there were plenty of American workers who could have and would have taken the role if it was represented properly and actually paid a competitive market salary.
- reissbaker 6y agoThe higher pay seems like an overall positive change to reduce the prevalence of "body shops" and so that H1-Bs aren't an easy way for companies to lower overall pay rate. I'm not sure that narrowing degree qualifications is a win; high-skill immigration is a significant boon to America's economy, and I think ability to do the work, and American company willingness to pay above-rate salaries (legally mandated now to 95th percentile for the highest-skill work) ought to be enough signal, and having a particular degree is not as useful a measure at that point. I know plenty of people who are incredibly qualified in terms of industry experience who don't have advanced degrees. I've been pretty impressed with Taiwan's Gold Card work visa program, where you either need certain educational achievement qualifications, or need to be a highly-paid employee in specific fields — but not both. And it's not tied to a specific employer, which I think helps negotiation (and thus also helps domestic workers, by raising labor prices). I wish America's immigration program worked more like that — specific quibbles about what exactly the rate should be aside; Taiwan's is certainly too low to use for the US — since I think encouraging high-skill immigration would help much more than it would hurt: high-skill immigrants tend to generate more jobs, and also tend to pay more in taxes than the services they receive, meaning it's a win-win where immigrants can get the jobs they want in the country they want to be in and Americans end up with more jobs available and more government services per (American) tax dollar spent.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Florin_Andrei 6y agoWhat makes the immigration process in the US truly horrific is the extraordinary time it takes to approve or reject a greencard petition. In many cases it takes years - or even over a decade or more. That's insane. People bring their spouses here, they have kids who are born and go to school here, and all along the way their immigration status is uncertain. And meanwhile they are tied to whatever job they're in. It's insane. Make that process faster. Give people a thumbs-up or thumbs-down like 10x faster. Months not years.
- rayiner 6y ago
- fmajid 6y agoIt would be simpler to award the limited pool of H1-Bs in order of descending wages, and cross-check with the IRS afterwards to verify those salaries are actually paid. That would kill all the bottom-feeding body shops.
- fredophile 6y agoThat has the added benefit of removing the unpredictability of the current system. Companies would very quickly figure out roughly where the line is and could pay a premium to guarantee their employee gets one of the spots.
- cheese65536 6y agoOne issue with this is that it would favor H1B workers working for companies located in high wage areas (the coasts) over low wage areas (mid-west).
- cryptofistMonk 6y agoSo go for highest percentile wage in the region of the hire
- vostok 6y agoI don't really see a problem here. If you are in a low wage area and feel that your workers are as productive as workers in high wage areas then you can pay them a high enough wage that they get a visa. If you don't feel that way then obviously the visa should go to a more productive worker and it doesn't matter that they happen to be in a high wage area.
- michaelt 6y ago> I don't really see a problem here. If you believe immigrants are good for the economy and make everyone richer, strengthening existing companies with their unique talent and expertise and founding many successful new companies, why let rich costal cities get all the benefit when poor cities have a much greater need for an economic boost?
- obviouslynotme 6y agoI remember the first time I walked into the "residence" for a major contractor's H1B visas. They were packing a dozen people in a 3 bedroom apartment in a bad area of town. You then see how they are treated by their companies at work, and it disgusts me. This is why you can't have second-class citizens like this. They are terrified to go for help if they even know how. It's even worse for undocumented workers. At least they can quit though. H1B workers are tied to their sponsors, which has to stop.
- splintercell 6y agoAlmost all of those people you saw there are now living in pretty enviable situations for most Americans. Calling these 'guest houses' as people living in second class of the society is as incorrect as calling the residents of Pied Piper house in 'Silicon Valley' as 'living like second class citizens'.
- bdcravens 6y agoSilicon Valley is satire, and meant to make fun of the idea, and even on that standard, they aren't as cramped as the parent comment is referring to.
- mathisonturing 6y agoNot from there nor do I know the place by any means, but didn't Bill Gates call Silicon Valley (the series) pretty close to the truth? I'm just genuinely curious
- dehrmann 6y agoIt's about 90% accurate with 10% creative license.
- pankajdoharey 6y agoSimilar conditions do exist in actual startup Incubators.
- heavyset_go 6y agoDid the administration actually make a change, or are they just talking about it like they've been for the last three years?
- tuna-piano 6y agoI have heard stories (that don't seem too uncommon) of unscrupulous companies doing a variety of things - including charging the hopeful visa recipient payments to secure a job, paying the required salary only for the months leading up to the H1B interview and then lowering the salary immediately after, etc. Not sure what fraud these new rules will prevent, if they are implemented.
- FilterSweep 6y agoI tentatively agree but feel employers will somehow turn this into hurting both domestic and H1B workers even more.
- shams93 6y agoHowever the best solution would be the replace h1b with just citizenship - if you have rare skills why shouldn't we offer immediate citizenship to the talented?
- analyst74 6y agoThat's what countries like Canada has, while they do have a work visa program, getting permanent residency is actually easier for talented folks.
- mcrider 6y agoNot really; If you have an in-demand skill set you get extra 'points' on the PR scoring chart, but you need to demonstrate many other things to reach the threshold required to get status. I went through that process and was denied because my work experience was through contracting (which for whatever reason didn't count). This was 10 years ago though, so things may have changed (also after three applications I finally got PR and then citizenship as of last year).
- RspecMAuthortah 6y agoNot really. It has gotten worse. It used to be if you are a graduate or have experience working in a Canadian company you would score points. Which was much less prone to abuse. Now they still have point based system, but the above don't get any extra point, and if you have those said qualifications anywhere, as long as you can prove (through documentations) you get the same points. Result is rampant abuse with overseas companies that "vet" candidates' degrees and experience providing certificates and such things. And it takes longer for graduates from Canadian universities or someone with experience working at a company here since they compete in the same lottery pool. It is still far better than US, but it could take you a while before your points start closer to the draw.
- nsonha 6y agoI went through the thing in Australia just 3 years ago. We have the same problem with people from certain country having a lot of experience and inflate the point system. The exp points in Australia acummulate twice as fast as exp overseas so those who worked in Australia like myself still have the advantage. However I am now not a fan of the point system as it's just another standard test to be hijacked by multiple attack vectors. I'd much prefer the european way where work visa is given out easily with fair wage and better mobility, (in Australia you have 4 - 6 weeks to find a new employer, not impossible for software but a bit tight). From what I've heard there is no real incentive to acquire citizenship/PR in many european countries b/c temporary residents enjoy the same stability.
- tequila_shot 6y agoWhy is this on the top of the hacker news? The article talks about nothing that will stop the abuse. There are indeed a lot of RFEs that are being given out if you don't have a CS degree and apply for a Software Developer position already. The Pay structure that the article mentions is NOT true anymore. Take a look at the links[1], it's withdrawn and the rule is not valid. How is hiring folks with a CS degree for an SWE position a solution to H1b abuse? The rule published here specifically talks about three things(Yes, I read it line by line just so that I can do my due diligence before I comment here)[2]: 1/ Change the meaning of "Speciality Occupation" and tie this to the College degree that the person has. 2/ If you are part of these "body shops" and you are working as a contractor, your visa will only be extended for 1 year. 3/ Some general statements about Site Visits. 4/ No comment on increasing the wage. The first child comment that we see below is an anecdotal evidence about seeing a house with dozen(?) folks in a 3 BHK flat? What does it do with H1B visa abuse? How is sending money home AFTER taxes H1B abuse? Still debating how we went from thoroughly researched and thought provoking comments to these. I don't debate that there is H1B abuse. - Programmers are paid very less when compared to prevailing wage. - Programmers cannot leave their employers so employers hold them by their balls and get work done overtime. - Programmers stay away from their family, contribute to taxes AND to social security. KNOWING that they may never see a day to collect Social security. All of this is H1B Abuse. There is no evidence that folks on H1B visa compete with a US Citizen's job. (I'm taking about H1B, not offshoring). Literally NONE of the changes that this administration is doing is addressing ANY of these concerns for both the US Economy and the H1B individual. Comments like these are dangerous since they give an illusion that the administration is doing something to improve the economy, but they are just party tricks. [1]https://www.reginfo.gov/public/do/eoDetails?rrid=131148 https://www.reginfo.gov/public/do/eoDetails?rrid=131148 [2]https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2020-22347.pdf https://public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2020-22347.pdf
- nathanvanfleet 6y agoThere were companies hiring people under H1B then finding them contract work. Something they are specifically limiting now because they were abusing the system by under paying them as well as hiring them after they get the visa instead of before.
- tracker1 6y agoAgreed... been saying for a long time, there should be a pay floor of 8-10x minimum wage for H1B workers. These are supposed to be for positions we cannot fill locally, there's no reason they shouldn't be 6-figure jobs at a minimum. I really don't like his personality, but really do appreciate a lot of the things Trump does in practice.
- d1zzy 6y agoSome of the changes I can see a logic behind it. But making electrical engineers not qualify for H1B for a SWE job is just silly and doesn't match reality. Just ask the SWEs in any 1000+ software company how many of them are electrical engineers.
- abc_lisper 6y agoTrue for the most part. But there are unexpected consequences for this. Startups will be ill afforded to hire foreign talent now. All the immigrants will look for jobs at BigCo. because they are the ones who can pay those high salaries.