3 ms·
I feel bad for Epic. I know their intention, but the way they are going into this battle is just wrong. And they are kind of losing public support and court ord
by ksec 6y ago
I feel bad for Epic. I know their intention, but the way they are going into this battle is just wrong. And they are kind of losing public support and court orders, all while burning bridges with Apple and Google.
One could argue Epic is trying to demonstrate Apple and Google are basically Visa and MasterCard. ( That is purely my guess, personally I dont see Epic has planned a decent, long term strategy other than simply charging into battle ) And in EU Visa and Master had to lower their CC processing fees from their 3-5% in US to somewhat sane %. Similar case in AUS as well.
I wonder if Tim Sweeney saw the opportunity from DHH / Hey.com, decided to take a bet and jump onto it. Simply judging the flow from Twitter and people within his own circle. ( or Bubble )
I actually have no problem with Apple or Google charging 30% for gaming. I do have problem with Apple charging business like Fitness class, Online Email Services, Education or all other Services simply for access through their Apps. Had it been something like 5% to 10% I think everyone would have been happy to pay. It was estimated 80% of App Store revenue were from Gaming. Apple could have lower their non-gaming cut without substantial loss of services revenue stream.
But it seems there are large enough group of Americans thinking Apple can charge whatever they want. It is their platform.
- Qahlel 6y agoThe 30% is overkill and who says it will stay at 30%? What if Apple tomorrow decides to increase it to 40%? What can any dev do? Stop being this naive.
- RL_Quine 6y agoWhat if they don't? What if they demand your first born child? That sort of hyperbole is not a good argument.
- jasonzemos 6y agoThe statement is a slippery-slope, but it's not a fallacy. The concept of a monopoly is one we can agree on, and the exposure to the risk being described is a real one. What is to stop a monopoly deciding 30% becomes 40%? Not much.
- ksec 6y agoIt is the same with Playstation and Xbox. No difference. And if you actually read what I wrote it was for Gaming. And Gaming only. And Gaming company will no longer develop for their platform. >Stop being this naive. Very Rude. But you are perfectly entitle to your opinion.
- oh_sigh 6y agoThe major difference is that almost no one buys a playstation and xbox for their built in capabilities - the games are the major reason people want these devices. Yes, people stream netflix on them, but usually because it is convenient with their AV install, not because it is some major differentiator that other devices don't have. Whereas with smart phones, it is reasonable and common to never touch the app store. Or at least never touch non-free apps from the app store.
- DivisionSol 6y agoThere was a point where people bought a PlayStation... something, because it was the best Blu-ray player. The line you’re drawing is arbitrary
- Dylan16807 6y agoThat point in the past doesn't change the typical and current situation.
- oh_sigh 6y agoI'm not drawing any kind of line - I'm explaining why Microsoft and Sony need to treat their game platform developers better than Apple/Google needs to treat their paid app developers.
- millstone 6y agoThey can increase their prices. Not sure why this is controversial. You pay more at Whole Foods than at WalMart for the same lemon.
- chii 6y ago> I actually have no problem with Apple or Google charging 30% for gaming. I do have problem with Apple charging business like Fitness class, Online Email Services, Education or all other Services simply for access through their Apps. Why differentiate gaming and non-gaming? The platform should be blind to the content and be a platform. I would also argue that a platform can curate, but the platform should not lock-down the user from escaping the platform. For example, side-loading should be a legal right that an owner of a device should have.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rblatz 6y agoI love the fact that the computer that is my second factor, has access to my password manager, has all my banking apps on it, has access to my retirements accounts, has access to my personal investment accounts, and has access to my Bitcoin wallet is locked down and I’m not expected to side load a bunch of shady apps. The breach of my phone is a actually way worse than a breach of any of my computers.